I usually like their pizzas, but today I ordered a large pizza with mushrooms and received a metal staple inside the pizza. Luckily, I found it before eating it. I took it back, and I don't recall hearing even an apology from the manager, just, "I'll make you another one," which I declined and got my money back. read more

This place is definitely worth a visit. Looking and trying as many places as possible in Deland and coming from NY to FL finding a great pizza is a must. This location is convenient with lots of parking since it's in the Publix Plaza... The staff was very cordial and very outgoing, I got a couple of pies One Cheese and the other with Pepperoni... The dough was excellent crispy thin and chewy just like NY pizza. The flop was also a hit as you can see by my images and the flavor was all there, so far best pizza I've had in Deland... I did takeout but looking forward to a Dining in experience soon... read more

See all

I came in for two slices and also to order a pie to go. The two slices from their premade case took over 20 minutes to arrive to my table. They tasted fine as expected. 20 minutes later the waitress brought me the check and said the to go would be ready in a "couple of minutes". Ten minutes later I walk up to the counter to ask how much longer they told me there was a mistake on the pie "it had a hole in it, so they were remaking it." I asked how long and was told 20 minutes. So for two slices of sit down pizza while waiting for a to go pie will now be over an hour. What upsets me is they didn't show me the courtesy of telling me of the situation. If I didn't bother to ask, who knows how long I would be waiting. Great pizza, not at all good service or professionalism. IMHO. read more

Love the pizza, salads and pasta! Friendly fast and delicious! Best NY style pizza in DeLand!

Such an adorable area love the historic district the vibe is so relaxing & welcoming the servers are very knowledgeable & helpful! Pretty quick service for it being a sit down & eat kind of restaurant also AMAZING FOOD! 10/10 read more

Pizza is my favorite food, and Anthony's has some pretty good pizza! But what takes the cake is their giant garlic knots! Loaded with garlic and olive oil and paired with their amazing marinara sauce, they have become a family favorite! This visit I had a half cheese and half bacon pie which was cooked perfectly with minimal flop (pizza fans know what that means). We were a party of 7 and called ahead and we're assured we would have seating available. Inside is small so be mindful if you have a large party, there's really one big section/booth. Our server was attentive and helpful throughout our visit. Prices are average for a pizzeria but the options are endless. I recommend stopping in or ordering ahead and picking up if you're in the mood for some almost NY like pizza! read more

Anthony's Pizza - Cheese and bacon - Pizza Near Me - DeLand, Florida

See all

Not happy about the 3% surcharge for credit cards. Nobody uses cash anymore and it's dangerous to carry cash. read more

Saw some lower reviews on here but still thought we'd give it a try. We got garlic knots and pizza for lunch and I thought everything was pretty good. read more

AWESOME LUNCH Specials! SAD Wait Service, even though Kitchen kept the food coming out! I DIDN'T feel TOTALLY comfortable with their plan for COVID Table Distancing. I WILL ONLY CONSIDER future requests which INCLUDE SOCIAL DISTANCING. Thanks. I Visit DeLand for weekly appointments and try to explore favorite Lunch Spots + SUPPORT LOCAL! Places change WEEKLY. Honestly, would return just for the homemade Wedding Soup! OMG! There's a LUNCH SPECIAL (at TODAY'S POSTING) you can get 1/2 Sub + SOUP! OMG! Delicious. GET in here for some AFFORDABLE + EVERY DAY DELICIOUSNESS! YUM! read more

Shey S was awesome. Definitely recommending. Great pizza. Will definitely be coming back

I love their calamari spicy sauce and pizza( Hawaiian). Their oven is nicely seasoned to bring out the flavors you love in your pizza. Would recommend for pizza lovers. read more

We usually always order take out from Anthony's and it's always great but for my birthday we decided to eat in at the restaurant and our waitress Sierra really made the entire meal a special one! She was the best waitress we have ever had and the food was amazing as usual! We will be eating in more often! I highly recommend this restaurant and the pizza is just like New York pizza! Best in town. read more

Had dinner with Dad. We enjoyed our dinner eggplant parmigiana , fried mushrooms,garlic knots Shayla did a great job. read more

Anthony's Pizza - Eggplant Parmesan - Pizza Near Me - DeLand, Florida

I dropped in to order 2 slices to go. The girl who took my order was friendly and said my slices would be ready in 5 minutes. I sat down and while waiting the cook's were chatting it up and another girl came up and sprayed cleaner in empty spaces of the display cabinet right above the pizza I had ordered. I approached the cashier and asked her to cancel my order as I was concerned about the spraying of chemicals near the pizzas. Still friendly she said she had to get a manager to do so. The manager that came out and gave me the voided receipt and said here's your proof its voided. No I'm sorry. No acknowledgement of my concern. And the only amount of customer service I received was from the cashier as the cooks were still talking and had yet to start warming up my over priced already previously cooked and contaminated slices. read more

