I came here on a Saturday afternoon with my husband and absolutely loved the setting - the rolling hills with the trees changing color was just magical! We purchased food from the local food truck in the parking lot. Nothing special but a nice option when you're hungry. I was happy to see they had lots of fruit-based wines. Unfortunately I wasn't a fan of the ones I chose except for one. The others were too sweet and syrupy for my taste. The live music was really good and we enjoyed sitting out on the patio watching the alpacas. I'd come back to give this one another shot if just for the scenery alone. read more

See all

Be sure to add Yellow Butterfly to your list of wineries to visit! My friend from out of state visited a month ago, so we dedicated a Saturday to visiting some wineries in the valley. If you can't tell from all of the photos in the reviews, the landscape is absolutely stunning. They also have alpacas on the property which are fun to watch. The main portion of the winery is in a renovated barn. The inside is just as stunning as the outside. I may be partial since yellow is my favorite color, but the outside of the bar is gorgeous as well! Our service was wonderful. The two women working the bar were friendly, very helpful, and quick. The wine is also delicious. I always recommend getting a wine flight so you can taste a variety. Yellow Butterfly does a great job with their fruit wines! Their only downfall is their food menu. They often have a food truck, but it's not always what you are typically looking to eat with wine (there was a bbq truck when we were there.) Aside from this, they have bags of pretzels and other small snack to purchase. We wished we could have had a charcuterie board or at least some cheese and crackers with our wine. All in all, the Yellow Butterfly is a must! read more

See all

I really enjoyed our visit here. It has such a beautiful view of the hillside to enjoy while you sip wine on the deck. My mom and I did a tasting first at the bar to decide what to go with. While we are typically fans of dryer wines, we know that Ohio grapes are often much sweeter and it's usually just best to embrace the sweeter wine options! We quite liked several of the ones we tried and ended up getting a bottle of the Country Rose. There was live music outside and it was a beautiful fall afternoon/evening to sit outside, listen to the music, enjoy the views and each other's company. I would definitely come back if in the area again! read more

See all

Amazing property/working Alpaca farm with a huge outdoor seating area. Staff is really friendly and enjoyed our bottle of wine! read more

See all

This is a great place to just relax and enjoy the wine and the beautiful view. They even had a guy playing music and singing . He was really good . They have a large outdoor deck and the rolling hills and fall leaves made a beautiful setting . This is the second time we been here as we don't live in the area otherwise I would be there al the time read more

See all

My wife and I agree that this is the prettiest setting of all the wineries we've been to in southern Ohio. It was so peaceful and idyllic. We enjoyed a grilled cheese from the food truck in the parking lot. We unfortunately did not enjoy the wines we chose - they were too sweet and syrupy for our taste. So 5 stars for the location and 2 stars for the wine. We enjoyed watching the alpacas as we drank our wine and ate our sandwich. The staff were friendly and helpful. We enjoyed the live music too. read more

Delicious They have tastings 5 w a glass you keep for $8.50 or 6 without a glass for $7.50 The pink Catawba was a stand out for us!! read more

A great and picturesque winery in the country. Wine is good atmosphere is fabulous and they usually have music on Saturdays !!!

I visited one of my besties in Coshocton and she took me here to sample a wine slushy. The views were beautiful and loved watching the lamas. The peach margarita slushy was pretty good, but the view topped it off. I thought the inside was beautiful and they have a lower level you can rent out. I would love to go back and do a wine tasting. read more

See all

They were very nice. I enjoyed the very dry red. They made a good selection for my husband who is not necessarily a wine drinker. He enjoyed the wine they suggested. Scenery was beautiful. read more

Had a great time. The staff was super friendly. Very helpful. Atmosphere was cozy and clean. It was a 50 degree day (end of October) and not cold inside. Wine tasting with a take home glass (extra). Great wine variety! A lot of them have an apple flavor. A few in our group purchased Pink Lady. Oh. They have a field of Alpacas. read more

