Having moved from the original home of Which Wich, ( Dallas) I was so happy to see one while visiting Tally! This had been a local favorite before their expansion. Love the way you can place your Wich specifications on your bag, turn it in, pay and viola a yummy fresh sandwich is ready! My go to is the black bean burger on wheat, deli mustard, with lots of veggies. The small Wich is 7 inches and is plenty for me . Milkshakes are available and now french fries too! I saw someone enjoying them and that is something different from the " competition". Maybe I should look into opening a franchise near home in SW Florida...hmmm. read more

Really fun meal. Brought the wife and kids and we had fun filling out our bags, but that takes a while. Their iOS app is something I will be looking into, as the entire process will feel less rushed when I can pick from the convenience of my home. The sandwiches were made quickly and hot as ordered. Really great. The employees were really friendly which made the experience all the better. We will be coming back. read more

Which Wich - Sandwiches Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

Great menu, friendly service, and very clean restaurant. When you walk in the first thing you want to do is look at the menu board, once you have a sandwich picked out you grab the paper bag that has your sandwich name on it and you'll write what you want in your sandwich, pickles, lettuce, etc. this excludes specific sandwiches like the gyro or banh mi. Those sandwiches come as they are. Then bring it to the register and that bag is what your sandwich will go in. I got the Banh Mi (Vietnamese sandwich) and my husband got the gyro. The bahn Mi was tasty , but what makes a true bahn Mi is the pickled veggies and Pâté. This had fresh veggies and no Pâté with pulled pork. Still a tasty sandwich (loved the egg) but if you expecting a traditional banh Mi this is not it. The gyro was big and packed full of meat. It also had red onions and lots of taziki sauce. I'll definitely go back and try the other sandwiches. read more

Which Wich - Banh Mi sandwich - Sandwiches Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

We were so very pleased to meet Everest while passing through Tallahassee. I am a customer service representative who trains and manages folks in the service industry so I can tell you this young man has it all. He knows his product, his service was impeccable and he sells his company when asked. We really enjoyed our visit to your sandwich shop. He's a keeper. read more

$17 for a sandwich and I can't get a free refill??!! Get out of here. Menu is confusing and inconvenient Won't be back!

Gross can't even order without filling out a form on a bag. Staff rude. They wasted my time just wanted to order a sandwich and they made it difficult. read more

We brought a group of 12 people in and were the only ones in the restaurant. You'd think we brought a stadium of people in. Every employee was making comments like "no way", "you've got to be kidding me", etc. we've got ears people. We can hear you. Had we not already started ordering I would have left. The workers were extremely rude the whole time. The person I'm guessing is the manager took things off the menu that he said they couldn't do with a big group. Food was okay but any customizations didn't happen. Wouldn't recommend coming here if you're going to expect the employees to make your sandwich. I think they're hoping you'll pay them and just walk out. T Can't imagine what happens during a lunch rush! read more

This place I think is pretty awesome if you love subs. I really like the ordering process for some reason. It satisfies my logistical obsession to optimize proficiency. Food: I ordered the pesto chicken sub and what more could I ask for really? Bread was nice and toasty and the food was tasty. It's a super solid sub and I think. read more

Which Wich - Sandwiches Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Confusing ordering process and underwhelming sandwiches. I honestly feel like I could have made a better sandwich at home, but this was about the only place open so we were at their mercy. Probably won't return. read more

Which Wich - Wicked - Sandwiches Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Headed for a little vacation down on the Mississippi Gulf Coast and decided to stop at the Wich Wich sandwich shop in Tallahassee just off I-10. Easy to find. Very fast service. My wife had a turkey sandwich which look delicious. I had a turkey salad with double meat. I especially like that you can get whatever you want prepared just the way you want it, with the ingredients that you want in it. It was really good. The price is very fair. Parking is very easy right out front. The people were very friendly and prompt. The place was very clean including the restrooms. read more

Which Wich - Sandwiches Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

First time trying this and I can say it's pretty darn good. I got the turkey, upgraded with bacon. Toasted. I would put this on a par with a Publix sub and definitely better than Subway. Quick service and their unique ordering system. You grab a sandwich bag and check off your ingredients. It's about $1.50 more than the Subway combo and we'll worth it. Update: I ate so fast the first time I didn't realize why I liked the sandwich so much. It's the bread. Fresh, soft with a perfectly crunchy exterior. read more

