Food was great! It's a small place w a few tables but perfect for our lunch date! We had lunch specials....my husband had the Chicken Parm Panini and I had the Sausage w broccoli rabe (they switched up chicken for sausage) The Panini's were delicious! They came w Salad or fries and bottled water $13.99 The staff were very friendly and polite! The young lady at the counter served us at the table and couldn't be nicer! I'm going to be a regular! read more

See all

The margarita pizza at Amici is the best on Staten Island. Their dishes are also great they have great sauce the eggplant is very good and they make a pasta primavera that is very tasty. I hope they are there permanently. read more

Been ordering from here for years and Was not up to par. Got grandma pie half sausage. The pie was way thinner than usual and the sauce was incredibly salty. Very disappointing. Maybe time to find a new spot. Sad read more

I ordered a pie and a calzone, and as soon as I sat down to eat the cheese in the calzone was bad.. It was so bad that I had to throw it out and whoever was answering the phone didn't give anything I said any value. I will not be ever ordering again read more

Great atmosphere, great pizza and friendly, very hospitable owner. Good for couples or families.

Their pizza is excellent! The sauce is not too sweet and the spices are the perfect blend. You will not be disappointed. Delivery happened in a timely manner. read more

Wow!! I drive all the way from queens with my 2 aunts just to eat an entire pie (grandma pie). Plus I take a pie to go back home to last me read more

Amici Pizza - Grandma pie - Italian Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Best Grandma Pizza i've ever had. Affordable and you're getting what you paid for, a quick high quality slice everytime read more

Amici Pizza - Grandma Slice and Sicilian Slice - Italian Near Me - Staten Island, New York

This is how pizza used to taste!! Sooo good! I'm from CT and hubby is from NYC (so we know GREAT pizza) and this was top class. Prices like they used to be, food like it should be. We got a spinach and cheese Stromboli and a large cheese pie. Just absolutely delicious. read more

We received a menu in our mailbox a couple of months ago. We were so disappointed in the pizzeria's around my neighborhood. They lacked the love that goes into the food they make. I do have to say is that my family and I will be trying pretty much everything on their menu. Only 2 items we didn't care for, but that might be our tastebuds. The reason I say this is so far the food is fabulous. The grandmother pie is so well made and the sauce is amazing. If amici's made a stuffed artichoke tender non baked I would love to try it. I'm a huge fan of flavor. I recently had a vegetable lasagne for the first time in my life at a hospital that make's homemade food and it was absolutely amazing. Flavor is king when cooking. You guys, I would consider Royalty. Thank you for another outstanding meal. People I'm serious when I say give them a try. read more

I ordered a meatball park hero and the meatballs weren't cut and the bread was inedible. Hard as a rock. I was very busy after it so I called them a few days later to let them know about it and the woman who answered the phone was beyond nasty. She told me I should've called Friday when I ordered and what would I like her to do about it now in the nastiest tone. read more

We own a rental (2 units) on Station Ave and for the past few months have been renovating 1 of the units after a jackass tenant left. We have ordered from Amici 3 times, once was plain pie with wings, 2nd was marsala chicken pie and today 11/16 we got the seafood pie and ALL have been very very good! Such a good feeling giving 5 stars to a restaurant that truly delivers! Amici, you make Staten Island a better place for sure! read more

The worst chicken parm hero I've ever had. The sauce was disgusting. I would be ashamed to serve food like this.

Amici is aways a great place to order Italian from in the neighborhood! I live right down the street, and we order from here at least once a week! The food is always very delicious and fresh tasting. Thank u guys for being dependable and yummy! read more

Updating again because we tried the grandma pizza after the last mishaps from a few years back and it's delicious again! The food is great quality at Amici. read more

Ordered a grandma pie because I saw so many reviews raving about it so I had to give it a try. Definitely didn't disappoint. The driver was very nice and the food was even better read more

I order from this place all the time... Love their food and their Grandma Pie is excellent!!

Always a good pizza & they do deliver. The pizza was cooker well done as ordered. They deliver on time.

Amazing pizza. Fast delivery. Definitely recommend trying, you won't be disappointed!

I am very picky when it comes to pizza. I love dough, just enough cheese, not too much sauce, but just enough...and a lot of pepperoni to cover the entire pizza, but not too overwhelming. Let me tell you, with how complicated that sounds, this Pizza is by far the best I've ever had! From their sweet staff to the variety of options in the menu, it's very fresh, flavorful and well prepared. I wish this pizzeria was nearby where I live because I would be there all the time. I 1,000% recommend! read more

See all

Fabulous pizza and meals. Great cheese . Great sauce. Entrees are reasonable and generous.This is a takeout pizzeria. If you don't live to far, its one of the best pizzerias on Staten Island. read more

Truly the best grandma pie I've ever tasted. Fresh and Delicious!

