Hands down my favorite ice cream place! My husband and I probably visit this location weekly, yes even during the winter. Why? Because custard is good all.year.long! His go to is the 87 concrete, Travis Kelce's featured concrete for his foundation. I usually mix up my choice every time we visit because everything on the menu is good. Drive through line is always long, so park and get in line, it will go faster I promise. read more

Drive-thru experience was quick and efficient - easier when close to the menu though, even with a crew member taking order. Kid sundaes and strawberry concrete were tasty and prepared carefully. read more

See all

Always great!! We go here more than we should! LOL Always busy but quick, accurate service.

This was the worst service I've experienced in years. The woman at the counter wouldn't acknowledge us, and when she finally did, she was rude and unpleasant. We waited far too long, no one was in the drive thru or at the order window. So no excuses. We ordered three items and only received two--and both were the wrong sizes. Thankfully, we weren't charged for the third. On a positive note, the items we did receive tasted good. I did try to clarify the issue with her, but she had no interest in correcting it. read more

The custard here is always delicious and consistent. My favorite is the James Brownie Funky Jackhammer. The drive through line here moves very slowly so be prepared to wait. My tip is to just park and walk up and order - there are heaters. No indoor seating. Staff is always nice. read more

Andy's Frozen Custard - Small concrete with butterfinger - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Shawnee, Kansas

Andy's always has something for everyone! Great treats and great prices. Service has always been great! Highly recommended.

FPO wanted to try Andy's Frozen Custard for a while. We were finally in the area and stopped by the one on Shawnee Mission Parkway. It was a hot, humid July afternoon and we could see a lot of people in the drive thru as well as walking up the counter. It seemed like this is the place to go after you get done at one of the many public pools. I got a medium Key Lime Pie Concrete. FPO got a medium Strawberry, Oreo Cookie Concrete. Our total bill came just over $14. The concretes were okay but I personally prefer Freddy's. Still, it was a nice afternoon and nice treat. read more

See all

The ice cream tastes amazing here, but they cannot get an order correct to save their lives. 5 times I've ordered vanilla with cookie dough and 3 times that is not what I've gotten. Ice cream is worth but make sure you check your orders here read more

They were quick and the service was great! The custard is amazing. The brownie was so soft and delicious! I like how you can see the custard machines in the window too. read more

See all

Very good concretes, my one treat a week and I make it an Andy's (pecans, Reese's peanut butter cups & Heath bar -well mixed- medium)! The service is good, they are working hard because a lot of people come here and they do a great job getting orders out quickly. There is no indoor seating but the ambience is community! A lot of people eat outside and take photos with the big ice-cream statue. A lot of people park and eat their treat too. read more

Love this place. This is a great Andy's location. Never disappointed. Great custard. Friendly servers. read more

See all

I went back yesterday and it was great :), got my order within like 3-5 mins headed home and everything was on point.

Every time I come here they always give me the wrong order. I suggest you got to a different location

Andys!!! My favorite frozen custard! I come here every weekend and my go to, is the snowmonster. For the snow monster, they take chocolate sauce that hardens and splashes it in your cup around the edges. They also put it in the vanilla custard and blend it with strawberries. So it has a great sweet tang to it. Plus I love at the end scraping all of the chocolate from the sides. I have tried other seasonal items too. My favorite seasonal is the pumpkin pie concrete. So buttery, creamy and just a great flavor. The key lime pie concrete is ok to me. I think its not one of my favorites because key lime pie can tend to be too sweet for me. I do love the pie pieces in the concrete. I had mentioned earlier I loved the snowmonster but this summer (2021) they introduced the version with blueberries. I prefer it with the strawberries, I found myself chewing the blueberries a lot and picking them out of my teeth. Also the sweetness and the tartness plays off better with the strawberries and chocolate. My dad orders the banana split and he loves that, nothing special its just a banana split. He also gets the butter pecan concrete and loves it as well. As for sizes they used to have only large and regular but now I order small. That is enough for me. My advice is order the snowmonster, you will not be disappointed. read more

See all

About 10 days ago I had a very disappointing experience at Andy's. I slept on it and when I woke up still frustrated, decided to email customer care. I expressed my dissatisfaction. I received no response. No apology. I will take my business elsewhere! read more

My second favorite ice cream place next to Yogurtini. I came to the new location they recently opened on Shawnee Mission Parkway in Shawnee, KS. They have loyalty cards that works like Yogurtini. Where every dollar you spend, you would accumulate points and when you get 50 points you get a free one. I like getting their sundaes. The first time I came here, I got the Stolen Brownie Sundae which consisted of homemade brownies covered with hot fudge, roasted pecans, and topped with a cherry. The hot fudge make it really rich and too sweet for my taste, but overall it was a nice treat. Therefore, the second time I came here, I got a basic kids size vanilla sundae with cookie dough topping. It was the perfect amount of sweetness I could handle. I would definitely come back for their other specialty ice cream and to add on to my loyalty card! ^_^ read more

