So far, I have ordered twice from Wicked Good Cookies! They are great sugar cookies; in both taste and design. They really helped add a special touch to my events. They came packed very well and arrived in tact, and ready for my event(s). Both times, I chose a specific delivery day and they arrived on time as scheduled. I had a minor issue on my second order and they quickly and graciously responded to my concern. They adjusted and helped me with what I needed almost immediately. If you need great cookies, don't hesitate to order from this kind company. They have a fantastic product. read more

Great cookies, responsive service, that was helpful for ordering something a little last minute as a gift. Seems to be a quaint family owned business. Not the friendliest or welcoming environment, just right down to business. Not a true fan of that, but the cookies are divine and were definitely enjoyed by many that we provided them to. read more

Not sure if they have an actual storefront. I have been getting customized cookies from them for a few years now and they are great. They will keep in touch with you through out the process and make sure everything is right before they send you your cookies. I usually use them once a year for Boston Marathon weekend. read more

Wicked Good Cookies - Specialty Food Near Me - Boylston, Massachusetts

Great cookies and the designs are always so great! Thanks again for the quick turnaround on our order.

My husband and I recently moved to West Boylston and took a ride past the Wicked Good Cookies small bldg nearby. My husband just got out of the hospital and was hoping to get a fresh chocolate chip cookie. When I stopped in, I was told they only sell online. But hearing our story, the owner gave us 6 free cookies and a special March Madness Cookie for our grandson's birthday tomorrow. I was so appreciative at the generosity and compassion of this owner whom I had never met. I will definitely place many orders with this company and the cookies were especially delicious. 5 stars to Wicked Good Cookies read more

We stumbled upon this company somehow and thought we'd give them a try. So, we ordered dozens of cookies from them with our company logo. We were absolutely thrilled with the results! They arrived promptly. They look fantastic! AND they taste amazing! We are thrilled with this company and will continue to use them! THANK you, Wicked Good Cookies! Chris and Peggy White- Alexandria, Virginia read more

I am so impressed. Just ordered cookies with photo for my parents' anniversary. Not only did they work tirelessly and patiently to accommodate my changes but they also delivered on time. Swift response. And they gave me 6 free cookies with my order! The cookies are beautiful especially with the added ribbon! read more

The owner all the employees are very friendly and the cookies are awesome definitely recommend to adults and kids.

Thanks for making this small detail for our Open House a BIG statement! Appreciate your company delivering on time and that the cookies were delish ! I'll be ordering again! read more

Wicked Good Cookies - What an amazing job!! Smile Kingdom Dental had the big Open House . Lots of compliments! Thanks for coming through! - Specialty Food Near Me - Boylston, Massachusetts

See all

Wicked Good Cookies were delivered at work today! The peanut butter cup cookies are delicious! I look forward to them ever Christmas as a vendor we work with sends them our way! They are WICKED good! read more

These are top notch cookies! I sent a last minute request for photo cookies for my daughter's first birthday and they delivered 40 (+5 extra!) cookies in just two days to Washington DC. The cookies look gorgeous (just like the sample they sent for approval) and taste delicious. I am beyond satisfied -- couldn't recommend them enough! P.S. you can really taste the orange juice in the cookie. yum. read more

Excellent customer service! We ordered an order for an event with the customers logo on it, we received many compliments and with the order came a Thank you card attached from Amy with (5) additional complimentary cookies. You guys Rock! Thank you read more

Big shout out to Mark and friends at Wicked Good Cookies! You were the hit of my nephew and his fiancé's surprise engagement party yesterday!! The heart shaped picture cookies were delicious!! Can't thank you enough!! read more

We had my daughter's birthday here and the kids a great time. The sugar cookie package included enough dough for each kid to make plenty of cookies and all the colored sugar you could need. While the cookies baked we enjoyed pizza that the staff ordered for us, charging only what they paid for it. Overall it was a great time, a very easy party, and a great value. Did I mention that they made up a PDF invitation for me to bring to Staples? It looked great and was just one more thing off my mind. Call Mark and he will get as involved in your party as you let him. Or if you are bit less eagar to give up control, he can do that too. Party here. The kids will love it! read more

The cookies we ordered that featured our daughter's logo were perfect. They arrived on schedule, and we were very happy with them! They made great party favors for the graduation party we held for our daughter. Thank you Wicked Good Cookies! I would happily order from you again. read more

Wicked good is right! There cookies are so yummy. My five year old son is always asking to go make some cookies. You can walk in a make your own cookies right there and they clean up the mess! You roll out some dough that they give you, cut them out with sone of the many cookie cutters they have, decorate them and they put them in the oven for you. A few minutes later you have some warm delicious cookies to eat there or take home. My eleven year old loves to do this too. The staff there is so nice to me and my kids. They really let the kids get into making the cookies. And the best part for me is that I don't have to clean up the mess! Update 2016: Wicked Good Cookies has really become part of our community in town. On many occasions they have participated in helping out at events at the library as well as an event that was held to honor the police officers in town. They really are a stand up business. Glad to have them so close! read more

What a great place to get some cookies. I use them for corporate basket and my recipients just love them. Thanks Wicked Good Cookies. read more

I recently had an amazing experience with folks at Wicked Good Cookies! On very short notice (less than 5 days) they helped me to create favors for a large family celebration. Special shout out to Mark Shooshan who worked on the entire project with me via email! He took a picture and designed the perfect logo to commemorate a special occasion. Very accommodating and professional. Have also heard that one of the owners, Chris Agby, is a very nice guy too :) Highly recommend this company for any occasion ~ large or small!! Donna and Carl Simone read more

