This is a pretty good pizza place, but I feel it has gone a bit downhill in recent years. I used to eat here very often and the pizza was amazing, but once the facility changed ownership, the food has become just average. The cheese pizza is a bit greasy and lacks sauce, the Sicilian is average but has hard crust, the chicken parm pizza is very good, with tender chicken and a great sauce to cheese to crust to chicken ratio, and the Margherita was very fresh and tasted pretty well. However, even though I enjoy a bit of sweetness in the sauce, this experience I found that it was a bit too sugary. I feel that instead of using sugar to sweeten the sauce, a bit of carrot purée would help make it more subtle and improve the consistency. Going to Amici's is a hit or miss at the moment. When they hit, it is a great pizza experience, but unfortunately this time it was a miss. read more

Amici's Pizzeria & Restaurant - (From left to right) Sicilian slice, chicken Parmesan slice, Margherita slice, (bottom) Regular cheese slice - Pizza Near Me - Peekskill, New York

Stopped by on our way to Massachusetts. Pizza tasted ok, chicken parm was okay. Meatballs with ricotta was really good. Our friend's order was cancelled because the server never put it in. Not sure how that happens? Nice, open area for dining in. Beer on tap and wine available upon request. read more

Do yourself a favor and skip amicis. I ordered some slices that were overpriced and appeared to be ancient.The sauce was almost nowhere to be found and lacking in flavor. The new owners are much less friendly and seem to care much less about quality and service and more about making an extra buck. read more

never fails me, magherita pizza tonight melts in the mouth. fresh basil, mozzerella and sauce. im in heaven.

Usually, Shopping Centers are centers for bad things and occurances -You get the usual "Bad Strip Mall Slice" -Your car gets dinged up by a pick-up truck -You get arrested for smoking weed -Your highschool girlfriend gets preggers -You miss the bar mitzvah bus and your Mom wont drive you Sometimes good things happen- You find a good secret slice spot- AMICIS Damn!- real good, elements of Bronx Style mixed with New Haven Apizza style cornmeal and dalmatian tinged bottom. will be back. read more

Haven't been here in like 4 years and the place must have changed hands, as the pizza is definitely not the same. Unfortunately, it's just not good, anymore. read more

Not sure what happened with my order this evening but Amici really dropped the ball on the Lasagna meal I had ordered.... Not only did it take twice as long as what I was told on the phone but I stood inside waiting for the Lasagna to be prepared all the while the manager keep saying.. just two more minutes...two more minutes I apologise for the delay..... So I finally get the meal for my wife and I and brought it home and when I took off the plastic cover I knew this wasn't going to be good... Really disappointing. I know it's a Friday but they had twice the amount of time to get it right and they couldn't. All the while I was waiting for my order I see orders going in and out and people coming in to pickup their orders and I figured.... sometimes perfection takes more time but not this evening. I think this will be my last Friday order unfortunately. Buyer beware. read more

Amici's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Lasagna...poor attempt at it! - Pizza Near Me - Peekskill, New York

Great food and service. Newly renovated and the venue is gorgeous. The ambiance and drinks at the bar are a perfect touch to a quiet evening. Your taste buds will do a little happy dance once you try their various dishes oozing with flavor and delicious ingredients. Great for catering and private parties as well, or take out! I would definitely recommend this place. read more

See all

I readily admit that my reason for going here was the positive reviews by my fellow Northern Westchester Yelpers. It's lunch time so there's no crowd and no problem finding a seat. The pizza lived up to my expectations with the regular slice being fairly thin crust and perfectly done. My other slice, I think it was Grandma (although this term seems to differ slightly from one pizza joint to the next) was not quite as good although the basil was obviously fresh and imparted a noticeable flavor to the slice. If I'm in the neighborhood, I will def be back, but frankly, this part of town is not on my normal travel path. read more

1 teen + 1 tween suffering from a bad flu + 2 adults debated what to have delivered for dinner. I'm not sure why we didn't immediately decide on pizza as it is always a crowd pleaser. Although this crew had lived in Peekskill for about 20 years they did not know that Amici delivered. The order: A large grandma's pie I wanted Sicilian (square) but they could only do it round. Not sure if the do grandma's pies out West but here's what it is homemade sauce (not gravy), fresh sliced not shredded mozzarella, and fresh basil leaves. Perfect ration of sauce to cheese and the pie was cooked crispy. A medium pie 1/2 pepperoni and 1/2 Hawaiian - yes it broke my heart to order Hawaiian but the boy child gets what every he wants. Ham & Cheese Calzone it was ok but not what I was expecting---a bit doughy for my taste. Yes it seems like a lot of food for 4 people but the kids had to have cold pizza for breakfast and lunch the next day. The only down side was we ordered on a Friday night and it took 11/2 hours to get our food. So be warned if they're busy you will have to wait for delivery. read more