Andy's Frozen Custard - Left: Stolen Brownie Sundae Right: Customized Chocolate Concrete with Strawberries - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Shawnee, Kansas

See all

Love to try the monthly specials and the specialty items they have. Currently they offer a "drumstick concrete"...soooo good. after getting it 3 times in a row...needed to get something new. Opted for the James Brownie Funky Jackhammer....vanilla custard, peanut butter, hot fudge and a brownie.....wonderful! Unfortunately, I usually share it with a friend, so I don't get to eat the whole thing...but at least it's half the calories!! It's usually busy but the line moves fast. One of my favorite frozen custard places!! read more

Andy's Frozen Custard - James Brownie funky jackhammer - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Shawnee, Kansas

I love finding hidden gems, although It isn't very trendy in my area we decided to check it out because we love finding good dessert places for after our dates. I love that it had a drive thru but also that is had a cute retro looking exterior to park and get it out if you wanted to. Although all the employees were pretty young (or so I think) they were all very polite, fast, and professional. I got the James brownie funky jackhammer and omggg! I didn't know how much I loved custard until I tasted this. the nice warm fudge and brownies were the perfect combo for me. My S/O got the jitterbug concrete because he's really into anything that taste like coffee and I've gotta say, I might not be the most fond of coffee flavored stuff but this one definitely won me over. we will most definitely be returning. read more

Andy's Frozen Custard - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Shawnee, Kansas

I came to visit my Mother and saw this new ice cream joint there, though I found out that they served custard not ice cream. I wanted to try it out since I saw a line there and thought it must be good if there a line to get buy custard from there. We went after church service so there wasn't a big line there when we went. I ordered the butter pecan concrete which is a more frozen longer than usual custard is. It really hit the spot since it hit about 92 that afternoon. If you are ever in or live in KC, I recommend going there to satisfy your sweet tooth. read more

Always quick and good service! Great ice cream.

We stood in line for 15 minutes for ice cream and then they gave my order to someone else who ordered way after us. I had to ask them 3 times to remake it. read more

consistently gives orders wrong in the drive thru. happens about 70% of the times I go through. I like the ice cream but they either need better attention when taking orders or better attention when giving the ice cream out. read more

My regular size Straw-Ana ($4.74) was nicely sized, with plenty of delicious strawberries, and plenty of freshly-cut bananas on a bed of creamy frozen custard. The service was amazing (cheerful, professional, friendly, and fast). There was a drive-thru, and a small seating area outside, but no dine-in. Excellent! read more

See all

This place is my ULTIMATE WEAKNESS!! I shouldn't be eating Ice Cream (or in this case, Frozen Custard) - but come on, we should be able to treat ourselves to a little joy... In moderation. Andy's is so convenient. There are several locations all over the metro. You can't go wrong. Just order what sounds good. There are too many choices to mention - but one of their new flavors definitely should get an honorable mention... The Jitterbug!! So the Jitterbug is a concrete with vanilla custard, espresso, almonds and Heath Bar - all mixed up to perfection. If you are a coffee lover, this it IT!!! I tried adding fudge on one occasion, but I think it ended up being too sweet. So just go with their recipe, and you'll be on cloud 9 in no time. I should also mention that their service is fantastic!! Sometimes, I'm over the moon about how kind and attentive they can be. Once, I forgot my wallet. I offered to go home and get it, assuming they would keep our items cold... They said, hey you're a regular - don't worry about it. That really means a lot to me. We go here a lot, and what a generous way to show their appreciation of my business. Also, if you have a pup - bring them along. They offer complimentary sample cones. My dog goes nuts when we drive thru, because she knows what's to come. No time for pictures - sorry. This stuff is going straight down the hatch! Enjoy!! read more

Worst place ever in every regard from their custard to their customer service. I ask and pay for extra cheesecake with big chunks and raspberries and they give me extra raspberries and no cheesecake. I return it and they remake without hardly any cheesecake and raspberries like out of spite and tell me they are charging me for extra cheesecake. Unbelievable! Don't support this horrible business that treats people so poorly! This has happened now twice because I decided to give them a second chance but now I will not go back! read more

Andy's Frozen Custard - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Shawnee, Kansas

See all

I decided to try this place twice before I posted my raving review. My first visit - oreo turtle jammer. Vanilla custard with oreos and caramel with a fudge center. It was sooo good! I loved the oreo & custard combo and then to have a fudge center. Husband got the Aunt Elaine's strawberry sundae....do not recommend. I don't think their marketing group tried this before describing it. The cake had a gritty texture and a well funky taste. What a disappointment! Second visit - my staple buttered pecan concrete. I would rank this a little lower than their competitors due to the fact that they didn't seem to have as many pecans in theirs - the ratio was off. Would I and am I going back again - absolutely! I have plenty of other speciality items to try! read more

Andy's Frozen Custard - Oreo turtle - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Shawnee, Kansas

