Real people real pizza with that old skoo oven, good people great service with that hole in the wall ambiance you know is good when you can smell the food outside. It's a must try. If you like thin crust and good toppings, go try this fresh out of the oven. read more

Amy's is the definition of "a hole in the wall" and those always seem to be the best places to eat--it sure is true in this case! There's nothing flashy about it, it's easy to drive right past and not even know it's there. In fact, there's a fancy newer-looking place next door, but I bet it doesn't hold a candle to this pizza. The toppings are plentiful and the crust is soft and fluffy but not soggy. I will say, the sauce is a little too basic to pair perfectly with this flavorful pizza, but at least it's not too sweet or too spicy. Aside from that, it couldn't be better! The service was great, it had that down-home feel that is hard to find these days. Give 'em a try! read more

Amy's Pizza - The All Meat pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Harrisburg, Ohio

This business has been around for nearly five decades! The owner and the chef were extremely friendly and helpful! It's a little hole-in-the-wall with a cozy, well-loved atmosphere and nostalgic decorations going back several years. Now the food... the meat lover's pizza and personal cheese were delicious. I knew they were going to be incredible because the restaurant smells amazing inside! My wife had BBQ wings and she said they were delicious! read more

Amy's Pizza - Meat Lover's and personal cheese pizzas (already started enjoying them!) - Pizza Near Me - Harrisburg, Ohio

love the pizza... wish they had delivery, have/will get pizza her again... the sub-n-crust is good.

The cheese the sauce and the dry crust with Romano cheese sprinkled over the hot greasy pepperoni all combined to give our ole' favorite Cattlemen's a run for its money... read more

Absolutely amazing! All of the staff are so kind and sweet. I highly recommend their sub n crust it is so yummy and it's amazing every time. They never get the order wrong. Truly couldn't recommend them more. read more

First time husband and I have ever eaten at Amy's, we made a 20 minute drive to see what Amy's is all about after several friends recommended them as: "worth the drive" and they were absolutley hands down RIGHT!!! They were busy busy tonight and the kitchen staff was right on getting things out in a timely manner, I don't think we waited more than 20 minutes, after eating I would say they have one of theee best handmade thin crust EVER read more

Amy's Pizza - All The Way Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Harrisburg, Ohio

I want to give this place a 4 1/2 stars out of five. We start traveling off of our 71. The service was excellent! We ate in the restaurant. The food came out steaming hot! The meatball sub was delicious. The french fries were good along with the mozzarella sticks and the bread. The chicken Parmesan was average but came with salad and 4 pieces of bread. The salad was a good size for a side salad. Everything was nice and hot though. Nice to find a place like this while we're on the road. We will try to make another stop by! Thank you! read more

Amy's Pizza - Side salads, bread, Mozzarella sticks and french fries. - Pizza Near Me - Harrisburg, Ohio

See all

The food is amazing anything you get, service is great ! Ambiance is great everything is great!

Pizza was awesome as usual. Been enjoying their pizza for over 20+ years. However, tried the wings last night. Not so good! They tasted like something was wrong with them. The meat was a funny color too. Won't be getting them again. Ended up tossing them after eating one! read more

Amazing every time!!! Best crust ever?? And if you like Stromboli's or calzones Do yourself a favor and try the sub in a crust!!

We were visiting grove city , and decided to pull up yelp to see what local pizza places were in the area . This place is an absolute gem . We ordered a 17 inch x large , extra cheese , and medium 3 topping pizza , both were outstanding . Great taste , cheese is very good , adequate amount of sauce , and amazing fresh crust . Highly recommended. The only issue we found was our gps took us right by the actual location . It's very close to the Joseppies sign . read more

Amy's is our go to local pizza place. They have great chef salads. Probably one of the best.