Hands down the best pizza I've ever had since I left Brooklyn. You can order anything you want here and if I make a suggestion, order the grandma pie, it's delicious! They also have professional and courteous service. read more

This is one of the only two places I mess with on the south shore. And that's only cuz the other place is closer but amici is always worth the trip. First time We started with their pizza which was great. Then tried rolls and entrees and each time everything hit the spot. Most recently we tried their catering and everyone was asking where we got it from. Foods always been fresh and delicious. And Prices are very reasonable. Best thing is they don't cheap out on protein. Even the catered wraps were heavy and overflowing with chicken. The hot trays also had a lot of meat. Good place. They are doing dining right at amici. Oh and u definitely need to try their rice balls. read more

Love the cold seafood salad from here! Always fresh, plentiful and delightful! They give you a nice portion size- so much that I can eat it it twice, and it's only like $15 something. Must try! read more

Amici Pizza - Cold seafood salad - Italian Near Me - Staten Island, New York

I wish I could give this a higher rating. The people who work there were very accommodating, even offering to whip up a pepperoni stromboli from scratch, but I'm not certain this is the best Staten Island has to offer, pizza wise. I ordered a regular cheese slice and proceeded to it in a desultory fashion. The only way I could describe the taste is "unusual." It wasn't bad-it actually grew on me the longer I tried it-but it wasn't anything special. It's not a bad local pizzeria, but in terms of the quality of pizza I would rate it relatively low, unfortunately. Hopefully, that was a one-off experience. read more

I decided to call in an order late yesterday afternoon around 5:30ish. And let me tell you I just ate the BEST baked ziti I ever eaten (besides my own, of course, lol). It was so satisfying, that I will only order from here among the many, many other pizza place in this area from now on. The sauce was perfect as was the portion size. I also order the mozzarella, tomato & basil, which was also absolutely delicious. Next time I think we'll try their pizza, if it is delicious as the baked ziti was, I'll let you know. read more

Tonight was my first time ordering here and i ordered a grilled chicken wrap. The wait wasn't long at all and my wrap was done to perfection, and was delicious! Offered curbside pickup and the gentleman who brought out my food was very nice. Will definitely be returning. read more

The best grandmas pies on Staten Island !!! We been ordering the chicken franchise grandma pie and it's to die for !!!! All pizza is excellent. Give it a try !!!! read more

Omg my new pizzeria cafe. Super delish Pizza and really fresh tomatoes and mozzarella. There. service is very prompt since we had an awesome delivery guy that got everything right the first time.Grandma's pie are truly to die for so authentic tasting. Brings you back to the good old days in Italy!!! OMG!!!! read more

We did a little bit of everything- 1 buffalo, 1 bbq, 1 vodka, 1 chicken caesar and 1 margarita. Crust was strong enough to keep each slice straight, which I like. The bbq chicken was great and I like may have even had bacon. The caesar slice was weird. I think you need to cook the crust and then add the salad, because this one ended up a little chewy and tasted underdone. That said, the actual flavor was good, just weird textures. Overall, solid. read more

Pepperoni pizza here is fire. Would recommend. Crispness is right. Good spice level. Doesn't fall apart. Top tier.

Their Sicilian slice has an airy, light dough on the inside and delicious crust. I would opt for a middle piece if you like more sauce and cheese than dough. The white pie also has an excellent crust, perfectly done. Just enough cheese and ricotta. Would definitely go back to try different foods. read more

On their menu, they advertise their Grandma's pie, which I agree is well above average, but I was actually more impressed with their vodka slice, which is among the best I've had. read more

Amici Pizza - two slices of pizza on a paper plate - Italian Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Usually their pizza is amazing, but tonight was incredibly shoddy. I understand that it's 2 nights before Christmas and pribably a lot of other customers had the same thought "let's have some delicious grandma pie from amici tonight," but tonight is way below par. Waited over 1.5 hours for the 2 pies, boxes were squished and leaky. The spinach and artichoke pie was either under or overcooked, the cheese was spilling over the edges on both pies, very soggy crusts and cheese smelled a bit too smelly for cheese. If the pies weren't so badly made, I wouldn't have minded the extra wait. Tonight, it's leaky cheese stuffs and pepto. read more

Amici Pizza - Pictures not really doing it justice, but the cheese is spilling over the edges and smell odd. - Italian Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

Blown awayyyy. Went in for pizza they made me a burrata prosciutto and arugula pizza. It wasn't even on the menu but they helped me out. I'm mad I didn't save the picture because it was beautiful. The most amazing pizza I've ever had!! The service was amazing they were friendly and you can tell they take pride in presentation. I went in completely drained from work and left in a elated mood. Amazing highly recommend! read more

Recently started ordering from Amici. Spinach and artichoke grandma pie is a must have. So delicious, I had to call them back and let them know. read more

Amici Pizza - four slices of pizza on a plate - Italian Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Makes a great Grandma Pie. Some excellent lunch items as well. I would recommend for pick up or delivery. Not really a place to sit down and eat. read more

I ordered their Grandma's Pie the other night. It was excellent the crust was cooked just right not soggy not burnt. I also had their rice balls. I highly recommend the rice balls and the Grandma's pie. I will be going back again to try their other stuff. read more

The best grandma pie on Staten Island. Also they have very good chicken wings! The delivery was prompt also. Definitely a must try!! read more

Amici Pizza - Great grandmama pie! - Italian Near Me - Staten Island, New York