Needed a smash cake and cupcakes for a first person. They were a big hit! Everyone enjoyed them! Highly recommend. Communication was great!

Ordered a birthday number cupcake cake for my daughter's birthday and Amy did not disappoint! The cupcake cake was beautiful and tasted great. I emailed the business through their site and got a very quick response, sent an inspiration picture and Amy did an amazing job bringing my daughter's vision to life! Can't say enough good things about this business- super friendly and easy to work with plus the treats are delicious! read more

Amy's Custom Cakery - Number 6 cupcake cake- 18 cupcakes 1/2 chocolate, 1/2 vanilla - Custom Cakes Near Me - Dover, Pennsylvania

I walked in to check out what they had available since I had never bought anything there. I was greeted promptly. The cupcakes I bought did NOT disappoint! They were fresh and delicious. They're worth the price. It's not set up for ambiance but it is easy to find what you want. read more

I ordered custom cupcakes for a baby shower, and i was truly blown away when i picked them up!! Everyone was so nice on the phone and in person, the cupcakes were not only decorated perfectly and just what i imagined, they were SO delicious. All of the guests kept asking me where they were from, and commenting on how amazing they were! Worth the money, worth it all! read more

Amy's Custom Cakery - Custom Cakes Near Me - Dover, Pennsylvania

Left a recent review in another post! Best custom cake ever! Happy Birthday my dear daughter in Heaven. Spread your wings with the butterflies! read more

Amy's Custom Cakery - Heather's Birthday cake. Jan 24, 2025 - Custom Cakes Near Me - Dover, Pennsylvania

See all

The cupcakes that I purchased were very moist and delicious. I didn't pre order, but walked in and there were many choices.

Just picked up my cake. I'm sure it tastes good Unfortunately directions were not followed from 2 separate discussions for planning the cake. It's blah and borders promised are missing, agreements were forgotten or ignored maybe due to lack of time management. So disappointed License plate was to be flush. Looks rushed and unprofessional read more

Amy's Custom Cakery - a picture of a car - Custom Cakes Near Me - Dover, Pennsylvania

See all

I've always seen the Facebook page for this company and everything always looks amazing!! This was our first time in the shop- loved it we will be back. You walk in and it smells delicious. They have lots of cold coolers with lots of goodies in addition they have lots of other goodies that you can mix and math. We ended up buying a 1/2 dozen of cupcakes as well as 1/2 dozen cake balls. We did not even make it out of the parking lot before we were trying the cake balls. Very delicious, we will be back! read more

Absolutely loved this place!!!! Amy was such a joy to work with. She helped me pick flavors and help me find my vision for my wedding cake. On top of it all they delivered my cake and decorated it with the flowers the florist left for them!!! It was beautiful, and I didn't even need to be there when they delivered it. read more

See all

Ordered a cake this weekend from Amy.. the decorations were amazing! The cakes were good as well but was really sweet. Maybe there is some balance that can be applied so that it is not overbearingly sweet between the cakes, filling and fondant.. Thank you for the gorgeous cake! read more

Amy's Custom Cakery - a soccer themed cake - Custom Cakes Near Me - Dover, Pennsylvania

I ordered a birthday cake and cup cakes for a kid's flamingo themed birthday party from Amy's and was completely blown away by the cake when I picked it up! The detail and work put into the cake could have easily cost double the price (I paid the original price)! Not only were they able to help me on short notice, I also found their pricing to be very reasonable in comparison with other bakeries. Their cake with buttercream icing was so good and we received a lot of compliments on the cake. I will be ordering all of my cakes from them in the future. Their shop also has a counter with yummy looking cupcakes and treats. The location is a slight pain to get to and the shop itself is not super fancy but their work is amazing and totally worth it! read more

Amy's Custom Cakery - Custom Cakes Near Me - Dover, Pennsylvania

See all

They did an Amazing job, it surpassed all expectations that I had. If I ever need another cake they will be my first call. The cake was a reasonable price and the whole baby shower party loved it!!! read more

Amy's Custom Cakery - Baby shower cake - Custom Cakes Near Me - Dover, Pennsylvania

See all

Stopped on last minute and found exactly what I needed and it was delicious. They even customized my "off the shelf" purchase

The cake balls are a real treat! They come in so many different flavors, even seasonal ones like eggnog and gingerbread. A box of them makes a great gift anyone will love. read more

