Another Mans Treasures

I had seen this consignment store on social media and knew when I went back home to Naples I knew I…read moreneeded to check it out. This is not your typical consignment store and is filled with high end luxury brands which is nice. This store though is on the high end but if you are looking for a retired designer item this store is your best bet for finding. Every nook and cranny is filled with designer high end brands. Didn't buy anything on the visit but was nice to dream and drool.... Store carries designer clothing, shoes, jewelry, and purses.

Sally was not helpful in my friends purchase. She was laughing as we asked for assistance and was…read morebelittling as a response

See all

Twice As Nice Consignment Shop

4.2(22 reviews)

Pleasant staff, wide assortment of carefully worn upscale clothes, congenial atmosphere, honest…read moreconsigning practices.

This is my favorite consignment shop in Naples! They always have great shoes and bags! Lots of…read morehidden gems here!! Staff is always very helpful and prices are great!

Octopus pin

See all

Happily Ever After Consignment

3.0(4 reviews)

I come to your stores every weekend and every time I go I always find a few things especially at…read morethe north store and James is great very helpful with everything great customer service I will definitely keep shopping at both locations..Thank you. Sincerely. Dom

The staff at this business is the worst I've encountered in awhile ...I was told about the great…read moreselection of men's gently used clothing...while I was shopping at the downtown location a sales women was assisting someone who was interested in consigning . She was beyond rude and I was so put off by her nasty attitude..then another customer came into the shop and again her nasty attitude had me so upset I left ...so the owner should know about her staff or get a camera to watch how she interacts with customers ...I'm sure she would be fired immediately

The Difference! Never call us a THRIFT shop..

Paying Consigners fair prices

See all

True Fashionistas

3.2(93 reviews)

10.3 mi

I stop here every time I'm Naples and I always find something great. The prices are a mixed bag -…read moremost items are reasonably priced but I think some others are overpriced. The store is bright, clean and very well organized. It feels fun to shop there. Much like the prices, the staff is also a mixed bag. Some employees were super nice but others felt like they couldn't be bothered. That being said, I do enjoy shopping there.

I am not usually a consignment store shopper, but I do love Lilly Pulitzer. I heard that True…read moreFashionistas had a huge Lilly collection so I went along with my mom and sister when they were shopping. I was delighted to see that they had several racks devoted to just Lilly Pulitzer clothing. As usual, there were many items in sizes ranging 0 to 4, and not quite as much of a selection in larger sizes. I was able to find a few size medium dresses and I ended up purchasing one. I found the staff at the fitting rooms, and the checkout counter to be helpful and friendly. In addition to the Lily clothing, there are racks and racks and racks of other clothing items. It is literally the size of a department store! They also have an entire wall of shoes and a section devoted to furniture and small household items. I didn't have time to shop too much more because we were there literally 20 minutes before closing, but I will be back the next time. I'm in Naples.

Effortlessly chic and easy to wear! This navy striped poncho paired with denim creates a flattering look for brunch, weekends...

Find your feel-good look at True Fashionistas Designer Resale in Naples, FL. Explore flattering dresses, statement earrings, ...

See all

The smartest shoppers know luxury doesn't have to come with a luxury price tag. Discover thousands of pre-owned designer piec...

The Salvation Army

4.0(24 reviews)

3.6 mi

•$$$$

I have never been in a Salvation Army Thrift Store that is identified as super expensive, I'm…read moretalking about $$$$ prices! So we had to check it out! This is an affluent area of older, retired people who maybe get tired of their things or want a change or have passed away and their items are donated. The operative word is DONATED so the money can be used for the non-profit mission Salvation Army does....BUT what I saw was over priced if not full priced items for sale! Shame on management there...your goal should to be to sell everything that is donated at less then "reasonable" priced 2nd hand, thrift store prices! If it is not sold in 4-6 months you priced it TOO high! You are not a retail store, price it accordingly!! Do the good work people think you are doing thus we donate to you instead of Goodwill!