This is not a typical food review, I apologize for that. This is a review to address the outstanding integrity and business side of this restaurant. My son accidentally called a take out order this Amici instead of our regular Amici in West Nyack. Realizing the mistake, I called to pay for the order which I wasn't going to pick up (much too far of a drive) since it was my mistake. After all of the closings of restaurants during this pandemic it was the right thing to do. Amici of Peekskill thanked me for calling to clarify the mistake and would not accept payment. I offered half. They accepted nothing. We have a long summer left of "quarantine-ish" lifestyle... and with 3 kids, I see a road trip to Peekskill to show my appreciation. Thank you again for you kindest of understanding. read more

Awesome! Great thin crust pizza! Was looking to try places in my new neighborhood and the Yelp reviews caught my attention on this one so I decided to try it. We got the "fisherman's pizza" with clams, calamari and shrimp. Loved it! I agree with the other reviewers that this is a close to NYC pizza as you will find in this area. I've been searching for thin crust pizza for a while and this one is definitely a winner in my opinion! I'm thinking next time I will get just the plain cheese. Reminds me of being in NYC again! The staff is very friendly and the place is small inside, but it's a great spot to grab a couple of slices or maybe a pie to go. Also they have a sit down restaurant attached which I will try next time! read more

Can you please tell me why amicis would advertise the hours of business opened till 10pm and I call in a order at 9:28 of chicken Parm dinner I was gonna pick myself living within a mile away to be told the cook has left for the nite so why even answer the phone or change the time of business to 9:30 pm online i Guess you don't need any new customers read more

Ordered a cheeseburger and got a wedge with a hamburger patty on it. Not what I ordered for $12 dollars. Disgusting

UNDER NEW MANAGEMENT! I've been to this local Cortlandt Manor pizza joint slash Italian bistro previously, but decided to come again since our group heard about their new management (also it was in close proximity whilst we were debating dinner options). There are two sections of the establishment - the classic pizza parlor side and the restaurant; our group was primarily interested in the latter. As the door was broken to the restaurant side, we entered through the pizza part and proceeded to stand in an awkward hallway next to the kitchen for about 10 minutes while our table was "prepared". Once we were seated, service proved to be irreparably sluggish. From taking the order through getting the check, there always seemed to be an inexplicable delay that came to annoy some of the more impatient and dramatic among us (me). At the end of the meal, we asked the waitress for the check. Five minutes later, she returned, but somehow forgot that we asked for the check. Small moments like this added up so that our quick, casual Italian dinner turned into a nearly three-hour affair. That being said, the food and atmosphere were stellar. The place was clean, tastefully decorated, and comfortable, and the food was well-apportioned, well-seasoned, and well-received. I particularly enjoyed my penne alla vodka for its unconventional spice. The gnocchi with pesto sauce also looked and tasted great. The fried calamari appetizer had good flavor, but was slightly too chewy for my taste. Overall, a quality establishment with clear potential that may need to work out some kinks in the service department - perhaps this will come with experience as the new management settles in. Until then, 3/5 stars. read more

Great Service and beautiful decoration without over doing it for the holidays. Food was delicious. I had a chicken marsala over penne and it was so delicious. The mushrooms texture was great. Overall a great place to dine in and relax. read more

I have never had a bad meal here...the food, whether at ravenna or amici, is consistent! the best pizza in peekskill...more importantly all the food is very good, and if you venture out of the regular menu items, like a hamburger or italian combo, its sure to please! read more

This is a great pizzeria that has been here a long time. Twenty years ago I lived nearby and ate their food several times a week. Now I have moved back to the area and I'm glad to see they are still here, although I believe they've changed ownership. I've had their pizza many times since moving back and it is still one of my favorites. read more

Ordered a large pie with half pepperoni and two 20 oz root beers for delivery. Was told it would be 45 minutes, but the pie did not arrive for an hour and 20 minutes and there was only one soda. The pie was cold and I called to complain. They apologized and said they got very busy (as they do on Fridays, Saturdays and a Sundays). They credited my card for the order and I reheated the slices in the oven. They were excellent. I'd certainly order again based on the quality of the pizza, but I'll pick it up if it's on a weekend night. read more

Every other time we order from here, something is wrong. The pizza isn't too great to start with, but we like their wings... when they get them right. Their bbq wings are usually delicious, and a great option for people who don't like spicy food. Except for when your local pizza place thinks it would be funny to prank you and just put bbq sauce on top of hot wings. Seriously??? Probably won't be ordering from here again. Wasted too much money on getting orders wrong or items missing. read more

Moving up here, from the city, It was reallllllyyyyyy hard to find a good pizza place. You get very spoiled with good pizza and really appreciate a good slice! So far, Amici's is the best I have found in the area. its nice and thin, crispy, and just the right amount of grease! i haven't tried any other food from here though. read more

Amici food is stale, old and sloppy. We've eaten their pizza, and it's Awful! Their sauce is tinny tasting and the chicken parks are greasy. We've been there about 10 times, cause its a convenient location, but that's it! No more! read more

