We were so glad we booked our stay across the street at Tranquility Bay Resort because it led us to…read morethis gem! This restaurant is an absolute MUST if you're visiting Marathon. Whether you're looking for a relaxing breakfast or a delicious dinner, this is the place to go. We ordered the omelets, which were fantastic, and they came with fresh Cuban-style bread that was absolutely delicious. Pair that with a café con leche, and you have the perfect start to your day. What made the experience even better was the hospitality. The owner, Kenia, came out to visit with us and made us feel genuinely welcome. Our server, Claudia, was an absolute delight, friendly, attentive, and full of positive energy. The food and service were so good that we ate breakfast here twice during our vacation, and we're coming back for dinner tonight. That's probably the best recommendation we can give! If you're anywhere near Tranquility Bay or just passing through Marathon, don't miss this place. Great food, wonderful people, and the kind of welcoming atmosphere that keeps you coming back.

Nice cafeteria with authentic Cuban food staff arguing with each other in a very collegial Cuban…read moremanner Very tasty that's what we ordered on the way back home very traditional. Pan con busted is tasty but had very fatty meat used when pm cooked has fat on the edges A few tables and bar seats inside and various tables outdoor.

We stayed at the host resort (Tranquility Bay), so we ate here often. It was consistently…read moregreat--fresh + delicious food, friendly and fast service, and beautiful atmosphere. I LOVED the Butterfly Risotto. The Filet Mignon was delish, and you can get it with lime cilantro butter or blue cheese crumbles or sautéed onions. Their key lime cheesecake is the best in the area--and it's gluten free! They also have an amazing flourless chocolate cake. They have plenty of gluten free options, and it is marked clearly on the menu. My only criticism is that the kids macaroni + cheese was made with fake cheese sauce sometimes (but once it was real). At a nice place with these prices, I expect real cheese ALL the time. I highly recommend Butterfly Cafe whether or not you stay at the resort. :)

We dined here 7/6/2025 at 8pm. Great ambiance, delicious food and amazing service by Anthony!…read morePosting this review a year later.... Found it in my drafts.

We have eaten here many times, which should tell you something, since KW has SO many options…read more We shared the Mahi bites, which was a lot, and my husband also had the fish sandwich while I had the blackened shrimp wrap. We both had side of fries. The Mahi bites app & dip were delicious. My blackened shrimp wrap was gigantic, easily shareable, in my opinion. His fish sandwich was sticking out of the bun on both sides. Everything was on par, as always. Even though we sat outside, this is one of the coolest restaurants, due to misters and giant fans. It's ambience is very casual, fun to people watch while eating, especially people stopping at the misters. Service is super efficient. It's

If I could give this place zero stars, I absolutely would…read more This has been one of the most disappointing and upsetting experiences I've ever had with a restaurant. On Saturday night, I ate a shrimp quesadilla here, and by Sunday morning I was violently sick. I had nonstop vomiting and severe liquid diarrhea for hours, couldn't keep down even tiny sips of water or Pedialyte, and the cramping became so intense I could barely stand or walk without help. Things got so bad that by Sunday evening I ended up in the emergency room due to extreme dehydration. I needed IV fluids, medications, and hours of treatment. I was vomiting bile, hyperventilating, extremely weak, and dealing with muscle tingling and cramping from how dehydrated my body became. What makes me the most angry is that food poisoning is NOT something minor, especially when seafood is involved. Situations like this can become life-threatening, and restaurants should understand the seriousness and responsibility that comes with serving food safely. Nobody should go out to eat and end up in the hospital less than 24 hours later. Now I'm left dealing with recovery, stress, and expensive medical bills from an experience that should never have happened in the first place. I genuinely hope this restaurant immediately takes a serious look at its food handling and safety practices before someone else goes through something even worse. Lastly, if it were up to me, this place should be shut down until they can guarantee proper food safety standards. I will also be looking into taking legal action because nobody should have to go through something like this from simply going out to eat.

What a great find. The reviews on Yelp were very helpful. When we pulled in I wasn't sure what to…read moreexpect, from the outside it doesn't say this is the place. But, once you walk in the place is really cool. The food was excellent and the portions were shareable to say the least. The edamame and calamari was delicious. We shared the seafood special and they plated it individually for us. Be sure to ask about off menu items, there were a lot. Best part is we went on our second night in Marathon and we are already planning to return again before we leave. Great spot!

