Three strikes you're out. Strike one a few weeks ago: online ordering wasn't working. Strike two a couple weeks ago: online ordering worked until it failed at the order placement process. So I called to place a delivery order and after being on hold for six minutes gave up. Strike three tonight: online ordering worked! Delivery person was very friendly. However...food sucked. The pizza looked and felt like it had spent a bunch of time at room temperature. Almost all of it is in my garbage can now. Sorry Alfy's....I'm done. read more

I thought the people we dealt with were very friendly - the pizza wasn't amazing, but it was good. The salad bar, again, not amazing, but pretty good. And we fed 6 adults and 5 kids with drinks and salads and 2 X-Large pizzas for $35. Um, seriously, $35. Again, not life changing quality of food, but the ambiance was great for a group, the people were friendly, the kids loved the free Xbox and N64 games, and it really deserves 5 stars on the value-meter (but Yelp isn't strictly value-meter, so it gets 4). Anyway - if you happen to be in Monroe and need to feed a small crowd, it's about as good an option as you've got. read more

Easily the best pizza on the Eastside.....Its always fresh, warm and checked and doubled checked for accuracy. They offer any of thier pizzas for take and bake at half price, have a buy one get one free special every Monday and Tuesday and have 5 gaming consoles set up in thier restaurant. read more

Alfy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Monroe, Washington

See all

Scratch this one off my list... I decided to start checking out the pizza options in the area, including this one, found off Yelp (shameless plug). Got a small two topping pizza and it was only $7. That was the good part. I don't want to finish the 2/3 of it I didn't eat, for starters. I would accept $7 to do it, honestly. Place just feels kind of like a Pizza Hut about to go bankrupt. The pizza looked unappetizing and lacked any kind of real flavor. In short, I'm sure I've had better pizza at chuck e. cheese's. It has some small town charm, I'll give it that. But that might be another reason I don't desire to live in a small town. read more

Super unimpressed. $55 for two pizzas to be delivered nearly 2 hours late and very cold. What a disappointment as we were looking for something hassle free, delicious, and hot as it was our first night moving into our new home as Monroe residents. The driver called me after a long time and said he went to Echo Lake by mistake - GPS failure. I asked him to call his boss to let them know - expecting a reduced fare for what would be obviously cold and soggy pizza. I was right - the pizza sucked cold and soggy. The driver was apologetic and said I could get 50% off my next order, but gave me nothing to redeem it with. Should have gone with Seharra. read more

Well, here I am again, I'm personally not eating but a family member is and my said family member prefers tables because they are bigger...Well it is 7:35 and the chairs at the table were up so I moved two down so me and him could sit, and red hair waitress wth glasses tells me the area is closed and has the audacity to have me and him move elsewhere....When I ask when they close, they close at 9...Also there was no egg for the salad bar out and no bread sticks made...I will be hopefully contacting the manager. Getting really tired of lazy workers, and yes I have worked fast food before and know what it's like to have to clock out at a certain time. read more

Alfy's Pizza - Chairs are up by 7:35 (probably earlier since we just got here) when red hair glasses girl works. - Pizza Near Me - Monroe, Washington

Years ago they use to make a half way decent pizza but as the years have went by the crust has got thinner and thinner and the toppings less and less. Its to the point now its not much better then a frozen pizza you can pick up at your local grocery store. I will still pick one up from time to time during their half price special but would never pay full price for one. read more

this is, imo, best pizza in Monroe. not only that but the one time i have had some small error they fixed it with a smile and i got a nice bonus of a spare pizza. Kids love this place too! they have plenty of games to keep them entertained while u wait for the pie. oh yeah and the beer is great! a pitcher is correctly priced! TY for the good experiences with kids and friends read more

This is the pizza that I grew up with. They are a bit pricey but they take ANY coupon, they are half off before 2:00, and they are half off if you order an unbaked pizza "to go". So if you pay full price, you're a sucker. My fav is their Garlic Chicken. Extra points for having Scuttlebutt's beer on tap. read more

The pizza is always good and the staff is super friendly. It's a nice, comfortable family place. It's great for birthday parties or any other type of family get together. They have a fresh salad bar and it's always nicely stocked. There is also a small game room and other free console games for the kids. Love this Alfy's! read more