Incredible! Not the Salvation Army you are used to, more of a mash-up between a high-end…read moreconsignment store (but without the consignment aspect) and a Junior League resale, this store has excellent furniture, homewares, decor, and apparel. Name brands from all of the best department and upscale stores: Saks, Nordstrom, Neiman Marcus, Lilly Pulitzer, St. John. There is smaller store in the shopping mall to the east that has a more traditional thrift layout and more run of the mill merchandise. Prices: commensurate with the high dollar value of the items for sale. No real "bargains" here, but you will pay about 50% to 80% less for these items. Case in point, a St. John beaded knit dress for $90 that likely originally retailed for $500 or more. The rich old people of Naples have to kick the bucket some time, and it looks like a lot of their stuff ends up here. This would be a frequent haunt of mine if I lived in the area just for browsing alone! Note: if you look hard enough, you can find some exquisite vintage clothing and a few nice pieces of Danish MCM furniture. And an Enchanted Tiki Room-themed display.

$59. Has some issues but does the job of getting from A to B

Not for sale?!? I would have bought everything on that shelf!

See all

Bargain Box

4.7(17 reviews)

1.7 mi

Opened in 1975, the Bargain Box is the oldest church mission thrift store in Naples, Florida…read more Almost 50 years strong, the store is run by volunteers from Naples United Church of Christ. Donated items are given to individuals and families in the community in need and profits are distributed through the church charities. To date they have donated more than $1 million to charities that provide human services locally and globally. They have also partnered with 30 local Collier County charities including Neighborhood Health Clinic, Healthcare Network of SW Florida, Meals of Hope, Baby Basics, Echo, Dental Outreach, Grace Place, Literacy Volunteers, and Habitat for Humanity. I was pleasantly surprised to see the store was much larger than I thought it would be from the outside. Several rooms are filled with gently used furniture, a ladies boutique with name brand and designer clothing, accessories, men's clothes, children's clothes, jewelry, art, holiday decorations, books, and more. Prices were great and I loved the selection of like new merchandise. The volunteers were so friendly. Furniture prices are negotiable and they were having an additional sale on select items. Hours are rather limited, they are only open Monday, Wednesday, and Friday from 10-3 so it makes it difficult to shop here if you have to work more traditional 9 to 5 weekday work hours. In any case I am glad that I finally got to stop in and support the great work that they do for this community.

The Bargain Box has an excellent variety of merchandise all at excellent prices. They have the…read morenicest most helpful volunteers anyone could ask for. This is definitely my very favorite thrift shop in the entire Naples/Bonita Springs area.

See all

Treasure Island Antiques

3.7(23 reviews)

4.8 mi

Oh my god seriously the prices of the stuff in this place in the thousands. Really it was nothing…read morespecial, I have the same kind of things in my house. Come on. And with the prices being as high and crazy as they are you would think someone would come and say something to you. No way not a place to visit while on vacation.

The prices here are ridiculous. Way more than the items are worth. Do a visual search before you…read morepurchase.

Racist statuettes displayed at Treasure Island Antiques.

Life size sheep

See all

Enamel box

Chelsea’s

5.0(2 reviews)

Beautifully displayed something for everyone loved all the vintage jewelry and furnitureread more

Chelsea's is located in an area of Naples filled with second hand stores. According to their…read moreFacebook page "Chelsea's Resale Shoppe carries furniture, pottery, jewelry, home decor, clothing and more. Located in the prestigious Design District, it's an artsy shop." Chelsea's had several rooms filled with home goods, furniture, art, decorative items, clothes, light fixtures, floral arrangements, pillows, and china. In addition to the second hand items they also sell hand made items from local artists. On the day I visited, everything was on sale except for the artist items. There were so many interesting things to look at here. Items were arranged together invitingly in rooms, so you could get design inspiration. It is definitely worth a stop if you are in the area.

See all

Gannon's Antiques and Art Center

4.1(43 reviews)

28.8 mi

Now that we have a new space in Westchester, we've been leveling it up little by little and thought…read morewe can bring a few art pieces back home. Gannon's, in Ft. Myers has a lot of that. Every booth here has something different with one-of-a-kind art and sculpture pieces. Prices are all mixed- but for the most part, be ready to spend a bag if you want the real standout pieces. If Gannon's your vibe, this is the spot for you.

Good place to shop for antiques. Would recommend when you're in the Ft Myers area. Something for…read moreeveryone.

Coca Cola memorabilia from times gone by

Treasures

See all

Dress Up

The Shelter Options Shoppe

4.2(26 reviews)

this is the best place in town. it's like a treaure hunt every time you go in there. it's a worthy…read morecause...and everyone is wonderful. thank you for my beautiful patio set.

