Okay, so this place is amazing. So much cheese of all flavors... and you can try a lot of them…read more Samples everywhere. This was my favorite part (as with many people who visit). By trying some of them, we found a couple of cheeses that we took home. So delicious... you really can't go wrong with many, even with the weird flavors. They even had cream cheeses that you can try with preztels. Lastly, you can watch them make the cheese. Such a great experience and definitely worth the stop.

Stopping at Heini's is an Amish country tradition. What was always great about this place, was…read moretheir samples. You could try all the cheeses and take home your favorites! COVID guidelines took that away, but I'm happy to report the samples have returned Locally made from fresh ingredients, you will find some of the best tasting cheeses here. Plenty of other interesting items as well, like nuts, candies both new and classic and many other things for the eager tourist.

Always a must when I am in New Philly! It is located on the outskirts of town among farms…read more They have a nice selection of cheese. I always love getting the variety cube bag so I can try all of their cheeses. Trail Bologna is also a must!

The freshness of the cheese and everything else they sell. Wish I lived closer. Never been…read moredisappointed with the quality or the service.

This was my first visit to Grandpa's Cheese Barn after passing it for many years. It is a cross…read morebetween a roadside attraction and a gourmet cheese shop. They have an abundance of parking and every kind of cheese you can imagine. I appreciate that they had staff cutting and handing you samples instead of samples sitting out. There were plenty of staff to answer any question you may have and you could request a sample of any cheese. They actually encouraged you to try the cheese. We walked out of the cheese barn with a bag full of goodies and stroll across the courtyard to the candy shop. I was told Sweeties was a new addition. They had so many options it was overwhelming. The two stores could multiple charcuterie boards. We ended up with a bag full of sweets also. The courtyard was very cute and welcoming. As we were leaving an Amish man arrived in his horse drawn carriage to sell homemade baskets. It was nice to see a larger business supporting a small business. I would not hesitate to stop on my next trip.

We stopped in after a tour of Ashland U., & it had been over 10 years since our last visit. We're…read moreso glad we came back! The renovations are phenomenal, and we loved the indoor/outdoor dining and play area. Our active 2-year-old didn't want to leave the mini play barn, which gave the adults time to enjoy the delicious food and treats. Every employee was welcoming & friendly- the entire experience was Gouda-Fun . We'll definitely be back & often! Dick and Vera would be proud to see all the WONDERFUL additions to their barn!

I visited in July 2025 with some friends. We were visiting Ohio Amish country for the day and…read moredecided to stop by this store. My friends really wanted to visit the Guggisberg cheese factory but they were closed for the day. This store offers not only cheese but other smaller grocery and household items such as butter, apple butter, mugs, t-shirts, etc. I don't like cheese so I didn't buy any cheese. My friends may have bought small cheese blocks but I can't remember. They did sample some cheese which they liked. MY PURCHASES -- I bought an Italian bread dipping mix which is a small tin of herbs. I finally tried the dip in April 2026 by adding olive oil the dipping bread in it. The spice mix is too strong so I don't like it that much and I don't believe it was made locally. I also bought Apple butter which is locally made and tastes good. The Apple butter is too sweet for me though so I've hardly eaten it but it goes well with toast. If you're in the area, stop by this local store. The back of the store is cute because of a little fountain and a well-kept lawn. **** GOAL of 250 reviews in 2026 - 87/250 total reviews in 2026 - 928 total Yelp reviews - Reviewed on 19 May 2026

Part deli, part gift shop, part factory. This cheese shop's…read moreclaim to fame is is that they are the creators of baby swiss. They are apparently now one of the largest manufacturers of swiss cheese in the US. When you enter, there is a shop which is a combination of gift shop, cheese accessories and grocery items. There is signage that shows off their awards, talks about some of their history and also takes about the difference between regular and baby swiss. The deli where you can get freshly sliced cheese is in the back. The clerks were extremely friendly answering questions and providing samples of anything you want to try. Much like the outside, the inside continues the swiss theme. The reason I gave it four instead of five stars is the space itself. It was really congested even though it wasn't really all that crowded. I can't imagine what it would be like on a busier day. J don't know what, if anything can be done about this that, but it definitely can be hard yo navigate if you have mobility issues or don't like crowds. Oh and the cheese hats are a fun nice touch.

