Definitely worth the hype. If you are looking for a high spot, that seems to be a neighborhood institution, go here. The pizza is excellent and the vibe has that old school family feeling. Like a place where you take your family on a kid's milestone birthday. Actually got the pizza to go, and the customer service was excellent. The pie arrived even faster than I thought it would. read more

Pizzeria Giove - Italian Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

Restaurants that take care of their customers and employees are some of the best I have been to, and this one is no exception. Schlepping all the way out to Staten Island for this pizza was a risk I decided to take, and it paid off. The restaurant is close by the Staten Island Railway, and inside feels like a true Italian pizzeria, but not like one you would see in Brooklyn. This one is more high quality, and it shows in their pizza. The pizza is phenomenal. Outstanding. I got two pies, one red and one white, for contrast and both are worthy of terrific merits. El Naso, the red pie, is beautiful in color and taste. The porky sausage and the hot soppresata add a nice flavor to the pie, the crispy crust, it was all lining up nicely to be a great pie. I am happy I went with my gut and got this. For my white pie suggestion, I asked my server, Leslie (more on her in a moment), what to get. She suggested El Pizzaiolo. Like the red pie, it tastes gorgeous thanks to the silky and luxurious truffle oil. The crimini mushrooms and Italian sausage accentuate it beautifully and the Parmesan reggiano cheese provides a sharp, salty note to the pie. It rounds the whole thing out nicely. Leslie is one of the reasons I enjoyed my experience. At first I thought she was just a tease with her giggly and youthful demeanor, but after talking to her I found something more deeper and meaningful. There is a depth of intelligence that she has but a naïveté that needs to be cracked before her. The fact that tips mean nothing to her speak volumes about who she is. I really wanted to give her something significant to take home with her, but fun conversation and the fact she is mentioned here will be enough for now for this attractive, lissome soul. Since both pies filled me up nicely, I had to pass on dessert. But I promised that down the line I will be back because the pizza is just so darn good. Leslie, thank you for the lovely experience and I hope someone sees my compliment and gives you a little extra in your next paycheck. You deserve it. Like this pizzeria well deserving of a five star review. read more

Pizzeria Giove - Italian Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

We haven't been in this place for many years and me, being the biggest lover of white pizza, decided to come back and order one white and one red pie. We tried white one first and it was something off and taste was wrong for both of us. Red pie with sopressata was super good. We decided to try white again and it was the same. Because we wasn't far from restaurant, I decided to go and tell them our problem (and I'm introvert so it was stressful for me). I explained our problem and they offer me to make a new pie. Main chef came and asked how I would like it. I told you can make omakase (chef choice). And he made us SUPER GOOD PIE! It was unbelievably delicious. 10 stars and excellent costumer service! read more

Pizzeria Giove - Super delicious pizza! Now my favorite - Italian Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

Good pizza fast.getting it! Wish they delivered. Would recommend it. Hope to order again. read more

My boyfriend and I had a date night at Giove Sunday evening. We had an excellent meal and cannot wait to come back! He has been there before, but it was my first time. We decided on the caprese for our appetizer and then we split the large vodka pie for our main course. It was absolutely delicious! I wish I knew our waiter's name because he no was so nice and attentive. In the beginning of the night, I had ordered an apple spritz and developed a small allergic reaction to it causing me to stop drinking it and to take Benadryl. Our waiter took the drink off our bill and replaced it with a cappuccino which was very yummy. The ambience was cozy and intimate and a great date night spot! We will be returning soon! read more

This is a nice small restaurant with a large pizza menu, featuring white and red sauce options. It's fun to watch the pizza being prepared. We got 2 pies, wings, mozzarella sticks and chicken entrees with veggies sautéed with garlic and oil. Everything was delicious and service friendly and attentive. We've come here when visiting family and it's always great. read more

