Great food and prices. The buffet is good but can run out quick if a crowd is there. Clean restrooms and good atmosphere. The Oreo dessert pizza is a must have! read more

I love their thin crust pizza! It is the best tasting pizza in Peoria in my opinion! Their service is fast and and the taste is high quality! I highly recommend them! Try it today read more

460° Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Illinois

See all

Hot food, even hotter prices. Admittedly, I have had 460 quite a few times before this visit but that was always a former workplace ordering lunch for us or I would pop over to grab a sandwich to-go. I wanted to actually sit down and enjoy a meal instead of eating it in a work break room. So, I barely twisted my dad's arm to go with me on a lunch outing. 460 Pizza is almost a fast casual style restaurant. The inside is small-ish and there is no wait staff so you have to grab everything yourself. While a bit confusing because it seems like its set up like a restaurant, its not all that weird. There is a sign near the counter telling you how to order and all that. You place your order and the owner/chef will bring it out. Based on prior experience, I knew what I wanted and that was a Spicy Buffalo Chicken sandwich. The Chicken Bacon Ranch is my second pick for this place. My dad got the Philly Cheesesteak sandwich. Why get a sub sandwich at a pizza place? Because the bread. I have no idea what they put in the bread but its the best bread ever. If I even think about it, my mouth will water and I will have to fight myself to not make the 20 minute drive to grab a sandwich to go. The food took about 15 minutes to come out as the owner was also cooking pizzas for the buffet. Speaking of the buffet, it's only $10 for the whole thing, drink and salad bar included. I've not had the pizza myself but may try to convince some other friends to come here and try it sometime. For the price, how could you not? The interior of the pizza parlor is a bit lacking, though. If you are expecting something upscale, look elsewhere. But who cares whats on the walls when the food is so, so, oh so, very delicious. In this age of high prices at restaurants, 460 Pizza feels like a relic from the past when you look at the prices on their menu. A sub sandwich that nearly makes two meals and a $10 all-you-can-eat buffet is just not something you see anymore. As always, support local so we continue to have bombtastic places to visit like 460 Pizza. The world is a more delicious place with these kinds of restaurants around. read more

See all

Absolutely terrible service and water was dripping down from the air conditioning right beside the salad bar And the way waitress delivered our food was despicable which and suinued argument between us this place has problems read more

So this was our second time eating at this restaurant My wife, kids and I. We absolutely love the food here. We drove the 45 minute drive just to eat here and the food was deliciously amazing and the service was even better. We showed up a half hour before closing and was not expecting to be able to sit and eat but due to the heavy rain storm that came through they allowed us to stay and enjoy our pizza while the storm passed. Most definitely one of the greatest places we've ever been to and we plan to keep going as much as we can. We greatly appreciate you and your business!! read more

460° Pizza - Pizza Box - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Illinois

Ordered Carry Out NY Style Meat Lovers. Really liked the sweet pizza sauce and it had plenty of toppings. We will order from here again soon! read more

Good food if it arrives intact. The picture is of how my food was delivered. When I called to complain they said it was my problem. read more

460° Pizza - This is how my pizza arrived. 460 said it was my problem - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Illinois

Excellent Food! Had the buffet. I like the shredded lettuce in the salad bar. The pizza is wonderful. Different handmade crusts for each. The bread is also hand made from scratch. I also ordered a Philly steak sandwich. Juicy and tender, and baked just right. The buffet is served everyday. Should you try these guys. read more

Lived in Peoria now six years. Was way out North Knoxville on a Sunday midday and went through the Northpoint Shopping Center and this was the only place open in a Sunday. Food was okay - just okay Restroom was F I L T H Y! Sign says dining room is self serve - no wait staff. Bathroom cleaning must be on the same ideology. Grossssssss! They once used napkin holders that look like they came from a defunct 1970's Chinese restaurant. They're piled everywhere around the salad bar and haven't been dusted since the stopped using them in 1996. Speaking of the salad bar, the sneeze guard is so scratched up that one must put their head clear inside the darn thing to even see what one is taking! Another gross factor. Someone dropped a bunch of the plastic plates they use back in the kitchen. After being here I can guess with great certainty that they didn't get rewashed but rather picked up and restacked for use. Another "one and I'm done" restaurant in Peoria for me. This is becoming the norm now around Peoria. So sad. read more

Pizza is good. New York style is awesome here. Service needs improving. They need about 2 more staff people to get this place up and going. All in all I like this place. read more

Food is delicious! Great, local pizza with awesome owners! We got the veggie pizza and cheese bread. Definitely recommend. Love the sweeter pizza sauce recipe and homemade bread! read more

Great tasting pizza! The sauce is amazing. Hand toss and thin crust are both good. Haven't tried the deep dish yet.