Yellow Butterfly Winery - Alpaca Farm - Wineries Near Me - Newcomerstown, Ohio

I was most excited about this winery. Mainly because of the bright yellow everything. The lady said they have an upstairs but no heat in the winter. The wines were good from what I tried. They had 3 dry reds, 1 dry whites and the rest were sweet. I got a red dry that was good. Overall the staff was friendly and it was a nice experience and location read more

See all

We almost skipped this winery while doing the wine trail due to timing/distance but I am so glad we didn't! Tastings were affordably priced and within a group of 4 (who have widely varying wine preferences) we found a wine we all loved! White Lily. The alpaca farm and rolling hills were icing on the cake. read more

Yellow Butterfly Winery - Wineries Near Me - Newcomerstown, Ohio

See all

Just what my wife and I needed. Great atmosphere, good music and great wine! Staff including the owner were very friendly. This place is in the country and scenery is beautiful! We ended up ordering dinner which was delicious as well. Kudos's to the chef on the beans! read more

Yellow Butterfly Winery - Wineries Near Me - Newcomerstown, Ohio

Beautiful area! The winery is housed in a large barn which I believe is 92 years old. The wines were absolutely wonderful. We tend to go for the sweeter wines, particularly fruit wines. We found several that we loved - the blackberry and the apricot were amongst our favorties. Our hostess was lovely and made recommendations. She chatted about the area and made us feel very welcome. Although we liked several of the wines, we only purchased one bottle. We were going to visit 10 to 12 wineries over the weekend and we didn't want to take home 50 bottles so we were limiting our purchases. Yellow Butterfly was one of our favs. We will definitely be back and we will make more purchases. read more

Venue nice, way up in the hills. Wine decent, enjoyed Vidal Blanc. Proprietor rude to employee in front of us (customers) made us feel uncomfortable. Should have walked out. read more

Yellow Butterfly Winery - Entertainment - Wineries Near Me - Newcomerstown, Ohio

Visited five wineries in one day. Not bad for a light drinker and an easy drunk! I had to stop driving after the third one, remember, they give you just sips but I'm not a drinker! Anyway, I am not a wine expert so bare (or is it bear?) that in mind. I find it difficult to find wines I like. I like sweet, not dry. I found a few here. The host of the tasting is the wine maker himself. Very knowledgeable and friendly. He helped us understand the blends and his methods. Out back you can see alpacas too! Stop in for a tasting, I doubt you'll be disappointed. read more

This winery sits in the middle of Amish country and is in a beautiful setting. Their wines, the one's we tried were excellent. read more

Yellow Butterfly Winery - Wineries Near Me - Newcomerstown, Ohio

Excellent place. Luved the atmosphere and the ambience. Great selections of wines. The bar and the patio were my favourite enjoyed every minute we were there. The weather was great and the live music added more to the experience. We danced and had a great time. A special thanks to Wendy who was very nice (and funny too) and we laughed a lot and she made sure everyone was having a great time. Would most definitely come back. Highly recommend this place. Thx DR MD read more

Dear Michael, The Yellow Butterfly is a beautiful place. Your Vidal Blanc was very nice, I am not a wine snob so I can't critique all of your wines. I do know people and my opinion is for your continued success you should polish up your people skills or hire a person with a personality to serve your tastings and talk up your wine. Perhaps we caught you on an off day, but we ran into a group of ladies at another vineyard who shared the same feelings about their experience at your beautiful facility. I'm hoping that my critique will help improve the experience for other guests at The Yellow Butterfly. read more

