I love Old Fashioned Ice Cream! I'm not a dessert or ice cream person but if I'm in the mood I'll…read morestop in and purchase a quart of Grapenut ice cream because theirs is just that good. Their staff is always helpful, patient, and quick with their service. Considering the fact that it's always customers in there when I visit, I appreciate their consistency. I highly recommend grapenut as well as their rum raisin ice cream.

I was disappointed with the service and icecream. It was my first time here and a friend…read morerecommended. I got the impression that the person helping me was not too thrilled to be there. I asked her if I could have two flavors in a Small. I did not ask if I could have it on a cone. I just asked if I could order a small scoop and have two flavors. She said yes. She did not say it had to be in a cup if I wanted two flavors in a small scoop. When I ordered I told her which two flavors I wanted and then said I wanted a sugar cone. She proceeded to scoop a nice sized scoop onto the cone, then went to put another same sized scoop of the second flavor but that's not what I wanted. And I was charged for two scoops on a cone. The icecream was so soft, I had to put it in a cup after all that. It was disappointing and I would not come back.

Cute little spot to grab ice cream! The kids enjoyed. They also have dairy free options, but not…read moremany. The 1 employee working was helpful. The price was a little high for the quality.

Stopped into Scoop & Cone in Farmingdale NY. Maria made it 5 stars with her complete service. She…read morehelped me pick what I wanted and how I wanted it. Donut alamode. They have been there for a few years. Thing is- they are a bit in the corner so not immediately visible. In an ajacient widow is a sign of info for rent of other available stores. The shopping center sign on the outside caught my eye and I entered to check them out. They have a few machines for toys and candies. (see pix) A cute little place with a variety of ice cream and toppings to stop in if in the area.

We decided to take a quick trip to Coyle's in Lindenhurst because we needed a place with vegan…read moreoptions for my daughter. Thankfully, they had four vegan flavors available! When we arrived with our party of seven, the line was out the door. Since it was a nice summer night, a line was to be expected, but the issue was that there were only two staff members working to serve a huge crowd. It took a very long time to get to the front, and when we were finally served, I asked for caramel on my ice cream. The gentleman barely put any on, so I asked if he could add a bit more. He said yes, but then immediately proceeded to serve the next customer. As I stood there holding my melting ice cream, I had to ask the other server to remind him about the topping. I had to wait until he finished helping the next person before he finally added it--mostly dumping it onto one side so it started dripping over, without offering a napkin or anything to clean it up. The ice cream itself was okay, but the service definitely left a lot to be desired.

Coyle's Homemade ice cream has a wide selection of cold, rich and creamy flavors that you can get…read moreon a cone, cups, cake and sundae style. I have personally tried a few flavors on there own in previous visits which usually hits the spot. This last time I opted to upgrade to one of their suggested menu sundaes: "Salty Munchie Sundae" and oh goodness was it super sweet and very filling. I literally had to pause and freeze half for the next day. Nonetheless, if you have a sweet tooth and a big empty tummy feel free to give it a whirl. My Mr had the brownie sundae and was able to finish with ease. Service is super friendly and pretty quick, so if in the neighborhood looking for a treat outside of a bakery item, pop in here. :)

Amazing place! $5 bubble tea is the right size and worth every penny. Waffles are crunchy and…read moredelicious. This is a great place to have dessert (weather you go healthy or not!) Don't walk run here and enjoy. They are also open late!;

Customer service was so great. Visited on a rainy Saturday. Had quite a few menu items, my favorite…read morewas the waffle, thin, crunchy, hot and cold mix with the ice cream. The tapioca boba was chewy and plentiful in the mango milk tea. The decor could be better - lots of decals and plastic backdrops but it seemed clean and organized.

The best ice cream on Long Island. I especially love the vegan Oreo and strawberry flavors and come…read morehere way too often. The soy-based Oreo flavor is extremely creamy and pairs magically with the peanut butter drizzle (you're welcome). Like a true addict, I shall return for another fix, yet with a confident calmness rather than desperation, for I know that with each bite, I shall experience a high as sweet and strong as the first.