Alfy's Pizza - Medium sausage & pepperoni! - Pizza Near Me - Monroe, Washington

I've never been a big fan of their pizza but I love the Salad bar. My only issue is that the hours don't seem set in stone. Tried to go in for dinner one night and was told they were closing early. Another night we tried to go in 35 minutes before closing. I just wanted the salad bar but was told no as they were closing the salad bar but it was open and no closing procedures were taking place. We never went back. read more

Passing through Monroe, we stopped by for first time during lunch, which is half-off from 11-2 and a good deal for good pizza. The staff was very friendly and even noticed my credit card and gave me a military discount without my asking on top of the half-off pizza. There are free old-console video games for kids and there is plenty of space. Not sure why so many negative reviews but maybe things have changed and it's worth a try again for all of you naysayers! read more

First time here. We got there for half price. If not it is pretty pricey for a basic pizza. $25. But half off worked.

Tonight we had my nephews birthday at Alfys in Monroe. As we were leaving I discovered my daughter misplaced her lovie (aka her comfort item she has had since she was born). I asked if the person cleaning the room saw it. She didn't respond so I asked the man at the counter " has someone turned in a little dog looking blanket" he looked in a drawer and said no. I went back to the room and looked through the trash. On my way out I asked the man for a manager. He said it was him and I got his name (Sebastian). I said "could you help..." he interrupted me and said he had more important things to do then look for a stupid stuffed animal and that i needed to leave. I then asked for the owners contact number and he said it is corporate owned and I needed to figure it out. My sister then went in to look for the lovie and the man told her I called an employee a "stupid Mexican" and that she needed to leave. Never in my life would I ever say anything of the sort about anyone, that is not me! It shocks and sickens me that I was accused of something so awful. I am just a mama looking for my child's toy. I have never been treated so terrible by anyone at an establishment. So if anyone sees this lovie at alfys tonight you would make a little girls heart so happy. read more

I have a coupon through the Entertainment app. I ordered in advance and when I came to pick it up and use the coupon they wasted a bunch of my time trying to figure out how to use it. Finally, the manager came out and said they wouldn't take it because it wasn't their coupon. I said your address is on it and I got it through this app. Manager said we don't have an app. Of course you don't have an app you are a local pizza chain. It is an app that I pay for to gain access to local coupons. If you don't want to be on the app don't, but don't advertise a coupon then not honor it. Manager was totally rude and just walked away. I was coming back from mountain biking and had sat in traffic for two hours. Super dissapointed. Avoid these jerks at all costs read more

This use to be a 3 and a half star alfy's but wow horrible pizza barly any cheese on it,the chesse falls of when you bite it, some very rude employees, way to much tomatoe sauce, and their side condiments (being parmasean cheese, crushed red peppers,salt,and pepper) Taste horrible I wouldnt give it to my dog much less my family I still go just out of tradition because I fell bad if I dont and every time I go I hope "God please let this pizza be good so I can come back" But god can't heklp if theirs crap cooks read more

Stopped in for salad bar during lunchtime. Greens were wilted and slimy. Was informed that is the way they are. Lettuce brown. Overall not appetizing. read more

The girls that work here rock!!! The pizza is ok nothing special, but their dessert pizza is awesome!! The stella draft here is awesome! Did I mention free unlimited Xbox play so moms and dads can get a little alone time. Salad bar has a pretty decent spread and I love that they servd ivars chowder sometimes also read more

So walked into Alfy's pizza in Monroe. First of all they were super busy. Which not to surpised on a Sunday at noon. We order 2 all you can eat salad bars 2 drinks and a xtra large half and half pizza. Went to pay I only had a bill on me I was spending almost 40$ he told me he does not have change really rude like. Personally I did not believe this due to how busy they were. So I left walked to o'reilys in the same parking lot and they changed my hundred for me no problem didn't even make me purchase anything. Went back order our food. Salad bar was good. But that is kinda hard to mess up. Now I haven't had Alfy's pizza in some time but I am pretty sure the crust that I got was not proofed enough because it was floppy soggy and gross. I didn't complain because I just really didn't feel like it. But would not recommend this Alfy's to anyone. read more

Does anyone remember the time when Alfy's was good? I think most of them have gone out of business now, and I can see why. . . its fallen a long long way. I know its hard to be too critical of a place that sells their pizza for half price at lunch time, but it just isn't very good and its time for this Monroe branch to follow the lead of the others and close up shop. Its really nothing better than a place to take kids for cheap pizza and baseball team parties, and I apologize on behalf of Alfy himself to anyone who pays full price for this. read more

School lunch tasting pizza, typical salad bar. I would not come back, but when you have hundreds of Nieces and Nephews too rowdy to hold a birthday party in anyone's home it is inevitable I will be back read more

You can get better pizza from Papa Johns. Their pizza ranks down with Chucky Cheese. 1/2 price pizza before 2pm.

