Don't be fooled by the lack of fancy decor or ambiance. This little gem has the best pizza and garlic knots in town. Hands down!!

Worst place ever. Do not order anything from here. They will for sure get it wrong and not even bat an eye. I made the mistake of ordering twice for a bday party and both times they messed up my order. They only refunded me $9 because I had a picture of proof otherwise on the phone they were saying they had given all the items I ordered. Save yourself the trouble and order somewhere else. Plus pizza does not taste good either. Your tummy will take you later. read more

My husband and I went to Antonio's Pizzeria tonight and got food to go what we ordered was a Pepperoni roll, a Spinach roll, 2 plain slices and also a beef Patty we got home and my husband had the Pepperoni roll he complained that " it was very spicy to me. I had the Spinach roll my complaint is " that is was very greasy the grease just kept dripping on to my plate as I was trying to eat it. I wrapped up the 2 plain slices in foil we will eat those another time. The beef patty wasn't all that great didn't like the way that the meat looked. That went into the garbage after trying to eat it just couldn't eat it. I was very disappointed. The people who work behind the counter are very very nice They took our order in a Very Professional Manner!!! They also work very hard for their money. If I could give them 10 stars I would but for the food that we did get tonight I wish that I could give zero but that's why for the food I gave 1 star I know that my husband and I will go to Antonio's again BECAUSE THEY REALLY DO HAVE GOOD FOOD!!!! So we will go again and I'm percent sure that they will get 5 stars again and again and in my mind 10 stars over and over until we have tried everything on their menu. Even dessert's every now and then would be good to enjoy but also have to watch the sugar. read more

See all

I don't eat pizza regularly but when I do Antonio's has Great pizza. The sauce on the slice is delicious and the dough is not thick and heavy it's just right read more

This place is a bare bones pizzaria - The way it was meant to be. 4 guys behind the counter making food, taking orders, and working the register. At lunch time when I went they were busy, but flew right throughbthe orders. Theu seemed a lil disorganized but that is part of the charm in this hole in the wall joint. I ordered a chicken roll to go. Ready in about 5 minutes I took it back to the office to eat. Every bite was delicious. @ 6 bucks I was a happy customer. I left a star off for minor offenses - the sauce coulda been a bit chunkier and when I 1st walked in I wasnt acknowledged. I personally like to be greeted with a "Ill be right with you" if they are too busy to take the order. Instead I stood like a dummy and waited for someone to notice me. And a regular came in after me and got a big "Hello!". Im splitting hairs here - stop in and grab a meal. I will certainly be a regular... read more

Antonios Pizzeria - Chicken roll w/sauce to go - Pizza Near Me - Peekskill, New York

See all

Best pizza in Peekskill. Something magical about their sausage and mushroom pizza, it's delicious! read more

Solid pizza can't go wrong with a regular and a coke for 4.50 now a days. Very quick and friendly service, I grab a slice when I'm in the area and never disappointed. Old school vibe pizza place. Regular is like 6.9 on the pizza scale maybe higher on some days no flop crisp yet not thin crust. read more

Popped in here on a Sunday night for some last minute eats after a few hours at the local elks. They were just about closing for the evening but had a few slices and assorted goodies out. We got a few mixed slices, a pepperoni roll and some Jamaican beef patties. My Margherita slice was perfection and my brother got a bbq chicken slice that was piled and I mean piled w chicken! Looked awesome. Friendly guys and service. I would return read more

Ordered a large pie with zeppoles. The pie was half plain half sausage and onion. I was around 8pm and the pie was FRESH! the zeppoles were amazing . Nothing but good things to say about this place. Well update: ordered a large pie again half plain and half sausage and onions. Got a large pie, half sausage and half onions . NOT good when your 9 months pregnant and just want a plain slice of pizza. read more

THE MOST INCOMPETENT STAFF !! This was my new favorite pizza/Italian food place, but I won't go here again. Twice the messed up our order but the 2nd time was a real dozey. I called an order in for 2 different pasta dishes, Spaghetti without cheese and ziti with cheese. When my husband went to pick up the food they forgot one of the orders and what order they did give was ziti with no cheese. When I placed the order iMessage repeated myself three times just to make sure they had the spaghetti with no cheese. My husband was so upset so I called the place when he got back with the one order. They did not know what I was talking about. I will never deal with this establishment ever again their food is good but they are so incompetent that they can't get an order right and this is the second time this is happened. To forget an entire order that is just bonkers. They need to get a staff that is competent and that is old enough to even work. They lost a very good customer read more