See all

Loveeee Andy's. I'll admit I'm always in the mood for custard, but Andy's Custard is a different type of delicious. There is always a huge selection of things to choose from, including seasonal desserts, malts, sundaes, and banana splits! But if that's not your thing.. no worries ! You can choose between all of Andy's different mix ins and create your own ! The service here is so nice and friendly too, so it makes the experience that much better. Not to mention how creamy the custard is and how happy your taste buds will be when you decide to stop here ! read more

This place is so good. Their Espresso shake is so great, I could eat it every morning in place of coffee but that's a bad idea sadly. I've never had anything bad here honestly. A bit pricey but what isn't anymore? A once in a while treat is what it should be anyway. read more

yummmm concretes! big menu with lots of options for toppings. vanilla or chocolate custard and then choose premades or customize yourself. i can come over and over and get different toppings for different experiences. the location is great, a window to walk up to or a drive thru. its crowded whether its hot or cold out because its always a good time for frozen custard. they also have sundaes. more options than sheridans. some of my favs are almonds, blueberries, marshmellows, and chocolate chips. read more

Simply the best frozen custard I have ever had. I am from Wisconsin....the land of frozen custard! And I have to say, this is the best custard I've had, including custard in Wisconsin! It's better than Culver's. Which is an entirely different review I have yet to write! Andy's is also all about community service. Our church held a fall festival, and Andy's graciously donated gift cards for our silent raffle, and buy-one-get-one free coupons by the hundreds to hand out as prizes and to people who bought wristbands for rides. They are very conscientious about peanut allergies; my daughter is allergic and they always announce peanut allergy, and make sure to make it in a separate area than the rest of the custard treats. The drive through is ultra convenient, and we've even bought quarts of custard to take home! The other nice thing they do without hesitation is let you make substitutes like chocolate custard for vanilla on sundaes. This is our family's "Favorite Treat" place. Make it yours!!! read more

Andy's has become one of my favorite ice cream places. I was never really a big ice cream fan and could only tolerate it in small amounts but Andy's has something for everyone. I am a huge fan of the Snowmonster (Tip: add banana to it). Service has always been wonderful weekdays AND weekends. read more

Very good quality custard with a great rewards card. However, my fiancé and I ordered a large size concrete to share, and it wasn't blended well. The last 1/3 of the cup was just vanilla custard. So we were disappointed that they did not blend it all the way through. This is my third favorite custard place as a result. Their custard is not as rich as Sheridan's. However, the rewards card is great, and I prefer their hot fudge over Sheridan's. I come to Andy's now and then if I am in the mood for something that I don't find at Sheridan's. read more

This is my new fav spot to get a chocolate custard with strawberries and bananas! They open till very late night so it's perfect for after dinner's dessert. I go with my love or with my sisters! You order, pay and wait for your order. Employees here are friendly, patient, and great! You can stand and eat your dessert or sit on the benches they have. Outdoor only. There are heat lamps for when it's cold outside and the area is clean! Hits the spot read more

Andy's Frozen Custard - Kids size vanilla oreo and kids size chocolate with strawberry & bananas - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Shawnee, Kansas

I love this location! Easy in and out. The staff are very friendly and quick! The ice cream always hits the spot, menu has quite a variety, ice teas are also very good!! You order at the window where you also pay, when the line is long (but goes by quickly) someone will come out like, chick fil a and take your order. Since there's plenty of parking you can go through the drive thru and park and sit in your car and enjoy your ice cream too! read more

Smooth, creamy, silky, velvety? You'll just have to go and decide yourself on which word is best to describe this dang good frozen custard. Welcome to Shawnee Andy's! The location is great, and I like the building itself. The big cone out front is a nice fun touch. They have a drive thru that moves at a good clip, which is a good thing. You don't order talking into a box, but at the window. I know it's just opened, but the employees were smiling, upbeat, and appreciative of your business. I went with a butter pecan concrete. The vanilla frozen custard on its own is delicious. Throw in some butterscotch and roasted salted pecans, and I was in my happy place. They may need to pass a law against eating one while driving though. I think I swerved a couple times. Price to portion seems fair. There are so many more creations to try, but I'll definitely need to pace myself, and I think I'll eat it in the parking lot next time. read more

In the drive through getting a single scoop on a cone - they must use those tiny fruit scoops for $1.75 (QT across the street is 3x the size for $.49). And he hands me the cone WITHOUT GLOVES! HELLO? COVID???? Gross! read more

I love the frozen custard at Andy's. I have tried several different menu items and have enjoyed them all. The drive-thru makes it easier to get ice cream in a hurry. read more

Great frozen custard !!!! Have tried numerous menu options and never found any not meeting my expectations. Great hot fudge and other toppings, too. read more

Yum! So ready for the Andy's KC takeover. One on every block, please! Went through the drive thru for a Strawberry Shortcake sundae. No complaints! The service was fast and friendly. read more

The ice cream was awesome! Beware the sizes are huge, got a medium and it was much bigger than expected