My fiancé and I made a reservation. Upon arrival, we were greeted with smiles at the doorway. We were then led to an area against the wall where every other diner was. I wish we had been sat in an area showing off more of the restaurant and its decor. The service was ok. It wasn't anything memorable. However, the owner (?) came over to us a few times to ask how everything was. We ordered a couple of cocktails. They were pretty pricey, coming out to ~$20 per drink. The branzino was delicious. It was everything I hoped for in a bite - buttery, soft, with some crunch and nuttiness from the hazelnuts. It all blended together very well. My fiancé ordered the maiale. His order was also very good and he enjoyed it. read more

See all

What a fantastic experience! Service is very attentive; no glass was allowed to run empty without offers of refills. We dined in the enclosed outer area which was beautifully decorated for the holidays. The food here is among the best in New York City. The beet salad appetizer is fresh and delicious. The focaccia is huge and perfectly balanced. The calamari was the only dish which could have been portioned a bit larger but was also fresh & cooked perfectly, with 2 outstanding sauces. The Caesar salad is very generously portioned; be sure to let them know your preference about anchovies! The short ribs are top notch, on a bed of broccoli rabe & mashed potatoes. The branzino is cooked to perfection in an absolutely amazing sauce. Prices are substantial but justified: this is a case of you get what you pay for. read more

See all

Another wonderful meal! We have friends visiting from out of town and brought them here to celebrate a Birthday. We are consistently impressed by the portions and service. The manager makes a point to speak to every table and is knowledgeable about how each dish is prepared. Our server Terry was the absolute sweetest in helping us accommodate a meal for a child that was with us and brought out her meal prior to ours to ensure her mom was able to eat with us! The crème brûlée espresso was a perfect way to end the evening! read more

Pastavino - Rigatoni e Burrata - Italian Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

Food was extremely fresh. Had multiple appetizers including arancini, meatballs, calamari and flatbread. Pasta dishes are all fresh and you can taste the love and care put into them. Service was not rushed. Server was not intrusive. This is a special occasion place. Not close to my normal regular spots. read more

See all

Pastavino is as good as it gets! There's literally 1000 Italian restaurants on Staten Island and Pastavino knocks it out of the park. Had a reservation for the family and we came out on a holiday weekend to a packed out restaurant. Always a good sign. The menu itself is clear and concise. Appetizers ordered were unique and absolutely delicious. The entrees were nice sized and tasted great. Not a single complaint here. Funny enough with the meal being a good as it was we were actually blown away by the desert options. We went with the carrot cake and it was 10/10. Perfect way to end off a wonderful meal. Eat here! read more

Came here for a birthday dinner. It was a quite empty this night at the time we came. The restaurant is beautiful and very romantic for a first date or a nice occasion. The Wait staff here is amazing. They check on you all the time and aim to please. Problem here is I think they had an off night ( I hope). Like really really off night!! I ended up speaking with a friend who happened to be there the same night and found out he had the same exact experience. Over the course of dinner their food was over salted, bread was stale, and when the food came out it was luke warm to cold. I really don't like to complain during a meal (kills the vibe) so I spoke with the manager through email after the meal. Things like this shouldn't happen. Especially if we are spending $200 for a meal. It should be on point especially for a seasoned restaurant. It ruins the experience of a date, occasion, holiday.. read more

See all

Sat outside overlooking the water. Great service and large portions -- shared the escarole salad (dressed perfectly and delicious) and eggplant parm with my husband and both were big enough, like double portions. Wine by the glass selection was also excellent. read more

The food was great, but I'm giving 5 stars because of our server, Terry. This was my first time at Pastavino, and I already had good expectations based on other reviews, but the service was so on point. Terry was one of the kindest and most patient waitresses we've had. She took the time to give recommendations especially for the kids, kept checking in throughout our meal, and made sure we always had what we needed. I know some people might say, "Well, that's their job," but you can tell when someone really puts their heart into it and truly wants to make sure you have a great experience. We also had someone joining us later, and she never made us feel rushed or inconvenienced. She stayed patient, continued checking in, and was genuinely kind the entire time. The food was very good. I had pasta with clams and it was delicious. Our drinks and apps were delicious as well but great service can completely change an experience, and Terry really stood out and made our visit enjoyable. I'll be back for sure!!!! read more

We came from New Jersey to try out this spot since it was 25 min away . The ambiance was super chic and intimate - very lovely place for a date night. The food was amazing ; we had chicken parm with vodka sauce and apple pie for desserts . The drinks , the service , and all our dishes were delicious and very large size portions . We enjoyed our visit here read more

Pastavino - Chicken parm - Italian Near Me - Staten Island, New York

We had a few concerns. The owner contacted us to review their procedures, and the manager spoke to me at length and resolved any concerns I had. I am appreciative of their attention read more