I will start by simply saying this place makes the best pizza in NYC and every visit is a challenge to figure out which of the many great pizzas we are going to order. Tonight we ordered 5 smaller pizzas (6 slices each) for the 6 of us that went, just because we couldn't decide. We got the famous Variopinta, Del Pizziaolo, Parma and La Barese to start and for "desert" we got a classic cheese. We debated which was the best on never came to consensus. Stop reading and go now. If you want to keep reading my other thoughts feel free. I may be from Chicago (hold back comments about our stuffed pizza) but I am ready to admit, despite being a life-time Chicagoan, that NY style pizza is the best!! I manage to get up to New Haven and NYC quite a bit for work. I use these opportunities to do everything I can to find the greatest pizzas. Pizzeria Giove is my favorite hands down. I hate to admit I found this place because my in-laws live 3 blocks away. I'm used to finding gems thru lots of web research and watching Guy Fieri. I know this post is getting long but I need to say that the most important thing about this place is Giorgio, the owner. The guy is a legend--he has lived my dream life making pizza and living in Italy. But most important for this review is that the man has been at the restaurant making the pizza EVERY TIME I come. That is what differentiates this shop. He didn't stop after he perfected the recipe. He has dedicated his life to making people happy. And he is a good guy. He is always friendly and willing to chat about whatever you desire (in my case, giving advice how my kid can improve his pizza dough recipe). Thanks again Giorgio for giving me time, advice and another great dinner!! read more

Pizzeria Giove - Giorgio making a Margherita pizza with olives. I only wish I wasn't so full or would have ordered this also!! - Italian Near Me - Staten Island, New York

The food was delicious and the service was attentive and courteous. I enjoyed the low light atmosphere with tasteful decor. The price was decent considering everything is more expensive with inflation...parking can be hit or miss. read more

Food was good! Delivery was fast! They were nice. Very good pizza! They have thin pizza! read more

Best pizza in AMERICA! Can't believe how incredibly delicious the pizza and food are at Giove! An absolute must have! read more

Great service, very spacious, lots of people ordering pick up. Red pizza - in general nice new york thin slice pizza Naso 5/5 very good! was skeptical about the tobacco but it added a nice touch Margherita 3/5 surprisingly disappointing. it was your average joe read more

Pizzeria Giove - naso pizza - Italian Near Me - Staten Island, New York

This place had some really good food. The appetizers were to die for. I didn't get photos of everything. The Shrimp Parm was not to my liking, too salty. The Chicken Parm was excellent. I can't attest to the rest but my daughter said the Pesto Pasta was really good. The Cheese Pizza was excellent. The service was impeccable. We were seated quickly and constantly checked on to see if anything was needed. The place was a little small but very clean with a nice atmosphere. I don't know the price because my son in law snuck and paid for it but I am assuming it was over 300 for 7 of us. And he left a 100 dollar tip. Overall it was a great place and we will go back when we visit again. read more

See all

Amazing amazing and amazing. Hands down the best quality food and pizza I've had on this island and 1000% consistent always! That's why he beat Bobby Flay! read more

Nothing special here, typical pizzeria It was Loud when we were there Pizza is ok Parking horrible as it is a busy area The service was average read more

If your thing is too find a good eat in Pizza spot where you can order a personal pie with an espresso. The Pizzeria Giove is where you want to go. It's a quaint space in the middle of a hectic New Dorp Lane. Whether you want a bite while waiting for someone, to share a small pie after a study session, or share a large pie with the family Pizzeria Giove is your place.Its a little pricier then some places. But in this case your paying for good food with the addition of the great ambience in the restaurant. Friendly and courteous staff. What better a place to order in at. read more

The rice balls are excellent as is the pizza and the service! Highly recommended! It can be a little loud inside but totally worth it.

