I live between the tiny towns of Quasqueton & Rowley, Iowa. Wolfey's Wapsie Outback is literally the only restaurant within 8 miles of me, so regardless of whether I considered this a five-star masterpiece or a single-star dump, it truly wouldn't have any bearing as to how frequently I visited, because its nice to go to a restaurant without having to drive 10+ miles.
Wolfey's is located in a bar that had been out of business for a few years. It is obvious that the owners did a wonderful job renovating it and made it much more inviting to both fans of late-night boozing and lunch or dinner dining. The walls have a log cabin style, and behind the bar is filled from wall to wall with wildlife art that the owner actually painted himself.
For the most part, the menu is what you'd expect in a small town bar & grill. Lots of deep-fried appetizers, burgers, sandwiches, etc. What sets Wolfey's apart from every other small town bar & grill is that they offer pizza.
Their pizza is hands-down the best in rural Buchanan County. You'd have to drive nearly 9 miles to Bill's Pizza and smokehouse to even give them a run for their money. I prefer their thin crust, as the thick crust is too doughy to me. As for toppings, I prefer the Wolfey's Supreme or their Pineapple & Canadian bacon. My only gripe with their thin crust pizza is the consistency of how it is baked. You never really know whether you can expect to get a well cooked pizza that has crispy crust and golden brown cheese, or an undercooked pizza that is too doughy to support the barely melted cheese and toppings.
Aside from their pizza, I also enjoy their reuben sandwich.
But Wolfey's is not just a restaurant, it also happens to be a very fun place to hang out and drink on a Friday or Saturday night. It has a very friendly crowd, and I've always been treated very well by the bartenders.
Drink prices are reasonable, and no more or less than any other bar in the area. It seems that on a busy night, every age group is well represented. Whether you're in your 20's or your 70's, you will not feel out of place. There is a nice deck that overlooks the Quasqueton Dams that is fun to congregate at on a warm spring or summer night.
Overall, I really enjoy Wolfey's. It was a much needed addition to the rural Buchanan County area. Once they get some more experience in the kitchen, I expect I will like it even more. read more