The best pizza in the area. Spendy but was so worth it. I always get the Greek pizza with extra…read moreolives. The owner is pretty nice and his baklava is amazing. Sad I moved back into the cities but will maybe have it again one day

Best Pizza in town! Had Margarita Pizza, with large slices of roasted tomatoes and basil. Excellent…read morecrust from fired oven. pick up at bar in restaurant was easy. Will be back...

The food was awesome as always, done in 20 min, prices are low and there was plenty of seating.. I…read morewill be back!! Good vibes!

Delicious! I'm a pizza girl and I wanted to see what they had to offer. The pizza reminded of thin…read moreNew York style pizza. The wings were so good too, but small; thankfully the flavor made up for their size. I ordered online without any issues and my food was ready when I arrived. If I'm in town again I'll definitely swing by.

Amazing food. Good service and great vegan and vegetarian options. What a gem in this town.read more

What a great find! We stopped by for breakfast with a large group. We got lucky it was early and…read moredaylight savings and we got a table right away! All 8 of us ordered different items, and every bite was incredible. Every dish was full of flavor and so fresh. The service was quick and friendly. I would love to come back for lunch!

I gave Polito's a second chance. I'm sorry to have to say it, but it's the worst pizza in St…read more Cloud. They make the pizzas early in the day. Then the already-cooked pizza sits there, drying out and cooling off. So, when you walk in, there are several pizzas that look interesting and like they might be worth trying. You choose which pizza slices you want. They then toss them into the oven to heat them up. On my second attempt, the server didn't heat it up long enough, so when I received my slice, the toppings on the supreme weren't heated through. I was eating a slice that was still cool. How is this okay? Maybe if you ordered a fresh, whole pizza, you might enjoy it. I, however, haven't had a good experience either time I've been here, and so I won't be back.

I was shopping downtown on Small Business Saturday and saw that they had a deal for the day. My…read moreother half and I tried it out. It was a bit confusing how the pizza seemed to be displayed out in the open with no heat or cold on it. I was glad to see that the pizza was warmed up in the oven before served. They could have used some signs with the pizza name. I had to guess at what the different kinds were. I liked that the crust was crispy on the bottom. Large slices, one would be enough for anyone. The deal was 2 slices and a drink for $6. That seemed about right for what was offered. I may try again and call in an order to compare.

Back in town for a visit and the pizza never disappoints! We had the meat lovers and a few drinks…read more The service was prompt, the server was attentive but not pushy. I was catching up with an old friend. We sat in the bar and had fun catching up.

Staying at the hotel here. Probably one of the top 3 pizzas that I have ever eaten - and I've had a…read morelot in my 59 years. It took a little longer to get it but it was worth the wait. Tons of cheese and quality toppings.

Hello my name is Eric and I wanted to leave a review of my experience at this fine establishment…read morethe service here was very good me and the fam really liked eating here I've recommended it to a few of my friends at work and they all thought it was very good I will be coming back to this pizzeria soon this place deserves a 5 star

Best pizza in Minnesota baby plz come check them out .............,,.mmmmmmm..............m.....read more

Ordered Delivery and it arrived in 35 mins! So Fast! Besides the delivery they took my order with…read moreease and confidence! I ordered an XL Cheese, XL Bacon Cheeseburger, and a cheese bread. Everything was awesome! Have you had Papa John's Cheeseburger pizza?? That one's aight, but Dimaggio's Bacon Cheeseburger Pie is AWESOME! I've heard great things about cream cheese and pep, and also the spaghetti pie, can't wait for next time!

So first things first, I travel a lot. I mean the kind of travel where I am in a different hotel…read moreevery night. Most days I forget what room number I am in. For this reason, even though DiMaggio's was about a half mile from my hotel I decided to get it delivered. Usually when I order pizza delivered I expect it to be lukewarm or even somewhat cold, but that was not the case. My pie was piping hot. So hot it scorched the roof of my mouth (my fault). But I do fault DiMaggio's for having such delicious pizza that I couldn't stop eating or even slow down. The toppings were all fresh and bountiful. Not just a sprinkle here and there, the toppings were enough to give you a taste of everything in every bite. And I'm not a single, two or three topping kind of guy. I had Italian sausage, green peppers, mushrooms, onions and black olives. I cannot remember when I had a better pizza as of late and I had pizza in New York three weeks ago. The pic I posted only shows what is left after I inhaled the rest. I believe this will be a delicious cold pizza breakfast in the morning. I don't know if you guys are related, but DiMaggio's sure hit a home run with my order!!

We went here for my daughters birthday recently and it was a hit! The pizza was great! The whole…read morefamily enjoyed our selections. Highly recommend the Buffalo chicken ranch pizza - it was awesome! Also would like to add that the staff was phenomenal. We will definitely be back.

Service was great. Pizza was good, but not great. Still searching for a great pizza in town.read more

I'm from NY and am very curious to see what the rest of the world tries to pass as pizza…read more I was in town for work and ordered some dinner from here. I planned on getting the most standard, basic shit in a cheese pizza, to really be able to make a comparison. That completely went out the window when I saw some of the topping options, which, in retrospect, doesn't come as a surprise given the name of the place. I couldn't resist the wisconsin cheese curds and noodle options. For some reason I was expecting spaghetti which makes zero sense but I was very curious to see how they would pull that off. Much more practically, the noodles are macaroni and they are a wonderful addition to pizza. The cheese curds were, as expected, fantastic on the pizza. There was nothing special about the crust, it was your typical pizza chain deal. Nothing else blew me away but it was probably superior to what you would receive from a domino's. I wouldn't pass up the pizza in naples for this shit but it's not bad and I love their shtick with the toppings.

Pizza maker had an open cut with bandade making pizzas bare hand. Using no utensils to grab…read moretoppings also. Then got mad and caught an attitude with me when I asked for him to put on gloves. "Told me you're not supposed to use gloves" GROSS!

Below average. It doesn't seem that anything was made…read morein-house. They might have chopped or cut some stuff up but that's all. Pizzas cut in squares are just weird to me. The crusts are cardboard'ish and covered in cheap cheese. The wings seemed nuked and then loaded up with canned sauce. The lady that brought us are pizzas was courteous and pleasant so two stars for the service. Last words... no thanks.

This was our second time ordering from Gary's in 3 years. The first time, in 2017, the pizza was…read moretoo salty and greasy, and toppings were sparse. We ended up throwing most of it away. We wanted to give them another try since there are limited good takeout options during the pandemic. This time (July 2020) we were pleasantly surprised. We got the large "meats" pizza special with cheese bread, using the online coupon from their website. The pizza was *loaded* with toppings. It had some serious heft to it when I picked up the box. The pizza and bread tasted great when we got home. My kids scarfed it down, and the adults enjoyed it too. Maybe the first time was a fluke, or they changed their cheese supplier, sauce spices, or pizza recipes in the past few years. But right now, this is the best pizza in the St. Cloud area, in my humble pizza-loving opinion (and having lived in Chicago for 2 decades, I know pizza!) We will definitely order again! I removed one star from the score for the fact that when I arrived to pick up the pizza, several staff, including the cashier, were not wearing face masks as recommended for all food service personnel by the Minnesota Department of Health during the COVID pandemic.