Alimentari kind of gives off a slightly pretentious, hipster vibe, and you know what, they deserve to be able to do that. You don't go to Alimentari if you want a piece of bread with meat. You go to Alimentari to treat yourself like the king (or queen if you prefer) you are. Some other reviewers say that they're expensive, but when you first taste that wonderful capicola, you know why you're here. Alimentari isn't for everyone. But if you're in the mood for a GOOD sandwich, and are ready to pay a little bit more than other delis in town, then stop reading, and just go here. Get anything. It's all amazing. I won't spoil it for ya - try it yourself. read more

Very delicious food and good location also friendly staff. And a very comfortable atmosphere.

Still a 5 and still my favorite place to get a sandwich. I can now say I have tried every sandwich now. The Porchetta is still my favorite. The Bahn Mi is my least favorite. The bread is still heavenly. The staff is still the best and the restaurant/storefront is cozy and fun to look at and be in. 10/10 one of my favorite places to eat in Madison. read more

See all

Went here to grab some sandwiches before a road trip, and was surprised how large the sandwiches were. The bread was super thick and I'd say the sandwich was probably about 8 inches long. One note on the bread though is to be careful not to cut the top of your mouth as it is a pretty crisp crust. We ordered the prosciutto and the spicy soppressata. The prosciutto was the stand out favorite of the two, with its ample amount of meat, mozzarella, tomato, and arugula. It was also dressed nicely with the balsamic and EVOO so that it wasn't overpowering or soggy, just a good flavor complement. The spicy soppressata was a solid upgrade on a classic Italian sandwich. It had a little extra pop and the meat was high quality. The hot giardiniera added more value than the nduja mayo. It didn't land quite as well as the prosciutto though. We also picked up a jar of the extra hot giardiniera which we are loving. Definitely will be our go to place to get this! Overall, pretty good food. It's a little pricy for a sandwich, but you know the ingredients are high quality. We'd say it's one of the better sandwich shops in town, but definitely a great deli. read more

Alimentari - Prosciutto - International Grocery Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all

killer sandwiches nice products, chill vibe nice service found this on a whim visiting town, random spot but a lovely find! read more

See all

Five stars is the only suitable rating given the quality of the sandwiches and the deli offerings. The grocery selection is super broad and you can find pretty much any Italian specialty item not available at a conventional grocery store. read more

Stop here on my half-day after work for some lunch to bring home. I purchased the artichoke sandwich with salami. I brought it home and then toasted it in the oven for just a few minutes and it turned out perfectly. The bread was fresh, crunchy, and all of the flavors mesh together phenomenally. This was by far one of the best sandwiches I've had in a while. I will definitely be returning to try more sandwiches and purchase a few items from the deli and market as well read more

Alimentari - Artichoke sandwich - International Grocery Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

Little piece of Italy right here in Madison. This unassuming, modest market has all the essentials you need for Italian cooking. From fresh and dry pasta, wine, cheese, charcuterie, chocolate, ice cream, selection of olive oils and balsamic vinaigrettes, etc... it's everything I need! Most importantly, their take out sandwiches are phenomenal. Their most recent sandwich with the truffle parmigiano spread and brown butter balsamic vinaigrette reminded me of All Antico Vinaio in Florence, Italy. my husband and I have just been chasing that same taste ever since and this sandwich right here was the closest! So good. A favorite is also the spicy soppressata sandwich. Really great spicy kick from the giadianera with the spreadable nduja is jsut perfection. Love it. The prosciutto sandwich is simple but packed with flavor I love the arugula, olive oil and balsamic vinaigrette. We come here every other week and everything we've had is just excellent. read more

Alimentari - Spicy soppressata and their new italian ham, truffle parmigiano spread, brown butter balsamic vinaigrette. - International Grocery Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

Best sandwich in Madison. I love their salads, sandos, wine selection, pasta, specialities. Just the best.

Probably the best sandwiches we've had in Madison!! Quite a nice variety on the menu with something for everyone in your party. We already can't wait to go back and try more! Plus the people working were super nice and knowledgeable. I also want to explore the store more and definitely try their fresh pasta (it looked great). Our favorite sandwich was the spicy soppressata, but the prosciutto and pastrami were also great quality and delicious. These sandwiches were definitely two meals for us as well (nicely stuffed with thick and excellent bread). Will be back for sure! read more

See all

Love their sandwiches, specifically the Spicy Sopressata Sandwich. This is a perfect amount of bread ratio and what a great amount of food it is. Each bite has such great texture and taste. read more

AMAZING! I cannot say enough wonderful things about Alimentari. Not only is their food absolutly to die for but their customer service is above and beyond. We recently celebrated an event and the original carter cancelled last minute Ricco and the Alimentari team pulled together a fabulous platter of sandwiches and pasta salad. The quality of the ingredients and the creative way they are assembled is fantastic! Thank you do much Ricco and crew!! read more

Every time we visit Madison we are super impressed by the food scene. We wanted sandwiches and thought we'd give this a try based on the great reviews. The pork porchetta sandwich was incredible! Plus we picked up a few fun extras for later. We will definitely be back to Alimentari! read more