My wife gave the Escargot 4*, I gave it 3*. Mashed potatoes,…read more5* Duck, 3.5* Service, 3* Bananas Foster, 3*

I found Fisherman's Cafe after a not-so-great experience at one of the neighboring spots, and I'm…read moreglad I did. While waiting to order, I was able to browse the menu and decided on the shrimp and crab wrap with fries. The cashier answered all of my questions about the wrap, which made me feel confident in my choice. The wait wasn't long, especially since everything is made fresh. The fries came out hot and definitely needed a minute to cool down, and the wrap was warm on the outside while the inside stayed cool and fresh. Everything was tasty, and the pickle was a nice touch to round out the meal. Fisherman's is a small restaurant with limited seating, but there are several benches across the walkway where you can sit and enjoy your food while watching the boats and people nearby. A great, laid-back spot with a nice view.

Yes, please. Best little spot on the wharf next to Jimmy Buffets recording studio. No frills…read more Outdoor seating. Best blackened fish tacos Ive ever had. Cooked to order, friendly and fast. Cheap lunch time eats with options.

Okay... I don't say this lightly because I eat sushi all over the country for work -- different…read morecity, different restaurant, basically every week. But THIS?! This was next-level, "where-have-you-been-all-my-life" sushi. I'm talking fresh, melt-in-your-soul perfection. Every bite had me questioning whether I've actually had good sushi before today. The flavors were insane, the presentation was gorgeous, and the rolls came out looking like edible artwork on a slate plate. Honestly, if you're driving through the Keys and pass Mile Marker 30.5 without stopping here... that's a personal decision I cannot support. This place isn't just good. It's "text-your-friends-mid-meal," "dream-about-it-later," "plot-your-return-trip-before-dessert" good. Holy sushi heaven, Batman.

Stopped in for an early lunch and glad we did since the restaurant began to fill up about the time…read morethe food was delivered. The food was really good, especially the roll. On the lunch special. The banh mi sandwich was really fresh tasting with pork belly and fresh cucumber slices. The tiki vibe be is fun and our server was very good.

Food was ok. Nothing crazy good ! Sat where I could…read moreobserve kitchen prep and conditions ! Don't do this ! They need hygienic training. I know, I know every "greasy spoon" is like this. At least set a couple of spray bottles in view and wipe something down occasionally. If you wipe your brow use a paper towel ! I won't talk price because that wouldn't be fair because everything is crazy price in Key West. Except for Circle K. 44oz pop at soda fountain $1.06.

BOs is everything it needs to be quiet, quirky, and a good vibe. The food is pretty okay in my…read moreopinion and is convenient if you don't want to wait in the long lines for other places at lunch time. They were also open New Years Day which was great for us. The service was great and the staff was very kind. There were some seats that I felt I might fall through though. Overall, solid 3.5/5.

Loved it! It's probably the only Mexican restaurant in key west you can get molé sauce!!…read more We got a sopé for appetizer which was small but delicious. My entree was chicken enchiladas with mole sauce , loved it! The refried beans were a little bland, but otherwise the food was great. Also the prices are great! BYOB , I didn't realize this and which I brought a bottle of wine or some mixed margaritas. I'll be back and will remember this for next time! Very cute decorations inside, there's tables or booths. Service was great. Can't wait to come back!

Excellent. The opening salsa was fresh and tasty. Not overly spicy but bursting with flavor…read more The chicken mole was the the thing of the day - everyone seemed to be ordering it, so I went with the flow. The flavor was excellent and the chicken very, very tender. I also ordered the Chile Releno because that's what I do. I went with only cheese. They do have a steak and cheese option. It was extra large and packed. The egg batter was thick. Lots of city workers and locals chilling out. All were very happy. The music plays and laughter filled the air. The staff is excellent, a little erratic on speaking English or not. The server was very attentive. I stumbled into El Molcajete on the walk back from fishing all morning. I was unable to finish it all and will have leftovers later. I'm glad I dropped on and will be back.