We came to this lovely winery because of the musician. We had heard him before and liked his style, so we came to hear Jake "Barefoot" McCoy. This place has the most beautiful setting! Even though it was raining I stood out on the back deck to take pictures of the rolling hillsides, one with horses. There are alpacas at the bottom of the hill but I didn't go down because of the weather. The winery is an old barn fixed up. It was chllly and damp (we have had unusually cold weather here lately and the rain was caused by the recent hurricane in Texas.) They have a limited food menu, but everything that we saw being served looked good. We didn't order any food because we had dinner plans for later. Wine samples are 3 for $1, which is reasonable compared to some wineries we have visited. I wasn't crazy about any of the 3 I tried (the only dry wines, which are normally my favorites) and we selected one of the ones my husband selected which was a semisweet, but not so sweet that I couldn't drink it. Most of the wines are very sweet. Two tastings and one bottle of wine was $17.58. I don't know that we will go back as the drive was a little over an hour, but if it were closer, I think we would go for the music. We like wineries with food and live music! read more

Location is beautiful and very scenic. The food is very over priced for what is offered. The owner is not easy to work with and very quick to temper. I was part of a larger group ( of over 30 people) and the group was not treated very well. People trying to buy wine were ignored, they made the group organizers jump through hoops for no reason and were very unaccommodating. Sure the wine is good, but it's hard to enjoy after being treated poorly. read more

I was just there as part of a bus group 16 people. The same group was there last year I was once again disappointed. I believe they are not prepared for doing large groups. The wait staff was rude and disinterested the same as last year. The owners seemed to take issue with those of use who do not drink and did not participate in the wine tasting. The food was so so the same as last year. Once again people eating steak were subjected to not getting there food with everyone else. The told one lady that someone else in our group got her food, when the event coordinator double checked our meals with our orders they were exact. Then the poor lady was told her steak was set off to the side and did not make it out with the rest of the meals. My mom who was part of the group was asked if she wanted her dessert because they had run out of desserts. That was the tipping point. They knew who many people are coming this trip had been booked for months, and they ran out of food. W.T.F. Never again, I believe in second chances but not 3rd. This will keep me from doing this annual trip again if they are the restaurant/ winery we go to. read more

Excellent wines, food and service. Very friendly. Very relaxing with great view. Enjoyed it a lot.

Recently I had the task of helping to organize a low key bachelorette party for a friend. The bridal party eventually decided on this winery. You need to make reservations by Thursday if you're going on Saturday and be prepared to let the staff know whether everyone wants the steak (how they want it done) or chicken and ribs when you make your reservation. This place is a little out of the way, but so worth the drive. The staff was very friendly and accommodating even offering to take pictures for us. The wines were delicious (and I am very picky about wine) and food was AMAZING! This place was quiet and we felt like we pretty much had the place to ourselves. Views are breath taking and all for a very fair price =) . Whether your going out for a night with the girls or on a romantic dinner date with the hubby I would highly recommend the Yellow Butterfly. read more

Yellow Butterfly Winery - BBQ chicken and ribs - Wineries Near Me - Newcomerstown, Ohio

See all

Amazing service and wine!! Definitely my favorite and I never leave without purchasing quite a few bottles!! Mayor Mike White is super friendly!! #cleveland #theland read more

Applied to be a wine steward on indeed. The next day I got a call from a unfamiliar number and asked who he was calling. His response was " clearly not you"! I could not believe it! Wtf! When I researched where the call came from, I decide to drive up there to see what this prick looked like. Clearly, I was no longer interested in the job or being a customer, but I had to see this. I arrived at about noon on a Saturday, about 20 minutes after he called me,but he wasn't there. The staff was also rude, even though they had no customers. Two hours later I returned and staff told me that he was here somewhere and I could wait if I wanted. I walked all over the place for about 20 minutes. It was beautiful and country quaint. They now have 3 customers sitting at a table. It was Saturday and they would only be open two more hours so I was wondering when they would get busy. Shouldn't a wine\restaurant be open on Saturday night? Michael finally came out. I introduced myself and he said , "yeah, I know who you are" and had me write my number down again and said he would call me later that night. He never called. Guy is a flaming ass hole! read more