This is a cute chain place set in a shopping center, and conviently located next to Petco, which is where I take my Yorkie to get groomed. I love that I can drop her off, get a bite to eat at Which Wich, pick up groceries at Fresh Market, medications at Walgreens, and then go shopping at Stein Mart, all in one trip! On this occasion, I'd been trying to eat a bit healthier (blah!), so I was delighted to discover I had the option of a lettuce wrap, instead of a huge, hoagie bun. The ordering is easy enough, just grab a pre-printed bag, write your name at the top, and check off any options you prefer. There are so many choices, everyone should be able to find something to please them! The service was quick and with a smile (including eye contact!), my order was served with only a brief wait, and in the same bag you just filled out. So ecological! It was so satisfying to bite into a cool, crisp Krab Salad wrap, instead of a heavy, calorie-laden bun! My only dissatisfaction was the level of mayonnaise in the salad, but I'm not a big fan of mayonnaise, so it might be perfect for someone else. Next time I'm in, I will ask if the salad is made ahead or on-the-spot, if so, I'll ask for less mayonnaise! Otherwise, this is a great place for a family to pop into to get a satisfying meal, for dine-in, dine-out on the patio, or to-go! I advise parking in the larger parking areas, or to the left of the building, as Which Wich is so close to the entrance, it is very difficult, actually dangerous, trying to exit from the parking spaces. Visibility in exiting the shopping center lot is complicated by the fact it is uphill, on a blind curve, and steady on-coming traffic makes an exit difficult at times. Drive safely! read more

Which Wich - Krab Salad lettuce wrap - Sandwiches Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Which Wich is a delicious sandwich spot. The name is fitting because there's no many options that I am always truly asking myself, which wich? The cool thing about this place is the way you order. The sandwiches are highly customizable, but not with the usual assembly line style ordering you may be used to. You walk in, take a look at the board, and grab a sandwich bag to order. Each bag has a different category. There's one for chicken, turkey, beef, etc. Then on the bag you have a choice of what you want under that category. For example, with the beef bag you can get the french dip, cheesteak, reuben, roast beef, or corned beef. So you check which you want. Choose your cheese. Choose your spreads and sauces. Choose your veggies. And choose your oils and spices. And voilà you're ready! Your sandwich is quickly prepared and warmed by the staff, and you're ready to dive into the deliciousness. My go-tos here are the chicken and the french dip. The chicken has a healthy sign next to it so I usually go for this one when I'm trying to watch what I eat, although i don't know healthy it is once I add all the fillings. This is what I had on my visit to this location. I always get the honey mustard sauce with it, it's delicious! The french dip comes with an au jus to dip your sandwich in. This is truly my favorite sandwich that I've tried here. It is so flavorful and tasty. All in all, great sandwich spot. You will no doubt find something you love! read more

Which Wich - Chicken with honey mustard - Sandwiches Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

If you are indecisive, this is not your sandwich shop. For those of us that like choices and variety, this is a great sandwich spot. Each person orders their sandwich on their own bag that lists the endless options and combinations to make your sandwich truly your own. The olive spread is awesome! . A sandwich combo is a little pricey : 10" sandwich with chips and drink was $11.50, but that depends on your sandwich choice. Bread is fresh and just the right density and chewiness. We love choices therefore we love which wich! read more

I enjoy grabbing a quick sandwich here from time to time. I like being able to fill out the sandwich form to my personal wants. It's fun, vibrant and cool. I like it. read more

Which Wich - Chicken Pesto and lots of veggies! Yum! - Sandwiches Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

I really like Which Wich, so when we needed a quick lunch stop on a road trip, I directed the husband here. It was mid-afternoon, so they weren't busy and we were able to order right away. I recall I had a loyalty card somewhere, but the cashier said they've switched to an app, so I guess I missed out on that. I got the French dip and the husband got a lettuce wrap. Now, what makes a French dip a French dip is the jus -- the titular "dip." When they called out my order, the husband came back with the the sandwich. I had to send him back up to ask for the jus. Let me remind you that (1) it's supposed to come with the sandwich and (2) they were not at all busy. With the jus, my sandwich was ok, but not as good as I remembered. The husband enjoyed his lettuce wrap, though looking at the receipt, it seems like they may have forgotten to charge him extra for bacon and egg. All in all, for $14, it was an adequate lunch stop, just not as good as I had hoped. read more

I ordered the Avocado wich with lettuce, tomato, American cheese. pickles, mayo, mustard, oil and vinegar on wheat bread. It was made quickly, and when I opened the paper wrap, it smelled like heaven. It had been lightly toasted which gave the bread a nice crunch. Everything tasted fresh and delicious. The staff was super friendly and the restaurant was clean. I will definitely be back! read more

