This is a quaint Italian pizzeria that has a welcoming feel. It gives off a very comfortable atmosphere. One of the ladies with me recommended a great place for a lunch outing. They have an extensive menu that contains many selection from salads, pizza, and main courses. Unfortunately, my Caprese and eggplant pizza was not freshly made and probably stayed out for more than a day or two. I wasn't impressed. One friend had a huge salad that she found was fresh and very tasty. My other friend had the buffalo chicken slice along with an eggplant Caprese Tower. She thought it was very delish and very tasty. The server was okay and she did come over to check on anything we needed. Overall, it's fine for a nice atmosphere and certain selections. read more

Anthony's Pizza - Front Cover of Menu - Pizza Near Me - Palm Coast, Florida

Wow. Food is amazing and service is great. Dinner portions is good for 2 persons. They also have wine selection. read more

See all

The food is good every time we go... Salads are truly the best! Mussels to die for Pizza is always on Point! And lasagna is outstanding.. service is always wonderful and feels like home... thank you read more

Anthony's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Palm Coast, Florida

Just re-tried Anthony's and have to say it seems to be back to the way it was a year ago which is a huge plus in our book. For a while I thought I'd have to find a new place. I just wish that the pies were consistent. Last week we ordered a large sausage and it was great. The crust was nice and crispy and the toppings were sufficient without being overloaded. This week we ordered the same but the crust was soggy so it flopped and didn't hold up. read more

The young lady who waited on us was very pleasant and attentive came back to check on us four times We had the antipasto salad, we split it more than enough for two people, absolutely wonderful fresh and tasty Italian dressing was delightful. The dining room was clean and quiet. We then ordered a peace of the meat lovers pizza just to try it ,was great we were completely satisfied with the meal we will be going back! Jim DiProspero read more

I've ordered from Anthony's for years now, the last two times now they're just leaving the order at the door and walking away so keep your eay out not sure what's going on over there. read more

I ordered a large cheese pizza for a pick up . It failed the flop test completely ! Disappointing when you order from them periodically. The search continues read more

I've been to this pizzeria a few times and it's been good, but the last 2 times we had burned pizza, I hope it was just a bad day and they improved after that. Service was good . read more

Service was attentive. However, the regular slice lacked freshness and tasted like it had been sitting around for a while. On the upside, the artichoke pesto with red pepper slice was better. They don't offer bottled or canned soda, and the fountain soda tastes watery. While nothing compares to New York pizza, this isn't a place I'll be revisiting anytime soon. read more

Really good pizza and chicken parm hero- sauce was tasty and the pizza was crispy. Wouid def go back

Always delivered fresh and hot. Delicious! We really enjoy the food here, and everyone is so nice!

Excellent Pizza. We love sausage, bacon and jalapeño . To die for. Excellent service.

This is my first ever yelp review. New to the area and this place seemed to have good reviews so figured I'd try it out. I got the linguini Alfredo with chicken and a buffalo chicken calzone with the side salad. Long story short they went 0/3. With the pasta half was lukewarm and some bites were ice cold. Most bland Alfredo sauce I've ever tasted. The calzone was soggy with barely any chicken at all paired with an abhorrent amount of cheese and again tasted beyond bland. I wish I took a picture of the salad before I tried it because it was very obvious someone just grabbed a handful and threw it in the clamshell container and said "good enough". $50 wasted. Credit where it's due, the woman who took my order over the phone was very nice and respectful and so was the delivery driver. read more

We had their pasta and it was beyond amazing. Their pizza was delicious too but in honesty it isn't our all time favorite but pizza to me is very subjective to one's personal taste. read more

The pizza never disappoints. Great crust, cheese and sauce. Love this place and the service is amazing. They make you feel at home. Will return again and again read more

Excellent spot in Palm Coast for takeout or dine in. I ordered take out- very friendly when walking into the restaurant. Good ambiance- very home feeling with good vibe. Had a fantastic perfectly cooked Chicken Parm Hero- damn it was good and a very large Antipasto Salad with fantastic home dressing. Highly reccomend Anthony's. read more

Anthony's Pizza - Chicken Parmigiana Hero - Pizza Near Me - Palm Coast, Florida

See all

Always excellent! Consistently perfect food and service! Super clean restaurant and amazing servers' always friendly and attentive. I highly recommend this place. read more

See all

I'll start that I give this establishment a 4.5 star review. Found it by mistake in reality. It's in what I'll call a strip mall. Saw a sign for two slices and a drink under $6 I found the pizza to be better than Joes and Bronx house pizza. The sauce isn't sweet like the others. I tried the rustic pasta and very much enjoyed it. We will definitely return and try new items read more

Our first visit to Anthony's was May 9th. The atmosphere was as expected and pleasant. Service was good and the servers were attentive. We ordered pizza with mushrooms and onions. Overall the pizza was flavorful but the center portion of the pie was undercooked and doughy. With regard to the two toppings, $3 each seemed pricey. That said we will go back as some of the other dishes being served looked worth trying. read more

Delicious salad and margarita pizza with great service and ambience. Chianti topped off the meal.

great food,great customer service,from the seats to the surroundings ,it was awesome experience all the way around read more

Anthony's Pizza - us enjoying our experience - Pizza Near Me - Palm Coast, Florida

We had the garlic knots and they where good and the pizza was really good i really recommend giving this place a try read more

Anthony's Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Palm Coast, Florida

Delicious perfect pizza! This was our first time ordering, will not be the last. Looking forward to getting their other specialty pies.

