The store was absolutely filthy. Not a clean table to sit down at. We ordered 2 sandwiches and 3 shakes. The team behind the counter could have cared less. Took over 15 minutes to make the shakes and the sandwiches were cold. I asked what they were going to do and the guy was a smart ass and said he would throw them in the microwave. I said no thanks and let him know there restaurant was filthy and he said thanks, good bye and that shakes should take that long. The shakes were only half full. read more

Which Wich - Half made shakes. - Sandwiches Near Me - Silverthorne, Colorado

Only few customers at 6:30 PM on a Wednesday night, and now I know why. My vanilla shake somehow took 15 minutes from the time I ordered but tastes like it was made with fake ice cream and imitation vanilla. My avacado .and tomato sandwich came on a good roll but it was only the size of a hot dog bun. The avacado was a paste and the tomato almost too thin to find. Mostly just shredded lettuce. Don't waste your time and money. This dinky little supper cost over $12. read more

Which Wich - Shake. - Sandwiches Near Me - Silverthorne, Colorado

We decided to try this place after driving by. When we first arrived it was packed! The line moved pretty fast tho. I like how we get to fill out our order first. I like it better than any sub place that I have ever been to. I ordered the cookie sandwich but it wasn't very impressive. 2 stale cookies on top of scoop of icecream. I was expecting to have soft cookies. Other than that I like this place and the whole concept they have. read more

Which Wich - Sandwiches Near Me - Silverthorne, Colorado

Went to get a sandwich today. Waited about 20 minutes for it to be made. There were only 4 of us in the restaurant. 2 employees were working and another 2 seemed to be off the clock making themselves sandwiches, one while talking on their cell phone at the cooking area. As I waited for my food, I noticed that ALL the tables had food on them. The employees who likely were getting their food at the end of their shift didn't bother to wipe these down, nor mop up a sloppy mop job of very dirty mop water. It smelled like a gas station bathroom in the entire dining area. Also, this franchise is in a terrible lot! No windows towards the back. So depressing! It didn't help that it was filthy, that the employees all seemed new and unenthused to be there. I'm a fan of this company but my visit today left me grossed out at this particular branch. read more

Which Wich - The dining area towards the back. - Sandwiches Near Me - Silverthorne, Colorado

My favorite sandwich place of all time! Amazing that they started in Salem, Massachusetts! j.k. Your first time ordering might be a bit different, as you select a paper sack, based on type of meat -e.g. turkey, ham, gyro, vegan, etc. and then check the boxes on whatever toppings you like. Pretty fool-proof *except* if you're illiterate -that might present a problem- then again, you wouldn't be reading this review if you were, so should be a non-issue. Anyway, everything was very fresh and yummy. Even the iced tea was great, and they had lemonade on the soda fountain, so made an Arnold Palmer. Overall, just great! read more

Never been to a Which Which before Amber was very good at helping us through it. My only criticism is that if you are from Philly you understand that a Philly cheesesteak does not come with onions or peppers. This is also my first yelp review. read more

Extremely addictive! Great food and I love the LTO's! So many choices and shakes made with real ice cream! read more

Which Wich - Amazing location!! Great food, incredible atmosphere, and good value. - Sandwiches Near Me - Silverthorne, Colorado

So I have been to this location twice now while traveling and will always return. First time: I was traveling with my students for a debate meet and the really wanted Which Wich. I had called the location in Frisco at 8pm to let them know I had 15 people coming at 8:40 which there reply was "you know we close at 9 right?" In a very rude tone. So I called the Silverthorne location and asked if it would be ok to show up with that many people since by the time we would get there it'd be basically almost 9. There reply "no problem, we'll stay open a little late to make sure you get here" the greeted my whole group with a smile and our food was made fast and it was delicious. Second Time: I was having the absolute worst day (Flights cancelled, the delayed, diverted, then 6 hour drive) stopped there for dinner and they could tell my day was bad. The were so nice to me. They asked what was wrong and I told them and one employee made it his mission to make me smile and surprised me by buying me dinner just because...Literally the best employees EVER!!! They are all about the customer service and genuinely care. Thank you for always making my bad days a little brighter!!! read more

Came in today and had no idea how to order. I was looking at the menu and the guy working came right up to me and helped. I loved his energy and his positivity! read more

The Customer Service at this place is great. They do a wonderful job of keeping the store clean and moving at a decent pace even during busy hours. Love the small talk and the help that staff gives their customers. I come through Dillon once a month for work and try and stop here on each trip for a delicious sandwich. Nice work to this Which Wich franchise! read more

I love the Wicked, get it with some hummus it rocks. Staff is polite & I always look forward to eating here when I travel to Silverthorn. We don't have one in Wichita... Yet read more

Which Wich - Sandwiches Near Me - Silverthorne, Colorado

Great food and pretty fast definitely worth a try nice quick stop.im done writing but this dumb app makes you write more.

