Our "premium line" home was constructed with builders' grade double-hung windows, and in winter,…read moreyou could feel cold air shooting up out of the slider track, springs broke constantly, and condensation was a big problem, especially in winter. A friend, who had a high-end house, had his windows and patio door replaced by HomeSealed with Okna products, a brand I had never heard of. I was so impressed with the quality and looks of his windows and patio door, I called HomeSealed and arranged for replacements. I love the windows. It's 0 degrees F right now, and I can run my hand around the windows, and not a draft anywhere. Same with the patio door. The windows are easy cleaning, they lock securely, and the install job was great, with little damage to exiting trim. Great warranty too and an easy online service portal if something is not right. I had rental units and used a discount window company for replacements, and those windows failed frequently. You get what you pay for, and this is an investment that will last many years and pay for itself in fuel savings. If you have the funds for Pella or Anderson's best, you ought to check out Okna. If you're thinking about windows from a big-box store, good luck if there's an install problem, or parts/ warranty service are needed.

Can't frankly say how good they are at the job - because they failed at the sales cycle…read more For four windows in a base configuration, they were north of $14k. To put in perspective: Home Depot installed the highest end Simonton windows possible with the specs requested and came in at around $7k installed. Which means that HomeSealed has excessive profits padded in. So...if you don't care about the money side, they might be perfectly fine to work with as a local outfit. EDIT: laminated was requested as a cost compare option, not a requirement. Even if laminated were a requirement, Home Depot's was still cheaper by over $3k. Fact is - as we said - HomeSealed is just priced higher because they don't use every manufacturer, they only use the ones they use, which tend to lean the higher cost. That's what we said: they might be fine at their job and you might want the best of whatever, maybe they're fine. BUT...if you're like 95% of homeowners who feel that significant pricing differences for basic things like colors is illogical, HomeSealed isn't for you.

Infinity Roofing. Recommended to us by a friend, Infinity has become our go to for those projects…read morethat I just won't be doing myself. I'm an electrician by trade, there are many things I will do, roofs and doors aren't on that list. Our first project was quoted by a salesperson named Aaron and it was a rip and replace of our roof. He was a good guy and came in and gave us a solid deal with all the service and upgrades I was looking for. Financed this venture through Enerbank USA and paid it off interest free in the years' time allotted. Our latest venture happened through a simple phone call. We had just dealt with the seriously cold Polar Vortex and noticed some issues with our doors. Infinity happened to call us to check on our roof and during this conversation, I had requested anyone with experience with doors. Well guess what, they do doors! About a week later a salesperson named Mark came out and gave us, the Provia doors booklet and a bit of homework. He then came back and we proceeded to build some doors, three to be exact. Again, we will be going with the 12-month interest free financing. We are excited as can be to get these new doors installed and seal this house up. In the business of home remodeling, there are many fast wheelers and dealers out there. We personally have found Infinity to be more of a partner than just a contractor in our home ventures. You really get what you pay for these days and pay for what you get, so why not deal with a company that has your back? I'll throw some pics up once our doors are installed. It was a little pricier than we initially expected but I am expecting the quality of the goods to be second to none. Another plus is not only did we get a deal for the time of year we are purchasing but we also received a nice loyalty discount of an additional 5% since we are on our second project with Infinity. That's what's up as every penny counts!

AVOID INFINITY EXTERIORS AT ALL COSTS…read more They did not fulfill multiple aspects of the contract, our roof has been leaking all week just shortly after installation, and the company has failed to acknowledge or remedy this. They also chipped paint all over the exterior of the house and damaged our brand new windows. In addition, they reused extremely rusted materials despite the contract specifying they would be replaced. When told of these, the quality manager came out -- he papered over some issues, said he would get back to me on others (and didn't), and told me the area with ripped metal where water was getting in was "fine" (that night, we had even more water coming in). Our package also included a "50 point inspection" afterwards to ensure everything was installed properly. Not only did this not happen, but when the Quality Manager came out in response to my complaints he admitted multiple things were missed on initial installation. These were only caught by me having to go up on my roof and check, instead of the 50 point inspection. I am more than happy to update this review should the company decide to fulfill the contract and fix the failing roof. For now, I am forced to spend my time and energy calling, consulting lawyers, and contacting NARI.

