I have no been to the actual location to back up what some of these reviews are saying... But I can…read moretell you this: My girlfriend and I decided to try a new place near us via DoorDash. We both ordered the Penne Portobello and for an appetizer, the House Special Garlic Bread. First off, the salad that came with the dinner was delicious. It was my first time ever getting a salad that had pickled onions in it, which were extremely tasty. The salad also included fresh cherry tomatoes and kalamata olives. Very yummy! Now the main dish.. amazing. Sooo many huge slices of portobello mushrooms and the penne was cooked perfectly. And the sauce? Creamy and yummy. The size was portioned enough to have leftovers for the next day. You know when you get a Alfredo sauce and after you microwave it, the sauce turns into straight oil. Nope, not here. The sauce was still creamy and as good as the day prior when we ordered it. Exquisite. The appetizer... Homemade garlic bread with cheese, pepperoni and what I believe is parsley. So crunchy and tasty. Not too greasy at all. Definitely would recommend it! Pricing isn't bad either. Two dishes (with leftovers), two salads, appetizer, delivery fees, tax and driver tip... Only $45. Crazy. People of Middletown: this is a must try! Next time you're ordering on DoorDash; try out John's of Arthur Avenue. YOU WILL NOT BE DISAPPOINTED! 5/5!

Heard many praises about this place through FB. Just ordered large pepperoni pie from this place…read moreusing the Slice app. Actually wanted to try this pizza place for first time. This town has so many food places anyway. It was very good pizza; not so saucy, thin crusted, plenty toppings and cheese. Maybe only minus is price is little high but hey; you pay more to have great food! Typical symbolic textbook NY style pizza! The way should be. Would defintely order here again.

excellent pizza and a friendly owner who supports the Orange county fair grounds…read more I was very pleased with my experience there

I ordered through a delivery app and everything went very smooth. The time of delivery was quick!…read moreThe food is hot ! I ordered sausage with onions and peppers sandwich . The taste of the sauce is very nice! The sausage is delicious and the peppers and onions were cooked perfectly. Definitely will be ordering again!

The greatest deal in Middletown, the pizza is always delicious and I love talking with the owners…read morebecause they are so friendly and welcoming.

Love this place - husband and wife team work hard and produce such good food. Their entrees taste…read moresooo good.

Was in the area doing some shopping & wanted a quick bite to eat. First time at this pizza shop,…read more which serves more than just pizza. Greeted at the counter. There is plenty of seating inside. I ordered 2 slices of pepperoni pizza & a drink. I also was given an extra slice of what I believed to be a chicken cutlet slice to try out. It was pretty tasty. Now I know of a great pizza shop when I'm back in the area

Breaking up a long trip in Middletown and Joeys was near the hotel. Best pizza we've had in quite a…read morewhile. Excellent sauce and plenty of pepperoni. Wish we had a place this good back home.

Food was excellent but the service received from our server, Maddy really made the night! Have…read moreeaten there many times and will definitely be back.

Food was delicious. Filet mignon egg rolls were a great appetizer. Thoroughly enjoyed my vodka…read moreparmesan foccacina and my husband's prosciutto pizza was very good too. Service was great as well.

I love their tacos. It's been awhile since I've been here and I wasn't disappointed. They moved…read morefrom the corner to right next door so I walked into their old spot when I first arrived and was told to go next door. The cashier was friendly and I ordered 3 steak tacos. They were fresh and delicious. It was my first time trying the hibiscus drink and it was lightly sweetened and refreshing. They also have horchata, watermelon, and pineapple flavored drinks as well. I will definitely be back to try more. Can't ask for anything better than pizza and tacos in one place.

Absolute GARBAGE service…read more I ordered two simple sandwiches for myself and my girlfriend. They decided to NOT send me those two sandwiches, but send me some garbage, thrown together wrap. They called us and when we answered, it was too loud and unintelligible to understand. We tried to call back and nothing. When our food was delivered. It looked horrible, unappetizing and wasn't hot, just lukewarm. I'm extremely disappointed in the food, but more so, I'm disappointed in the customer service because when I called after and complained, they said "go ahead and ask for a refund." As a Hispanic man, I always try to support local Spanish business, but this is ridiculous. I do not recommend this restaurant at all.

Hands down the best pizzeria I have ever gone to. Amazing services, food is beyond amazing and at a…read moregreat price as well.

THIS PLACE SUCKS!!! IF I COULD GIVE ZERO STARS I WOULD…read more Served bruschetta hot with melted mozzarella and told me that's how it's done, NOT!!! Bruschetta is tomatoes, onions, roasted peppers and cheese. NONE OF IT SHOULD BE HOT, then , they drown it in balsamic vinegar so deep it's soggy and gross, if you complain, he says that's how it is and walks away. I have been ordering this from this place since they had a hole in the wall on 17m and the owner was the only employee other than the delivery driver. Now, they are too good for complaints!!!!! Left the food on the counter cause it wasn't edible, so many other pizza places that are sooooo much better!!!! WILL NEVER EAT HERE AGAIN!!! ITS GROSS

We stopped here as a halfway point between NYC and Cooperstown…read more We ordered both pizzas and sandwiches. The pizzas are about 25 centimeters in size and can easily be shared, or enjoyed individually if you're hungry. The sandwiches are also generous enough to share. The pizza here is incredible, with a perfectly executed crust. The house salad is made with fresh lettuce, tomatoes, and onions, served with a balsamic dressing. Everything tasted very fresh and crisp. Cosimo's does not disappoint.

Love this place! Haven't been here in a long time so it was way over due! Stopped in for date night…read morewith girlfriend and I had my absolute favorite "pasta del la Nona". Location is perfect because then after dinner you can hit the brewery just around the corner to continue a date. Perfect date night scenario. Service is awesome, ambience is perfect and I love this place. Give me pasta or give me death!