SO good! We were passing through the Madison area and were looking for a sandwich shop. We came across this place and it didn't disappoint! It felt like stepping into a legit bistro in Italy. Don't be deterred by the prices. You get a very big sandwich that you can easily share if wanted. I would highly recommend. The pastrami & swiss sandwich was delicious!! read more

Alimentari - Pastrami & Swiss - International Grocery Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

5/5 - my favorite place for a sandwich in Madison! Don't let the higher prices turn you off. The sandwiches are HUGE (seriously huge) and worth it! Their space also doubles as a small artisan market with fresh pasta, gelato, wine and liquor, and more. I typically go back and forth between the Porchetta (with goat cheese, apple, fennel, arugula, and honey) and the Prosciutto (with mozzarella, tomato, arugula, balsamic vinegar, and olive oil). They change half of their sandwiches every so often, but not feeling anything on the menu? The staff is very welcoming and can whip you up something off the menu! Another tip: Call before you arrive to make sure they haven't run out of bread. And final tip: you can't enjoy your sandwich without a bag of their Calabrian chips (found next to the checkout). They're a little addictive, so you might want to grab more than one. read more

The Alimentari is my latest obsession. Between their daily fresh pasta, cheese selections, pantry items, frozen raviolis, and more - it's every Italian food lover's dream! This place feels clean, friendly, affordable, and most importantly - no bullshit (can I swear on here?). Honestly, 10/10 - I love this place and can not recommend it highly enough. Note: I am a vegetarian HOWEVER I have heard nothing but amazing reviews about their deli meats/sandwiches and I'd recommend people try those for a quick lunch or dinner. read more

See all

There's not much I can add reading previous reviews. They have a delightful selection of Italian deli and pantry items keeping our snacks and meals delicious. Try the pasta! And the wonderful sandwiches are generously sized. We have found a couple wines we enjoyed and bought a case or two. read more

Every single time I come here I'm compelled to tell every single person I encounter about it I love it I love it I love it I can't get it off my mind I have to call my mom and tell her about it every time. god, the flavor the freshness the love that's poured into it. There's not words for the way I love it, I think maybe I will have to paint you a picture or orchestrate a symphony to tell you how I feel read more

Nudja mayo. Who knew I was missing it in my life? Small menu of sandwiches available for takeout, three fresh pastas available when I stopped by (buccatini, rigatoni and a gemelli-like shape), and meats and cheese ready to be sliced. They also carry a nice selection of wine, oils, balsamic, dried pasta, etc. Super friendly and able to help you find the right thing for your tastes/intended use. I tried the spicy soprressata sandwich and it was super delicious. Layers of flavor. Every detail counted. The bread was the perfect crisp on the outside (but won't cut your mouth) and pillowy on the inside. 6" long, about 4.5" wide, so a generous size. And the homemade spicy calabrian chips are perfection...don't miss them by the checkout! read more

Alimentari - Calabrian chips - International Grocery Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all

Great choices, very upscale. Expect to spend $10 on up for any item you see. They make some good looking sandwiches which are in the range of $15. I'll be back when someone gives me a $100 gift certificate. Everything looks tasty and unique. read more

A wonderful shop with a lot to offer. I found some of the most incredible truffles when I visited and I can't wait to go back for more. They have fresh pasta and wonderful sandwiches as well. Everyone was very friendly and helpful. The location is a bit discreet but I'm so glad my friends recommended to try this place! read more

Could be the best sandwich I ever had. Spicy soppressata was amazing. Can't wait to eat here again

Alimentari made mini cannoli for my wedding, which were a hit with my Italian family from the East Coast. Working with Enrico was easy and everything turned out perfectly. Would highly recommend sampling a cannoli in their shop or having them cater your next event! read more

See all

Must stop in Madison for delicious Italian sandwiches!! This was our second time here and the sandwiches were just as good as we remembered. We got the spicy soppressata (their most popular sandwich), truffle mortadella and italian beef. We all agreed the truffle mortadella was our favorite, but all three were good. The soppressata does have quite a kick so wouldn't recommend if you don't tolerate spicy foods. Can't wait to come back and try the fresh pasta! read more

The sandwiches here are fantastic. Every time I visit Madison we stop by for the spicy soppressata, it's delicious. My daughter loves the porchetta and her boyfriend always get the hot Italian beef. Everything we've had is delicious. read more

the sandwiches here are incredible, and the fresh pasta was so good to cook with as well as all of the premade options! definitely a gem in madison, wi! read more

This is a rustic bread, thinly sliced meat, classic and reliable Italian Deli. The sandwiches are massive and this deli is an easy go to for anyone looking for sandwiches/Italian grocery on their way to the lake/work/home/or anything in between! read more

Outstanding sandwiches and deli selection. Not cheap but still a great value considering the quality. I'm new to the area and will gladly be a regular. read more

Best sandwich shop east of the capitol! Huge mouth-watering sandwiches, some of the best cannoli I've had and a fantastic selections of meats, cheeses, and other high-end Italian goods. This a great spot for lunch, fresh pasta for dinner, or maybe a foodie gift. Don't sleep on the triple-dipped chocolate malt balls...mmm. read more