I hosted a birthday dinner for my husband's 80th birthday on Saturday night. I'm from out of state, so most of my communications were by email. They were wonderful helping me reserve the space, choose the menu and take care of my bill. The ambiance was conducive to a great evening. The food was delicious as well as copious. The serving staff was uber attentive and helpful in every way. Conner worked with me to make it an extraordinary evening for my husband and our family. read more

We ate at Pastavino Trattoria. As a starter I had the MELA E GORGONZOLA raw & roasted apples, gorgonzola dolce, arugula, shaved fennel, toasted almonds, apple cider vinaigrette. My daughter ordered the Caesar, which is described on the menu u as a "rustic" salad the waiter warned us that it was heavy on the anchovy but she ordered it anyway. When the salads arrived I could smell the fish and cheese and my daughter took a few bites and didn't care for it. I swapped with her but also didn't care for it. My salad was delicious. The manager came by to express how sorry he was that we didnt care for the salad and offered her something else but not being really hungry she declined. For entrees my daughter had the Italian wedding soup which she said was delicious, my husband ordered the gnocchi which is Ricotta gnocchi, butternut squash, sage butter, grated cheese and I had the MELANZANE ALLA PARMIGIANO Crispy eggplant, mozzarella, marinara, shells in spicy vodka sauce. Both entrees were fabulous. We finished dinner with cappuccinos and strawberry gelato. An overall wonderful meal. And this is where they rose above the average restaurant. When our waiter delivered the check he informed us that they'd removed the $20.00 Caesar salad. This was an unexpected but very much appreciated effort in customer service. They didn't have to do that. But I will say that excellent customer service is something I really enjoy in a restaurant. And we loved the decor and ambience! We will definitely return. read more

See all

We went to Pastavino for my birthday on Saturday night, everything was perfect and super fun ! The service was impeccable and fun!! the ambiance is both perfect for a date or celebration ! The burrata salad and chicken Marsala were some of the best food I've had outside of Italy ! They serve Affogato which is a 10/10 and aperol spritz with a twist ! read more

See all

We've been here before but it has been a while. The ambiance in the restaurant is simply beautiful. As I digress, we started with the tuna tartar which was delicious. I ordered the seafood fra diavolo. Not too spicy but just enough. My husband ordered the shirt ribs which was fantastic. No room for dessert. Thank you for a great meal and a knowledgeable server who knows what he is talking about. We will be back read more

Too loud...no real view...and so so food! Way over hyped! I don't mind paying $20 for a cocktail if it has a goodly amount of liquor in it...that wasn't the case here! Service was fine! read more

Pastavino is arguably the best Italian restaurant on Staten Island. We went on a Friday night and the vibes were awesome. The place was packed and the music was great. Our appetizers were the highlight of the night. The Calabrese focaccia and the octopus were great. For our entrees, the short ribs were pretty dry and the greens in the cavatelli were not my favorite. I wish the rabbit ragu was prepared with more of a sauce base. Regardless, the pasta itself tasted very fresh and is noticeably homemade. The short ribs are probably something to pass on in my opinion. read more

See all

We had our family Christmas Eve dinner here and we were so happy we came! The food and service were amazing. The food portions were nice size and cocktails were delicious. The restaurant was beautifully decorated for the holidays. We come here a lot and always enjoy our time here. We will definitely be returning next Christmas Eve with the family! Thank you for a great night ! read more

Everything here is absolutely delicious! From the drinks to the food, I don't know what I enjoyed most. Friendly & helpful staff & such a beautiful atmosphere. The gnocchi with sausage was delicious, the chicken parmesan with vodka sauce was absolutely amazing, & The frozen espresso martini was to die for! We will surely be visiting this place again & again! read more

See all

Really nice ambiance but the staff was rushing us the entire time. It wasn't even close to closing time but they seemed almost annoyed at us when we asked for more time to look at the menu. Really disappointing read more

Omg! I feel like this place is a hidden geeemmmmm. Especially if you live in one of the other boroughs -- don't skip Pastavino. Sergio -- you're amazing!!! He helped me pick the best possible wine to pair with my dinner. I'm not a wine snob or in fact know anything about it so having someone like him who knew exactly what I should try and ended up liking. Yessss. Also, the portion are INSANE. I cannot believe how much food was on my plate. And yes, it was effing GOOD. I love the decor and they're right next to the water. So make sure you try going when the water is nice so you can sit outside. Overall 14/10! read more

