I am utterly disappointed in the public library system for San Jose. My experience today was filled with rude people and patronizing managers.
I was a student at San Jose State and I have been an active user of the libraries for years. I am a teacher in San Jose and I use the San Jose Public Library system for my classroom, as a resource for my students and their families, and as a personal resource for my family. All of that being said, I doubt I will be using it, or recommending it, in the future.
My story:
I requested two books that I thought might be good to add to the collection in my middle school classroom, but I wanted to read them before I buy them. The books took an extremely long time to get in, even though they didn't seem to have a waiting list, and when they finally did come in, I got the email right before a weekend. I have a family, and they have a busy life, so I couldn't get to the library that weekend. I am sure many people know how fast time flies over the weekend. The West Valley Branch is closed Sunday-Tuesday, so the next time I could go in was Wednesday. Unfortunately I had a church meeting that night. I had to rush home from work, feed my kidlet, and rush off to the meeting. Alas, no library. On Thursday I went to the library, literally less than 10 minutes after it closed, which was earlier then I realized, and so no book that day. The following day I flew out of town for the weekend. I went to the library today to pick up the books, which was the next day they were open, and they had not only returned the books to the "back room," but I had been charged for them. I was told, in a very condescendingly magnanimous way, that they had "waited until Wednesday as a courtesy since the books had actually hit the 7 business day mark the day before," a day in which they were closed. The books have totally disappeared and there is no way to get them back, again, even though there is no one on a waiting list for them. I noticed on the screen that the extremely rude assistant manager showed me that the books had been pulled at 11:19AM, but they were unavailable for me to check out now. That was when I saw the fee. I know that there is a fee if you don't pick up requested books, but I had never given it much thought. Well, it's $3.00 per book. I then was referred to the manager who apparently thought I was three and spoke to me like the witch probably spoke to Hansel and Gretel, and she ended up waiving the fees, after a tedious and long explanation about the library's policy. I also noticed at that time that there were three more fees for the same thing that I didn't realize I had even paid. Now, I admit it is kind of a sad testament to my life that I paid fees I didn't know I had, but I have a very active 4 year old who has inadvertently placed a book somewhere in the car and I have not realized I didn't return it until a few days too late. I have always paid those fines, because I know that it is my responsibility to return the books on time.
Why the outrage? Well, it's simple. I don't believe I am the only busy parent. I work about 35 minutes from the library, which happens to be close to my house though, and there are no libraries convenient to work. It is easiest to use the West Valley Branch. We have sports, church, friends, and family obligations, which again is not unusual in this area. All of that being said, when the library is closed three days out of seven, and has operating hours that mirror most work places, it is unreasonable to think that a family can always get there within a seven day time frame. There are some weeks that it simply won't happen. I think that is is fine to charge a fee for overdue books, although the price is quite high in my opinion, and I get why they don't want people to constantly request books and never pick them up, but there should be a fine after a specific number of books are not picked up, not after a set amount of days.
Sadly, no one in the library seemed to care. I can afford the fees, but there are many families who can't. I think that the way the library system in San Jose is being run will discourage families from using it, and I can't in good consciousness support them any longer. I also really dislike rude people, and I met several there today. read more