They did a STUPID REPAIR !! Put it above a water heater on the outside of the wall !!…read more Owner said it couldn't be put back inside wall?? Why Not that's where it was??

See more unrecommended reviews

Glass platter

Cute purse

See all

Untitled

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

49 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Tami A.

5 years ago

I just recently moved to Naples and needed to furnish my whole apartment. When I walked into Another Mans Treasures I was in heaven! I knew immediately this was the place I'd find what I was looking for. Susan was such a pleasure from the first time we met and throughout my shopping experience, I feel like I've known her for years! I've only been in Naples for two weeks and have been to the store three times. Needless to say, my living room is fully furnished with the most beautiful pieces! And, btw, at very reasonable prices!! This store is a must see if you are in the Naples area! Oh, and Jazzy, Susan's adorable little dog, will greet you at the door and check in on you throughout your visit....she's a lovebug!! read more

Warren S.

4 years ago

We went to this mall to visit a Cafe we'd read about, only to find it closed. Not wanting to waste the trip we went into this business because it looked interesting. And we were not wrong or disappointed. A fantastic collection of just about anything and everything. We tried to look at it all but that's just impossible. Then we spotted the dresser we'd been looking for nearly ten months now. Right size. Right capacity. And most important. Right price. It was delivered today and it fit perfectly into the space. Susan even made the extra effort to make it look even better than it did on the showroom floor. So glad that Cafe was closed and we found this business, Susan and our new dresser. read more

Alyssa T.

4 years ago

We were on vacation and decided to stop by because of the great reviews and we love antiques! This store did not disappoint. The merchandise is great quality and very reasonably priced! We bought more than I thought we would, but the prices were so reasonable! Susan the owner was very friendly and made our 4 year daughter feel so comfortable and gave her little souvenirs which she loved. Two days later when we were about to leave the area, our daughter asked "can we go back to another man's treasures?" It took me a moment to realize she was referring to this store she had such a great time in, that she remembered a name that I probably only mentioned once driving there that day! read more

Erin K.

6 years ago

Susan was wonderful! I was looking for something very specific for my son's room. I inquired about items that might be in another location or store. Susan immediately shared with me a picture of a full size bed set with two drawers she had for sale, but was not located in the store. It was exactly what I had been looking for! She even assisted me in picking up the items and helping me deliver it to our home. She was friendly, professional and very accurate in her selection of furniture that would suit my son. Thank you Susan, he LOVES the new bed! I would highly recommend Susan and Another Mans Treasures in Naples for quality furniture and exceptional customer service. read more

D. M.

5 years ago

I just moved to Naples with little to no furniture and have been hitting all the consignment stores on a regular basis. Another Man's Treasure is one of the best. Susan has a collection of pieces that are artfully arranged with care and they are of good quality. No junk! She also has a great design eye and helped me choose a bedside table for our guest room. I trusted her opinion and it looks fantastic!! Thank you, Susan. Most of the items in the shop have prices that are negotiable too. Lastly, when we were loading up our goodies she brought us ice cold water bottles. I look forward to continuing to frequent this shop as more treasures come in. read more

Ali B.

6 years ago

Another mans treasure is an absolute gem! Susan has an incredible collection of pieces that is ever changing! So there are always new pieces to discover and fall in love with. The store is thoughtfully organized and styled, which really inspires and gives you an idea of how pieces fit and work together. This is a true testament to how talented Susan is. On top of the amazing selection Sufism herself is a joy to work with. She is super knowledgeable and makes you feel right at home. I can't recommend her incredible store enough. It is a must visit! read more

Diana K.

6 years ago

We were fortunate to find this great consignment shop while wintering in Naples, Fl. They shop is chuck full of great finds in styles to suit various tastes and design. Products were all in good condition, The owner was on site and had a very good design eye. She helped us to select a lovely contemporary, handmade metal fish sculpture that will be used to fill in an empty space in our kitchen. I will post a picture of it when it is home and in its place of honor. I highly recommend a visit to Another Mans Treasures! read more

Carla S.

5 years ago

I had a tricky design problem to solve with unique chairs from South Africa that I love. I'd been watching Susan's photos online and would swing thru occasionally. But one weekend, Suzy found the PERFECT set up as we played around with design ideas and brainstormed together. I loved working with her, and am SO happy with the result, I can't stop glowing about my new couch, table, lamp, and overall newness! Thank you so much, Suzy, you are the very best!! I highly recommend Another MANS Treasure. read more

Kat C.

