Food was amazing! Service was incredible, and the place is very sporty very cute! they have live music at night

Quite greasy, even their "healthier" options slapped with Greek/Mediterranean labels were just regular greasy pizza with some of these ingredients. Very misleading labeling. Meh for me. read more

Got snookered! Got there about 6:30, seated quickly, waitress took drink order. Ordered a XL pizza, (the works) menu had it at $28. When it came out, looked good, but after a few bites it was luke warm in the middle even tho the outside crust looked done. Seemed like it sat in the kitchen for a few minutes. Then I noticed it seemed small for an X-LARGE. Looked up on the wall at the pan sizes. Our pan size seemed more like a large. Called waitress over who called the mgr over. He assured us that was a XL which is 16". Further research found out there is no medium size. Just SM, Large and XL. Asked to see a menu, but was not provided one. Seems like Amici's eliminated the medium and down sized the large and XL. I had added extra toppings to the tune of $6, along with two drinks at $3.50, making the bill $43. Only gave a $3 tip. I use to go here a lot in the past. Unfortunately the Amici's in Conyers, Ga closed which was by far better than the Covington on the square location. read more

Food was great. service a disappointment. if you're charging an automatic 20% gratuity for a large group (12) at least try to wait on them. empty drinks for longer than 20 minutes is unacceptable let's not even talk about the disaster in getting the checks together - even after we lined it up and ordered per couple/ family at the start. read more

Nice little place to sit outside. Onion rings are very good. Pizza is about a 6 or 7 but surely not worth $7 a slice. The Caesar salad was good but I'm pretty sure the menu said olives and there weren't any. Waitress came out multiple times to check on us which is nice. However they slows dogs and nobody ever offered our dog any water ok this hot day. read more

Good pizza for a good price. Nothing crazy. Nothing bad. Just a straightforward pizza spot where you can actually sit inside and catch up with folks. read more

Not sure why I'm surprised, I've lived here 16 years and this happens every so often at Amicis on the square: it gets so bad you just can't go there. We live just blocks off the square, and love the proximity and the patio. But there's a reason we don't go twice a week anymore, instead twice in the last year. Latest issue was a take-out pizza order. 3 "large" pizzas (there's small, large, XL - so the large is actually deceptively a medium): spinach and cheese, a blonde Greek, and a woodsman. All three had barely any cheese? The crust, comically thin, and they don't do thin crust. And all 3 were waaayyy over cooked. The total after tax and tip (not sure why I did that) was about $80.00. Eighty. Dollars. Little Caesars would have been better for twenty bucks. I'm sad: I like this place and recently was told management had changed for the better. So do better Amicis. read more

Amici - Covington - Italian Near Me - Covington, Georgia

See all

Let me start by saying the service was swift and great. My server was very attentive and made sure I had everything I needed to enjoy my food. The kitchen made my pizza to perfection, as well as the fries & mozzarella sticks. I travel a lot and this was by far one of my best experiences!!! The ambience of the establishment was very cozy, but I can tell that when they have live music it must be fun. The place has a great vibe!! #YouGoGirl Layla!!!! read more

Amici - Covington - Bar - Italian Near Me - Covington, Georgia

Went to the new location in town center for lunch with my little one. I was so disappointed. I thought this could possibly be a place to get something quick to eat. Hmm no. Don't think I'll be returning. Soon as I walked in the place was a complete mess and they didn't clean it up until a group of people had walked on. I ordered a Cesar salad which took a full 15 mins just to come out. But I had notice the large group that came in before me had gotten their salad very promptly. My main dish was 6 wings and my son had spaghetti it took them 45 WHOLE mins to bring 6 basic wings out. The server was nice and apologized. read more

Food never disappoints. Service is usually on point! The restaurant is awesome and accommodating and clean. There's inside and outside seating. My work crew eats here about once a week. read more

Amici - Covington - Bar - Italian Near Me - Covington, Georgia

See all

Food is awesome!!! The lunch specials: salad and a slice for $10.99. Great deal!!! Fast service!!!

