Cancel

Open app

Search

American Pie Pizzeria

3.8 (20 reviews)
ModeratePizza, Italian, Salad
Closed • Closed

Order American Pie Pizzeria Takeout or Delivery

American Pie Pizzeria Photos

Business Info

AMERICAN PIE PIZZERIA ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Quiet
Casual
Good for groups
Good for kids

You might also consider

More like American Pie Pizzeria

Recommended Reviews - American Pie Pizzeria

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Menu as of November 2019
Klemens T.

Came here for the first time with my family. We met up with my son and his high school JROTC team who were visiting from Hawaii to compete in the U.S. Army JROTC Raiders National Championship. There were 46 of us total and this place was able to seat us instantly and take our orders. I don't recall what everyone got specifically, but I've seen "party pie" sized pizzas, pastas, and chicken wings come out. The largest pizza that they have which is the Party Pie is so big, I think it's larger than the Costco sized pizzas. My wife and I ordered the medium pizza and some mild chicken wings and it was more than enough for us. We didn't know what was delicious here so the cashier recommended the Chicken Alfredo. It was delicious and it actually tasted like Chicken Alfredo and the dough is so soft. The chicken wings were ok. You cant beat the prices. Coming from Hawaii, everything here is dirt cheap to us. The portions are huge and totally worth it. The staff here are very friendly and there are a lot of tables and chairs. They have a small little arcade at the back near the restrooms. The parking lot is huge and shared with other establishments.

Lunch Pizza Bar
Michelle G.

Food: 3.5 (Average Pizza but fresh) Customer Service: 5 (Shout Out to Alex) Inside: 4 (Organized & Clean) My coworker and I decided to stop here for lunch during one of our professional development and was pleasantly surprised to find quite a good deal for a lunch special. For $9 we were able to get the buffet (pizza and bread balls) with a drink for $6.99 and a salad for $3. The buffet had multiple pizzas with a variety of toppings including chicken. I did notice all the pizzas had meat and I don't care for meat on pizza so I made a request for a pizza with only veggies. Alex our cashier, was very helpful and put a request in for a vegetable pizza. When I asked about how long the wait would be (so I would have an idea when to come back up) I was told that it would only be a few minutes. Sure enough within maybe 5 minutes. Alex was kind enough to walk over to let us know the pizza was available. They also had these little bread balls. One with garlic sauce which was a little on the dry side for me since they didn't serve marinara with it but the buffalo bread ball was actually pretty good and I'm surprised that I like it. I still needed a sauce so I dipped it in the blue cheese dressing that was served with my salad. Generic salad but it hit the spot and none of the dressing are homemade which was fine for the price. The pizza was pretty good, it puts me more or less in the mindset of the type of pizzas that you would get if you were at CiCi's Pizza or Sam's but of course not as quiet as big as Sam's Club. The food had fresh ingredients and was freshly made. It was definitely worth of a quick lunch. The staff was friendly and it was extremely clean in the inside. Definitely worth a visit if you're in the Griffin area and don't want to spend a lot of money.

8" Tater Pie
Heidi S.

So good! The tater pie is yummy... the 8" is more than enough for one person and it's a great deal.

Polished off half of an 18'
Bettina M.

Pizza is awesome! Very fresh ingredients and fluffy dough. You can actually see them toss the dough in the back so you know it's going to be great. The Greek salad had the right mixture of veggies and cheese. The large was enough for three of us to share. All of the staff are friendly, and the restaurant is very clean and spacious. I'd definitely come here again the next time I'm in Griffin.