See all

Ambiance: This restaurant is lovely - there is no denying this. It is located by the harbor waterfront with gorgeous views of the city skyline. Inside, you will find a bar and wine display in the back, along with a spacious dining area. Service: When we initially arrived, the service given by the waiter and staff was okay - nowhere close to excellent. Then, once I was spotted taking photos of the restaurant and food, their attention towards us shifted and the service we began receiving went from okay to good, which is what we initially expected upon arrival for this fine dining experience. Once the waiter became aware that I would be reviewing this restaurant (he asked), he became more attentive and began sharing the history of this restaurant and its chosen location on the island. I am unable to tell if we would have received a good service experience if he wasn't aware that I would be reviewing this restaurant as it was not consistent with what we had when we initially arrived. Food: We ordered the rice balls, chicken parmigiana and a pasta with vodka sauce- food was tasty and we were satisfied. We didn't have an appetite for dessert; however, we did notice those around us did enjoy theirs. read more

See all

Definitely! Haven't been in a while, but the service, ambiance & food is excellent. The manager John always visits the tables & remembers every customer. Wonderful place. read more

See all

Very good service and food. Highly recommend this location. The restaurant was very nice inside and clean.

Great spot in Staten Island and I would definitely recommend this place to locals and/or visitors. I was very please by the friendless and attentiveness of our server. Phenomenal Italian food, nothing disappointed. The ambiance was romantic with candle light and warmth. The place was buzzing with people and their conversations. This place does get packed so you definitely need a reservation. read more

See all

My wife and I absolutely love it here! From the ambiance, to the service and most importantly, the food, it's an amazing experience from start to finish. We're very lucky to have Pastavino on Staten Island! read more

We made last minute reservations on Easter Sunday, and thankfully they were able to accommodate us. From the moment we walked in, we were greeted by the hostess, taken right to our seat and our sever introduce himself. He went over the menu, offered recommendations and took our drink order. Our drinks were perfect, and the food was outrageously delicious! Cacio Pepe, has to be their best pasta dish! Our server didn't miss a beat. He was friendly and attentive but not overly attentive. The vibe is everything. We had a fantastic holiday celebrating with Pastavino. Thank you!! read more

See all

Top notch modern Italian restaurant, consistent, fresh, nice outdoor patio by the ocean, great drinks, this place does it all...very well.

if you go to pastavino you MUST get the burrata pasta! the pasta is so fresh as well as the burrata. the ambiance is cozy and a little on the fancier side which makes it perfect for a date night or special occasion. they also have frozen espresso martinis and a lemon spritz which are great to sip on as well! read more

Pastavino - burrata pasta - Italian Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

Amazing on every level!!!! Trendy Atmosphere and delicious food. What can be better? The location is great with onsite parking!

Pastavino is very aesthetically pleasing, where once you walk into the restaurant you feel as if you're transported into a relaxing and elegant atmosphere facing the waterfront! The service is also very professional, attuned, friendly, and warm. Our server, David, was very patient and kind, taking the time to explain to us certain ingredients we weren't familiar with, which we are very appreciative of! He also helped us find a seat that was warmer (in the terrace), which made our experience a lot more comfortable because today was definitely quite chilly, and the indoor dining was definitely colder due to it being air-conditioned. I want to take this moment to thank David for being so considerate and for demonstrating exemplary service! Now given the amazing service by David and the amazing ambiance, why the low score? Unfortunately it boils down to the food. We started off with the Polpo, which was the Spanish octopus with crispy potato and garlic aioli. The sauce was very mild in flavor, which did not enhance the flavor of the octopus by much. The octopus was also not cooked consistently throughout, where some parts was incredibly soft up to the point of having a raw texture, and some parts was overly charred leaving an intense bitter taste that overpowered the taste of the octopus. As you can see in the picture, the char was not consistent which left some areas tasting more burnt than charred. For our main, I got the Chittarra and my wife got the Bucatini Neri Vongole. My chittarra was overly al dente, which diverted my energy to chewing rather than savoring its taste. The owner, John, was kind enough to explain to us that due to their pasta being all homemade, it is often not possible to make them any softer than al dente due to it not having time to dry out to reduce its water content. The owner was kind enough to replace my dish with a different pasta which I appreciated. Would be helpful to highlight that on the menu in the future since not every diner will know this fact. However, although the remade pasta was softer, the dish itself was overly salty and the pork pieces were a bit burnt, which altogether detracted from the dish's creaminess and richness. My wife's bucatini was also very al dente, but she enjoyed it due to its generous amount of clams (although more shells than actual clams), which you can see in the pictures. The garlic, lemon, and crushed taralli all blended into a refreshing and savory mix, and my wife definitely enjoyed its flavor profile more than I did. Overall, I want to emphasize how amazing the service is from David; he really worked hard to ensure and provide diners with the best experience possible. Unfortunately this time it was a miss for us, but it could likely just be due to the selection we chose that was subpar and underwhelming. This is their autumn menu and will likely change depending on when you read this review, so good luck! (: Lastly, there was this little fly that bothered us the entire meal, so just keep that in mind if you dine in the terrace! Thank you for reading and best of luck! (: P.S. John, one of the owners, was kind enough to reach out to inquiry about our negative experience, which shows that he is dedicated in addressing issues diners have and trying to improve the restaurant as best as they can during these challenging times. However, the rationale he provided for the charred octopus was that it was typically served charred, and the saltiness of the Chittara was that it was simply how it is typically made in Italy, which was dismissive and highlighted only one issue without addressing my other concerns regarding the dishes (e.g., the inconsistent texture of the octopus, it being overly and inconsistently charred, mild flavor of the sauce, burnt guanciale, etcetera). Rationalizing a subpar experience of a dish by trying to normalize it by saying that is how it is made does not validate or empathize with the diner's experience, nor does it suggest any desire for growth and betterment, it dismisses and places the blame on the diner for not enjoying the food. Nonetheless, the important note to keep in mind is that if your experience is not optimal, do your best to speak up at the moment for David and the other friendly servers appear willing to remedy the situation as best as they can. I have not experience any rude waiters or waitresses as highlighted by other reviewers, but I have experienced the heavy handedness of the saltiness of the food that others have wrote about. If your dish comes out too salty, bring it to your servers' attention and I am sure they will do their best to address it! Ask for David and you will be professionally taken care of! Hope this review helps and best of luck! (: See read more

