I have been to All Tranz many times and I have always received great service! Sully, has been doing this for a long time and I bet he knows more about transmissions than anyone in Madison. When you go to specialists you get someone who only works on only one part all the time vs. a car dealership who deals with tons of problems. If you needed brain surgery you wouldn't go to your general doctor to perform the surgery would you? Also, I've received a fair price from them which I truly appreciate it. Which is why I always go back to All Tranz. Thank you Sully! read more

Can't give a lot of stars to ANY business who doesn't return phone calls. Replaced our transmission. Job was fine, but now there is a problem and Sully won't return calls and has not been at his shops the 3 times we have tried to see him in person. Go to !McDermott instead. read more

Very rude ppl work here and they are very unprofessional. Way overpriced to get a transmission rebuilt, and it failed before 3000 miles. Then the owner wants to put the blame on the customer saying he must have abused it and charge more money to fix it even though it was under warranty. Also get it back with leaking transmission cooling lines, the owner said they were to rusty and refused to fix them. Do not go to the crook ass shady as fuck shop. read more

Found about All-Tranz by word of mouth, I have been in the automotive business a long time and they have done multiple transmission's for me in a timely manner at a fair price! Sully and Joe do a nice job. read more

Took my transaxle to Sully to be overhauled. He did so quickly and within his price quote. I had an unforeseen problem, a crack in the aluminum cover and he repaired it without extra charge. He knew I was on a fixed income. That's an honest man. I will definitely bring more business and recommend All Tranzmission in the future. Thanks again Sully! read more

Earns five stars because, 1) speed: they rebuilt my dead transmission in less than 24 hours, 2) honesty: saved me $900 by checking the TCM (Transmission Control Module) and noticing it was still in good condition before replacing it and 3) reliability; giving their work a two year, 24,000 mile warranty and 4) more honesty: letting me know up front what their estimate included. The work is done in-house by a tight knit crew of experts. Go here! read more

I wish I didn't have to even give 1-star, I tried it wouldn't post without checking it: I don't need fluff, glamour or glitz. What I do need is a person to treat another person with respect and that is NOT Sully. Sully was probably the most unprofessional mechanic I have ever dealt with. After he cussed at me on the phone and hung up, and threatened to hold my car hostage for 5 days I eventually had to get the police involved just to get my vehicle back. It all began when I dropped my car off and it was diagnosed. I was working with my insurance company so they needed a quote. I called Sully and gave him my email address three separate times since it didn't come through. Well, come to find out later he never put a subject in the subject line so it went straight to my junk box. When I went in there to explain it might be easier to give him my email address in person he begins to yell and cuss at me for wasting his time. He said and I quote "I have half a mind to just tell you to take your F***ing car". I apologized over and over and eventually after a few more cuss words he calmed down and I eventually received the email with the quote. No letterhead, nothing formal just a written email, with many grammatical errors and in-proper use of punctuation which is fine this is a mechanic shop not a college level English course. However, my insurance company was not impressed. They actually called me and said they would pay half of my transmission but highly recommended I go to a more professional and reputable mechanic, turns out they have had issues with All Tranz in the past. (you can see alot of character in Sully from all the negative posts) So I figured that was a good idea after his actions the previous day. So on 9 September 2016 a day after he had gone off on me in person I looked up on the internet his hours of operation and found and they were M-F 8am-5pm. So I had Uber pick me up and take me the 21 miles to All Tranz, I arrived at roughly 3:15 pm and found the door locked. So I called the number on his sign posted outside where again his hours were posted M-F 8am-5pm. Sully answered since it is his cell phone and I asked if the shop was closed and he said "yes" I said but your hours online and on your sign say 8am-5pm. Sully said we close at 2pm on Fridays (summer hours) what do you need. I said I"m standing in your parking lot trying to get my car. He said you can pick it up Saturday before 9am. I said so now I'm just suppose to pay another $55 for a cab to take me back home. Sully's response and I quote, "on second thought F*** it you can pick up your car on Wednesday and hung up. Today, I had to call the Madison Police Department to get involved just so I could get my vehicle back, since he was holding it hostage until Wednesday. If you want to be cussed at and treated like CRAP go to All Tranz, if I wanted to be treated like this I'd go to a Jets game with a Giants jersey on. All Tranz has a 15% off discount for military, I'm a Veteran with almost 20 years of service and if they offered 110% discount for the military I wouldn't go there. Also, there is NO WAY that some of these posts can be honest, I'd like to know who some of these people are that give 5-stars. They don't seem to use their actual names, and the few times I spoke to Sully he cursed at me more than 3 times read more

Brought my vehicle to this business to have my transmission rebuilt last year. Was given a 2 year-24000 mile warranty. Had a leak, made sure that fluid levels stayed constant until I could bring it in. Brought it in, was told that there was a leak in one of the coolant fittings. I asked if the fluid level was down and the tech told me it was fine. Shortly after it was "repaired" I started to get a transmission hot alarm. Brought it in and was told by the owner that it was a false alarm and that there were other engines codes that were causing "false" codes from the transmission. Brought the vehicle in to the dealership and got all codes repaired. Drove about 50 miles and got the alarm that transmission was hot. Called All-Tranzmission and the owner accused me of driving with low levels, told me I was 4 quarts low off the top of his head, started to yell at me telling me the problems are my fault and won't do anything about it just because he doesn't want to lose any money. Stand behind your warranty!!!! No more return business or referrals from this person any more. Very poor customer service. read more

Sully did a great job. Nice to deal with such a capable and honest person.

I waited over a year to write a review for All-Tranzmission Service to see how my repaired transmission would hold up. I have a 1998 Honda Accord (97,000 miles on it) that had the typical transmission failure 1999-2004 Honda cars have experienced (which has become an EPIDEMIC). If you have a Honda made during those years, and your transmission has not failed, count yourself more than lucky. I noticed the car jerking, not going into gear, etc. I was driving on Hwy 18/151 when the transmission completely seized up and I am lucky I did not lose control of the car. Honda would have replaced the failed transmission (at my expense and for almost double what I paid All-Tranz) with the exact same transmission which would have inevitably failed again, as Honda has made NO modifications or corrections for this "known" transmission issue - they just keep putting the same problematic transmissions back in the cars that had transmission failure. My very trusted mechanic at Phoenix Foreign Car Repair told me about All-Tranzmission Service having designed a "correction" for the chronic Honda transmission issue. I brought my car there. Certainly this is not a glitzy outfit and a bit unconventional in how they deal with customers. I can see how other people could be put off. But, the proof is in the pudding and a year after they replaced my transmission (now at 140,000 miles) I have had NO issues whatsoever. Initially, I spoke with Sully over the phone and he was polite but matter-of-fact. I dropped my car off after hours and left my keys in the slot. Sully's partner did the actual work on my transmission and it took about 3 days. Sully was there when I picked up my car and he was quite friendly and professional. If you own a Honda experiencing transmission issues, take it here. Don't expect a lot of "customer service", hand holding, or even normal 9-5 hours, but you will get a top notch repair, and you'll be on the road again with a sense of security at a fair price. I've given a 4 star review (my highest) because nothing in life is perfect. read more