My boyfriend and I love Alfy's pizzas (hand-rolled crust!) after skiing at Stevens. The crust is thick and chewy. We love Alfy's vegetarian pizza and artichoke and feta pizza. Ohhhh, they are just so delicious. read more

OK, any place that has free video games to keep my kids entertained AND decent beer on tap to keep me entertained is off to a fine start. The pizza is fine -- nothing to write home about, but certainly a step above Little Caesar's or Pizza Hut, which puts it a step below Papa John's and Sahara and definitely out of the league of any haute cuisine. But c'mon, it's cheap and family-friendly -- that's why you come here; let's keep it in perspective. A better salad bar would earn 4 stars -- like others, I've been disappointed in the variety and quality. The greens are fine, but more fresh veggies, meats, and toppings would help. Still -- I will not complain that there actually IS a salad bar, as eating an entire meal of pizza and beer would make me feel entirely too guilty. And we can't have that. read more

Stopped here after a long weekend up in the mountains near Index. It wasn't busy at all, good for us, bad for them. We had 2 pretty good pizzas, some drinks, and the salad bar, which had many options and was really delicious. The guys working were nice and attentive. Prices were decent, too. read more

Had an issue was told it would be fixed on the next order. Placed my next order and was told it could not be honored at their word. Then attempt to tell me they needed a minimum of $20 to even deliver the mistake they made in the first place. It is the last time we will deal with this Alfys most likely for ever read more

absolute garbage, ordered some pizza's for my family and a group of friends, threw around 80% of it over the fence. Terrible in everyway possible, undercooked, crappy sauce, bland cheese, vomit worthy at best. read more

Friendly staff. Better prices than Sahara for the same quality. Better pizza than the domino's in town. The deal you get for take and bake beats papa murphys too. read more

I was calling all over Monroe this morning around 10 trying to find a place that delivers lunch so that I could have it delivered to my boyfriend (25) for his birthday at work. After many fails I finally got the go ahead from a girl (dont remember her name sadly) and she said she could definetley have it there by 11am. She not only went out of her way to make a delivery when they were opening but also threw in free cinnamon sticks for his birthday and a balloon! Now if thats not great customer service I dont know what is! I highly suggest you give these guys a shot, they know how to make a consumer happy! read more

4 stars for the salad bar! So great to have a place with a good salad bar and fairly priced. They have tasty breadsticks and a pretty good selection of toppings for your salad. I have had their pizza once and it was the worse pizza on the planet. The restaurant is nice, huge and open and good to take your kids. They have video games for them to play with is cool. So enjoy the salad bar not so much the pizza!! read more

We used to get Delivery from them until the last 2 times the pizza was so skimpy we couldn't even tell if it was what we ordered. We won't order from there anymore. read more

What a difference a year makes. Before we moved out here, we stopped in and feasted on Alfys pizzas. The quality has really gone down hill. We have stopped buying pizza from this store. Fridays are "Pizza Movie Night" for our family. Now, we're on a quest for a new restaraunt. It is really amazing how badly and frequently folks can mess up "Family sized Peperoni Pizza". Hopefully, things will change. If they do, we'll try again. read more

The pizza is okay, better to dine in for the kids- awesome salad bar.