Very disappointed in service. My husband ordered an egg plant dinner to bring home and we live 25 minutes from restaurant. When he got home it was an egg plant sub. We called them and there was nothing they could do. No manager interaction. No apology. The place was practically empty and I understand why. I'm read more

Used to be my favorite place to go with my Dad, but their service died with him. Last visit we walked out because we waited and waited for service, then our server was rude. Thanks to our last experience, I tried a new place down the street, which is even better and the servers are nice despite the lunch rush. read more

Ordered a sixteen I ch pizza with extra cheese and a godfather sub. Pizza was BLACK on the bottom, regular cheese - not extra. Sandwich bread was cut all the way through making it so hard to eat. This place has gone way down. Will never return. read more

Ordering was very easy. We bought a 16 inch cheese, half pepperoni pizza and an order of garlic notes. Our total was $20.24 which wasn't bad to feed 3 people. It could feet 3 adults and a small child too. It was delicious and hands down some of the best crust and pizza sauce I've tasted. They where the only pizza place we wanted to try in Deland that was open on 1. Sunday and 2. Before 4:00 p.m. I will defiantly be a returning customer when I am in this town. read more

Anthony's Pizza - Far lic Knots (6) - Pizza Near Me - DeLand, Florida

See all

I walked in to get 2 slices of pizza to go and walked right out! Now, as of late, they want to charge you an extra 3% if you don't pay cash! This greedy restaurant will not get business from me ever again! Good way to go out of business! read more

Food was great, price was alright, portions where large! Overall had a wonderful experience! read more

See all

Bronx pizza was closed so we ordered from Anthony's. Pretty expensive for what you get, and the pizza was way over salty. Ok so I just ate the last leftover slice and it was like eating a box of salt. Could barely taste the ingredients for the salt. Whoever started working there that changed the dough recipe, please change it back and resign. read more

Mediocre pizza and hoagies, absolutely terrible service. my father ordered ahead, and when we arrived we decided that we would just eat at the restaurant. it was a slow Thursday night and only two tables were occupied, but we were told that we could not eat in restaurant we had ordered by phone. I understand that policy on a busy Friday or Saturday night, but they literally had eight or nine tables open. Attempts to reason with them fell on deaf ears. From the cashier all the way to the manager, all they could say was "it's our policy". Congratulations Anthony's Pizza, your policy has lost you a weekly customer and resulted in a bad review on yelp. read more

So disappointed, sat us down order our meal... waitress came back 15 minutes later to tell us no dinners are served due to them doing a catering. They should have told us prior to taking our order... felt like it was a bait and switch...so upsetting read more

We arrived over two and a half hrs before closing. They had no garlic knots but could order cheesy garlic bread for $2 more than knots and like everyone else in there we did and it arrived to the table burnt on bottom. I ordered 2 slices of pepperoni pizza and was told they were out of pep slices for the night but could order a medium for myself and take the rest homeand we did. We also ordered two sweet teas when we sat. So when the pizza arrives the server tells us there now out of sweet tea WTH is going on here? This place forces you to spend extra money once your in. $7 for two teas they couldn't refill,one piece bread each and 2 slices each rest to trash $40 read more

Anthony's Pizza - a closeup of a pizza - Pizza Near Me - DeLand, Florida

3.5 stars A new pizzeria has opened in Deland. They have a Italian-American Brooklyn vibe. I order the chicken cacciatore. The sauce was excellent and flavorful. The chicken was served on angel hair pasta and surrounded by onions, peppers and mushrooms. Sadly, the chicken was rubbery and slightly burnt on the edges. I did like the pizza; it was thin and crispy. The service was okay. The waitress wasn't personable, although, I would blame it on the fact that they're still new. They seem like they are still trying to figure things out. read more

See all

They couldn't even get my order correct which was even written on the receipt! Supreme pizza with meatballs and olives added and all we got was meatballs and olives!! It was terrible!! The only apology was that they offered a 25% discount, I wouldn't go back if the pizza was free!!! They didn't even offer to make it right!! I just don't understand businesses nowadays. read more

This place used to be great but has gone down hill the last several months. No A/C in the restaurant and awful service. Went to pick up 2 pizzas and garlic knots yesterday. Got to the place and the garlic knots weren't ready but the pizza was. Waited 10 minutes for the knots. Asked if the Pizza was still hot and they said they kept it on a heater. Got home 5 minutes later and pizza was ice cold. Went back to restaurant to complain and the cook yelled at my father in law blaming us. Said it's not their fault we showed up late. Keep in mind we showed up on time and the garlic knots weren't ready. Guy was totally unprofessional and told us not to come back after giving us new Pizzas. What a way to treat customers who have gone there for 3 years. The cook is getting his wish because me and my family aren't returning. read more

