Picked up a lot of pizza for our multi-family camping trip, nearby. Like to hit up the local places, and Allyn had a good rep. Glad we did. Big pizzas, heavy on the toppings. Perhaps a little more cheese than I like, but everyone else loved it. The veggie pizza was by-far the favorite. I should have gotten two of those. Super Meat lived up to its name. Great services, ambiance was in my opinion aided by the owners' kids running around and being sweet. Good for a pizza joint, bad for a date night. :-D read more

L we wanted a quick and easy pizza to pick up. It was filled with all sorts of delicious toppings. It was a beautiful pizza. I do think the sauce needs a little bit more seasoning. Loved the owner. She brought out the pizza for us while we waited in the car. read more

Allyn Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Allyn, Washington

Met Juvy, a wonderful, down to earth and easy to speak to owner. We ordered a couple 18" pizzas, one with sausage and pepperoni and the other with sausage, pepperoni and olives. We also ordered newly fried lumpia and frozen lumpia as well (we will dry this later when family comes to visit.) The dough is handmade every day and not frozen, her sauce is homemade as well. Ate all the lumpia and still working on the last 3 pieces of pizza. The ambiance is comfortable and inviting, her food was just amazing! She is open 6 days a week. Stop by, you will not be disappointed and you will leave with a full belly! DELISH! read more

Allyn Pizza - Pepperoni, sausage pizza, pepperoni sausage and olive pizza, and lumpia with yummy sauce. - Pizza Near Me - Allyn, Washington

Yelp recommends Allyn higher than Westside so we visited. Friendly folks with friendly service but this is not truly a sit down but caters more to takeout. They have seating but it feels like an afterthought. Chicken wings were the high point - meaty and tasty and great portions for the price (fed two hungry guys). The pizza was good, but not great, and the salad the same. If you are expecting delicious wood fired crust and gourmet toppings this is not that. It's more like a perfectly fine slice you can get anywhere including Dominoes. I want to give 4 stars but Yelp is about the food quality so three stars (for the prime focus of pizza) but the wings are four stars. read more

See all

I was charged $2 more for my pizza than posted price. When confronted, the representative was unapologetic. They lost my trust. I will not come back read more

Hubby has been wanting to try this place for months, he's a pizza fan. We finally called in an order tonight and the woman on the phone was very friendly to take our order. Great customer service! We were impressed by the fresh ingredients, great quality of food, full of flavor, and sauces tasted like they're made in house. Cheesy garlic bread sticks were bomb.com! So much flavor and the right amount of cheese. Huge serving of them! Marinara sauce was way better than most pizza joints. Buffalo sauce which we normally don't like (ordered on the side for wings), was amazing and didn't have that Tabasco vinegar spicy taste most buffalo sauces or wing sauce contains. I'm glad we got it on the side to try anyways! The cinnamon twists come in a huge order for 16in, I wasn't expecting so much and wished we got the smaller order but they were delicious. Light and fluffy and right amount of cinnamon and sugar. My hubby is going to take their advice and try it in his coffee in the morning. And the winning dish- the Pizza! Since hubby is a pizza fan he wanted to start with a basic pepperoni with extra cheese and get a feel for it. His jaw dropped when he saw how big the slices were and instantly fell in love with this place! lol The first thing I noticed was how fresh the pizza crust looked and it's artisan style, was even better when I tried it. The extra cheese covered over great quality pepperonis with the pizza sauce and fresh crust, it was AMAZING! He said no more Seabeck pizza after having Allyn pizza. Thank you for making your food with love and fresh ingredients, it shows in the quality and taste of the food! We will be coming back for more! read more

Allyn Pizza - 18" Pepperoni with extra cheese - Pizza Near Me - Allyn, Washington

Their veggie pizza was pretty tasty. Nothing extraordinary, just reasonably good pizza for takeout.