I highly recommend Immortal Exteriors. Mark ensured that every aspect of the project was completed…read moreto the highest standard. Mark was extremely responsive via phone and email and was always friendly and professional. I never felt rushed when we met or to sign a contract. He made sure all my questions were answered. Part of my project involved an insurance claim, and Mark was proactive in attending every meeting with the insurance adjuster. He was also very knowledgeable of the insurance process which was extremely helpful. Even given the mix of insurance requirements in this project, he managed a tight and complex timeline with great efficiency. The teams responsible for the roof, siding, and gutters were all professional and friendly. He was present throughout the project and installation. After each phase, he took the time to tidy up the work area, which I greatly appreciated. Additionally, Mark's pricing was competitive, if not better, than other quotes I received. The roofing products he uses are of much higher quality, providing fantastic value for the price.

I received a call from Mark O'Neill after spending time talking with Adam at the 200th Milwaukee…read moreHome and Garden showy. I had not heard of Malarkey shingles, and prior to the home show had received eight estimates from roofing companies. I showed Adam the estimate that I received from the roofing company I was going to use. I pulled up files with the names of the other companies that's sent representatives to give me estimates. Adam felt strong that Mark would be able to beat the price. I made it clear what my budget was and it wouldn't include shingles, gutters, and replacement of any facia boards that needed to be replace replace replaced. I also emphasize. I do not want a hard self. Mark O'Neill called me the following evening Anne Wood only push an emphasize the malarkey brand. I had chosen Owen's Corning Duration. What I thought was rude and unprofessional was his attitude about other companies. He also mentioned that he contracts the work out. He delivers the materials, but usually is not on site for the job. He explained to me that his jobs are, 'Fillers' for a group he has worked with for ten plus years. If he has worked with this group of guys for ten years, why has his company only been incorporated since 1-2-2024. What was the name of previous company and why are reviews from 2024-25 only? If he speaks so highly of them, why contract? They have other jobs. I made it clear I want to work with a company that employs their crew. He did not respect my opinions. What happened to respecting the customer and allowing the customer to have an opinion?

First project- bad communication from salesperson who was fired or quit. Work quality was decent…read morebut details like caulking gaps made me worried, but they said they would come back to fix and they did. Second project- Bay window ordered, said it would arrive on October 2nd to their warehouse. I had to call the day before install (October 13th) to find out what time they would arrive, and they didn't even receive the bay window yet and need to push the install. No call to tell me it was delayed! Install went well until I noticed the poor quality wood they used for the bay window frame (huge gouges in the wood) and crack in corner of the bay window. Salesperson was totally disengaged and did not follow up as I would expect. Absolutely horrible customer severs, only one person has the answers and they are not easy to get a hold of. Attempted to take the window screen off the garage window for winter I then noticed that the installer had caulked my window screen to the window frame. This was extremely alarming as this is very basic to do and to understand that caulk doesn't belong there. I asked to speak with the owners multiple times and finally called me in December and I had to explain everything to him and he didn't even have my file in front of him. I negotiated and they only would offer a discount if I signed an Non-disclosure agreement, very sketchy practice. This is how they maintain a good review/rating! This has been a extremely disappointing experience, especially as a returning customer who didn't' have best experience the first time. Lesson learned! I will not be reaching out to them for my future big money projects like the siding and roofing of my home and neither should you! They should hire more customer service people and skilled installers and stop spending their company money on the annoying TV adds. They do not care about you as the customer and this experience has proved it to me! Stay away from this horrible business! I wish I had!

We had our roof replaced yesterday by siding unlimited and we could not be happier. The entire…read moreexperience from quote with Dayton, Sales Rep, to the crew that installed the roof and cleaned up our yard, and I mean they clean up. I got 4 quotes from different companies and Siding Unlimited won our business and I highly recommend them.

I needed a very small siding repair. I was NOT interested in a two step process with an estimate…read morefrom a salseperson followed by a visit from the actual workers. I made that very clear to the scheduler. The scheduler confirmed that that could be done. I subsequently received an email confirming the appointment. I replied, repeating my insistence that I simply wanted the repair made in a single visit without a separate visit from an estimator. Sure enough, an estimator arrived 20 minutes late without any equipment. He was downright rude when I complained, saying "no one does business that way." I told him that Guardian was put on notice at least twice that I was not interested in a two step process. I would not have bothered taking time off from work had they simply told me they required a two step process. At my request, the manager called me, and I explained the situation. She was pleasant on the phone and said that she would she she could find someone in the organization to address the issue. I forwarded the earlier email for her records. She promptly acknowledged receipt. That was all two weeks ago. I never heard from her again. She did not respond to three follow-up emails of increasing urgency. The repair still have not been made, and I am back to square one. I DID receive a robotext asking me to rate my experience. (eyeroll). Stay away from these people. They are arrogant and beyond worthless unless you have a major project, and even then you have to worry about how they respond to a problem. Dear Guardian: am sorry I am not worth your precious time. It will not happen again.