Our first experience at this restaurant was ok. My husband, 16 yr old daughter and myself were in the mood for pizza and, being new to the area, we disregarded the negative ratings and took our chances. It's pretty expensive for a pizza establishment. We ended up spending over $50 for our lunch, which consisted of a one-time visit for one to the salad bar, a soft drink, a pitcher of beer, a personal pizza and a large two topping pizza. Everything tasted pretty good, and it wasn't too busy for a weekday at lunch hour. Several of the tables had plates of food and empty glasses on them, so maybe we missed the lunch crowd. We left feeling like we would visit again, and that's where the trouble started. After a day out school shopping, my daughter and I decided to stop and pick up a pizza and take it home to eat. There was a sign on the counter saying that there was a "summer special" going on; any pizza, any sauce, any toppings for various prices. I asked for an extra large Royal Alfy's with Alfredo sauce and stuffed crust. The price was $17.99 but the stuffed crust was an additional $2.00. I agreed to the price increase and paid $19.99 and was told it would be a 15 to 20 minute wait. It was ready in 20 minutes and my daughter carried the pizza to the car and sat it on the back seat for the 6 mile drive home. My mistake was not opening the lid of the box and looking at the pizza before we left the restaurant. My husband was home waiting for us and when I opened the box my heart sank. They had given us some sort of thin crispy pizza with thick fat tomato slices sliced in half on the top. There were no toppings whatsoever on the outer edge of the pizza about 1" from the edge. There were sporadic pieces of toppings scattered around that make no sense. It did not resemble the description of a Royal Alfy's in any way. I immediately picked up the phone and gave them a call. I explained who I was and that I had just left. The young lady on the other end said she remembered me and before I could finish explaining the situation she began to be argumentative and saying that I said I didn't want to spend the extra $2.00 for the stuffed crust. I said that it was partially my fault for not looking at the pizza first but that I didn't get what I asked and paid for. She said, in a very snotty tone, that she would have them make me a new one, but that I'd have to bring the other one back. Perhaps they have had problems in the past with people wanting a free pizza, but I wasn't one of them. I said that I lived 6 miles away and that it would be 18 miles total if I had to come back to town, and she let out a sigh and said " so what do you want to do?". I just hung up the phone and made up my mind that what I wanted to do was to never visit their establishment again. Her horrible argumentative attitude sealed the deal for me. Such a shame that a mere employee holds the fate of customer satisfaction, but that is the power she was given and I will find a new restaurant for my family to visit. read more

You could spend $2.99 at Albertsons and buy a better pizza than what you would get at the here. I thought the sauce and cheese was horrible

We come to Alfy's for the salad bar & soup. Alfy's offer a large variety of nutritious choices in their salad bar. They also have very good soups. If you are into healthy eating you likely haven't considered eating at a pizza parlor. However don't miss out on their salad bar. We haven't found another salad bar as good as this one anywhere nearby & the prices are very reasonable! We also enjoy the oldies softly playing in the background. read more

Alfy's Pizza - The best salad bar around. Mondays Alfy's offers a senior special (age 60 & up), All-you-can-eat salad bar & bread sticks for $3.49 + tax. - Pizza Near Me - Monroe, Washington

Absolutely HORRIBLE! Pizza wasn't nearly as good as Snohomish Alfys and it was not worth my money at all. Also, there were green bugs in the Parmesan cheese and when we informed the employees they immediately exclaimed, "again?!" I'm sorry, again? Meaning you have had this problem in the past and you haven't fixed it?! I am NEVER giving this location my business again and the only reason I'm giving them one star is because zero stars is not an option. Incorrigible. read more

Great beer batter crust! At least I think that is the secret ingrediant. For the life of me I cannot recreate Alfy's pizza! So I of course pay for it. As a native Snohomish county resident I feel like most of my life has involved Alfy's pizza. Its nostalogic for me every time I see an Alfy's. Our kid birthday parties, church events, little league, and average lunches included Alfy's. The pizza is good! The lunch special is the best deal around. Sometimes when I travel and feel like pizza and cannot get Alfy's I'm reminded what a special gem this place is in Washington. Also, I like supporting local businesses. I would rather support my community than some random big business. read more

So, where to start with this restaurant nightmare; the poor service, the mediocre food, or the rude inconsiderate staff and management? First, because their kids food sucks and our 2.5 year old son won't touch it, we brought in nuggets from a fast food place. As we settled in to order our lunch and gave our child his food, management informed us no outside food no exceptions. Clearly not aware of toddler psychology the manager insisted in causing a massive tantrum. Despite this breakdown it was really in our best intrested to leave and save our cash since the salad bar is poorly stocked and the food is usually very bland anyways. I recommend Zeeks over this trainwreck. read more

I use to really enjoy Alfys pizza. The last time I ordered we noticed it was salty. Decided to give them another try and once again salty, but this time the dough was undercooked. My bf ended up instantly vomiting after eating. Pizzas are overpriced, I was originally going to buy 2 medium pizzas to have it delivered, they said it was going to be $46! Mind you this does not include a tip for the delivery driver. Ended up just getting one xl pizza and it came to $32. Driver never looks happy or talks to you. I called and they said they would refund me my money, hopefully they don't back out of that. read more