Small cheese shop My…read moreson loves cheese so we made a stop while out exploring. The shop is small with a Selection, chocolates and other snacks. The staff was great. They had pre packaged cheese or they will slice it for you on request.

While the items they sell are good and reasonably priced, their customer service communication is…read moreless than desirable. Their shipping speeds tend to be on the slow side, but recently it's crawled to an almost complete halt. Federal Trade Commission (FTC) rules state that if a merchant cannot ship an item within 30 days (or their stated timeline), they must notify you, give a revised date, and offer you the option to cancel for a full refund. It looks like I'll have to take action on this last order of mine to get satisfaction. I hate to say it, but this will be my last order from them. It's just not worth the aggravation.

Looking for hyper local? Run - don't walk - to old Brooklyn cheese company…read more They offer a selection of in-house and local cheeses. After trying their new goat cheese + honey + apricot spread, we quickly got a small container. Paired with locally made crackers, our pre-dinner appetizer was set! The mustards are made in house and are award winning. Don't be shy - you can sample them all! And when (not if) you finish a jar, you can bring it back in for a discounted refill. Our favorites are the Original (IPA) and Smoked. They're so delicious that we eat them straight out of the jar (yum), add it to our cheese platters, or use it in cooking. They offer a sampling trio, which we purchased as a gift. They make other creative mustard mixes (think horseradish mustard) that isn't part of their regular offering - so be sure to ask to try what new flavors they have that day. They offer a selection of other locally made food stuffs, including pickles and hot sauce.

A nice selection of cheese and mustards. Staff offers helpful advice and provides samples to assist…read morein purchasing decisions. When we visited for lunch they had a nice array of grilled cheese sandwiches, a cheese board and soup.

Nice selection of wines…read more They have flights - which I love so you can try things They give you a baggy of crackers and pretzels with your flight

This is a small store that offers everything from local cheese and wines to collectibles. The…read moreselection of cheese is pretty limited compared to some of the other cheese places in the area. The wine selection is mostly sweet, but there is a dry red blend. The store is definitely worth a visit when in the Sugarcreek area.

My parents always make a stop by Ables Cheese on the way back to North Carolina from visiting…read morefriends in West Virginia. Ables has an extensive selection of cheeses & meats along with some general grocery items. They also carry alot of the Amish jams & jellies, homemade pimento cheese & some bulk candies they package into small bags for purchase. Everything I've ever tried that my parents bring back from their trips has been excellent.

What cheese is available is still good, but to be honest it is a shadow of its former self. In the…read more90's that place was amazing! I went back last summer and was very very very disappointed. I assume new ownership and a lack of managerial skills is the reason. The cheese is still decent, but the place is nothing like it once was. But, to be honest, what is. The 90's were the best of times and we are living in the worst of times. That being said, the cheese is still good.

Incredible selection of Amish cheeses and bake goods..read more

From the owner: Valley Cheese has been family owned and operated for three generations. We specialize in Amish…read morecheeses, meats, jams, jellies, beef jerky, noodles, chocolates, gift baskets, party trays, and much more. Come try our full line of deli meats and cheeses sliced to perfection for the perfect deli sandwich.

I just started juicing and this was my first location at buying fresh ingredients. I may have…read moreoverdone it as I purchased about $100 in fruits and vegetables. Let's say I still have bottles in my freezer. They have a very nice selection of apples and they even provide free samples of Cider which I made myself when I got home with varied varieties of apples. Thanks Hillcrest Orchard. Oh I forgot to say that I was greeted by a dog just walking around. He was friendly but it caught me off guard.

We visited this lo diy place because we had a coupon for a free 1/2 gallon of cider. I'm so glad…read morebecause I don't think we would have known about it otherwise. I love all things apple, so this was a little slice of heaven. When you walk in, you are greeted by the glorious smell of apples. They have many varieties available for sale, everything from individual apples to giant bushels. In addition to the apples themselves, they sell freshly pressed cider (they were pressing and bottling it while we were where there). They also had cider slushies and hot spiced cider available for purchase by the cup. And lots of sweet treats individually packaged. My husband got some mini buckeyes and I got some dried apples. All of the staff was extremely friendly and prices were great. Definitely worth a visit if you are in the area!