I love Which Wich and I really like this location. Friendly staff and great sandwiches

The best which Wich with the really cool employees. Very nice people and fun to talk to. Thanks Autumn, Amber and Gwen! You guys rock :)

Truly awful!!! Roast beef on the french dip was frozen and then opened the ajus container to find a straw wrapper floating in it. Won't go back and I don't recommend it to anyone. read more

So you want a crappy Quiznos sub at twice the price? Which Wich has you covered! If you look beyond the confusing and inefficient ordering system, the tremendous cost ($13.81 for a medium sub and a coke), and the hastily thrown together sandwich... You'll find a Which Wich. The meat - over salted. The vegetables - couldn't be bothered to be put in the bread. The wrapping - fantastically wasteful. Total fail. You could make dinner for three for about a buck more? read more

We stopped here for lunch out of curiousity and because I had a craving for a turkey, havarti and sprouts sandwich on whole wheat (and I didn't want to go to the grocery store, womp womp). Well, these guys don't offer havarti OR sprouts. So we both tried the Italian grinder which was pretty good - warm, toasty, not overly meat filled and lots of veggie topping options. The bread was decent, and I really detest most fast casual sandwich chains' breads - just the smell of Subway or Quizno's breads makes me want to puke. I also liked how efficient the ordering process is and how I could dilly dally on my decisions without holding up a line at the cash register. On the downside, our two medium subs plus a soda ran us $22. A large sub is $14 here before any add-ons. I could think of a lot of things I'd rather eat for the price. read more

They're sandwiches are alright, nothing special. But every time I go there the workers are extremely incompetent, be prepared to wait 15-20 minutes for a sandwich, even when there's only a couple other customers. Also, the workers have been very rude. read more

SKIP IT!!! WASTE OF $6.74. We stopped to grab a quick bite en route from Denver to Aspen. My boyfriend went to Chipotle next door and I have never had Which Which so thought I'd try it since I was in the mood for a sandwich. Since we just wanted to grab something & go I ordered something simple- the caprese sandwich with tomato, pesto, and mozz cheese. I thought this would be quick for them to put together and toast (since I ordered the "hot" version). I placed my order at 1:14pm thinking it would be ready in a few minutes. At 1:25pm it still was not ready. I was standing there waiting and the people working made no apologies for the wait or updated me on the status of my sandwich- I had to ask them how much longer it would be and then saw mine on the toaster behind several others. FINALLY- about 25 minutes later my sandwich is ready- by this time my boyfriend had ordered and finished his Chipotle order. I jumped into the car and we took off, unwrapped my sandwich to find out... the bread was completely burnt and the cheese on the inside was not even melted. There was a little bit of pesto and very few tomatoes. I can honestly say that this was one of the worst sandwiches I have EVER had not to mention really poor customer service in the restaurant. If you are looking for lunch in this area- go to Chipotle or even the fast food restaurants that are near by. If we hadn't been driving the opposite direction I would have gone back in to show them my sandwich and demand a refund. A very disappointing experience that I am happy to share so that others don't make the mistake that I did. Shame on you, Which Which. read more

I had never been to a Which Wich before, but am a big fan of toasted subs/sandwiches. I was a little overwhelmed by the # of ordering choices at first, so I asked an employee for a couple of recommendations. He recommended the following: Grinder - White bread, american cheese, spicy ranch, spinach, tomatoes with the hot pepper mix. OR Crab salad - White bread, american cheese spicy ranch, lettuce, crispy strings and garlic. I went with the medium Grinder and my girlfriend took a chance on the medium crab salad sandwich. A medium should suffice for the average person; I'd only attempt the large if I had the munchies ;) Best thing about ordering each, was the ability to split and share them both. To my surprise, I actually ended up liking the crab salad sub more (although my grinder was nothing to scoff at - very delicious, fresh and made to perfection). We washed them down with the most delicious Oreo-banana shake I had ever tasted. I will definitely be back as the overall experience was much more than you'd get at a typical 'chain' sub shop. The wait staff was super friendly, the restaurant was immaculate and the food was delicious; all in all, a great combination! read more

Outstanding sandwiches! After eating there I don't know why anyone would go to a chain sub-shop when this is the alternative!