I have been a customer of Amy's for years and thought it about time I documented my satisfaction with this establishment. This is the best pie in the Orient area. It is consistently tasty with a thin and crispy crust, which I prefer. You receive the pizza the way you ordered it. That may sound like a given, but that hasn't always been true with other local pizza places. Also, don't worry about it being fully done, as that has always been my experience. Jerry F. read more

Since we've moved into our home a year ago Amy's has been our go to on pizza night! Definitely not a disappointment that we have pizza here about once a week. The crust is what makes it and the pizza is just plane good!! The owners and staff are always super friendly and we love giving our business to locals in our community!! read more

We go there almost weekly at this point. These are the best subs we have ever had. We get the Italian, all the way subs and I promise they will not disappoint. There has been no sub place that even comes close to comparing. They have delicious pizza as well. It's the perfect crust with just the right portions of everything else. Always a quick turn around, and very friendly employees. Will continue going here for years to come. read more

PHENOMINIFICENT!!! This pizza place is a local, hole-in-the-wall joint that has some great grub! The price is reasonable, and the pizza is absolutely astounding. This is one of my favorites as well. Between this and Larry's, locally in Mt. Sterling, I'm in pizza heaven. They are always pretty quick getting your order ready, and the staff is always welcoming. This would definitely be one of my recommendations for best pizza places! read more

Good Pizza, thin crispy crust, tasty sauce,quality cheese. Italian Sub is real good as well, quality meats, and a great sub bun. I have added this place as one of my favorites in the area ! A great value too !!! read more

Amy's has, bar none, the best pizza anywhere in central Ohio. There's no contest. And that comes from someone who lived in Sicily for 3 years. Although their pizza is great.. their wings will knock your socks off! I think they get their chicken locally sourced and fresh. It's enormous! Notice how there's all 5 star reviews for this place then 1 one star review? That's someone from Joseppis Pizza next door. They hate Amy's. Yes, Amy's only delivers twice a week.. it's a family owned business. Joseppis delivers any day.. usually in 3 hours. That's no exaggeration. I found Amy's because I couldn't stand Joseppi's delivery crap anymore.. besides the fact that their pizza is barely edible. Thanks Joseppi's, for sucking so bad that I was forced to find Amy's superior pizza! read more

Great pizza! Thin crust, sauce tastes awesome. No chicken pizzas, but standard pizzas are very good. read more

Amy's Pizza - a menu for a home of the sub - n - crust - Pizza Near Me - Harrisburg, Ohio

See all

Stopped here for carryout driving on 71 and got the chicken parm sandwich with all the toppings, so good and great price!! Definitely would love to go back read more

We order weekly, literally, unless we are out of town. They are FAR better than any chain place, and they do deliver, but my husband likes to get it himself so it's even hotter :) The crust can vary depending on who is baking that night but it's chewy and crackery at the same time. The sauce is a bit sweet but not overly and the toppings are always ample. We get it when we have guests and they always love it--because unless you live close to here, one one ever has had it and we like to share :) Our kids love the salads. They are MASSIVE and well stacked with ingredients. The individual serves 2 and the large is probably 4ish. Breadsticks and garlic bread are par for the course, but we get them about 50% of the time regardless. They also have a nice punch card for repeat customers, which is normally a few bucks off or a salad or something--it's nice regardless. read more

Stopped while traveling south on #71 on Yelp's recommendation. We were not disappointed. Mostly carry out but they accommodated us with a table as only couple available for seating! read more

We moved to the area about a month ago and decided to try this place. So glad we did. The best pizza second to Zami's.

This food is ok I don feel like it's all that good with what you pay. They only deliver like twice a week which is inconvenient. I don't recommend this place. read more

I love this pizza place! The sauce is the perfect sweet acidic combo and they don't skimp on the cheese everyone is always friendly when I go in. The prices are also great no it's not 7.99 for a large pizza like other joints, but...you get what you pay for people read more

Sub in a crust!!! We are hooked. Have served it several times for extended family. They really like it too! Definitely a favorite.