Loved the sandwiches and excellent service. Our one-year old was particularly fond of the cannoli! Highly recommend. read more

Alimentari - International Grocery Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

My boyfriend and I are OBSESSED with the spicy soppressata sandwiches. The staff is always attentive and helpful. Loved their wine recommendations! An excellent Italian deli with high quality ingredients. read more

Alimentari is the sort of place that makes me happy to live in Madison! Their sandwiches are incredible, the fresh made pasta is the best you can find anywhere, the staff are remarkably knowledgeable and helpful, and the selection of specialty grocery items is broad and rich. I could not be happier to have this delightful market as part of our community. Pro-tip: engage the amazing staff in a conversation about what you're looking for, what you're thinking about preparing, and/or any particular recommendations they have. They're all fantastic resources for you both in terms of what's available and how best to enjoy it. This is not the sort of place to pop in and grab something you've seen dozens of other places in town, rather it's a warm and welcoming atmosphere that encourages lingering, discussions, tasting, exploration. I honestly love it! There's an emphasis is on Italian ingredients but it's far from exclusive with options from across Europe, the Mediterranean, and here in the US. Take a moment to sample some of the phenomenal meats in the deli case and equally delicious cheeses on offer. The wine selection is not huge but is expertly curated and you will almost certainly find something exciting and new to fit your desires. Cap it all off with a house made cannoli or two because OF COURSE YOU SHOULD!!! I've tried all of their sandwiches and they're all great! It's clear that thought and skill have gone into balancing vibrant and flavorful ingredients in each option. The fresh bread is PERFECT for big robust flavors; neither ephemeral nor dense, boring nor overwhelming. It's structured without being tough and flavorful in its own right. My personal favorite is probably the spicy sopressata (which is PHENOMENAL) but the Italian beef, meatball with giardinera, and all the others are very good as well. Strongly, STONGLY recommended! read more

I'm obsessed. As soon as I finish a spicy soppressata (the best sandwich in my opinion), I daydream about when I will have it again. Yes, $11 is a bit steep for a sandwich, but it's pretty large, so it could be two portions. If you are like me, though, you won't be able to stop until the sandwich is done! Always friendly, great random groceries (gelato, wine, fresh pasta, Italian-inspired goods). read more

Absolutely LOVE the sandwiches here. We ordered both the meatball sandwich and prosciutto sandwich... both were delicious! The meatball sandwich was flavorful and hefty. It was served hot and definitely hit the spot. The prosciutto sandwich was so fresh and packed with flavor! They don't skimp out on the prosciutto and it is cut so fine that it is almost buttery. The ingredients in the sandwiches were fresh with bright greens and tomatoes and crispy bread. I shared both sandwiches and was able to make it two meals. The service is fast and the employees are courteous and safe! Will 100% return and definitely recommend to anyone looking for a sandwich with high quality ingredients! read more

Love this place!! Such a good find this weekend! Went here for sandwiches and WOW were we pleased! Got the prosciutto and spicy sopresata. Both with chewy fresh bread and generous stacks of meat. We loved the spicy giardiniera. Also tried the homemade potato chips, mixed olives, and a FRESH CANOLE! I was a happy lady. My boyfriend loved the sauce on the sopresata so much they sold him a small Tupperware. The staff were super friendly! This place is so fun to browse. Definitely coming back to get some fresh pasta to take home some night. read more

Amazing sandwiches and Italian products for cooking. I visited twice now and both times I had unbelievable sandwiches. Highly recommend!!

Awesome little neighborhood deli. I read all the other positive reviews from other places and questioned whether this place could be THAT good. Well, turns out it is. Sandwiches are huge and delicious. I got the spicy sopressata and it was amazing. I'm very excited to go back and try some others, but I cannot recommend this place enough. If you want a tasty and filling sandwich, you will not be disappointed here. read more

As come in the door, take a hard right to the freezer. Reach in and grab a lasagne. It's not cheap, but 4 generous serving per container. Take it home and bake as instructed on the label. Enjoy and thank me later. By the way, their sandwiches are amazing. read more

Creating the perfect sandwich is an art. It takes quality ingredients and an understanding of what works well together. I've had some amazing sandwiches in my life. Zingerman's in Ann Arbor, Il Ritrovo in Sheboygan and the bánh mì at Braise in Milwaukee come to mind. I had high exceptions for Alimentari. Sadly, it did not deliver - pricey without the payoff. In theory, the Porchetta sandwich sounded great, but the apples lacked the brightness needed to balance the richness of the goat cheese. The marinated artichoke sandwich was also disappointing. Plus, I think it was supposed to have Roma tomatoes, but instead had sun-dried tomatoes, which clashed with the cheeses. At the end of the day, neither sandwich made our mouths sing. read more

Okay, this is hard for me to say, and I've been back multiple times to confirm but... ok here it goes: Alimentari's Spicy Soprasetta Sandwich is THE BEST SANDWICH I'VE EVER HAD. That felt good. Real good. Seriously though- get this sandwich! read more