First time ordering a to go pizza from Allyn Pizza Had it ready in 30 min I think it's a mom and pop business The pizza was hot and reasonable price I will be using them again read more

The four of us went in after golf today. The garlic cheese bread AWESOME. 18 INCH works pizza was fabulous. The crust is amazing start to finish. The pizza was piping hot and tasted so good. The lady working there is so awesome.What a sweet heart with a big smile. The store itself is quite quaint. Clean. You can sit down and eat but I'm sure take-out there is quite common. Certainly will stop in and try more the next golf outing at Lakeland or a pass through Allyn read more

Allyn Pizza is by far the best pizza! Super delicious tomato sauce...always perfect crust! The lumpia is authentic and so good! The dipping sauce is wonderful too. Great items on the menu for everyone! Always kind service and a smile! read more

We were staying halfway between Allyn and Shelton, trying to decide on which way to go for pizza. Allyn was a little closer, so we tried this place out and we were so glad we did! The phone ordering process was quick and easy, pizza was ready in 15 minutes! We got the 18" Meat pizza with a couple additions. It was more than enough for 3 people, with leftovers. Cooked to perfection and plenty of toppings. Dough/crust was moist and soft, with a little crisp on the crust - just the way we like it. My only gripe was that the slices were so big. Maybe ask to cut into more slices if you're sharing. We also ordered the cheesy garlic sticks/bread and garden salad. Not sure if we missed the memo on ordering sauce with the sticks/bread, they were definitely tasty but could have been better with some red or ranch sauce to dip. The garden salad was huge too, with good, fresh veggies. Both were perfect for sharing. The establishment is doing a great job with COVID protocols too... everyone wearing a mask (correctly!), shields up, and sanitizer available. read more

See all

For an American staple, its shockingly difficult to get good pizza in the PNW. I have been awaiting Allyn Pizza to open for absolute ages and was surprised by the owner doing word of mouth marketing in the Post Office that they had opened two days prior. I was told that the Alfredo Pizza was fresh so thats what I got ; as should you. This thing was outrageously good. The crust alone would be good to eat by itself - perfectly chewy and crispy. The staff was friendly and cracked jokes. The stereo was playing Tyler Childers and the lunch special comes with 2 slices and a can of soda for $6.00. Go try it out and support a small local pizzeria that desperately is needed in our community. read more

See all

The pizza is Awesome!! The sandwiches are very good!! It's nice to have a pizza place in Allyn! But... I just wish that they would offer a delivery service!! ‍ read more

Still one of my favorite pizza joints! I asked them to make me a pizza without the cheese and they obliged, and it was delish! read more

See all

We really enjoyed the pizza and the Korean wings! It's a hidden gem in Allyn. We will definitely be back. Don't miss out! The crust was amazing and we loved the sauce. read more

Allyn Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Allyn, Washington

We ordered two 16 inch pizzas from here and man, we could have done with one. They're HUGE. We also ordered lumpia! Weird combo but it definitely works. First of all, let's talk about Allyn. Not a lot goes on around here and there's not a lot of places to eat, so we were so happy to find a pizza place near us. Okay, let's move on to the pizza. They're HUGE, but kinda pricy. We ordered two pizzas and lumpia, and our total was about $80 with tip. My husband ordered "the works" and I ordered a mushroom, pineapple, jalapeño pizza. I'm not sure if I ordered it with olives too, so it could have been either 3 or 4 toppings. We ordered lumpia too, I believe 12 of them. The pizza was pretty good, cheesy with a great amount of toppings. It was pretty awesome pizza. The crust was really crispy although we debated if it lacked salt or something else. We couldn't put our finger on it. We decided this is the type of pizza you go get when you're hungry, don't want to cook and want a good local pizza. It's not fancy or fantastic, but it sure hit the spot. We highly recommend you try the lumpia too. (Filipino egg rolls.) The pork lumpia tasted like home, so savory, crispy and amazing. I could have eaten all of them but I had to share! read more