These are great cookies! My first order was small. They were delicious! Then I placed an order for 100 for a social distancing drive-by graduation party. They were a hit. I love this cookie company!!! They included extra cookies with each order in case some break during the shipping process. My first order no cookies arrived broken. But, for my second order they were so kind and generous to include 9 extra cookies; and only 3 were broken. So, I was extremely thankful for the extras!!! I will be placing my third order soon!!! read more

The company has horrible customer service. Over the years we have used the company to send cookies to friends and family. But recently we placed an order and it was never delivered by DHL. Instead of handling the issue directly with their vendor DHL, they told us it was our responsibility to deal with DHL directly. In the end, the cookie was never received and we were not refunded. Do not use this company. They do not value their customers. I recommend finding another source to send cookies to your kids in college. read more

I was working close-by so stopped in to check out the cookies! Chocolate chip and Peanut butter puddles were delicious!

I called Wicked Good Cookies from Los Angeles today to get some cookies delivered to my best friend, who is in Massachsetts for the weekend under horribly sad circumstances. Even though it was close to the end of the day AND my delivery address was out of their zone, they went out of my way to help and made great suggestions. My cookies were delivered on time and made my best friend smile. As an owner of a small business, I know how important it is for people to know when service is personal and great. So I am letting Yelp know that Wicked Good Cookies is Wicked Awesome. Thank you. Mark and Peter! read more

I have used Wicked Good Cookies twice. Once for my best friend's 30th birthday and recently for my mother's retirement party. The staff is professional, accomodating and work in a timely manner. They always answered my questions and did their best to make any modifications that I requested. They also gave me suggestions to make the final product turn out as wonderful as possible. The cookies were beautifully done, photgraphs clear and individually wrapped, perfect for party favors! I will go back again and again to this company. Thank you Greg and Lindsay! read more

My cousin used this company to make cookie favors for her parents' 60th anniversary party. They were delicious sugar cookies with a photo screened on the fronts, individually wrapped. Very clever with a great taste considering the method of presentation. I was amazed at the likeness of the photo and really wished I had snagged a few more to munch on! :) I wouldn't be afraid to use them. Nice job. read more

My son's kindergarten class had a b-day party here recently and it is not worth it. I was initially excited to support a local business not named " pump it up" for a birthday party but quickly discovered that the young girls working in the store were uninterested in making it a special occasion. The kids don't actually take part in the fun of making the cookie dough. They just slapped a pre-made dough sheet in front of each child and gave a few cutters out. The kids then sit with nothing to do for 20 to 30 minutes while the cookies bake. Poorly run and not fun. read more

I ordered specialty wedding heart shaped cookies as a party favor for my reception. I provided a custom image and I worked with the agent to place my order after a sample was shown to me. Basically my hubby and i did all the work and they just resized it and printed, but it was a hit and everyone loved it. In terms of the taste, I think they were ok, nothing great but presentation was off the charts. I recommend it for party favors and keep sake cookies. They arrived on time and were securely packed. read more

So one day me and my family were driving and passed this place a few times. So we decided, "hey! Let's stop in to wicked good cookies and see what kind of cookies they got!" So we pulled in and there were cars in the parking lot, so we figured it may have been a little busy ( which we were thinking,"this place must be good then") So we walk on in only to see about a dozen kids and their parents staring at all of us. There was a birthday party going on! So to our embarrassment we walked out.. There were no signs anywhere saying there was a birthday party going on! So no cookies for us that day. My advice to your store is hmm maybe think about putting signs up when there's a party going on? Or maybe lock the doors? Or maybe put SOME kind of sign stating that this isn't just a walk in place. Just a thought. Won't be attempting to go here again. read more

I ordered photo cookies from here for a Graduation to be delivered to a hotel in North Carolina (I am in California).I was impressed with how easy and responsive they were to my requests and delivered exactly what I wanted and on time.Since I did everything via email it is great to know there are businesses that still take customer service seriously plus the cookies are delicious!!! read more

Wow, what can I say? Our company gave each employee a holiday cookie basket with custom logo cookie and an assortment of other cookies. The cookies are so good they did not make it beyond 3 days after delivery --- we ate them. My husband and I fought over the last cookie.. If you want something fun, unique and over the top tasty - order Wicked Good Cookies!! read more

If there were a no star rating thats what I would give them. 2.75 for a tastless dry horrible excuse for a cookie!The slice and back atthe grocery store is way better. I was embarresed to give them out at our party. I ended up throwing them away. They tasted like carboard with hard icing. So dissapointed!!! read more

This is a company we have used several times. We love these cookies, their taste and their designs. We choose them when we want something special for our family and our friends. Wicked Good Cookies has great service and has helped us with ideas for gifts. We will use WGC again and again and refer them to all that want a great tasting gift or just a fun time. Thanks guys, see you soon. read more

I had the photo cookies done for my Mom's 80th birthday! They were such a hit! Delivered in time. The cookies tasted great, too and loved that they were gmo free! I will definitely order, again. read more

I think this company is poorly run. When I tried to contact the owner I was told to email the general email. The man who was answering the main line sounded uninterested and high, to be quite honest. I am disappointed that they weren't more professional and this really lost them my business. read more

First and foremost, the cookies are delicious. Second, the packaging is legit, as they use a solid plastic wrap and professional looking sticker with the ingredients. Third, the quality of the artwork on the cookie is outstanding. Fourth, the customer service is excellent, very helpful and pleasant. Fifth, did I mention the cookies taste amazing! read more