See all

From checking in, to the service, food and ambience - we were treated like family. The food is consistently amazing and we always look forward to a meal at Pastavino. We brought family and they were as impressed as we always are. Thank you, read more

Finally made it to dinner last night with friends. Nice menu nice selections. The prices are Manhattan prices though, not Staten Island prices. Our appetizers and entrées were very good as were the drinks. My only disappointment was my affogato for dessert was just not good which surprised me. read more

See all

One of my favorite restaurants on Staten Island. The food is always incredible and fresh. The service is top tier. The male host/server is always so friendly and remembers all the customers when they come back. You can tell he takes pride in what he does and how he elaborates on the menus to help you pick the best meal. My favorite place for an intimate dinner with friends and family. read more

AMAZING! From the food, service, and ambiance this place was amazing. This was my first time visiting and I 100% would return and recommend. The food was fresh and delicious. We had it all from appetizers to entrees to dessert. You have to try the frozen espresso martini it was out of this world! Ambiance and service of the restaurant was also a 10/10. I would say this place is good for lunch or dinner, an intimate date or even a night out with the girls. read more

See all

I've been meaning to check out this restaurant for a while now and I'm glad I finally did! Restaurant is beautiful but the food and the stellar service is what takes it over the top. Sal took great care of us throughout our dinner, offering great suggestions that did not leave us disappointed. Cocktails are fun and creative and they have an impressive wine list as well. Can't wait to be back, especially in the summer, to enjoy their outdoor dining option and nice water views. read more

See all

Great food and spot on service. Wish I had gotten the waiters name...he was really on his game. Absolutely enjoyed our evening there with friends, thanks Pastavino,we'll be back read more

I enjoy coming to this place because of the delicious food and amazing customer service. All the times I have went the managers always ask if we are doing ok and they are quick to fix things if needed. This is also a beautiful place with great ambiance. Highly recommend! read more

We love, love, love Pastavino! It is such a gem of a restaurant. From the moment you walk in you are transported. The ambience exudes so much warmth and coziness. It is truly beautiful. The menu offers a broad selection of wonderfully prepared Italian dishes. The Caesar salad and fried calamari our just two of our favorites. We can't help but order it every time we go. The regional menu is a special treat too! I can't think of a time that I've dined there that the staff wasn't exceptional. All in all, Pastavino is a little slice of Italian restaurant heaven that we highly, highly recommend! You will not be disappointed! read more

First time here... I was expecting high hopes for this place but it disappointed. We had calamari for appetizer which was the only thing that was good out of our dinner, along with the side table bread. For main course we had the Paccheri Fra Diavolo & Pollo Marsala. The Paccheri was super flavorless and tasted very very sandy. Didn't give it a wow factor about it to match the price. The Marsala was basically salty soup with chicken sitting on top with some fancy garnish. The "soup part" was so salty and bitter that I didn't want to finish it. The chicken tasted rubbery. Service was very bleak and dry. The hostess you can tell she didn't want to be there. The ambience was weird nothing matched in there. read more

Food is always top quality and delicious. Ambience is nice and a cute spot to have a nice dinner. However, I did see a waitress come out of the restroom and not wash her hands thank goodness she wasn't the one serving my table! Edit: One of the owners reached out and said he would address the issue with all of the staff, which shows their commitment to quality and cleanliness. I am planning to continue to dine at this restaurant. Thank you for addressing the issue. read more

Pastavino - Branzino Secondi, Patate Contorni - Italian Near Me - Staten Island, New York