Have had a LOT of communication with Guardian over the past few years. They did a sealant on our…read moreroof, but due to the age of the roof that plan did not hold up - they did explain to us that we really should have a new roof, which we agreed with and they subsequently gave us a credit off of the original quote. Workers were very diligent and hard-working. The project managers had to deal with extra problems that were uncovered when the old roof was taken off - many layers and uneven spots, for which we did pay extra. Our problem is with the follow up. While our manager/site boss - not exactly sure what his title is -was communicative during the process and did come back to follow up with some debris that was left in the gutter, etc. we told him that our large front bush got damaged. He assured us that they have a company that they work with, and that he would have them get in touch with us. That was three months ago, and I have sent him five texts, none of which were answered. While the roof itself seems fine, the lack of follow-up communication does not bode well for potential future problems.

We love our new roof!! It looks great! The entire crew was…read morevery kind and respectful of us as well as of the items that were in the garden beds that were in their way. They did such a great job!! Plus their clean up was magnificent! You cannot even tell there was a crew here. Everything is spotless!! Please pass on our praise and give those gentleman all a raise!!

They don't even deserve one star because I never saw them. Salesman never showed when my wife and…read moreI took time out of our busy schedules to get an estimate. Apparently his time was more important that ours...news flash, EVERYONE IS BUSY! I was willing to hand them the job, they must not need my business. Never again, very disrespectful and inconsiderate.

Honest. Great description of work that was needed. Met the lowest of two other estimates. Dan was…read moreexcellent to work with.

I absolutely recommend Dan! Every time it would rain the vent above my stove would leak water and…read moreone particularly heavy rain I just looked up reviews and saw that he had good ones. Gave him a call and he was VERY easy to talk to. He said he would come right when the rain let up and he actually ended up coming the next day cause it rained too much that day. He reached out to me the next day and came in a very timely manner. He was professional, kind, explained everything very well and I honestly have zero baseline knowledge of this stuff. He had very reasonable prices from what I could tell and even fixed the roof leak right away. If it didn't work he offered to come back and had another plan in place, but he was right the first time and fixed it perfectly! It's raining quite heavily now actually and we have zero leak from our roof. If I ever need anything done I'll definitely reach out and I highly recommend!

In October 2024 I contracted with 1st Choice Roofing to replaced the failing roof on a 2 story…read moreduplex I own in West Racine. While they were not the least expensive, I selected them after reviewing the job with Christo, the owner. He was very knowledgeable and was straight forward regarding the extent of possible issues that may be uncover when the shingles are removed from such an older building (1929). Christo has an extensive portfolio of quality materials to choose from and his suggestions really helped steer me towards the best possible outcome. The work began very shortly after the paperwork was completed and even after finding that the original roof had 3 layers of failed shingles in some areas, had extensive wood rot at the decking, fascia and soffit areas, needed replacement roof ventilation and also required additional work to remove an old school TV antenna... the roof was completed beautifully and ahead of schedule! Communication was on-going and professional throughout the entire job. The clean up was meticulous and complete. Gutters and downspouts were installed a few days later and the house really looks great! I can 100% recommend 1st Choice Roofing... and have already passed their contact information on to both family and friends.

Yelp says that their response time is "excellent" - but they never responded to a quote request…read more Might have been an old metric.

I contacted BCI Exteriors after reaching out to a wide variety of contractors that specialize in…read moredifferent things to try and find a solution to a moisture issue in the bedrooms of our house where water was sitting where the ceiling meets the walls. Other companies offered suggestions ranging from additional insulation to an entire roof with venting. Kevin came in and within 30 minutes had diagnosed the problem with a fix that I could do myself in a couple of hours and for less than $100. This came just a week after a different company quoted me $19,000 to resolve the issue. Even better, he didn't charge me for his time! Next time I need something that BCI can help with, I will definitely be reaching out to them!

Beyond good. Their repair man arrived a few minutes early, and was very friendly. He got right to…read morework. We had a mysterious leak that was causing a lot of damage. He found the leak - a cracked shingle - and fixed the hole with tar. No leaks since! Then he comes down off the ladder and I asked him, how much. He refused to charge me! Said it was just a small thing and he wouldn't leave a house with a hole in the roof. An honest tradesman, he had a chance to make some easy money and chose to be a good guy. Thanks!

This is the best company for windows and doors in Milwaukee! I've used a number of companies to do…read morework on my house, but after working with Chamberlin Co I won't use anyone else. The quality of the work is just hands down better and they are extremely easy to work with.

I recently purchased 3 doors from Chamberlin Co and my wife and I couldn't be happier . Everything…read moreabout the process was extremely smooth , the installers were very professional and the finished product is awesome ! Keep up the great work !!