Was alittle skeptical after reading some reviews but decided to give it a shot anyways. We had wings as an appetizer alittle higher in price but the wings were hot and fresh and crispy and had good flavor. Got the buffalo chicken sub and chicken parm sub came out in a timely manner and tasted good!! over all i was satisfied. Only thing i'd change would be maybe cheaper wings and alittle spicer lol! read more

Service was ok but food was below sub par. Look at this soup, i could actually take out spoonfuls of the alfredo. Can't believe it made it out of the kitchen. read more

Amici - Covington - Literal alfredo soup, and chicken cooked to hell. - Italian Near Me - Covington, Georgia

The food here is absolutely delicious and a great menu. However, we have been here several times hoping for a change, and have been repeatedly disappointed with the very slow service- both with the wait staff and the kitchen. It's never been very busy when we have been there and there never seems to be more than one or two wait staff working. Most the time it's the bartender also waiting tables even when it does start to get a little busy. The kitchen is extremely slow, and could definitely use some extra hands in there. We have even seen a waitress or possible manager with her kids at work with her, going in and out of the kitchen. Kids do not belong in the kitchen. Please hire extra staff! read more

Hubby went last Sunday after church wth 11 ppl. He brought me home the Chicken Philly Sandwich wth French Fries. It was EXCELLENT! So refreshing to finally get food that serves quality well cooked food. The chicken was seasoned and grilled to perfection. The veggies of mushrooms, onions & peppers were crispy, yet tender. And the bread was extremely soft and warm. I had half on Sunday and ate leftover on Monday. Still tasted like it had just been prepared. Also, important to note is that the waitress was wonderful at her job. Ty Amici. read more

This is a nice place with good service and great food. Lala was wonderfully helpful. I have food allergies. She and the manager were great in helping me make my food choice. read more

The GM is awful all around. Frequently throwing the n word to her employees and drinks at the bar while her kids run around. Food is not good anymore and it's easy to see why. When no adults are running a place it's just a daycare read more

Sub-standard pizza with a price that was way out too high. You get better pizza at much better prices all over Covington.

Service was fantastic. Food was underwhelming at best. A smelly bar patron was loitering outside yelling at women and children (one of which was mine) by cat calling, generally harassing other guests and smoking around babies. Please remove the vagrant from the porch and stop the burning pizza. read more

Buffalo Dip was great. Great pizza. The pizza was cooked perfectly. Cold beer. A little pricey, but worth it.

Classic Covington restaurant that has stood the test of time. Great Italian food and some of the better wings in the area. Pizza is solid overall no complaints read more

Decent food & service. Not too terribly expensive. Enjoy sitting outside when weather permits.

Very good pizza joint. I really enjoyed their Greek salad. The choices of pizza were enough that most eaters should have a choice. If you like to cozy up in the bar, they have a great atmosphere read more

Slow bad service Ordered their homemade Alfredo pasta. After waiting an hour the waiter told me they were out of heavy cream and I needed to order something else. Was told they would comp us some mozzarella sticks. Waited another half hour and got pizza but no mozzarella sticks. Mozzarella sticks were brought out after pizza. Will not return read more

There two in Covington. The one just off the square is the best overall. Always enjoy this particular one. Food, service, and ambiance is great. However, be forewarned about the new one just built in the Publix Shopping Center. read more

Great tasting pizzas. Our server, Alana, was great....and overworked. This is a great neighborhood spot. We will be back. read more

See all

The managers there was rude and unprofessional. I am addressing everything she and the general manager said to the Health Department. (NO THIS DID NOT HAPPEN AT THE COVINGTON LOCATION) I do believe the COVINGTON location would have been more professional. I am not understanding how COVINGTON got involved in this. I never said and will never said anything bad about the Covington location because like I stated this happened in Conyers. No hair nets is being worn. If they wear hair nets this could eliminate the problem somewhat. The statement and I quote the rude manager " UNFORTUNATELY THERES NOTHING WE COULD DO BECAUSE EVERYBODY HAS HAIR" is about the most disrespectful thing a person could say to anyone spending there money in their Resturant. I will not be going back to this mess. So no thank you for you gift card keep it for those that like being treated like what I was treat like. read more

We dined in on Saturday after my daughter finished her work shift. We were seated immediately upon arrival. However, we sat waiting for a waitress for well over 20 minutes. We even watched while people who were seated after us received drinks and order before we even received a "hello" from a waitress. I actually had to walk over to the register where two waitresses were putting in orders to ask who was responsible for our table. The waitress who I believe was supposed to be our waitress based on the tables she waited on said she didn't know, but would take our orders. ‍. The burger I ordered was okay. I would've said it was great, but the bun was hard and stale. However, the meat tasted very fresh. I ended up just eating the meat and toppings because I didn't want to send it back. The wings we received were good. The fries were also good. Lucky for the waitress I tipped based on her service and not for leaving us sitting there. I literally had time to and did go and walk around the corner to get my car and move it closer to the restaurant. read more