I went in at 9pm and asked for a shake and was told that they couldn't make it because they…read morecleaned the machine. It was an hour before close

I LOVE THIS PLACE SO MUCH!!! The ice cream is amazing and the family running it is so sweet, we've…read moregone twice and we will definitely be going again. As I said the service is amazing and the atmosphere is like a cafe. Will go again, and highly recommend to anyone in the area looking for a sweet treat

[Edit] I have now returned three separate times and will change my review. I honestly love the…read moredecor and the staff is always friendly. I have now had a variety of their items: dirty sodas, ice cream sodas, shakes & ice cream sundaes. On my second to last trip the owner was back in Shoppe, made my ice cream soda perfectly as she did the first time; however, I'm still nervous to order it if she's not there to make it. This is the reason I have to dock the star. I waited a very long time for this Shoppe to open and I'm happy to have this neighborhood spot around.

This location seems to be a little older than the one on Main Street in Bay Shore, but one thing it…read moredefinitely has going for it is the variety of flavors. There is also a convenient parking lot, which makes stopping by much easier. The pricing seems to be about the same and is a little high in my opinion, but since the ice cream is homemade, you can truly taste the quality. Another thing I enjoyed about this location is that they have seating inside, so you can relax and enjoy your treats. There was a long line when I arrived, but it moved smoothly. The worker was friendly and patient, allowing me to sample a few flavors before making my selection. I ended up sticking with our favorites, Brownie Nut Fudge and Banana Oreo, but next time I'll definitely have to try one of the new flavors I sampled. Definitely recommend! If you're going to treat yourself to ice cream, it might as well be creamy, delicious and made with care.

Yum!! This homemade ice cream was awesome. Their specialty sundaes really hit the spot. The fudge…read moreand peanut butter sauce are amazing, and I loved the Mississippi mud flavor ice cream!

Came here on a whim, was in the mood for some sweets, and let me tell you, this did not disappoint!…read more I was a little shocked at the sticker prices, but after enjoying my chocolate and caramel covered apple, I will certainly be back. This is good quality chocolate. The ice cream was good, was it the best I've had, No but it was good. The star is the chocolate! Staff is friendly, and efficient. Location is clean.

New owners recently re-opened this location after it had been closed for awhile…read more Chocolate is hand made, delicious and Expensive. I wanted to get the Dubai truffle but one domed truffle piece before tax was $5.99. This is not a typo. Staff was friendly and made some suggestions when we couldn't make up our minds. They also have ice cream which is very popular. Great place for an occasional treat.

Has to be my favorite dessert place. Service is always super quick, there is no place to sit inside…read morebut that's fine because I imagine it'd be awkward. The ice cream always slaps though, especially because of their mix-ins, they got so many mix-ins, it baffles me. Goated spot for dessert.

I usually love Cold Stone, but my visit to the Babylon location today was incredibly disappointing…read more First of all, the prices here have gotten completely out of hand. I ended up paying $20 for literally just a kiddie-sized Birthday Cake Remix cup and one of their new ice cream tacos. $20!! I know inflation is a thing, but charging that much for a tiny kid's cup and a taco is just straight-up highway robbery. But honestly, the price wasn't even the worst part. What really grossed me out was watching the employee scoop and mix the ice cream without wearing any gloves. Especially at a place where they are constantly handling food, mixing things on the stone, and touching different utensils, not wearing gloves is absolutely disgusting and a massive hygiene issue. Between getting ripped off and watching basic food safety get ignored, I won't be coming back to this location. Save your money and go somewhere that actually cares about cleanliness.

This stuff is what summer is made for! Tons of yummy flavors. Choose from water (mostly fruit…read moreflavors) or cream (like ice cream but not as filling) flavors. Some of my favs are Java Chip & Vanilla Resses. Vanilla & Chocolate Malt flavors are awesome, but not always available. The fact that it's cheap and all over LI are bonuses! I used to have family bring this to me when I lived in Westchester in a cooler because it's so good!

Went in tonight and wasn't greeted . People came in after me and my kids and were greeted and…read morehelped. Wasn't helped until i said something and then was told by an employee "i didn't say anything to be helped". Very rude and unprofessional.