Still wondering why Which Which isn't all over the country. I would love a Which Which in South Florida. It is such a great concept that you are able to order exactly what you want by just checking off the ingredients on the bag. I love that you don't have to sit there and point out to the employee exactly what you want. I am able to add as many ingredients as I'd like without feeling annoying :) Also, somehow every time I go to which which they are able to fit all my ingredients into a lettuce wrap or spinach wrap perfectly. I've always had a pleasant experience at this which which and their is rarely a line. You may also order online and have your sandwich waiting for you when you arrive. Definitely my favorite "make your own" sandwich place that I've been to. PS. Don't forget to add the crispy onions to your creation. You won't be sorry. read more

This was my first visit to Which Wich. I was told that they offered a lettuce-wrapped sandwich. And since I've been doing a low carb diet, I figured I would stop in. Which Wich offers you the option to build your own or turn one of the existing wraps into a Lettucewich. I chose the Cobb Salad Wrap, which had turkey, hard-boiled eggs, bacon and cheese. All the ingredients were fresh and I was excited to try this Lettucewich. What I failed to realize is how well a wrap made of lettuce would the hold bits and pieces of the Cobb Salad wrap. It was wrapped pretty well, but as soon as I slid the paper wrap down to take a bite, the wrap began to fall apart. Each time I slid the paper wrap down a little for the next bite (whilst keeping the wrap together) I ended up biting off a piece of paper with it. Ultimately, I ended up eating the Lettucewich with a fork. So I was a little disappointed with that wrap. I figure next time I will try to order a wrap that contains slices of meat which probably holds the wrap together while eating it. Will update my review after my next visit. read more

I like Which Wich. When you walk in (or stand outside) you choose a sack from a holder, write your name down and then mark what you want for your particular sandwich. This way you get it your way. You take your sack to the cashier and they place your order. You can even choose to have them hot or cold. They even have the menu sacks outside so you can take your time deciding. The uniqueness of their ordering process is you don't have to feel like they are waiting on you to hurry up and make up your mind. I've had several. The gyro, their meatball sub, and their roast beef sub. The staff is always friendly, service is prompt, and the sandwiches are delicious. Simply a nice sandwich shop chain. read more

Good sandwich with fresh ingredients at a great price. They have a tone of toppings to choose from and they don't nickel and dime you.

OMG seriously? This has to be the absolute worst sandwich place I've seen in Tallahassee. Your very first clue should be that you select your sandwich by marking on a paper bag and choosing what you'd like to have, except there are no prices to be found anywhere while you make your selection. When our order finally arrived my wife and I were so disappointed in our sandwiches. Let's start with her selection that was called a gyro that came with the works. Sounds great. The problem is, it isn't a gyro, it's served on a thick sandwich roll, the meat was scarce and had no taste what-so-ever, and "the works" turned out to be some sauce and nothing else. My keys weighed more and was bigger than this tiny sandwich. (see pictures. Actual pictures mind you, not pictures of their promo shots.) Now let's move on to my sandwich, which was equally poor in quality and quantity. I had the French Dip, and I really felt like the dip when I saw how much I paid for this thing. $8.50 for this poor excuse for a sandwich that wasn't even an inch thick. This thing was almost all bread with a little meat added. Just like the gyro, the meat lacked any flavor. The bread was good, which is lucky because that's all your sandwich is at this place. Fortunately we had Au Jus sauce to dip it in. Unfortunately the tiny amount they provided tasted nothing like aujus sauce. (Please see pictures) Here's the part that really gets me... after paying $16.66 for two of the smallest/worst sandwiches I've experienced, we discovered that being cheap doesn't stop with the quality of the meat they purchase or the quantity they deliver. This place does not provide water at all. No water cups. No option for water. You are forced to purchase their over priced soda's if you want something to drink. There are so many great sandwich shops here in Tallahassee. Unless you have no taste buds what-so-ever, and you enjoy paying way too much for way to little, then you need to go somewhere else. We will not be back, and you can be certain we will warn our friends. Special reminder. Places run by kids usually try to boost their ratings. Beware of reviewers who only have one review, or all their reviews are on the same day. Kind of tells you something about a business when they have to resort to tactics like this. read more