5 years ago

We love this shop!!! Susan's enthusiasm for all things beautiful & repurposed is contagious! Always fun and so much to see! we kept finding more great items for our condo, after 3 trips back to the register for more treasures we spotted we finally made it out the front door. Such a fun Shop!! and her little dog is so adorable!! These are just a couple of the treasure we collected while browsing this trip :) Thanks Susan!!! We'll be seeing you again!!! read more

Eyes O.

5 years ago

I love perusing in this shop. There are so many interesting and unique things in there, and in good condition. The owner is a joy to be around, she is so pleasant and creates a very welcoming atmosphere. She is helpful and willing to negotiate on prices. I treasure everything I've ever picked up from this shop, they all add an interesting touch to my home. This shop is definitely worth a look. read more

Annmarie P.

5 years ago

I absolutely Love going to Another Mans Treasure!! You just never know what you're going to find!! Today my husband and I walked in and found this crazy Alligator.. we had to bring him home with us!! Alex the Alligator.. loves his new home! You have to take your time walking around for sure.. there are so many amazing things in all the Nooks and crannies of the store! read more

Ellen B.

6 years ago

Great place to find wonderful additions to your home, condo or apartment. The inventory changes often so if you see something you love, buy it that day so you aren't disappointed when you return. Susan, the owner is energetic and loves helping her clients. If you love consignment shopping, be sure and stop by and see the large showroom. read more

Monica S.

6 years ago

Susan was refreshing to meet. Friendly professional and definitely knows her business. Guided me through a purchase for the style I needed in my home. Loved the experience so much I've now consigned some of my furniture. You've got to see this splendid shop!!! Love love love! Not stuffy. Eclectic mix and priced reasonable. read more

John M.

5 years ago

Another Man's Treasure is one of those stores which is a pleasure to browse in. Look hard enough and you are likely to find a item or two that you wish to take home. Best of all Susan, the owner, whose good cheer is positively contagious and who is a source of unfailing good advice. You will definitely want to return. read more

Susan V.

5 years ago

Fantastic shop! A great variety--lamps, rugs, tables, ottomans, furniture, you name it Susan, the owner has it--in great shape and reasonably priced. Susan's energy and flair for design makes for a great shopping experience. I found the perfect desk for us after months of looking. And her dog...don't get me started. read more

Noelle L.

5 years ago

Susan is so charming and helpful. She has an amazing selection of things to chose from. She greeted us with a smile and and had great ideas and suggestions for what we were looking for. I highly recommend you take some time to visit this store if you are looking for furniture or decorating ideas. read more

Michael B.

6 years ago

Always a pleasure doing business here. Susan's personality is off the charts. Great variety of owned and consignment item. I unfortunately find more than I intended during every visit. Items are priced well and if you are nice and haggle a bit you can sometimes save. Highly recommend. read more

David K.

114

525

897

2 years ago

When you have hours on your door and your stereo is blaring, and your sign says open, but you have a locked door, you are certain to go out of business soon. Another wasted trip to this disappointing business. She must be wealthy in order to pay this rent and never do any business. read more

Idalia S.

7 years ago

Walked into this location to browse, found a loveseat in almost as new condition. Not only was it at half price, but manny accommodated me not only so that it would fit my budget but also in the delivery. Personalized, friendly, and accommodating. Absolutely LOVE THE STAFF!!!! read more

John S.

5 years ago

Susan is an absolute gem and this boutique is full of glorious and elegant home decor items. The layout of the space has a definite interior design element to it. A must visit and I look forward to visiting again when I come visit from Virginia. Thank you! read more

Another Mans Treasures - antiques - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Naples, Florida Restaurants near Another Mans Treasures

BEST of Naples, Florida Coffee near Another Mans Treasures

BEST of Naples, Florida Things to Do near Another Mans Treasures

BEST of Naples, Florida Thrift Stores near Another Mans Treasures

BEST of Naples, Florida Shopping near Another Mans Treasures

BEST of Naples, Florida Breakfast near Another Mans Treasures

BEST of Naples, Florida Hotels near Another Mans Treasures

Related Cost Guides

Florists

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Another Mans Treasures also viewed

Audrey's

3.9

(42 reviews)

Sally was not helpful in my friends purchase. She was laughing as we asked for assistance and was…read morebelittling as a response

The Shelter Options Shoppe

4.2

(26 reviews)

this is the best place in town. it's like a treaure hunt every time you go in there. it's a worthy…read morecause...and everyone is wonderful. thank you for my beautiful patio set.