Not only are the cakes beautiful, but they taste just as good. We have purchased a couple cakes from Amy's now and would highly recommend giving them a try. read more

Amy's Custom Cakery - Sweet 16 naked multi-level cake - Custom Cakes Near Me - Dover, Pennsylvania

I'm gonna go 4 starts for now, simply because I haven't had an actual cake yet. My cake ball experience was fully worth 5stars. They are delicious and the flavor selection is great. Cost is very reasonable and the baker who helped me pick was so friendly and helpful. This is a small business i want support! We have 2 birthdays coming up so I'll update after I've had a cake! I've lived in Dover for years and just now tried this place, my sweet tooth is sad I waited this long! read more

I cannot praise this bakery enough. We're from out of town and threw my daughter a birthday party at my parents, over the holiday, near Amy's. I found her online and sent the unicorn cake photo to her over email. She perfectly replicated it (as you see in the photo with balloons behind it) but on top of that it was DELICIOUS, and most important: VERY affordable. I buy specialty cakes for every birthday and this was the best pricing I've seen. Thanks! read more

Amy's Custom Cakery - Custom Cakes Near Me - Dover, Pennsylvania

See all

When I ordered my cake I was told she was too busy to deliver but I could pick it up. I emailed the owner and asked her if this would be boxed well and that email went unanswered. When I got there to pick it up Amy advised me that there would be no box as she was lifting it up a 3 tier cake and carrying it to my trunk. She place this $400 plus dollar cake in my trunk with no box, nothing to keep it sanitary or protect it from being destroyed. She should have boxed it in 3 separate boxes and we could have assembled it. We stood there in disbelief as she said this is how she delivers her cakes and that staring at it wont get it to its destination. She then wiggled the cake base and said it is fine. We made it 5 miles down the road driving like a snail and it collapsed. The night before my wedding and my cake was now all over the trunk. We called Amy's and she told us to bring it back. She then had an attitude, showed zero sympathy or empathy for our situation. She took my dirty destroyed cake and scraped all the icing off and re-iced 2 of the 3 tiers. She placed the two tiers together and again stuck it in a flimsy box bottom with an open top and sent us out with cupcakes to substitute for the bottom of my cake being destroyed. I ordered a 3 tier cake I left with a dirty 2 tier cake that rolled around my trunk. The 2 tiers never made it and separated half way to the venue. The night before my wedding and my cake was ruined at no fault of my own. I paid for a 3 tier cake I ended up with 2 dirty tiers and cupcakes and no apologies, or offers of a credit. Amy's response, "you are lucky that we even answered the phone when you called!" Had Amy's custom cake told me that it would be transported in this way I would have ordered else where. read more

See all

Even though there were about 5 employees there none of them acknowledged me so I finally left after a few minutes. This was the second time it's happened. . None of them were wearing masks either so I didn't feel great about that anyway. read more

Amy made 7 dozen cupcakes for our wedding reception - we had a Vegas wedding and Amy decorated the cupcakes with fondant poker chips and playing card suit symbols - she did an excellent job and we received so many compliments! The cupcakes & frosting were so fresh and delicious! We are so glad we supported a local small business ! read more

Found this place by accident while at the Amish Market in Hanover, PA. Amy has a small stand there also, which is how I found her main location in Dover, PA. We have tried the cupcakes, snowballs and scones. My wife loves the scones. My favorite is the regular and raspberry filled snowballs. We have not tried any of Amy's cakes to date but they look fabulous. read more

After weeks of planning a 50th birthday event for my husband my baker canceled 3 hours before the scheduled delivery. I was very upset and in a bind. I called many bakers as I needed a decorated special cake. Amy saved the day! The cake was amazing as far as appearance and taste awesome. Amy is now my only baker and her business ethics are top notch. I can not say enough positive things! read more

Writing another review since my review was removed from another site. We stopped in around Valentine's Day. No one greeted us the whole time we were there. There was no bell to ring so we walked around the front of the shop for a few minutes. We could hear a man and a woman talking from the back of the store. The conversation was very inappropriate for customers to hear. The woman mentioned something about throwing someone off a cruise ship. The man made a reference about "meat curtains" and the "F" bomb was dropped multiple times. What an unpleasant experience. First and most likely last visit to Amy's Custom Cakery. read more