Buffet is reasonable price & quality ingredients, we will be back! They asked what toppings liked and they made a pizza for me. read more

460° Pizza - Delicious! Buffet price reasonable & have wifi. They asked what toppings I like. Love the thin crust & the sauce, quality ingredients. - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Illinois

Been here twice, but haven't eaten here. First time they were closed on a Monday, understandably. Gave them a second chance. It's noon and the place is empty. A single employee is in the kitchen. We have to get his attention. Ten minutes later and he still hasn't greeted us, so we walked out. This place will never make and it's not on account of COVID read more

Note: This new 460 Pizza was purchased from the previous Firehouse Pizza owner by the former manager from the East Peoria Firehouse! So if you're looking for Firehouse Pizza, this is it! With a fresh new look! Trey the new owner is off to a amazing start! The pizza is sublime, the ambiance is clean and updated, and all your old favorites are there too. Ok gotta run and get me some Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza.... read more

Staff treats you like garbage when there's an error on their part Incredibly unprofessional read more

There are two 5 star reviews for this joint, both out of state, they are not honest reviewers. I loved fire house but this place is mediocre at its best. I base this on a 14 cheese pizza with house sauce. Bland, bland, bland. It might be better with the sweet but blah blah blah. Time will prove me right when this place folds in the next year, but i wish them the best. Another 5 star review just rolled in, the reviewers first and only review, 5 stars none the less and no mention of the food. The disingenuous are doing your business no good. You cant fake it till u make it in the pizza business. read more

460 Pizza does a great job. You can get pizzas with the original Firehouse Pizza sauce or several others. Specialty pizzas are very good too. Taco pizza is the best in the area. The subs are very good too, and the Thursday special of $6 subs is a great deal. Good wings too. read more

Great pizza and great service. Owner and staff are all awesome! Always have a smile on their faces when I visited with a few co-workers. We got the margarita pizza and it was awesome! Would recommend anyone in the area to try this place out! read more

Truly delicious pizza - love the sauce! We generally get carry out. Order online is easy and you get points toward future food purchases. Great service at every visit. read more

Horrible service! Pizza was horrible. Staff not wearing masks or gloves. Disgusting! Better off getting a frozen pizza from Kroger's a few blocks away ! read more

Ive only ate here twice and while I am not a huge fan of their crust or the traditional sauce, the sweet sauce is pretty damn good. My 5 stars goes for the service. The first time we ate there we ate outside. Every employee working was very kind. We was the only people there and could have been easily forgotten about out there but someone came and checked in several times. The 2nd time we called in a order to pick up. Get there and the wrong toppings are on one of the pizzas. Instead of just remaking the messed up one they remade all our pizza so they all came home fresh and hot. Glad to see they care about their customers. Most places will stick your other pizzas in a warmer while you wait 20mins and it really loses its appeal when that happens. read more

I ordered from 460 pizza prior to doing some shopping at Big Lots on 10/21/20. I had never been here but figured I would give it a go. I was told a large deluxe deep dish would take 50 mins. So I agreed and did my shopping. I picked it up and paid $30. For my order. The box was cool on the bottom but I didnt really think much of it. I immediately drove to my home. I opened the pizza and was appalled. The crust and the top of the pizza was charred black. We picked off the crust and top layer and attempted to give it to our dog who sniffed it and left it. My mate and I each ate 1 piece (rather what was left after the burnt parts were removed). It laid like lead in the belly on night. Horrible stuff. I took a piece to work the next day as I had hoped maybe it would be better cold. My co workers were appalled! I work for the federal government and once I told them where I purchased it and how much it cost. 460 pizza lost a lot of potential customers. It would have been easier to make a new pizza and make me wait a bit longer. I could have forgiven and understood that. Not sending out a charred brick and calling it pizza. GROSS read more