I would be fibbing if I didn't say I have intentionally went to Yellowbrick casino just to get everything wings from them! The service is A1 the food is even better. The pizza slices are a bit over priced but I have enjoyed every flavor and topping option they have to offer and they always come thru. I spend way too much money at the casino ofcourse so they owe me some free food and a win lol. I have sat and eaten here for my hubbys birthday after stopping up to enjoy the day and the dining area is always clean and spacious. A must try if you ask me!!! read more

Wicked Good Pizza & Plates - Chicken Riggies - Pizza Near Me - Chittenango, New York

Located in the casino, it has excellent customer service and is very clean in the eating area. I had the two simple slices of cheese. The pizza was cooked perfectly and had a good taste to it. Two slices of pizza in the water 10 bucks. read more

See all

Despite being quite far, i will say their pizza was pretty good! We ordered it for pick up over the weekend as a family member had casino points to use up. We ordered 3 different types of pizza and they piled on the toppings and it was well worth money. I would certainly order from here again. read more

This is not a family friendly place. It's located inside the casino. It seems like it caters more to the gamblers in the casino or take-out than a family that wants to eat in. The food was okay but the experience of trying to eat at a table was frustrating and annoying. read more

I have been a huge fan of this pizza! But, the last three pizza's have had crust like shoe leather! This time, I asked them in person, to pull it from the oven a little earlier because of the aforementioned issues. My name was called and no big surprise...shoe leather bottom again. Not ordering pizza from there anymore unless management makes changes. In my opinion, normally, it's a 5 star pizza! Like to see it come back to the pizza I know it can be! read more

Clueless customer service. Even though they knew I was waiting for a pickup, my pizza apparently sat in a partially open box for 15 minutes before they bothered to ask, "Are you waiting for a pickup?" Pizza itself was below average. Leathery crust like another reviewer said. Tasteless sauce. Bland toppings. Not going back. read more

It was one of those nights. I got home from work and knew I wasn't in the mood to cook. Having recently moved to the area, I decided to run down to Wicked Good Pizza for a couple slices. I had visited here once before and dined in, ordering a pizza, some wings, and an antipasto. On that night 2 years ago, the pizza was excellent, but slightly overpriced. Considering this was inside a casino, I knew what I was getting myself into and looked forward to my next visit. Fast forward to the aforementioned evening where I was in the mood for a couple slices. When I walked in, I was informed that the special that night was buffalo wing pizza and that they also had cheese and pepperoni slices available. I decided to be boring and grab 2 slices of cheese. Eagerly anticipating some thin sliced goodness when I got home, I was extremely disappointed to find a greasy mess. The cheese was pretty rubbery and the crust was not how I remembered. Like most people, I don't struggle to put down 2 slices of cheese pizza, but for the first time in recent memory, one of the slices found the bottom of the trash bin. I was really torn about giving Wicked Good 2 stars as I quite enjoyed our meal 2 years ago, but this most recent experience was awful. I am wiling to order a fresh pie and see if that makes a difference, but it isn't at the top of list. If you are at the Casino and enjoying a few drinks, Wicked Pizza will soak up the booze...otherwise there are better options in Fayetteville 10 minutes up the road. read more

They literally mess things up every time we order. It tastes good but they literally always mess it up and never make it right. Won't be back. read more

Decent pizza. Good to grab a quick bite at. Plenty of seating inside and outside. Connected to Yellow Brick Road Casino. Their selection of single slice pizza is small, but decent: garlic broccoli, cheese, mushroom, sausage, and pepperoni. There are more specialty pizza options if you order the whole pizza. Nothing spectacular or Wizard of Oz themed here, other than the name of the restaurant. read more

Wicked Good Pizza & Plates - Menu 5/25/18 - Pizza Near Me - Chittenango, New York

See all

I ordered a pizza large with a couple toppings and it was literally raw when I got it. I brought it back and they were extremely busy. I was ignored completely, so I walked out and went home. Needless to say I never ordered anything else from that place. read more

