Amazing experience! I was long overdue for a haircut and my beard was an overgrown mess because I was trying to grow it out to get reshaped after the last place butchered it. I've never been to American Shave before and I scouted them on Yelp before going. They had great reviews except for a couple negative comments about a guy named Maverick, but I was impressed with the owners commitment to follow up and make things right so I took a chance and went in as a walk in. I ended up getting a Signature Cut and Shave. The staff was friendly from the second I opened the door. The drink menu was a nice touch. I was greeted by my barber and when I sat he introduced himself; wouldn't you know...it was Maverick. At first I was a little concerned but that trepidation quickly went away. Maverick was awesome. He was professional. Did a stellar job. Carried on a great conversation over multiple topics. It wasn't long before we were laughing with each other like we were college buddies. His suggestions and attention to detailed were on point. Everyone else in the other chairs seemed to be having a pleasant experience too. The hair cut and beard trim was easily the best I ever received. If you're looking for a place to get a cut and shave from a clean, friendly place with competent barbers who know what they're doing then look no further than American Shave. And if you really want a great experience, ask for Maverick. Don't know why he had negative comments - I guess everyone is entitled to have one of those days. But based on my experience, he got hosed by someone looking for a freebie. read more

They ask for your credit card up front just to book the appointment- it doesn't shout trust! I mean it's not even about the card it's the principle and their attitude, which already was less than cordial over the phone! I gave them 3 stars as I'll never really know how the cut would have been, the barber I liked there left! read more

Felix is awesome and extremely skilled at what he does. I'm always impressed by both the quality of my haircut and how quickly he gets it done. read more

This was the first time I have ever experienced a shave with straight razor and hot face towels . Upon entering the establishment, I was very very impressed. The decor was very professionally, and we were greeted respectfully and asked immediately if we would like a drink. I accepted a soda since I don't drink alcohol, but alcohol is available wine, and hard liquor. I thought this was a great touch and was impressed. However, the shave itself was not as satisfying as I had hoped. The beard trim was outstanding and the barber did a very, very good job trimming my goatee. However, I felt that the shave was supposed to be a 30 minute session, but I doubt whether it took more than 20 minutes; I could be wrong. But I was expecting much more and I was disappointed. My feeling was that since this was a shave with a straight razor with two passes it would really give me a close shave. Also, I expected more of a face massage with the treatment however, this was maybe a one minute massage with facial gel. When I got home, I felt my face and there were spots which were not cleanly shaved. Overall, I was disappointed, but the staff is extremely friendly. Since this was my expa straight razor shave I am going to try other barbershops and rate accordingly. I'm not suggesting you don't go here. That's not my point but for my first time, I was a little disappointed. I just felt they could take a little more time giving me a closer shave which I expected. read more

Nice place and the barber Mav is awesome at cutting hair!!! Would highly recommend!!!

The service there is always the best. My barber, Nick, has always been a real professional. I don't miss an appointment with him every time I'm in the area. read more

I am a snowbird and been an American shave customer for many years.My old stylist left there so I chose Debbie as my new stylist . She did a great job on my hair and the shave she gave me was the best I've ever had. I highly recommend her and the salon read more

I left very disappointed yesterday, 5/28. I had an appointment with Maverick for the signature cut and beard trim. I have long hair and was hoping to get a light trim, about half an inch taken off the length and was immediately told that he does not cut long hair. I find that unacceptable for a barbershop which has these prices for cuts. I wasn't offered anything in place, just a refusal. Typically, I would have left and gone to another location but I am in a time crunch with a vacation in Miami coming up and had no other options. He was able to do everything else I asked for, shave the sides to the skin and the beard trim however the whole process felt rushed as if it were a chore. I felt like I was a nuisance the entire time. This was the third or fourth time I've been and I would say maybe half the times I've left disappointed. I'm new to the area and finding a new barber is very difficult which is fine but the overall experiences I've had have been underwhelming. Last thing, after paying and still leaving a generous tip despite the experience, I saw that my beard was left uneven in areas which I had to correct myself at home and I was left with beard and/or hair product on my neck with noticeable chunks of what I believe was the beard oil in my beard. I don't like leaving bad reviews as I have worked in the service industry myself, but I felt compelled to this time unfortunately. I do not believe I will go back despite overall better service from the other individuals I have seen. read more

Maverick did a badass job on my beard so I decided to get a cut as well. He killed that too! Thanks bro!