They did a STUPID REPAIR !! Put it above a water heater on the outside of the wall !!…read more Owner said it couldn't be put back inside wall?? Why Not that's where it was??

Serena & Lily

4.7

(6 reviews)

Serena and Lily in Naples is beautiful and has many samples in store. The staff is also amazing.read more

The associates are engaging, warm and knowledgeable about their merchandise. I loved working with…read moreAshley. She's a sweetheart but everyone is wonderful there. The have beautiful things for the coastal vibe.

Home and Salvage

4.7

(15 reviews)

I LOVE this shop! So many beautiful and cool pieces! I also love that you can have it at your…read morehome fast.... The girls that work there are always accommodating and the Owner is so nice! It's a busy place and if you haven't been there, GO!! Alice Roof

Was lucky enough to come across this gem of a store full of goodies. Susan was amazing at giving…read moreus advice and suggestions. This will definitely be a frequent stop as I love seeing all the new things that come in. You can't go wrong - ask for Susan she's a keeper!!

Designer Consignor of Naples

4.0

(4 reviews)

I discovered this adorable consignment boutique in the St. Andrew's Square plaza on a recent…read morethrifting trip to Naples. Inside the store is attractively arranged clothing and accessories. Some of the brand names I saw included Louis Vuitton, Coach, Kate Spade, Prada, Chanel, and a large selection of Lily Pulitzer. The owner Bonnie was very friendly and she explained to me how the pricing works. Clothing is priced based on how long it is in the shop. A Patricia Nash purse I liked was priced at $129 but if it is still here in December it will sell for $90. If you can't make it to the store in person the Designer Consignor Consignment has an Instagram account you can follow that features some of their best items including that turquoise leather purse. Another adorable bag that caught my eye was beaded to look like a watermelon making it the perfect summer picnic outfit accessory. There is a dressing room area in the back of the store so you can try on clothes. They also sell shoes and other accessories. You can bring in your gentle used and mint designer items to sell for a split of the profits.

Purchased a LVUITTON BAG CLAIMED it was authentic even had a printed paper saying it was, when I…read moretook it to the repair store she said she uses, they said the bag was as fake as they come. When I went to return it she said there is no return, but I informed her this is a fake bag, she refunded the money she knew I meant buss. She knew it was fake. Read your contract before you sign before you buy OR sell anything. WARNING THEY HAVE FAKES....

Happily Ever After Consignment

3.0

(4 reviews)

Happily Ever After Consignment Boutique

3.7

(3 reviews)

I have been consigning with Happily Ever After and am VERY PLEASED with the results…read more Jennifer and her staff are always kind and professional. And I make good money. Consignment is a roll of the dice and certain items have been returned to me or donated. Not everything sells. But overall I am delighted that I have a venue to recoup a portion of the money I spent on clothes that I no longer wear. Closet space is valuable real estate.

Here's an idea--if you're posted hours have you closing at 5 pm, maybe you shouldn't close before…read morethen? Needed to swing in to pick up one item, but door was locked at least 10 minutes early. Staff inside just stared back at me when I tried the door. Ick.

Gretchen Scott

3.6

(8 reviews)

Gretchen Scott is a beautiful store. Upon entering, the courteous employee asked my daughter and I…read morewhat we would like to drink. We each enjoyed a glass of wine. They have a nice and comfortable area for men ro relax and wait for their significant others. They have so many nice dresses and accessories. I saw some purses that were from Barcelona. They were reasonably priced. I purchased one and am very happy with it. I would say the only negative I sww is that some areas of the store are pretty cluttered. This made it hard to walk through those areas. If you are on 3rd Street, I would suggest stopping here. They have a lot to look at.

I shopped this store before COVID and purchased 8 beautiful dresses...So sad to see this store of…read moreGretchen Scott clothing have absolutely NO CUSTOMER SERVICE!I was there this afternoon around 3:00...Perhaps teach your employees to say a nice hello when a customer comes into the store, ask if they need any help...but sadly no one approached me to say anything...there was one other customer in the store...and they could not be bothered!! I won't be back! I can spend my money elsewhere!! Good luck staying in business...you'll need it!!

Petunias of Naples

4.5

(13 reviews)