This is plates and pizza now. Very clean fairly priced, people are nice. Considering this is in Yellow Brick Casino this has the least flavorful pasta dishes of the TS group. Alfredo lacked cheese flavor and it does come with chicken despite the lack of listing that ingredient on the menu. Chicken was bland also. Our other order was eggplant rolletini over pasta which was tender eggplant, skins a bit tough, and again no seasoning and sauce little flavor. Two meals one glass of wine came to $30 with tip. No it's not a 5 star restaurant but a little seasoning goes a long way despite the demographic of many who eat in casinos. Places are generally short staffed and wait can be a bit but with 6 people working this small spot with few to go orders and two tables besides ours, a 45 minute wait was excessive and we are pretty sure the order wasn't started until a half hour had passed and we inquired as to the status. Meh. Maybe I'll try the wings or pizza it much to them and the other one at Point Place is pretty good for those. read more

Dined at restaurant for the first time. I ordered a steak sub and opted for provolone cheese in lieu of the melted cheddar cheese. It was delicious !!! Made with actual steak and not chopped up steak ins meat. The fries were served hot and seasoned well. They hand you a buzzer to let you know when your food is ready but the waitress brought our food out to the table where we were seated . Excellent customer service . You definitely have to eat here if you can take a break from gambling as it is located in the rear of the casino read more

Wicked Good Pizza & Plates - a sign in a restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Chittenango, New York

Burn pizza crust that was overly thick. Sauce ok but lacking in cheese. $12+ for 2 slices and a bevy read more

See all

I can honestly say that for as many times that I have visited this very nice establishment this was the worst experience. I have never had to wait so long for an online order., over a hour! Also, my hot food sat on the counter as I asked several times if the order for Julie was ready, and I was told just one more minute one more minute. Even other customers spoke up on my behalf and said this lady has been waiting for a long time. They should look at their security footage to see how long I stood there. When I asked what took so long I was told we just changed shifts. The staff said nothing else and this is why the no tip option is available. Oh but would you like some plates to go with your extremely cold pizza. I must say that I am very dissatisfied as my food was cold and I should have received a discount if not a full refund. I can say I won't be back and we wont be buying our party foods there. read more

Ordered rigatoni bolenese and 2 slices of pepperoni pizza...that was 45 minutes ago and still no food. 2 cooks and 4 counter help working but no food coming out. I could've driven to a restaurant, ordered and be done with my food in the 45 minutes I've waited so far. read more

Seating area is always clean and looks and feels welcoming. Customer service is always good and the food is delicious. Thank you Wicked team

My husband and I regularly pick up pizza from Wicked Good, and while it isn't necessarily the most gourmet pizza you'll ever eat, the slices are huge and the price is definitely right. Also, if you're sticking around inside the restaurant to eat your slice, the whole place is super well-furnished, comfortable, and inviting. read more

There pizza is very good especially the sausage ! We also Love there everything wings

Had pizza here Monday afternoon. I must say that I have had better pizza at Sam's Club. I wanted New York style pizza so badly because I am from Georgia and have heard all the hype about New York style pizza I was truly not impressed. read more

Live close so I've had their pizza/wings many times since the casino opened. I'm not a big fan of thin and greasy NYC style. I've had a lot of different pizza and this one falls in the average category. The wings though are awesome! Make sure you order them X crispy. read more

The staff was very friendly and greeted us with smiles. The pizza was ok, but not amazing. I like that they sell it by the slice but when I went there weren't that many options. The drinks were very pricey which seemed strange considering this place is attached to a casino. Overall I'm glad I brought the kids here for a quick bite but not sure I'll make it a regular event. read more

I've gotten this pizza so many times and it never disappoints! The pizza is AMAZING, probably the best in the area! I also am super pleased with the service, as everyone who works there is super friendly. Highly recommend to everyone who comes up to CNY :) read more

Mediocre at best. It literally tastes like every mom and pop shop pizza, a vague generic taste. Large sized slices, but just not worth the money. $ Better spent at little Caesars. Yes I said that. read more

Delicious pizza. Outstanding customer service! Clean and welcoming atmosphere. All around great experience.