Love this place, my wife and I have eaten here three times the first week they've been open. huge selection of subs and salads, and the toppings and selections seem to be almost endless. so far I've had the meatball grinder, and two different versions of cheese steaks and all were delicious. My wife has enjoyed buffalo chicken and a cheesesteak. There are so many different ways, and toppings to have your sub completed, you never have to eat the same thing twice. One unique way of preparing the sub is to wrap it in lettuce rather than bread, for those folks who are carb conscious. Also any sandwich can be made into a salad also, for a healthier alternative. The ordering process is very unique and fun, and makes a little different spin on the traditional sandwich shop. read more

Flavors are better than Subways, service is good and fast too. It's a bit pricey (about $9/person including sandwich, chips and drink) but it's worth it if you do it once in a while. Definitely recommended and will definitely come back. read more

Which Wich - the outside of a restaurant - Sandwiches Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

We had which Wich for the first time the other night around 730. I was the only customer there at the time. I ordered the regular Italian for myself and the gyro for my husband. My husband liked the gyro. The regular size italian wasn't quite big enough for me though. Next time I'll get the next size up. For reference, I usually get a foot long at subway or a regular at jersey mikes & those fill me up. They also forgot my lettuce. Nothing out of this world but I'd try it again. read more

The service by the manager on duty was horrible. I ordered food to go and she placed my unwrapped fries on the counter and didn't even offer me a bag. She decided she didn't want to make my milkshake and told her coworker to do it and was rude to him as well. I asked for a water cup while I waited on the milkshake and drank some water. My two year old who was with me asked for my cup and asked for tea. I put no more than two ounces of tea in the cup so that she could have a sip and the manager on duty proceeds to tell me to it's not that expensive to buy a regular drink. I told her that I wasn't buying a full drink for my two year old to have a sip while we wait for the milkshake that she refused to make. She proceeded to argue and yell at me over giving my daughter the sip of tea and told me to not to come back. As a paying customer who regularly comes in after my daughter's gymnastics classes next door I was appalled and disgusted that I was treated this way. read more

Great subs and so many items to pick from. They have milk shakes and backed cookies and homemade chips. You can order online from the App and pick up. The staff all help you order and make picking your sub very easy. My food was great and I will be back to try other subs. read more

See all

Any way that you can think to have a sandwich, you can get it here. Be prepared to spend some time picking out the bag you want for the sandwich of your dreams. Once you have reached a decision of turkey, beef, or 10 other sandwich bags, you may then mark the bag for the options you wish; hot or cold, white, wheat, skinny, and then add the things that make it "your" 'which" in the perfect size; even a bowl! Write your name on the bag, add chips, cookies, or a fresh milk , or soft drink and you're good to go! Dine in or carry out. read more

First time eating at Which Wich. Neat experience. Quick,efficient and very friendly service. Excellent sandwich!! Melissa Haley Brendon and Turrel run a great shop! read more

Bottom line it's average. Service was great, and it's a nice place, but the taste is just bland on the club that I got. It's a better looking subway. Ing suggest trading your money to fire house if toasted subs is your thing, or my favorite a Publix sub. Probably won't go back, if I were to I might try the buffalo chicken since I ended up dipping my club in buffalo sauce to get some form of flavor out of the sandwich. read more

My new favorite sub place, great meatball sub and lots of reasons to come back. They do have 1.50 refills on the large size for returning customers when you bring back one of their large cups(a recycling effort?) recommend for lunch time, they can really handle large crowds well. read more

Usually pretty good, huge portions and cheap, way more toppings than subway, better meat too! I like their salads and wraps, I have had a handful of times where my order was incorrect read more

The food is always good and the employees are always nice and professional. Today, my son spilled his milk and the staff gave me another milk and then refused my payment. I highly recommend which which to all of my friends and family. read more

Great sandwiches and they also have salads. Good place to go for a quick bite when you want something better than fast food. Reasonably priced and good selecton. read more

Yummy sandwiches and tons of combos. Definitely a favorite! My personal favorite is the black bean patty with fresh veggies! Love the quick service and tasty food! Used the app to order online. Love that I can put in my loyalty number and it's so user friendly. Just as easy as ordering there! read more

Food seems good...however, the dinning area is a not clean at all. Every empty table is dirty..floors are in need of sweeping...and take the trash out. The recitals are over flowing. read more

Not bad. The bread is different. I wouldn't recommend the philly cheesesteak here but cold subs I have tried are good. I like writing what I want on the bag. This guarantees it's right or their fault it's wrong. Very good variety of sandwiches. read more