Stopped in and was very surprised how much inventory in what appears as a small storefront! I had the chance to talk to the owner and visit her adorable pup Jasmine! Owner is negotiable on pricing and I found a few things but be prepared there is a lot to look at so give yourself about an hour to look around. I ll definitely be back! read more

The posted hours are 10-5. I make the trip down from central Naples and arrive just around 11:15. The neon sign in the window is on indicating the shop is open and the outdoor music is blaring....but the door is locked. another couple arrive coming from further north to also be disappointed. I finally ask the business next door and the person working informs me that she just comes and goes. No notice on the door saying if or when she will return. Must not need to work... so disappointing. read more

Hours are posted, lights are on and OPEN sign lit but nobody ever there. I have tried 5 times to visit store. I would not recommend.

This store looks wonderful but like other stores they use fragrances in the store so we can't shop here. Some people have allergies to chemicals so hopefully this info helps more businesses to omit perfumes and room sprays, which are toxic to some people. read more

I happen to go into Another Man's Treasure last year. What a fabulous find it was. You will love Susan the owner and all the lovely items in the store. We found 2 beautiful beveled mirrors for above our vanity and most recently 2 club chairs for our wine room. A huge selection so be sure to give yourself time to find that perfect piece. read more

Do not ever use! I bought a house unseen - my mistake- staged by this. They charged me 15k for all the furnishings and never disclosed it was consignment or garage sale quality. I asked repeatedly about the mattresses as new was top priority and was assured all were new only to see hairs and totally scuffed corners on the mattress. More horrifying was the response 'I'm so sorry we don't know where that mattress came from. Yikes! On top of all of it when I just sold this staged house people came in saying she was shady....but read more

This is a great shop if you're looking for items to decorate/furnish your home or business. The owner, Susan, and her staff are a pleasure to deal with and, if you come ready to buy multiple items, they are willing to negotiate better pricing. She says she is ever on the lookout for quality estate sales and is constantly scouring and curating her inventory. Art, furniture, drapes, books, curios, bric-a-brac, jewelry; this place has a little of everything. Plenty of other places to visit near the area as well, e.g. Garden District, Bargain Box, Options, and several other consignment shops all within a couple blocks from each other. Great,friendly customer service, competitive pricing, constantly-changing inventory!!! Don't forget to take a look inside their back warehouse in a separate building also. read more

See all

Leave yourself lots of time to browse this gem. Lots of interesting items in good shape. The owner is friendly and helpful and up for a reasonable negotiation. She has trees in good shape, something I've found hard to find. Items are well chosen and you can see this is a passion for this shop owner. read more

Ok. We wandered into here with no expectations and three hours later we filled the house with treasures. Susan was an amazing help as she continued to show us things that made sense and had a better creative mind to put things together than we would've ever thought of. The prices were fantastic and we got a discount because we bought such a volume. Ask for Jasmin And you will get a 2% discount! read more

I was welcomed and serviced by Susan and she was very professional- including carrying my purchase to my car. I recommend this shop. read more

Another Mans Treasures - A coat / umbrella stand. Perfect for my entrance way. - Antiques Near Me - Naples, Florida

So happy I found this place via Yelp. The place has a fun vibe, is stocked with items, and has a wide variety of decor styles. Susan, the owner, is personable and helpful. I bought 2 slipper chairs and a table and Susan put everything into my SUV. When I went back inside to pay she gave me a discount without my asking. I'll definitely go back. read more

Shop is clean and neat compared to other antique shops. Susan and Manny are nice and helpful. Owner is in shop working and helping customers. Always nice to see owners putting in the work. Wife likes the cute dog that lays by the front door and greats you. There was a nice old round table we wanted but didn't have our truck. Living on the East coast it wasn't feasible to buy. Plus it wouldn't fit in our car. Not strapping that to the roof. Prices are good not jacked up. read more

Great antique store with excellent prices. Purchased an art glass platter and got it for nearly half price. Wonderful, nice staff. Huge place. Half of it is air conditioned and half isn't, kinda hot, but it has its charm. There is also an annex out back with more furniture unaircondioned. It is alright, but in the summer it is very hot in the building. Huge selection of furniture, art, glass, antiques, collectibles, lamps, etc. Been around forever and right on 10th in downtown Naples. Fun place for antiquing. Two levels and kinda winds around. Just a great place for a find. read more

Disappointing as far as anything unique or funky. This felt more like Bealls outlet & the prices are high for the quality