Absolute nightmare. Ordered online through a third party cause their website doesn't do direct orders. Chow now? I was never asked for a phone number or anything but apparently if you are not a regular in their system they will cancel your order then be rude when you show up and they had the wrong number.... If you want business in a tourist area have easy ordering options and don't cancel new orders you won't get new business. No thanks! read more

Excellent especially the soup the pizza was done perfectly and very quick must try if in the area

So I'll go ahead and do a review here because I see that the restaurant is allegedly "not good for kids." You'll have to tell that to my three year old daughter, because this is her favorite restaurant on earth. I've only ordered three things from here, and we've been very happy with all of them. I bring my daughter to eat pizza here once a week, usually on Friday afternoon. She always has a slice of pepperoni pizza, and I have one slice of meat lovers stuffed pizza. Both are excellent. I spent my entire adolescence and early 20's working in and managing a pizza restaurant, so I'm no stranger to how pizza should taste. The pizza here is great, and we've always been happy with the service. I've never felt unwelcome bringing my three year old here, and like I sad before, she loves it and the staff is very accommodating (cutting her pizza into toddler sized slices.) read more

Anthony's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Palm Coast, Florida

Get the lunch special..slice of pizza, salad and drink $9.99 very filling and delicious

Stumbled on this place because I was craving a slice and this place had amazing white pizza and eggplant pizza. Will stop in again.

By far the worst pizza I've ever had. I'm no food connoisseur and really easy going with food and this in fact is the first yelp review I've left. Pizza was so undercooked and soggy, the Dough was very wet and not near fully cooked. Save your time and go get some other food, Tbell, McDonald's etc. I would rather of ate some poor quality fast food than have had this pizza. Really disappointing given how hungry I was and wasting the hunger on this meal read more

Ordered large Bronx pizza with extra cheese for pickup. It was ready on time. Very nice clean dining area. Friendly staff. They also sell by the slice. To me it Tasted like NY Pizza and convenient to where I shop and live. Will return!! All of my guests also really enjoyed. Even better reheated the next day! read more

It's a small place that has a pretty big following. The pizza is delicious. The girl who makes the pizzas is the best, and never once has she disappointed us. Consistently good.I've eaten many things on the menu, and I would recommend most of it. The servers are the best. very clean and a charming place with great atmosphere. read more

Excellent Italian food with custom touches - for instance pizza with sausage and peppers has medium diagonal sausage slices and freshly roasted peppers! Not your chain pizza place stuff!! I had linguini with Alfredo sauce and shrimp. Nice size portion and included Caesar Salad with dressing choice and bread. It was very good. Staff is friendly and accommodating. Located right by Spectrum store in Palm Coast. read more

Great good, large portions, reasonable pricing and service staff are amazing! Sufficient seating for a usually 'take out' business, and menu is very much more than simply pizza! Do not be deceived by by heir 'Pizza' name, they have a varied and completely full Italian spread. Better than Carabbas IMO! read more

My parents were eating there for lunch and i have a serious food allergy, so i went to meet with them so we could all enjoy lunch together and i brought my own small sandwich in to eat. We were seated in the back corner away from all the other customers and i was rudely asked to leave the restaurant. even after i tried to explain them i had a severe food allergy. i walked out in tears. The staff and management could have handled this very differently instead i had to go eat alone in the car while they finished there meals. we will not be coming back. very disappointing read more

Was craving a couple slices the other day, was in Palm Coast at the Island Walk Publix... so I decided to give Anthony's another try (first time wasn't good). I got two cheese slices and what a SHIT SHOW!!! Two bites in and in the trash they went... soft, bland and just plain bad pizza. As a pizzeria you should want your slices to look the best, taste the best and just be the best... that's how you sell pies. Anthony's was so bad that I had to drive to Ormond to get two really good slices at The Bronx House to wash that garage out of my system read more

Best gluten free pizza in town I've had better, but this is pretty good for Palm Coast. read more

We go to Anthony's for their delicious pasta sauce. I like mine on baked Ziti and also on pasta with sausage, on the menu as Ball &a bat. My husband never differs from his favorite: Eggplant Lasagna. The servings are generous and flavorful. Our go-to place for pizza when we have company and I'm "taking the easy way out". read more

Terrible order once again waited over 2.5 hours and the sun and fries were hard as rock the fries were so soggy as if they were wet. Unfortunately this isn't the first time, we're done with this place. I mean we live less than a half of a mile from their store absolutely no reason but another wasted 20 bucks. We did however tip the driver as is wasn't his fault. We will now only order from Joes and mezzalunas sorry Anthony's can't afford to throw money away for terrible food and service. read more

Great pizza. Pizza was delivered to our condo at Cinnamon Beach and arrived hot. Driver was super courteous.

The eggplant slice and the white slice are so good. Great pizza. The regular cheese slice is really comparable to New York pizza. It reminds me of a penn station slice. read more