See all

Photo of Heidi S.
14
23
23

30 days ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 6
Thanks 3
Love this 6
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Heidi S.
82
51
43

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Jackson R.
128
59
35

14 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Lisa K.
19
30
11

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Good little pizza restaurant. Very family friendly. Would go again, but not our go to pizza place.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Love their pizza and especially their buffet. Great variety of pizzas you can't get most places.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

14 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - American Pie Pizzeria

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Pizza 752 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Angelo's Greek & Italian Restaurant

Angelo's Greek & Italian Restaurant

4.0(85 reviews)
2.4 mi
•$$

I discovered this adorable restaurant while spending a summer in a very quaint and beautiful town…read moreoutside Atlanta, Georgia. It sits in the heart of downtown, like many other restaurants. But this Greek and Italian restaurant stood out from the rest. The murals on the walls and the green and red colors made me feel like I was in Italy on vacation. We settled in a booth, took one look at the menu, and decided we would do what we call a sampler! So we ordered a huge pizza that tasted as if it came right from Italy, but it had that New York-style taste I so love, too. The pasta was very hearty, meaty, with a light, rich sauce. I think it was a buttery type sauce. We added wings and calamari, which were just as good and flavorful. I like a lot of crispy crunch to my wings! Also, we couldn't leave without adding a dessert on the way out. I have to say the dessert display case is really something to admire. So we started with one dessert. I believe it was the tiramisu and a slice of cake that led to several more tastings and the purchase of more desserts on the way out; they were just so good! Now I have to give the staff a big thank you! We had a little one with us; she enjoyed the food, but the murals on the wall really caught her attention. She asked the staff a zillion questions, and they were so kind to her. Thank you again!

Great food & service. Generous portions of all orders. So not only a wonderful dinner, lunch…read moretoo! Sweet & friendly staff. Very attentive but not intrusive. Place itself is small but quaint.

Photos
Angelo's Greek & Italian Restaurant
Angelo's Greek & Italian Restaurant
Angelo's Greek & Italian Restaurant

See all

Margo's Mediterranean Cuisine - Appetizer rolls

Margo's Mediterranean Cuisine

4.2(84 reviews)
1.8 mi
•$$

Who would've guessed this place would serve the best gyro wrap I've ever had, even compared to…read more"Greek" restaurants. What made it special was the pita bread, which they make from scratch. The appetizer rolls were also great, which are also made from scratch. And they claim everything else is also made from scratch. Well, I'll have to come back sometime and give that a test. Only negative was service was slow, but it was friendly. Some say the exterior is to be desired, but compared to other buildings in the area, it actually seems better than the others.

I found this place on a review site and decided to give it a try based on all the great reviews…read more When I pulled up, I almost turned around because the aesthetic wasn't what I would normally choose. But I was pressed for time, so I went in anyway. When I walked inside, food was actually being prepared in the dining room where guests eat, so it's definitely a true mom-and-pop establishment. That said... EVERYTHING else was amazing. I ordered the salmon salad. It didn't look like much when it arrived, but wow. I could honestly eat it every day. I cleaned my plate and even soaked up the remaining sauce with a lemon wedge. Yes... even the lemons were delicious. The bread? Incredible. The ice? Somehow even the ice was perfect. The service? Friendly, welcoming, and top-notch. This is one of those places that proves you can't judge a restaurant by its appearance. I'll definitely be back again... and again. Definitely recommend!

Photos
Margo's Mediterranean Cuisine - Cool  decor

Cool decor

Margo's Mediterranean Cuisine - I hated it.

I hated it.

Margo's Mediterranean Cuisine - Menu

See all

Menu

I Love NY Pizza - Philly cheese fries (without steak)

