The techniques taught by Animal Behavior Specialists, including Alpha-rolling, scruff-grabbing: grabbing the puppy by the scruff of her neck to correct, using a chain choke collar (sold to me by ABS) forcing the dog to the floor & standing on her leash to teach "down, stay" as well as others are rejected by the Animal Humane Society, Vets & many others.
I trusted ABS to teach me appropriate ways to train my 4 month old puppy & I used their techniques. The more I used the techniques, the higher my puppy's negative behavior escalated. When I discussed this, I was told I must not be following through or holding her down long enough. All training is done without using treats to reward success.
We enrolled in ABS's "puppy kindergarten" after paying for an initial private "lesson" in our home to address unwanted puppy mouthing.
We were told in PK, our puppy would play with other puppies the same age to learn bite inhibition, which is necessary for puppies to develop, to learn not to bite too hard.
In this class, which had far too many people in attendance for good things to happen, the trainer marked my puppy as one of the "dominant" dogs & she had me hold her on her leash while the other puppies were allowed off their leashes to play.
My puppy, as well as 6 or 7 other puppies, in the over crowded class, squirmed & watched, causing anxiety, being restrained until the end.
She also practiced some "training" during Puppy Kindergarten, the "Alpha roll", which is forcing your puppy over onto its back against its will until it "submits". As well as leash training that consisted of a constant yank on the poor puppy's neck with the command "no pull". Mind you these are 4 month old puppies.
We were told to practice the "alpha-roll" technique at home on our youthful, happy, exuberant puppies when they exhibited unwanted behaviors such as nipping. ( I now know that nipping would have come to a more natural end after the puppy reached 6-7 months & was more able to be taught correctly, had these cruel punishments not been used.)
The Obedience class was supposed to be for puppies 4-6 months of age. Obedience overlapped with puppy kindergarten. The class was again severely over crowded & was filled with adult dogs, mostly.
No other young puppies, like ours, were in the class.
Some dogs had issues, one wearing a muzzle, another incessantly whining. Another wearing a head halter, which the ABS trainer wanted me to use on my puppy also. I declined.
The trainer walked around the room, to ask each person to follow her instructions, one by one, while all the other dogs were held on their leashes, frantically jumping, whining & barking.
One week, my puppy spent over 30 minutes doing almost nothing but watching the dog next to us whine in pitches that could shatter glass. (This is the only thing my puppy did learn from that class)
We attended 2-3 classes & withdrew after the trainer, in attempting to teach the "down, stay" command, had me force my puppy to the floor by her leash & quickly stand on her leash to prevent her from standing up again until she "gave up".
When my overly frustrated puppy finally gasped a sigh & stopped biting her captor's (me) ankles, the trainer looked at me & said. "There. You won. Now you can let her up".
Due to this early cruel & improper "training", I now have a 7 month old puppy that is very difficult to get close to. She bursts into uncontrollable tantrums while walking (we no longer use the choke collar from ABS, but a harness instead). She sometimes growls at us for no reason when we approach her. She clearly has learned fear & anxiety.
We went to Animal Behavior Specialists, with a happy puppy, searching for techniques to socialize & train her up out of normal puppy mouthing & instead we were told to use punishments & cruelty, that increased her fear & frustration & caused her to develop inappropriate aggressive behaviors.
Those I have spoken to: Cornell Veterinary Behaviorists, my Veterinarian & my puppy's breeder, said these techniques will likely cause aggression in any dog.
I was advised by a Veterinarian Behaviorist that using an "Alpha-roll" is detrimental to a dog's well being because, First, your dog KNOWS you are not a dog. Second, a dog OFFERS a roll to another dog. They are never forced into this position by another dog!
I'm heart broken that I hurt my puppy & possibly my dog's life.
We'll now spend countless dollars & hours trying to do "counter conditioning" & "desensitization" to try to rehabilitate her from the trauma inflicted on her at such a young age by the teaching of Animal Behavior Specialists.
I guess anyone can call themselves a behaviorist. The owner has a large German Shepard she uses to show that her techniques work.
I have had well behaved dogs my whole life & I don't call myself a behavior specialist. It is noteworthy that her German Shepard bit one of the puppies in PK, causing the puppy to need stitches on its precious head. read more