So disappointed, again! When I eat in the restaurant, the food is good. But every single time I get take out, it is horrible!!! The sausage was so dry! Disgusting! the pizza, raw dough. $25.00 for an inedible pizza. Alfredo, hardly any sauce. Steak and cheese sub, Meat only on half and very small amount. Sorry Anthony's! Your loss!! I've tried giving you chance after chance. You started out strong, but lost it! read more

Anthony's Pizza - My dog won't even eat the dry disgusting sausage! - Pizza Near Me - DeLand, Florida

The one star I give this place is based solely on the management and the wait staff. Although they have decent food their customer service needs a lot of work. The management at this establishment needs to go back and take some new management classes and learn how to speak to customers. As well as a class on how to handle mistakes THEY MAKE when it comes to customer orders. Poor management leads to poor staff. It's sad because I've been coming to this place for years and over the past year this place has gone downhill with their management and wait staff. Hopefully this place can turn themselves around and realize what's needs to be done. It's a shame really, because the food is decent but the people and individuals who work there make it really hard to come back because of their poor attitudes and lack of customer service. A simple mistake could have been fixed but because of their lack of customer service and their poor management they would rather be negative then be positive. Decent food, extremely poor service. read more

Pretty Good. Not Great. Pizza and Garlic Knots were a little greasy.... Pictured is The All Meat Pizza & The Margarita Pizza.... read more

Anthony's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - DeLand, Florida

We go to Anthony's about once every couple of weeks. While the prices have recently skyrocketed (over $70 for 3 pizzas) they are still one of the best in town! As for their entrees and salads, you won't be disappointed! read more

So, In the time of Covid and quarantines and social distancing, more than anything we've craved Italian food. For me, it's an Anthony's calzone I crave! My husband indulges me and stops by Anthony's to pick up calzones on the way home from work and we tear into them like starving wild animals! Try them, you'll like them! read more

I was here yesterday and as soon as you walk through the door you notice how hot and muggy the restaurant is. We asked the girl if she could put on the air. She replied by saying "it's on but the door keeps opening". Food was mediocre at best. read more

wish i could give 0 stars. terrible service. even WORSE prices and food. pizza was awful tasting, lacking sauce and the sauce was only towards the crust, yuck! under carriage was not well and was very floppy. Pizza was greasy. i spent $75! on 2 large thin and crispy pizzas, 1 cannoli, and some zeppoles. i'm italian use to eating new york/ chicago stone cooked pizza. this isn't it. don't recommend feel like i got scammed. read more

Anthony's Pizza - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - DeLand, Florida

See all

Absolutely disgusting!!! This was my first time eating at Anthony's and it will be my last. I had my order made to go due to having two toddlers. I got home to find my tiramisu with white, fuzzy mold on top, along, with hairs surrounding the dessert. Spoke with the manager and she offered to replace it with a new slice. If you look close enough you can see the hairs in the pan above the dessert read more

Anthony's Pizza - Absolutely disgusting!! tiramisu had white, fuzzy mold and look close enough the hairs in the pan above. - Pizza Near Me - DeLand, Florida

See all

Typical bait and switch; charged us 10.00 more on a takeout order than what was advertised on menu prices. Food was good, I cannot deny that. But the person who took the order nor the manager were available at the time of pick up. read more

I love this place, I've been frequenting there Casselberry location for over 15 years, glad to see a location closer to home, I recommend the Sicilian slice, a side of meatballs and garlic bread! Update; 09/28/2018 Just went into Anthony's for two slices, one NY style pepperoni and then I noticed a sheet of square pepperoni slices so I asked for a slice of that as my second, the heavy set girl behind the counter was very short and did not look to be very customer friendly today. When I got my order and proceeded to eat it the square pepperoni slice had SOOOOOO much grease literally draining off it it was stomach turning disgusting, I literally have a stomach ache now.... read more

Anthony's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - DeLand, Florida

No social distancing, cook not wearing a mask and one of the girls at the counter with her mask down under her nose. Their pies are normally good, but they lost my business for lack of Covid safety protocol for their customers and the people that work there read more

I would give a 0 if I could. Our waitress, Jaden, never came back to the table once after bringing our pizza. I tried to get her attention a few times especially since the fact that my pizza was burnt as you will see from the pictures I will post. She tries to tell these so-called person on duty, Anthony, the owner's son supposedly and he gives two rats asses. I explained I wasn't looking for a free meal I will pay for the food since I am going to take it home. I wanted to knowledge that there's an issue. Someone else complained that evening also. He's like oh it's acknowledged. He's just an ass and I will never go back. I will continue to give Angelina's my business as they've been around for years and years and years and have never been rude. I don't know why I ever tried a new place like this especially after reading some of their reviews. read more

See all

Worst pizza I have had in a long time. Cold and tasted like it was thrown together in 30 seconds. No spices. No flavor. They are so busy that they have forgotten to put the love into their food. I had to sprinkle some garlic powder on it then microwave it just to make it somewhat acceptable. read more