I like to tell people when they do well as much as when the product isn't very good......and I like to support local business. I don't know if this was a "one off" pizza but it was bad. If the "Bobbley" pizza crust you buy at the store could be rated about 4-5 on the crust scale then this is between 2-3. We purchased the most expensive combo pizza they had and there wasn't much sauce and it looked like most of the ingredients have just came out of a can, and they were undercooked as well. If you have had a pizza at another local dealer (Seabeck Pizza) then you will be disappointed, even Little Cezar's pizza is a level above this pie. I hope the owner/operator will look at some other restaurants and be honest with themselves as to their quality of a $25 pizza. "You can fool your self but you can't fool you customers".....said Mark Cuban read more

I really like this place! If you live in the area, it's a true golden age for pizza lovers! They're in the perfect location right next to the little Allyn Market, across from the post office and the Mexican restaurant. I really like the people working there, stopped in right when they opened last weekend. A man I'm assuming to be the owner took my order and then my girlfriend called in later to a young lady to change it. They couldn't have been nicer. Great people, very positive energy surrounding this business. The food was pretty fantastic! We had a large two topping pizza, cheese bread and the boneless chicken wings. I thought the food was very economical and inline with the area. Given their location and their pricing, they come to mind first thing now when thinking about dinner for the house hold. The pizza was fantastic. High quality toppings and very well thought out. I think Seabeck has heavier deeper crust. But the Allyn Pizza was a fantastic lighter pizza with top ingredients well made. Both pizza is excellent and just depends on your preference! The garlic cheese bread is an awesome throw in. Larger than I thought it'd be, about the size of a small pizza. Very tasty and exactly what you'd want. The boneless chicken wings were the biggest hits in the house. Perfectly crispy and tasty with a wonderful sauce. I was disappointed I only got a couple. I admit, I was nervous. A new pizza place in Mason is a potentially life changing religious experience. Given Allyn Pizza just opening, I was nervous for them. But they're great! The pizza and the people are both top notch right from their grand opening. It is so awesome to have such a great pizza place in such an easy to reach location. Great business! Excited for Allyn Pizza's future! read more

I've been meaning to try this place as I pass through Allyn, based on the Yelp review. Was picking up a pizza and wings to go. First, the positives: 1)Very nice and helpful staff, very sweet ladies. 2) super fast getting my order together, they seems well organized 3) Plenty of toppings. I'm usually and extra cheese girl but give it a go for the first time to see what a new place does before I start piling on, toppings were generous IMO and no need to order bonus topping. Negatives: Really, just one. The crust. The pics I see in Yelp show that fluffy outer crust and a thin crust with the toppings. That was not my experience. I was expecting the classic NY style based on the pics. Was very flat and was clearly a brought in not home made dough. Had that slight "preservative" taste. Wings were just ok for me, but my friend loved them so I can fully admit, maybe it was just me. I might try them again, but would likely try one of the subs which looked pretty tasty. read more

Who thought the second best pizza I've ever had in my life, first was in Italy of course, would come from this small town right in my own backyard!? Helpful, thoughtful, and great workers! Ordered three individual slices and they hooked it up with the biggest pieces! All in all i got three individual pizza slices and a monster energy drink for a little over $9! Affordable price that i will gladly pay again. The pizza was perfect! Nice crisp when you bite into the crust. Lower level crust was amazingly soft. Pizza sauce was spot on with the right amount of sauce and cheese and tons of sausage on top! I'm swinging by here every-time i head to the lake and I'm buying a whole ass Pizza every-time! Extremely highly recommended! read more

If you're new to the area, the building is a little tricky to find. The driveway is between two street level lots and has a steep incline. The building, inside and out, is very unassuming. But don't let that deter you from ordering the food. Granted, the only pizzas I've ordered were cheese and a deluxe - and they were delicious! My family was not disappointed. read more

Simple and delicious. Definitely try the lumpia! Best takeout in Allyn. Service is consistent and friendly. Just do it.

Others reviews lack credibity. Pizza good, not special. Service was great. Forthright and accurate expectations set by way-smarter-than-average young server. Enjoyed their largest and most loaded pizza which fed 2 hungry retirees with about a quarter left over. Over $30 for just one pizza. Will likely return as closest pizza to where I frequently visit. Pizza good enough to not drive further for alternative. But, not good enough to drive extra for. read more

Great service and prices! I typically get the chicken wings and in house made lumpia !