I so love this Pizza. We usually order the thin crust in either plain or white pizza with spinach. The crust flavor is incredible!!! Can't wait to see how there dishes taste like!! read more

New York pizza has a lot of competition - compared to the selection available in neighboring town Yorktown this pizza is really good for wha it is. I recommend their vegetable slice; lots of roasted vegetables, YUM! read more

Terrible service. Got cursed at by a delivery driver once, without saying a single word to him. Plenty of great pizza places in Peekskill, no reason to deal with this place. read more

First introduced to their chicken masala sandwich, to die for. Since then, a slice has never let me down, their grilled chicken Cesar salad is out of this world. read more

Antonios usually has some decent food. I like their pizza and burgers more than almost any other Italian spot in Peekskill. Oh and their chicken francese too....not to mention their MONSTER wedges. However their people skills are seriously lacking and they lost me as a long term customer over a $5 coupon that was going to come back to them in the form of a tip anyway. It's the principle of things sometimes. read more

Best pizza we have found in Peekskill. Our usual order is xl pepperoni (it's huge) their supreme is good also. The sausage they use is very flavorful. They are reasonably priced and very quick to deliver. read more

Good pizza and subs...reasonably priced and friendly staff...a little hard to find if you don't know where it's located (in the Rite Aid shopping center) read more

Customer service was fantastic from the guy who answered the phone to the delivery guy who could deal with my high energy jumping puppy! The pizza was great - 2 large pies - well cooked with plenty of delicious toppings. We will be ordering from Antonio's regularly! read more

I suspect someone at Antonio's stole my debit card info. I have never called them for a pizza delivery. The one time I called in a large pizza order for an office lunch because a coworker recommended them, a few hours later I got a notice from my bank that someone used my card number to make 4 purchases at Lowes totaling $2000. I don't believe it's a coincidence! Whomever took the phone order gave my card number away and they used it for these fraudulent purchases. DO NOT GIVE THEM YOUR CARD INFO OVER THE PHONE. Or better yet use another pizza place. I am reporting them to the police. read more

Yo cmon man if you don't know the area you agree to deliver to, don't confirm the order. It's about to be 2017 y'all. iPhone has 7 versions out and Google Maps is about as detailed as it gets. There are multiple GPS programs out there. Your driver deada** called me 4-5 times. I'm not the GPS, as a business, that's your responsibility. NOT COOL. read more

Great pizza! And even greater prices. I was craving Italian and ordered online. I got chicken parm, ziti, salad, and bread all for $12.00. It was huge portions too!! First time trying something other than pizza and I will definitely be coming back read more

Very good pizza and very reasonable. Other dishes are also very good and as far as the wedges are concerned,you can only eat half because they are about 12 inches long and well stacked. Enjoy. read more

Their pizza is soo good. Quality= quantity Words can't emphasize how good it is you just have to try it for yourself.

Terrible absolutely terrible, was told over the phone 35 mins for my order waited over an hour before I called & asked where my delivery was , was told by owner sorry they mistakenly put pick up on order (even though they asked for my address & gave delivery time when I ordered) & it was on it way immediately , after waiting an additional 25 mins I decided to call back & cancel my order then I was rudely hung up on. Side note: Been going to Antonio's way before new owner bought about 10+ years back I WILL ABSOLUTELY NEVER GO TO THIS ESTABLISHMENT EVER AGAIN. Terrible when local business can't appreciate local customers. All I wanted to do was feed my daughter thanks for the food (sarcasm) read more

Love their Pizza, their wings however would be so much better if they would stop breading it first. I had wings from their yesterday and hated them. I hate breaded hot wings. I like my wings just fried/baked and dumped in sauce no breading. Actually this is the only place I know of in the area that breads their wings first. Please guys can we have wings the regular way, the breading makes it soggy and not very appettizing. read more