After reading the reviews, we decided to give this place a try after a company picnic. We were immediately seated after arriving. The restaurant is medium in size, with tables seating up to 4 people covering every inch of the floor. Towards the back is the kitchen, which you can watch while you wait for your food to be ready. Framed pictures also adorn the walls as well and the restaurant is dimly lit to evoke an elegant atmosphere. We ordered the following: Polipo al Rosmarino, which is pan-seared octopus with rosemary and creamy potato puree. Instead of potato puree, they gave us potato croquettes instead. I felt that there was more croquettes than octopus. Hubs didn't like the fact that the server didn't tell us that they didn't have potato puree while we were ordering it. If we had known that it was all fried, we wouldn't have ordered it. Small Bresaola Special, which is air dried and salted beef that has been aged for two to three months and served thinly sliced. Hubs liked it but didn't care for He said that it was similar to smoke beef jerky but it's on him because he wanted to try it. Daughter said that she liked it and thought it was tasty. I thought it was ok but I was a little disappointed with it. Small Margherita, which is San Marzano tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil & EVOO. The Margherita pie was good but nothing special. Daughter and I liked the Margherita. We thought it was tasty. Service was quick and friendly. Will probably return to try other items on the menu. Reason why I deducted a star is because we didn't care that they did a switcheroo on the potato puree with us. read more

Places recommended is one of the best pizza spots in the area by a local and it didn't disappoint. Nice crunchy dough with the right amount of salt, nice mozzarella cheese and the arugula was fresh. read more

Pizzeria Giove - Arugula with half sausage, half prosciutto - Italian Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Wowzer!!! Their panini on flat bread is exceptional! We had the grilled eggplant with ricotta and caramelized onions. To die for!!! The eggplant parmigiana hero was spectacular. We found our forever place! read more

I am new to the Staten Island dining experience, so I usually ask for recommendations. Somehow, this is the one place no one ever mentioned until recently one person told me about it. Coming from a pizza fanatic, this pizza hit every spot ! Surprisingly, I really enjoyed the white pizza which I never order. This place takes their pizza very seriously. They import some their ingredients and make their own cheese! Each pie to made to perfection ! read more

Pizzeria Giove - Italian Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

Heard so many good things about Pizzeria Giove that we finally had to try it for ourselves, cozy indoor atmosphere to dine in and the delicious pizza smell hits you right when you enter. We ordered the zucchini for our appetizer and it was good! Nice and light, then two of us shared the small variopinta pie and the classic Margherita pie, both were so good!!! Thin crust and full of flavor, I highly recommend to give this spot a try, we really enjoy everything! read more

See all

Loved loved this place! Went with family last night to celebrate a birthday. Great service , table was reserved and ready for us and great menu. Appetizers were all delicious and the pizza was terrific! One of the best crusts I have tired in awhile! Looking forward to going back soon . Def recommend read more

See all

Like many, I've heard so much about Giove so decided to swing by and would note 2 things: 1) The staff is so friendly, particularly one young lady at the front. 2) The pizza is fantastic; Marg w/sausage read more

The best pizza in Staten Island! Pizza tastes best if you dine in. Super thin crust, crispy. No flop. High quality ingredients. Unique and unlike any other pizza I've ever had. Tons of options for toppings and lots of unique pizza combinations. Great for groups, family occasions or date night. Service is quick and everyone is so friendly. Don't sleep on the mozzarella sticks , wings, or tiramisu best on the island hands down. read more

Amazing Pizza. Worth the price based on the value. I highly recommend them in the part of NY that boasts "America's best pizza" they stand out for specialty and non traditional pie read more

Everything was absolutely delicious! Service was phenomenal and they make you feel like you sitting at home with family. Great time!

Food was good. Good dough, sauce and crumbled sausage. Very tasty. Service was good. Nice place inside. Thin pizza. I would prefer a thicker crust especially with these ingredients. read more

Needed a spot to eat and found this nearby. Apparently, they were on throwdown with bobby flay and I am a huge fan of the food network. The pizza that was on the show was kind of funky but it worked. It was some kind of white pizza. The chicken parm hero was ok. Not my fav. Chicken parm tasted like something from a normal corner pizzeria. Stick with the pizza here. 3.5 stars read more

Pizzeria Giove - Italian Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Very delicious, thin crust pizza. Worth the treat once in a while. Toscana $27, Prosciutto Crudo $24, and Fungi $22 were delicious. Definitely preferred the thin crust to traditional, as the proportion of dough to other ingredients was a better fit for me. This place is always packed, as the seating is very limited. Always a line at the door, waiting to be seated, so plan accordingly. Delivery or take out takes some time, so learn patience in the face of hunger. Prices for pizza pies are not cheap, for SI. read more