I Love NY Pizza

4.1(127 reviews)
9.4 mi
•$

If you are from up north and you miss proper New York pizza, go to I Love New York Pizza in…read moreMcDonough. Seriously. Go. My partner is originally from New York, I'm originally from Connecticut, and we are both very fussy about pizza. We are the kind of people who will drive an hour from Conyers just to get a pizza here, with no other errands attached. That alone should tell you everything. We usually get a huge pepperoni pie and share it. They do have slices, and the slices are excellent too, but I recommend getting the whole pie if you can. Every pizza we have had here has been picture-perfect. Perfect crust, perfect sauce, perfect cheese, properly cooked toppings, and that real New York-style balance of crispy, chewy, melty, slightly floppy, and dangerously hot. The crust has the right crisp and chew. The sauce is flavorful without being too much. The cheese has that classic low-moisture mozzarella richness, and it is seasoned beautifully before baking. That is one of those details a lot of places miss. Up north, the cheese is not just bland melted cheese sitting there doing nothing. It has flavor. It has oregano. It has seasoning. It has personality. I Love New York Pizza gets that right. The first time we went, the owner was there, the family was there, and people were speaking Italian behind the counter. Then I saw the case full of slices and immediately thought, "Okay, we are safe. We are in good hands." You can tell just by looking at the pizza that it is right. Is this the greatest New York pizza you will ever have in your life? Maybe not. Is it possibly the best New York-style pizza you are going to get in this area? Absolutely. To me, it tastes like the kind of standard, classic, universally enjoyable New York pizza you would bring someone to for their first real slice experience. We almost always dine in, and there is always enough to take leftovers home. The staff is great, the service is great, the timing is great, and the consistency is honestly impressive. We drive an hour hoping to get the same perfect pizza we had last time, and they deliver every time. I will be honest: I come here for the pizza. I do not really care for the garlic knots, and I have not been especially attached to the non-pizza items I have tried. But if you have a serious up-north pizza craving, that does not matter. Get the pizza. Get the whole pie. Let it set for a minute if you have the patience, because it comes out burning hot. Or risk it all and burn your mouth on the first bite like I sometimes do. Worth it. I Love New York Pizza is the spot. Picky Northerner approved.

Huge portion for an appetizer! Loaded with goodies and served hot. I have only tried the loaded…read morefries they offer, but am pleased so far.

Photos
I Love NY Pizza
I Love NY Pizza
I Love NY Pizza

See all

Lovin' Oven Pizza - The Engineer | Slice

Lovin' Oven Pizza

4.1(112 reviews)
12.0 mi
•$

So Monday afternoon, I went to this Pizza place called loving oven Pizza and let me tell you the…read morePizza. There is great.\n Talk to a guy named Nate and he's the one that makes the Pizza. I guess he's the big box, I ask him to make me a slice, a special slice of white Pizza, which is Olive oil, minced garlic, wakata cheese. And he did a really good job , and my stepmom had the welded baked potato pizza and they were both outstanding , and I will be going back there very soon

We have been to Lovin Oven more times than I can count. We usually go on Tuesday nights so we can…read moreplay Popular Opinion with Lori (trivia with a Family Feud twist). Well the last few times we have been the game has been fun but the food has left a lot to be desired. Tonight we all ordered slices of pizza (5 of us in the group) and of course a couple of pitchers of beer. All of our pizzas were dried out, not a lot of toppings and large areas with no toppings at all (bubbles in the dough). This was our first time back in a couple of months because the food quality had already been going down on our last couple of visits. Tonight was just awful. Bad thing too cause we brought my sister for her first time and she was not at all impressed. I hate this because they used to be SO good. Service is about the same as it's always been (so-so) and we love the restaurant itself but I'm not sure if we will be coming back. It's just not worth $50+ for 2 people when the food quality is so disappointing. We noticed too that a lot of other Tuesday night regulars weren't there tonight. Wonder if they have been experiencing the same sad food. We will wait another month or so and maybe try again. It's really sad though when our other trivia spot is a bar and they have better food........

Photos
Lovin' Oven Pizza - Bar view.

Bar view.

Lovin' Oven Pizza - Half pepperoni half pepperoni with extra cheese and onions.

Half pepperoni half pepperoni with extra cheese and onions.

Lovin' Oven Pizza - Evacuating Hurricane Milton.

See all

Evacuating Hurricane Milton.

American Pie Pizzeria - pizza - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...