Based on a review posted earlier this month, I dropped in to this shop looking for an occasional table and lamp. Susan was very helpful, and looked at a photo of two arm chairs I was hoping to accent with the table. She had several of a style that would complement the chairs, and recommended one--which she cleaned and polished on the spot. I also found a nice table lamp in the same style. She gave me a good price on the two pieces. She has a number of nice pieces of furniture, so if you are looking for good prices, be sure to pop in. My only complaint was that neither she nor the other shoppers wore masks and she had no hand sanitizer at the entrance. I was very surprised to see that there was no signage, requesting customers to mask, either. read more

+'s * Over the years (old location, new location, and on Marco) my friends and I have consistently find treasures there. You never know what new items are going to be there - it's a treasure hunt. * The stores are spotless - not like some consignment stores. * Items are well priced - KEY! * Staff is super friendly and are there to help you find things. * Excellent quality merchandise - Theodore Alexander, Wedgwood, Waterford, good quality antiques. -'s Only minus is that the store is a little hard to see - it's set back in a strip mall and you often pass it on 41 before you see it. ways something new at the store so I stop by often. Many of read more

Don't know what the shopping experience is there but from the consignors viewpoint, this is not a good experience. Sent a lot of things there for consignment (first time doing it) and only received payment for 3 items out of about 30 things total. It cost me more to have them delivered there than the payment I received. Won't be doing that again! read more

Just the best service here and super friendly staff. I happened to go on a sale day and was thrilled with several little purchases but got a desk and a server which is why I went. Try even held the server for a month until I had a u haul for a move yesterday. Had a scuffle with a grumpy customer because I got the desk before she did, but staff was very professional and reasonable with the uncomfortable situation. The selection of this place is amazing. I know they are moving east a bit in November, but I'm excited because it's a little closer to my place. Love the diversity. read more

This store cheated me. They sold two of my chairs for the price of one, and a third chair I have never received payment for. I am considering taking her to court. read more

I have been to the Marco Island and Naples location. I can't say how much I really love these two locations. I have bought several pieces from Susan the owner (by the way she even delivered pieces to me at my home in her own car when they did not fit in my car). What owner does that --- goes that extra mile. Others would say -- get a mover. Not Susan. She is very personable and honest!!!!!! And her staff are amazing!!!! If you have the chance and you need something for your home, "Another Mans Treasure" is the place to go. You will not be disappointed. read more

A wonderful consignment shop tucked into a small shopping center in East Naples. Beautiful furniture, art, home decor items, and unusual treasures can be found, watched over by the owner, Susan Thomas, a soft-spoken, charming woman who is never too busy to give you her personal attention. I could have spent hours looking around but decided that I will make frequent shorter stops to see what new finds will catch my attention. Hopefully, I will never leave there empty handed!! Love, love, love!!! read more

Don't put anything in consignment here! I brought over 20 items to sell as we were moving from Naples. I had to call and pester them repeatedly to get my monthly check. The excuses were ridiculous - didn't have stamps, owner didn't sign the checks, on and on. When they did send it, the check was at least a month overdue. They sold nine items and I was never contacted about the remainder. Now no one answers the phone. Very crooked business dealings. read more

Stopped by to snoop around. Nice eclectic variety of quality furniture, crystal, decorative pieces, etc etc. Friendly casual salesperson, helpful and low pressure. Great prices ! If I lived here, we'd be buying here! read more

First time in and I will be a regular! The variety of home decor is amazing and the prices are fair for the outstanding quality. And to top it off the staff is amazing and helpful suggesting items and pointing out great deals....this is a definite must see when you are in Naples. read more

This is the most unprofessional "company" I have ever dealt with. I called and represented I had several things to consign. I scheduled Monday morning at 9:30. I took off of work to accommodate the pick-up time. The fellow showed up 20 minutes late and was driving a white pick-up truck. I met him and told him that I had sold the majority of the items yesterday - by luck- but I still had a very large oak desk/console and chair. When he heard that not all items were available, he stormed out of my house - without looking at the desk and chair - which I doubt would have fit into his pick-up truck - told me he had better things to do with his time and said that I was a liar. I do not recommend this company to anyone. Their lack of professionalism and respect is quite shocking. The website claims to offer cash, consign and many other things. PLEASE do NOT use this unprofessional company. I have never been treated so poorly. I did write to the owner of the company and have not heard back........ read more