Felix is the man. Best I've looked from the eyebrows up since the late 90's. Will be my barber moving forward! Great with the kiddos too. Had my five year old begging for a turn in the chair lol. read more

Felix and Morgan do outstanding work in a friendly and competent manner. I always feel great after a session at American Shave.

Great staff, very clean and well-lit environment, repeat customer. Morgan does a great job!

I've went to this place for years now. Different locations, some different people, new services. ALL of these transitions have been wonderful. I have never had a bad cut from any of the staff. Never been treated any way but professionally and super nice. I've never had a problem when booking with their online system either. I also love their selection of products and their willingness to help figure out how to make them work for you. Lastly, I have to comment that I first went to them primarily because they were close to my home. Well, I moved and they're not close anymore. It hasn't detered me one bit. The drive is not enough to change places. I rely on my looks for my job as a performer. The consistent quality of service is the #1 thing they provide and that is absolutely golden. I always feel confident with how i look when I step onstage and that translates to better performances. Thank you for that! read more

Brian is very polite and ALWAYS gives a great haircut. If you enjoy talking about international soccer at a barber shop, Brian is definitely your man! read more

Good cut, good shave, good products, good vibe, great people! 100% satisfied, 150% handsome!!

Terrific shave and massage for my spouse. He was tired from therapy when he arrived at American Shave and what a difference when I picked him up. A great morale booster and the perfect gift for a special someone who needs some pampering - Thank you read more

I've been getting my haircuts here since last year and so glad I made the switch. I've used Nick and Brian and have never been disappointed in my cuts. The staff are all welcoming and professional. The shop is always super clean and it's in a convenient location for everyone in Sarasota. Steve S read more

I have a huge beard and moved from Phoenix. Had a great barber there. Moved to Sarasota and had a bad experience at a different barber. I then met Felix he fixed the butcher job and got my beard lined back up. He nails the cut and beard trim every time. I will never go anywhere else. Take care of yourself Felix, I need you around! read more

I'm in town working and am a little weary to use a different barber. Made an appointment for a signature beard trim and decided to let them cut my hair as well. It was amazing, Alex really took his time and it's one of the best haircuts I've ever got. Very satisfied read more

Made an appointment for a specific time and showed up on time. I was told they don't have time to see me. I said why didn't I at least get a phone call to let me know that they are cancelling on me. They shrugged and said they have other people to attend to instead. Poor service and a poor way to say they are not interested in my business. ...Not even an apology read more

I've been coming to the establishment for over a year now. I always enjoyed it and was always satisfied with my service. I will not be going back after the raised their prices from 38.00 for a Traditional Skin Fade to now 45.00. That is outrageous. There is now way their overhead has increased by the much to charge an extra 7.00 per cut. And that was not the only service they increased prices on. They also don't even have a receptionist. Barbers are being interrupted while servicing their clients to answer the phone. So you raise the prices and I get worse service than before because my haircut is being interrupted by my barber because they have to answer the phone? This is ridiculous and I will not be back. read more

Always excellent service at American Shave. Nick is great and I always trust with my hair and beard.

I don't know where my hair would be without American Shave. Most women's hair cuts cost $60 or more in the Sarasota area. Here every cut is $25 no matter your gender. I wear my hair short and like to be experimental. They do a great job with fades, designs, textures, etc. They are also LGBT-friendly and kid-friendly. No matter your age, color, creed, gender, orientation, they just want to do good hair in an affordable way. Highly recommend. Brian and Lorenzo are my go-to's. read more

American Shave - Barbers Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

Today's first visit was great. Appointment setting was easy. Brian was ready on time and did a super job. Next, I'll be back for shave, too. Have to check that out before I rate 5 stars, but I'm pretty confident this is my new barber shop. Value of club membership appears solid. Look for my yelp review of Barbershop 941 in Nov. 2015. American Shave is a cooler place hosting a calmer atmosphere. B941 is amped up with a cocktail of ego and ambition. read more

Had appointments for a head shave, beard trim, and pedicure. I didn't know anyone there so I just randomly selected Jake for the shave and beard, and Sheri for the pedicure. I could not have been more pleased. Jake is thorough and listened to my questions and concerns, since I know zilch about beards. Sheri gave the best foot massage I've ever had and did a great job with the pedicure. I highly recommend this place, especially Jake and Sheri. read more

American Shave - Barbers Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

Outstanding haircut! Very professional! Definitely going back, strongly recommend! Thanks

Highly professional and attentive service with attention to detail and specific needs. Great knowledgeable staff. My favorite place for haircuts, beard treatment and grooming. read more

Matthew was quite good with my shave. The atmosphere is great! Great place, highly recommended!

