I'm usually a little reluctant to hand out 5 star reviews but I honestly cannot find a fault with…read morethis place. They stay in their lane and don't try to be something they're not. You order your pies and you get delicious pizza. End of story. The Spinach pie had caramelized redo onions, sauteed spinach, garlic and bacon, oh my, that was heaven in a square box. We also had a Roasted Red and White specialty pie, as well as a traditional cheese pie. All were outstanding and the people were very nice. I don't think you'll find better pizza for miles!

If you're familiar with Mount Pleasant then you know it's practically the Mecca for Ma & Pop pizza…read morejoints, The Junction is a game changer. With so much competition in the area, they are killing the game. The Junction Deluxe and The Roasted Red And White are off the charts. If you're bored with your typically pizza routine, give them a shot - you won't be disappointed! (Oh and if you're a crust lover, they have the best!)

Consistent. Never a bad pie here. Extra sauce is the key. Just had a banana pepper mushroom pie and…read moreit was delish.

Best pizza in town - no frills and limited parking but worth the effort. Their other food offerings…read moreare good as well.

Honestly, not sure how to rate this one. First off, Rodney's is probably 80% bar and 20%…read morerestaurant. If I had to sit inside, I would not come here. The inside is basically a poorly lit bar with a few tables. The outside, however, is a different story. They have a very nice patio area, which is where I chose to sit this evening. I was surprised that the restaurant was mostly empty on a Friday night at 6:00. The waitress informed me that things don't get hopping here until after 9:00, when they have live music or a DJ. Again, this is mostly a bar. Onto the food. I had their messed up taters and their caprese BLT. Let's do the bad first. The BLT was a poor attempt. It was mostly lettuce with some sort of balsamic sauce. I could swear I also tasted mustard for some reason. Very little bacon. I think there was supposed to be mozzarella on the sandwich but I couldn't find any. Two stars. I would stay away from that one. Now for the positive - the loaded taters were absolutely delicious. Lots of cheese, both cheese sauce and shredded. Plus a nice helping of bacon. Can't believe I ate the whole thing myself. Here's why I'm giving this 4 stars - the whole meal cost around $15. You can barely get a fast food meal for $15 and this was way better. My Blue Moon drafts were only $5. I will come here again on a nice summer evening, enjoy their patio, get the taters and try something different for my meal.

Had a dive bar feel when you walk in, but staff is very friendly and food was surprisingly good…read more Patio area looks awesome in the summer.

I had their spaghetti and meatballs,salad and bread and it was good! I would recommend it to anyone!read more

Instead of only carry out pizza, we decided to eat in and check out the menu. We were greeted by…read moreBrooke, our server, quickly after we entered the restaurant. We were seated in the dining room close to the windows looking out to the main street. After perusing the menu a couple minutes, we made our choices. A Philly cheese steak and a hot sausage sandwich plus a 4 cut pizza. Our sandwiches arrived first. The Philly was shaved prime rib beef with sauté onions, peppers and cheese. The hot sausage was loaded with onions, peppers. Both included fries. The 4 cut pizza had pepperoni and green peppers. All items ordered were delicious. We recommend this restaurant

My husband and I had the best experience at Out of the Fire Cafe! I accidentally ordered the wrong…read moredinner and felt terrible about it, but Patricia Rozycki took such wonderful care of me and made the entire experience so enjoyable. She is an exceptional waitress, and the food was absolutely amazing. We will definitely be back!

A Hidden Gem Worth Leaving the Turnpike For! After making…read morethe drive between Northern Virginia and Ohio for more than 20 years, we couldn't believe we had never discovered Out of the Fire Café before. Anyone who regularly travels the Pennsylvania Turnpike knows how hard it is to find a truly memorable place to eat. This one is absolutely worth the short detour. The atmosphere is charming, the view is beautiful, and the food exceeded every expectation. We had to try their famous mushroom soup, and even though I'm not normally a mushroom fan, it was hands-down one of the best cups of soup I've ever had. The smoked salmon salad was fresh, flavorful, and absolutely delicious. My husband ordered the Filet Mignon Sandwich special, and every bite was packed with incredible flavor. Our server was warm, attentive, and genuinely welcoming. She made us feel right at home and added to what was already a wonderful dining experience. We finished with the Bananas Foster. While it wasn't the tableside flaming presentation you'd find at a fine-dining restaurant, the flavor was outstanding and the perfect ending to a fantastic meal. We'll definitely be making Out of the Fire Café a tradition on our future trips. If you're traveling the Pennsylvania Turnpike, do yourself a favor and make the stop--you won't regret it!

Just had their lunch special today....pepperoni pizza. Excellent! It's one of my favorite…read morerestaurants in the local area

Ordered thier 18 cut combination pizza with extra sauce and anchovies. Sauce and anchovies barely…read morevisible on pizza. Flavorless sauce and cuts are 2 finger width. Crust was bland as was overall pizza flavor.

Absolutely no way they have 4 stars! I have tried multiple…read moretimes to give this place a chance. Every time is a complete disaster. Burnt food, missing items and below average food. Do yourself a favor...go ELSEWHERE!

Good quality. Fresh foods. The people are always very polite. Their menu has a nice selection.read more

My wife and I just had dinner here with a Road Scholar group. Service was friendly and attentive…read more The food was served buffet style, and we enjoyed the chicken parmigiana, eggplant parmigiana, and the dessert (a selection of tasty berry pies). The other dishes we tried, including a salad, and a pasta dish with vegetables, were OK.

Great food and even better atmosphere. The outside patio is beautiful. Especially when music is…read moreplaying or if they have a band. I had my sons baptism here in the upstairs room overlooking the entrance way and it was beautiful.. great food / & the service was excellent.

One of the worst pizzas I've had. The white sauce was just a salty greasy mess. The dough was…read moreflavorless and had texture like a frozen pizza.

I've tried a lot of pizza in the Mount Pleasant area and Doughboy's has become my favorite. The…read morepizza crust is chewy and flavorful and the sauce has a sweet flavor to it. Just the way I like it. They're prompt and friendly with their delivery and reasonably priced. Other than the pizza, their wings are delicious and I'm partial to the boneless wings they offer- wonderful!

10/10!!! Everything was amazing! The Brussels sprouts are so good- warm chocolate cake was amazing…read more Service was awesome.

A pleasant surprise Passing through on business trip…read moreSalad was great Gnocchi very good Good wine/ beer selection Would come back if I ever find myself in this desolate area again