Friendly staff all the way around. Someone greeted me as soon as I walked in. Hannah the cashier was very informative and helpful. She told me the promos and everything. Keep it up!! read more

I didn't know that there was a which which in the area and I ran across it by accident. This is a normal which which however like most chains the service is what makes the experience and this place is a more than a bit on the slow side. So the sandwiches are amazing but the service is laking. read more

Fresh, lots of choices and great for picky eaters: vegan, vegetarian, gluten frees. Except for the location on Colfax- horrible. They served my "un-which" in wilted, rusty lettuce. It was so bad I refused to eat it and have never been back. Too bad. read more

It was very busy at lunchtime but the manager came around and brought everyone fresh baked cookies to make up for the wait. All the employees were friendly and quick to help! read more

The food is always good here and I love their culture. The marketing team knows how to do it right. I also love that you get a free sandwich if you climb a 14'er. Note to management: PUT PEOPLE WHO SPEAK ENGLISH AT THE CASH REGISTER. She charged us wrong and didn't understand when we said we wanted chips and a drink... read more

Very slow service. Radio too loud and staff barely whispered names for orders. Could have gone to a restaurant for the same wait time and price of food. read more

There is always only one person working and she busts her butt.....but come on. One person to take orders and make sandwiches?? Whoever manages this restaurant, get it together. read more

Fast service and great food! Amber is great and the ordering process is fun. Will be coming back here instead of JJ's or Subway.

We walked into the Silverthorne location and were immediately greeted with smiles and friendliness. Christian and Tonya were especially helpful! I highly recommend this location. read more

One of the best Which Wich's I've ever been to. Ashlyn was super friendly to the whole party as we walked in and helped us get our orders straight because we were new to Which Wich. I had the meatball sub and an Oreo shake and both were fantastic! Highly recommend read more

Good sandwiches. Prices are decent, but you get a lot of sandwich. The staff was friendly and the line moved fast. Better than most fast food options in the area. read more

This is my first 5 star review... The customer service calls for it! Ordered a turkey club.. Noticed they forgot the bacon so I went up and asked for bacon, sat down realized they forgot the avocado too... Manager comes to register and refunds my money and makes me a new sand which herself.. Apologizing for their mistakes...and she delivered the sand which to my table... This is customer service at its finest! Thank you! read more

This store has management issues! Carries ONLY real sugar for iced teas! Had to go next door to Chipotle for Sweet & Low.

Not the first which wich I have been to. The staff put me off the first time they seemed more interested in visiting with someone on my side of the counter who was not ordering or picking up, so I went out and waited a bit. When I came back they filled my order and then went immediately outside to smoke with the person who they were visiting with earlier. Not horrible but just a little off. read more

We ate two 14" subs. One was chicken and the other one was cheese steak. Both with extra meat. Everything sounds great until...Surprise! We pay $40!!! Seriously?!? Why 2 stars? Because they have a lot less line than Chipotle next door. That adds them 1 star. Btw , the extra meat on my chicken was ham... Haha. Also the way you have to fill you order is extremely annoying! Never again... read more

I had a custom veggie sub and it was good. The veggies were better than I expect from a subway-type restaurant. Bread was decent. Didn't try anything else but it seems like a safe lunch stop before hitting the mountains. The ordering process can make for a deceivingly long queue, but the staff were super friendly and quick! Will stop again. read more

Awesome food and service after a long day of skiing! Tanya was very friendly and helpful.

Over-priced for ok food. I enjoy higher quality deli meats for this price. P.S. it is a franchise chain, under the orders of a big corporation. read more

Very clean spot to eat! Amazing concept, great food, and friendly staff! I would definitely recommend this sub shop to anyone vacationing in the area! Keep the Shrimp Po boy on the menu! read more