Very happy with this business! I was a best man (maid?) in a wedding recently and scheduled an appointment for the groom for a haircut on the day of his wedding. The groom was very pleased with the complimentary beverages (beer, water, sodas) while he waited for his appointment and the barber, Ben was very detailed with the cut and was fun and not bothered at all by several groomsmen hanging out and razzing the groom as he got his cut. He was extremely pleased with the results and looked dapper and well-put-together for the nuptials. The place was clean, smelled really good, and all the employees were in great moods and appeared to love working there. I would definitely recommend this business for any guys who want to just get away for a bit and get a professional cut and trim or for special occasions that require more than just a perfunctory cut and/or shave. read more

Great stylists, great experience, and top notch service. Cheryl goes above and beyond every time and is stellar with beard trims and haircuts. Have not ever had a bad experience here, they are always consistent and great! read more

Shay did a very nice job. I will be back. Convenient location. The store is clean and welcoming.

Very good signature cut from Amanda. Stylish barbery, great service from top to bottom, and complimentary snacks/beer? Yes please! read more

American Shave - Stylish masculine barbershop - Barbers Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

I decided to treat myself to a man's spa morning for a shave and a haircut. I did at a place in Lakewood Ranch and was indifferent about it, but decided to give it a second shot. I'm glad I did. Normally, you have to make an appointment online but it was early enough in the day where I was able to walk in and get a shave and haircut combination for $55. Amber was my "barber". I think it is to their advantage to have a woman work on you instead of a man. I felt more relaxed. She did a great job except she missed hairs just below the nostrils. I can come back for a 2 week maintenance on my hair cut if i have time or get a membership for $75-150 per month. read more

American Shave - Exterior - Barbers Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

It was a great experience from the second I walked in the door. The receptionist was very friendly and offered me a drink. Brian took care of me and gave me a great haircut. It was a really nice relaxing experience and I was very happy with my haircut. I will be back! read more

Yesterday was my fourth appointment at American Shave. Two with Signature Cut + Shave and two with Signature Shave. All with Brian. What a personable and talented young man he is. He is always on time, easy to work with, delivers a great service. I'm looking forward to coming back in a few weeks. I recommend Brian and American Shave. Schedule an appointment - you'll be glad you did. Mike read more

First I've had a bad experience with this place. Been going there for a while. And Deb that works there butchered my haircut. Thank god for Brian that works there, he saved it and made it look amazing. Id recommend but id ask if they have experience. There a good bunch thst know how to cut hair, not Deb. No apology from Deb and still had to pay and waste my time going back to fix it. I do recommend them. Just not Deb. She needs more mannequin experience. read more

Won't go back. I was going to treat myself to a shave and a hair cut for a job interview. i made an appointment, showed up five minutes early. I was told to wait. One client checked out and the barber and receptionist talked for 10 minutes. Then another client came in and went straight in the back. My appointment was 15 behind. I just left. I won't recommend this place and I will Make sure I tell at least 10 people not to go to. read more

I recently had a bad experience where the salon had to cancel my appointment, but I was not contacted and arrived at the scheduled time. Yesterday, a manager called me, apologized and assured me that procedures were now in place so that would not happen to any customer again. The issue has been resolved to my complete satisfaction and I will remain a customer. read more

Horrible customer service. They never pick up the phone. You drive there the place is empty and you think they're gonna seat you. No.. they say they are booked the rest of the day. Even the barber is out back smoking a cig. If I didn't know better, I would say this place is a front like the car wash place from breaking bad. read more

When traveling my husband was in need of a shave and haircut. I made him an appointment based on other yelp reviews and it was the best thing I ever did. He was able to get in that day and had a wonderful experience. AND he got the best haircut he's had in years. He looked great! People we met up with that night even noticed. He plans on coming back to Florida to get his hair cut again. Great job and he loved the shave too! read more