See all

Service was great. Food was not all that. someone got alfredo that had 0 flavor. I asked for a plain burger and got a sour meat patty smothered in onions, little brother got boneless bbq wings and they were so burnt you couldn't take a bite. Very obnoxious staff they were standing right behind my table talking to some drunk customers and kept repeatedly bumping into me, when I got up to use the restroom and said excuse me they just rolled their eyes and kept talking so I was forced to barrel my way through. Overall not a great experience, but the server was fantastic which made it a little better read more

Amici's has great food! Their appetizers are delicious, the food is always fresh and tasty. I don't recall that I've ever had my order be incorrect which is nice. Sometimes service is lacking. My last visit our server seemed to disappear for long periods of time leaving us needing drinks, take away boxes, and a check to pay. I'd say that was the only improvement needed is to have the servers be more present in the sections they're working. I would chalk it up to maybe they were short staffed but there were servers everywhere, just not ours. read more

The food was good, service was good, but pretty expensive for pizza ( watch all the add ons).

What's not to like about a home town Italian place. The pizza is cooked to order & the service is always great. I usually go on Tuesday & Thursday. Tuesday's are the best because of music bingo. The Bartender is amazing & is always prompt with your drinks. If you haven't tried it I recommend it. The one in conyers isn't as good as the Covington location. read more

First off this is not a review of our service Emma was our server and she was great! The kitchen however was terrible. The calamari came out undercooked the buffalo dip was good however the chips were stale. My pizza was lukewarm at best and the veggies were not cooked at all. It was very busy and the kitchen was very slow. read more

Kind of a hole in the wall place. Decent pizza and sides good beer selection. Heard they are moving to Covington Town Center later this year. read more

Waited 15 minutes after being seated and no one ever came. Got up and left. Waiters passed us by a few times. Wth. Wasn't busy. 2pm on a Sunday. read more

We normally love Amici. We especially love the Blonde Greek pizza. Tonight we decided to order two large salads to go. I ordered the Caesar and my husband ordered the Cobb. I asked for no dressing because I wanted to use one I had at home. His was supposed to come with BBQ ranch. When my husband arrived home, his box had no dressing/ only oil and vinegar in containers. Mine, fully dressed with Caesar dressing. That was frustrating enough, then I see that it was made entirely of iceberg lettuce.., seriously? This is an Italian place- I went back and looked at the menu. NONE of their salads come with iceberg. They shouldn't even have it in the store. My husbands Cobb was supposed to come with mixed greens, nope- more iceberg. If there was an issue getting the lettuce they should have told us when we ordered do we could make another selection. $12 for a salad with nasty iceberg lettuce is not what I wanted at all. read more

Amici - Covington - My "Caesar" salad... with iceberg lettuce. - Italian Near Me - Covington, Georgia

I have long been a fan of Amici's with my first exposure being in Athens, scarfing down gar-chee-mar after bar hopping... Covington is lucky to have this spot in their cute little downtown square. It's a staple for Friday nights! Live music in the bar area and lots of friendly faces from around town. You can expect a 45 minute to an hour long wait at peak dinner hours on Friday and Saturday but it's totally worth it. You can walk around the other local shops while you're waiting because they send you a text message which is super convenient. Don't miss out on the olive oil store or if you wanna put dessert before dinner you can stop in to Scoops. As I mentioned earlier I typically start with the gar-chee-mar. The original is the best but they do have a buffalo chicken style that is pretty good. This ain't nothing fancy. Just so I set your expectations correctly, part of the obsession with gar-chee-mar is the fact that I used to eat it every time I visited friends in Athens in college. It's simple but it's delicious. The wings here are exceptional. I haven't met a flavor I didn't like but I think my favorite might be the lemon pepper. Nice and crispy on the outside with plenty of seasoning but not too much. The inside is tender and juicy, just the way they should be! You can order a slice any time of day, any day the week. I love that especially when I like to start with the wings. You can build your own slice or if you're there with friends y'all can share a pie. Yum! Nothing goes better with wings and pizza than cold beer. They have a rotating tap and it usually has some great local varieties. I enjoyed the scofflaw basement ipa on my last visit! This is my favorite spot to meet up with friends in Covington! read more

See all

While Amici's "Caesar Salad" was delicious many of the ingredients like the Tomatoes and Feta Cheese seemed Greek to me. Of course, I assumed they just screwed up my order, but Amici's fervently denies this. So, I guess Gordon Ramsey and I are both idiots. Anyway, Payton Manning was right about one thing ... Their Chicken Parm does taste so good. read more

Amici - Covington - It's Greek to me. - Italian Near Me - Covington, Georgia

See all

Food was cold when it came out. How does pizza come out cold and the crust burnt on edges.

Their pizza and wings are good if you enjoy gas station quality food, the place stays busy only because it's also a bar.. I guess anything tastes good when you get sauced... read more