The food and service are still amazing! Have enjoyed this amazing pizza joint/ beautiful Italian…read more restaurant since the 90's...This place has been consistent for 30+ years!

we were there at 5 pm we were only the second table there . The server was trying but she must have…read morebeen new and inexperience, we had to explain what aldente meant, and she was very slow, We split the chicken dish with pasta, it was ok nothing special. The pizza here is great stick to that if your going here

We needed a new pizza spot by the fam to get take out at when visiting. Got a large round pie with…read more6 garlic knots. One of the better spots in the area to get pizza by far. Sauce and crust good. Right amount of cheese. Garlic knots were large and oily. Not too overdone either. All in all a decent spot to get a pie!

Love the stuffed knots and pizza varieties, food and service fantastic ! A plus plus on catering…read morealso - Thank you again

Super cute pizza spot with pretty good pizza! My mom had been saying good things. She use to work…read morefor the Town of Brookhaven before she retired a few years back. She said a lot of people would order pizza from here, so we decided to give it a shot. I got a few different slices and they were solid! The buffalo garlic Knot was a nice change from the traditional. The inside of the restaurant itself was not what I was expected. But it was a pleasant surprise (see photos). I could definitely see us picking up slices from here again for sure.

Stop into Big Italy Pizza to grab a few slices and this spot is a solid spot considering how far…read moreeast in Suffolk. The place itself is a bit small but has a nostalgic atmosphere with the various pictures and memorabilia inside. Ordered 4 slices to go ( 2 penne ala vodka, 1 regular and 1 margarita) the total came out to 19.54 after tax (cheaper to pay with cash which I opted for). The service was solid and everyone that was working at the restaurant greeted us and the lady that took our order welcomed us back to try more food.

Drago's pizza has consistently proven to be one of the best pizza places around the Suffolk County…read more We have tried different items off their menu and are we are always pleased. I highly recommend Drago's to anyone who wants exceptional service and quality food. If I could give it 6 stars, I would.

Stopped in for lunch as I had time to kill while in the area…read more I decided on a chicken bacon ranch slice. While it was good, it didn't stand out from other slices I've had if the same. They also don't have many regular slices here and most are the Sicilian square/rectangle type. For a slice and a 20oz soda it was just under $10. Staff was friendly.

When I am in the area, I make sure to come here and it's some of my favorite pizza out there…read more Everything I've had here is delicious but their pizza is always 10/10. The staff is very friendly too and they run plenty of specials!

Gave them ONE request. Please make the pizza WELL DONE. It came RAW. Cheese white as a ghost , not…read moreeven baked... crust also white. HORRIBLE

What a wonderful surprise! We stopped at Cafe Gia on our way back from the Tanger Outlets in…read moreRiverhead, just looking for a place to eat, and we ended up discovering a little Italian gem! The Italian owner, Dominic, was incredibly welcoming and made us feel right at home. The food was absolutely delicious. We had the pasta with shrimp, which was full of flavor, and the toasted bread with cheese was amazing -- the kids absolutely loved it! But the best of the best was the chicken soup. Oh my gosh! Seriously, some people can't even make chicken soup this good at home! It tasted homemade, comforting, rich and absolutely delicious. Mamma mia, che bontà! I would honestly drive another 40 minutes just to eat this soup again! Great food, warm Italian hospitality, and that wonderful feeling of finding a place you weren't expecting to love so much. Cafe Gia, we will definitely be back! Grazie, Dominic!

It's such a pretty pizza place with nice ambiance they sell this garlic bread with mozzarella,…read moresliced onions and tomatoes and it is Devine! The workers are very friendly, we came at a time they were giving away the dessert for free.

Awhile back, I left a pretty bad review for this place. Since then, they've changed owners, and…read moremade some much needed cosmetic changes to the storefront as well (not that it matters that much, but who wants to buy food from a place that looks like a dump?) Anyway.... I was hesitant to give em another shot, but after hearing about new ownership, fair is fair. And I didn't think my previous review would be "fair" to them. So I made my obligatory "3 visit" rule (I try out a place 3x times before writing a bad review; after all, everyone is entitled to have a bad day, right?). So.... I'm happy to report NOW that the place was clean, the staff were pleasant and friendly, and the pizza was GREAT. Lots of choices (I'm a by the slice kinda guy), all tasted fresh, and frankly, it's pretty damn good. With that: 5 stars, and a hearty recommendation! Enjoy!