When I moved into the area 20 years ago, in order to put something in the movers and our stomach I noticed Amicis close by. Bought a few pies and well the rest is history. Always get a couple of pies, calamari, garlic knots, pasta fagioili a couple times a month. Always ready when I call and fair prices. Says it all read more

Best Pizza around Peekskill, Cortlandt Manor, Yorktown and Shrub Oak by far... Place is on its way down but still has some good years left... You won't regret... Get the Calamari best bang for your buck... read more

It seems as though every time we order through Grubhub we face the same issues. We ordered two entrees and requested pasta and salad but only salad was selected. We received our dinner and it had two salads even though we had selected spaghetti and penne in addition to salad. They truly need to fix this. When we called to explain we received salads and no pasta, they stated that it was either or. I expressed that we selected pasta and salads, there response was, "we see here that you ordered a salad." Which we did in addition to the pasta. They basically gave us the, "well I don't know what to tell you" response. So instead of rectifying the situation, they were completely content with what had just happened and basically said, "oh well you got salad." So we now have chicken parm and eggplant rollitini entrees with two salads. Thank you for your lack of customer service and I would advise ordering from Nonna's in beach shopping center as they always rectify the situation. Glad we paid over $60 for chicken parm, eggplant rollitini, and chicken Alfredo with two salads. read more

Amici's Pizzeria & Restaurant - $60 for this. - Pizza Near Me - Peekskill, New York

See all

I don't know what happened to their menu or their recipes but it's not quite the same as the old owners calzone much smaller and hardly any filling very disappointed read more

Been going here all my life while I live near many other pizza places. The pizza is always delicious and the chicken alla vodka is AMAZING, only place I know that portions the meal out to be 60% chicken and 40% pasta, very worth it. only complaint is if you eat inside the place (idk if its one of the owners, worker, or just the local dude who hangs around the place all day) but this one guy can be obnoxious making it uncomfortable. p.s The White Slices or Pie are great and not oily or as greasy as many other establishment *Cough* forno's... read more

I stopped by with my family yesterday and the food was amazing! I ordered the chicken scarpariello and it blew me away on how great it was. Tip my hat off to the chef! The atmosphere/decor was nice. The staff was friendly. I would definitely recommend this restaurant! read more

Recently moved to the area from Queens and after 10 months, I think Amici is the best slice in town. Great sauce, thin crust with cornmeal, not overcooked and not overloaded with cheese. Don't get me wrong, there are some other good places around here (better than a LOT of places in the city these days) but it's the sauce here I think that wins it for me. read more

Was a regular here when Anthony was the owner. It has taken such a down turn it is not worth going to. Order for delivery which we have done hundreds of times and new owners never gave the address to the driver. Won't be coming back. read more

if you're looking for a great straight up ny slice in peekskill, this is the joint. nothing fancy but very solid ny style thin crust pizza. if you're in the mood for a little more upscale environment to dine , then go Ravina next door for dinner. it's actually the same kitchen and same food as Amici, but the dining room is set up nicer. the catering from Amici is really good too. we had them cater a party, and everything was excellent. highlights- meat lasagna, chicken parm, and bruschetta. read more

Since moving up from NYC could not find a decent pizza place. Tried many local places and either got sick or it tasted horrible. Amicis is NYC style pizza. Absolutely delicious sauce and cheese mix with a perfect crust. New goto for pizza night. read more

Best pizza I ever had!!! Sauce is flavorful crust is thin. great selection of toppings. And the prices are reasonable.

fabulous food ,, great pizza ,, calzone really yummy soups even better. so glad we found this place owner is stand up guy .,. greets you very hospitable 3 times a week at least ,,,, read more

Had some pizza & it was pretty good. Also had some wings with bleu cheese sauce. The bleu cheese tasted a little... minty? Both my brother and I thought that there was something different about it, but we couldn't tell what it was exactly. read more

I haven't ordered from them in about 5 years. When last ordering a pie for take out after returning home to the family, we found a pen cap in the cheese. We ended up tossing the pizza out. Yuck!!! read more

Coming up here from the Bronx, I was spoiled on good pizza! After a few dives I found Amici's . Thin crust semolina used for the crust, it's as close as I've found to Bronx pizza in most of Westchester!! read more

Awesome pies, especially being out of NY for 7 years, this place has become an Oasis to me. Excellent Pizza, it is my new "Go To" place!

Thank you my order was delicious the shrimp and stuffed baked clams yummy I recommend amici's

The food here is always solid. The service has always been lacking. Nine of us went out for a Sunday dinner, unfortunately the heating system was down but we decided to tough it out. Despite the restaurant being practically empty the service still sucked. A little nasty man named Kias was our waiter, we saw him three times, when he took our order, delivered our meals, then the check with a 20% gratuity added. Some meals came out and the rest came out 8 minutes later, nothing like eating together. Never did he come by to check on our drinks, did we need pepper or cheese on our food. Terrible experience. read more