See all

Visiting from Las Vegas and took my family who lives in the area to try as we saw the clip from the old Bobby Flay shows. The pizza was as good as it gets, the staff was great, and the place is really nice. The owner came by at the end and brought our desserts -- classy and a nice touch that put a bow on a really nice dinner. Everyone raves about Joe & Pats as it's very good, but I'd lean Giove. 10/10 read more

Pizzeria Giove - Pizza - Italian Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

Fantastic Fantastic service and excellent quality delicious Italian food and delicious pizza amazing workers and owner outstanding once again and always read more

One of the best pizza and sandwich place on the island! My boss introduced me to this place and we shared a large pie and calamari between 3 people which was more than enough. The calamari was delicious and you need to ask them to pair it with the hot marinara sauce (it has a nice kick to it if youre obsessed with spicy like I am). The pizza was really good too but my favorite is the panini. So on my 2nd visit I took my best friend here, and she also fell in love with the panini. The hot sorpressata one with cheese and olives just mixed really well together. It was more like a calzone then a panini but either way this is officially one of my favorite place on the island! read more

Pizzeria Giove - Hot soprresta panini - Italian Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Disappointed to say the least. The girl who took the order over the phone completely messed up. Upon pick up items were wrong. What turned into a 20 minute wait to pick up was 50 minutes later. Food is okay. Pizza is floppy. read more

Haven't been here in a few years, and the pizza is as delicious as ever. Service is excellent, store is spotless. A must for pizza lovers, and worth traveling to from out of the area. Parking can be a hassle. read more

Giove is my favorite place to eat, whether I'm dining in or taking out, they never fail. Giorgio is amazing and so talented! I would recommend to everyone to try Giove, I promise you will not be disappointed. read more

Love the pizza options! We ordered the garlic herb pizza and the Giove white pie. The garlic herb was fantastic. I will definitely be back to order that pie again! My boyfriend didn't like the fresh cherry tomatoes on the white pie-- he was expecting something else than what was described on the menu. I thought it was really great but it was more like a salad pie. We ordered take out and it was ready pretty quickly. Everything came out fresh and hot right as we arrived to pick it up. Would love to come back and dine in next time! read more

Disappointed, and it hurts me to say so. We love this place. We ordered pappardelle with cream mushroom sauce, which was delivered. We have eaten there but have not taken out in a long time. There was half as much pasta, no side of bread or grated cheese and they used what appeared to be freeze-dried parsley for the same price as eating there. Truthfully, the sauce was still delicious and our classic pizza was top-notch. That's why I still gave 3 stars. This has always been a 5-star experience. What happened Pizzeria Giove? read more

Pizza on another level. Every pie here is worth trying especially the pie that beat Bobby flay. Also the rest of the menu is as good as the pizza. Nice atmosphere. Street parking. Award Winning Pie! read more

I'm picky with my pizza and love this spot! Both the thin crust and regular pie are phenomenal! I come here often for lunch and between the vibe (indoor and outdoor), the food, and the service, there is nothing that disappoints! Even the pricing is very reasonable which makes it easier to come here more often on my lunch break. You have to try the pizza, burrata, baked clams oreganoto, tiramisu and Ofcourse affogato before anything else. Ofcourse everything on the menu, even the salads are delicious! Those are just my personal favorites. read more

See all

First time here in about 5 years. I have to say I was really disappointed with the service. Food was still good but their pizza oven and back kitchen do not communicate with each other. Appetizers came out relatively quick. Then came some of the kitchen items/ food. Like Pasta dishes. A good 10/12 minutes later the paninis came out with the personal pie. The wait staff---never saw waiter again until he brought check and way too many bus people for the small space. They hovered over us- I was afraid to put down my fork he might take it. And a pet peeve they cleared plates before all were done. One of the other staff, maybe a head waitress, asked if we were done kind of abruptly. Just weird vibe. I don't remember it being that way. Sorry if TMI but Both my kids left in a hurry for bathroom reasons! read more