Consistent. Never a bad pie here. Extra sauce is the key. Just had a banana pepper mushroom pie and it was delish.

Best pizza in town - no frills and limited parking but worth the effort. Their other food offerings are good as well.

The pizzas are excellent.. The atmosphere is great.. Hometown restaurant and pub... Great sandwiches also.. the owner,Johnny, makes you feel very welcome.. read more

3.5ish to be honest simply based off of my initial visit. I grew up not far from this place and early on worked in the town where this is located but never visited here. For years I would hear people rave about their pizza and many people I know would not go anywhere else for pizza. So on a solo nights in the mountains I decided to head down and order a pizza to go. The outside is somewhat nondescript and made me wonder what the inside was going to be like. Was it a dingy bar, what am I in for when I open the door? Well when I opened the door I was pleasantly surprised to see a very well lit bar and restaurant. The place is a little dated inside but was spotless. I saddled up to the bar to order a pizza to go and a beer. I was quickly and pleasantly greeted by a gentleman that talked to me like I was a regular. I ordered the pie and looked around to try and see what to drink. I saw tap systems but no handles so I guess no draft beer. I'm guessing no craft beer here either and I don't think a beer list even. So I look around and order what the guy beside me is having. As I sat and waited people came and went, lots more people eating at tables than sitting at the bar. Lots of people came for takeout as well. Very much a locals place, everyone seems to know everyone. The couple beside me chatted me up which was nice. They made suggestions for me if I come back and talked to me like I was a long lost friend. When my pizza came out I left and wished the folks well. I headed back to the mountains. Now the pizza was a bit cool when I finally arrived back and started to eat. I liked the sauce and cheese ratio. I know pizza is a hard rating because everyone is particular and has different tastes with pizza it seems more than any other food. I will say I enjoyed it, but I was a fan of the dough. It was too dense for my taste. Almost reminds me off a bagged dry dough mix you make at home. Again my opinion. The pepperoni and cheese and sauce were good. I'll go back now knowing what to expect, I'll just try something else. Oh and I didn't mention that the huge beer and pizza where cheaper than what I would pay for just a large plain pizza at home! I think my bill was $16.50, it was sixteen something, bargain. read more

See all

Pizza pizza pizza. Very good and price is very good. Very simple place with good food and drinks.

Pizza is exceptional! Couldn't tell you anything else they have. In 45 years, I've never made it past the pizza. Friendly staff who work their butts off most nights. It's usually always busy. Inside is dated but clean. Just a quaint little hometown place with outstanding pizza. read more

This place is nothing fancy, and the atmosphere is more like a social club, but the pizza is great, and I wouldn't change a thing.

The pizza is consistently great. Service is great. Families are welcome. Larger room in the back for bigger groups.

You're one of the few places that have been around since my dad was running around the town and he is in his 70's. Wings, pizza, staff are excellent! read more

Best pizza in PA. not just Mt Pleasant. It has a very authentic taste, unlike other pizza, you will find no matter where you travel.

I have been going here forever. This place is like family to me. Great pizza and friendly atmosphere.

Definitely the place to get a good bar pizza, plain and simple. It's a rough, hole-in-the wall type place, but is clean. One of the best pizza places in town for sure. The pepperoni and supreme pizza is always a good choice. I usually get a salad and cheese balls to go with it as well. The service is always pretty good and the staff is talkative and friendly. If you're looking for a place to grab a beer and have a pizza this is one of the best places around to do it! read more

See all

This might be my favorite pizza. It's definitely my favorite pizza in western PA. I recommend the deluxe, with a side of hot cheese balls. Eat in is much much better than carry out, but I'd be lying if I said that I didn't get carry out fairly regularly. The cheese is better when it's fresh out of the oven, so maybe if you have a short drive home it doesn't matter..... read more

Great place for pizza and a beer. You get a large pizza with two toppings and a large picture here for about $20. They have some other sandwiche, fried food. The pizza is pretty awesome. I like that whatever is left over they individually wrapped each piece in foil for you to take home. It's a nice touch. Friendly place read more

Love this place. Have been going here since a kid and its awesome. The service is great and the owners are very friendly. Highly recommend

After a coworker told me about Lobingier's pizza shortly after I moved to Mount Pleasant, I wanted to stop by. After about six months, I finally ordered to go and boy was it good. I've tried a lot of the pizza offerings in town and Lobingier's jumped right to the top of the list. Don't be put off by the unassuming entrance. After entering the door there is a long bar and tables. In the back you'll find a dining room. The staff and ownership is incredibly friendly and the atmosphere is comfortable. Will definitely be back! read more

Pizza is always great! Always a nice time at this long time neighborhood bar restaurant.

Love their pizza with pepperoni, sausage and green peppers. Chicken tenders are real chicken and really good. Service sucks almost always if Ronnie isn't waiting on us. She is great. The bar tender always asks if all is ok and refills our drinks. We usually never see our server once the food is delivered or to give us the check. read more

This was a nice surprise--the decor is anything but fancy, but this local hangout had fast, friendly service, and delicious pizza. Our server was a little slow, and the restroom wasn't very clean, but we still had a really nice experience. read more

Tried Pizza for fist time this year. I know pizza is a personal choice but I like their's. Very friendly owner - try this place

Without question the best pizza in the county! The house salad dressing is very good. They have very good burgers (lean meat) that don't taste like a load of grease like some other places in town. The menu isn't fancy, but all of it is very good. Generous drink servings. :) read more