Ordered the Northfork veggie pizza and the broccoli was missing which was a total bummer,…read moreespecially since I was charged for the broccoli. Overall, there weren't that many veggies except for olives and olives are actually considered a fruit. Ha! Oh well. We will try the other pizza place down the street next time. You win some and you lose some.

One of my all time favorite pizza places, which is hard on Long Island where pizza is great to…read morebegin with! They have a shrimp slice I'm obsessed with, and a cheeseburger slice I was addicted to before I started trying to be more health conscious lol. But I love how all their specialty slices always look so fresh! I also love their little stuffed garlic bread thingies soo much, dipped in the sauce they give or plain. Service is exceptional. The guys are so friendly, down to earth, and attentive. Cutest little place, very welcoming for all

I've been coming to Tony's Pizza for as long as I can remember, and it truly is a Medford staple…read more If you've never been, you absolutely have to try their barbecue chicken pizza--it's one of a kind and only found here at Tony's. Of course, all of their other pies are fabulous too. I wish I had a picture to share with you, but I ate it so fast I forgot to take one. (Trust me, that says more than any photo could!)

Medford Pasteria is my go to restaurant when I'm in the mood for Italian food and they dont break…read morethe bank AT ALL on pasta nights! Mondays and Tuesdays, a complete dinner is $21.95 and includes choice of salad with fresh greens or caesar salad, main dish, unlimited soda and for dessert, a choice of cheesecake or a mini cannoli! Last night, arriving at 7:30, there was only one table open. It was crazy busy with 2 birthdays being celebrated. My usual night to dine there is on Tuesday, no reason in particular, and it was nice to see, at first, that they have a person named Carmelo singing while playing the keyboard as entertainment! Will come back to this in a moment! The food is always great and consistent. On an especially busy night while I was there they didn't falter on service or food! The salad is fresh and they offer Thousand Island dressing, my favorite! I find that to be a rarity to have at an Italian restaurant but lucky me!! My baked ziti was an amazing blend of everything, the pasta cooked perfectly! Did I mention there are prepared entrees in a big refrigerator when you walk in that are practically free?? It's filled with a variety of ready made dishes including pasta, chicken, seafood and desserts! Everything is priced at $6.00! That is an over the top great deal on great food to me!! Ok, back to the live entertainment! Carmelo was very good! He sang Italian songs as well as popular ones! He even took a moment to sing Happy Birthday to the people celebrating that night which was very nice but....he was loud, a little too much!! The restaurant was noisy to begin with! A combination of the restaurant completely filled and the loud music and singing I couldn't hear my daughter, AT ALL! Instead of talking, we conversed via text the whole time we were there! Except for a few 5 minute breaks, this was extremely annoying to me but for some, this might be a good thing! I will absolutely be returning to Medford Pasteria as I have yet to try their pizza except.... I will not be eating there on Mondays!

The service was great - thank you Maria. Everyone was very attentive, filled up my water and my ice…read moretea. The food was excellent, had the shrimp parm with angel hair. The sauce was nice and thick, just like I like it. Price was right. I had nothing bad to say. It is in a slightly odd, 1/2 empty plaza, but that's why I'd call it a hidden gem.

Good food, great service, and a classic pizza shop ambiance is how I describe Donatina's. I had the…read moreAla Vodka Spicy Pepperoni slice and the Detroit style pepperoni cup slice. Both were very good, especially the Detroit Style Pepperoni cup slice. The cheese crust, the sauce, and pepperoni was delicious. The Ala Vodka slice was really good too. The crust was decent. Great service, and great selection of pizza. Looking forward to trying the Jonny Gravone Detroit style pizza next time!

Pizzas are outstanding. So is service. A+. My husband and I are there at least 2x a weekread more