Pizza is very hit or miss, it usually very over cooked or the dough has been overworked. But occasionally it is decent and the tomato sauce is always surprisingly pleasant. Great lunch deal as well! read more

Just bought my first 18" pepperoni from here and I want to thank you guys for opening up. Great pizza and friendly service. This will be my pizza place of choice from now on. read more

We were in town on vacation for a few days and picked up a pizza, breadsticks, and wings from this small place. The food was all delicious and huge portions. I recommend! read more

I had very low expectations. I mean ... Allyn, seriously? But after the recommendation of a friend and on a Saturday afternoon when I just didn't feel motivated to cook - or even slap together a sandwich, I ordered up a pie with pepperoni, sausage, onions, and mushrooms. I've got to say, it was a really good pizza! Not perfect, but really, really good. Pizza starts with the crust and this crust was good: not too thick, not too thin, blistery from the oven and pretty tasty. Sauce was good in flavor and quantity. Tasted as if there was some red pepper flake in the sauce. Cheese was there but not overpowering. The last thing I want is a pizza topped with a half inch of rubbery, oily, artificial, imitation, mozzarella-like product. This was pretty close to perfect. I would have preferred bigger chunks of onion and mushroom but maybe that isn't everyone's choice. My (American-style) pizza yardstick is the long defunct Maria's Roman Room on the west side of Cleveland, OH. Chunky toppings. Anyway, I'll definitely go back and after some repeat visits they may earn a fifth star (I never give 5 on a first visit for the same reason I never give 1 on the first visit). And next time I'll add anchovies :-) read more

This place is surviving COVID... it's overall good food.. pizza seems to be missing something, not knowing if it's flavor or spices or more red sauce but something is missing to give it extra flavor/kick. Things are a little pricey and I don't know if it's because of COVID or just needing to fix some prices but it's a little much. The flavor of the boneless chicken wings were spot on but they lacked a crispy factor and seemed to be a little more soft then I'd hoped for. The cheesy garlic bread was perfect. For the prices of things I wished they had given dipping sauces with the wings and bread. read more

We ordered two 18" (!) pizzas to pick up in 30 minutes. When I arrived, they had a couple of minutes more in the oven, so I had a chance to talk with the owner. She's really delightful! When our pizzas we're ready, she boxed them and brought them over to show to me before she rang them up. Beautiful, huge pies, made exactly as ordered. The crust was perfect- not too thick, with a good crunch. (You'll want to pop it into a preheated oven for a few minutes to crisp it up if you're more than 5 minutes away.) There was just the right amount of sauce and cheese, in my opinion; toppings were generous and delicious. These two gigantic pizzas fed four hungry adults, with 6 big slices left over (which we enjoyed the next day), for $40! Leave a nice tip, as she employs local teens. I highly recommend Allyn Pizza, and we'll be back! read more

Great pizza! We had the works and enjoyed it. We also had a plain cheese, also great. This is an awesome pizzeria. Other options in the area don't even come close. Allyn pizza will be our "go to" from now on. read more

Love this pizza! Crust perfect, not too much sauce, fresh, great toppings options. We like take & bake but, this works well when we buy, refrigerate and then reheat. Third time here and will be back again. Dinner salad also good. One is two servings we found out. Recommend! read more

Pretty good pizza, my husband loves it. Sandwiches aren't too bad. Pretty good service, we will be buying from there again.

Placed our order at 4:51 and was told it would be ready in 30 - 35 min. We are here waiting, it's been over an hour and still no pizza. I understand things can get busy but please give realistic order times. We live 20 min. Away and have been sitting here waiting for our order way too long. read more

I stopped here this summer soon after they had their grand opening. It was hot day i needed dinger and ordered a slice and beverage. The pizza wa old so she gave me second slice!! Because the pizza was old it tasted old. Was tough flavor was fine. But I'd go back and try to get a fresh one. Friendly people who seem to be working hard. read more