I have been to this pizzeria a few times but tried it again recently. We ordered a large cheese and…read morea chicken parm sandwich. The restaurant looked a bit dingy and the tables were covered with leftover cups and plates that wasn't cleared away. The cashier and pizza person left the dirty tables and it was gross because there was no where to sit that was clean. The areas with spices and trash area wasn't tidy or clean either. Instead they spent most of the time talking with each other and hanging out. The chicken parm was generously sized and came cut in half. The sandwich was okay. The sandwich came packed with thinly sliced chicken cutlet but there was barely any sauce and the flavor was kind of bland. I felt like it they didn't add any spice to the sauce or the chicken. The pizza was okay. The crust was hard and dry with no flavor at all. The pizza was average and had a decent amount of cheese to sauce. It's not the best nor the worst pizza I had. They charge a fee for credit card and tax isn't included in the price.

Food - the best tasting pizza on Victory Blvd Service -…read morePerfect Ambiance - Real, authentic, and I can be myself

I'll start by saying, that no, this is not going to be the best pizza in NY/NJ, but I will say it…read moreis above average in quality and quantity compared to most pizza in the area, and they DO have gems that make them superior to every other pizzeria. After years of being a customer, I can say without a doubt that their standard NY slice is likely the best in the Great Kills/Eltingville/Oakwood/Annadale area, and I believe it competes with Frank & Danny's, Mimmo's, and The Pizza Parlor. Keep in mind it's traditional though, unlike Nonna's which uses spots of fresh mozzarella on an extra thin crust. I've tried at least 50% of their entire menu and I must say, you rarely ever go wrong in terms of consistency with a good pie. Not many "bad days" recorded. Pizzaioli stands above all the rest by having the absolute greatest Buffalo pie. Fresh or reheated, it's the best Buffalo slice you can get in the entire Northeast from all my excursions. I do not like buffalo chicken, yet Pizzaioli makes a Buffalo pie using traditional Italian chicken cutlets, fresh mozzarella, and the best Buffalo sauce I've ever tasted in my entire life. I would pay any amount for a Buffalo pie from them and I'm blown away each and every time no matter what. This is an unforgettable slice you'll try and want every day. Prices are reasonable, and they do offer good online deals using their online ordering site, or on the Slice app. The workers are extremely kind, courteous, friendly, and always willing to cater to you. I even told them that my entire household has COVID, and to leave the pizza on the front step and leave it to not spread it. Upon getting the pizza inside and opening the box, I see a very kind message that made my family happy and appreciative of doing business here. They're not "Just another NY pizza spot on the corner" like so many pizzerias are, where they don't have anything special to offer, but you're getting a good slice regardless. Pizzaioli is above that, and though I don't think they're trying to be the "best," what they offer is still original in taste enough to differentiate it from the rest. If Joe & Pat's and Denino's is the Superman of pizza, Pizzaioli is the Batman of pizza, because Superman is the strongest we know, but Batman uses unique abilities to sometimes even outshine and defeat the strongest. Get yourself some Batman! I want to mention that their Rolls & Calzones are absolutely incredible too. Friends and family love their Sausage Roll especially, but I love their Chicken Bacon Alfredo Roll myself. They also have a killer Hot Honey Pepperoni pie!

Loved the grandma! Solid choice for pizza on a cold rainy day. Not to mention the chicken vodka…read moreroll. Fuego.

Casa Nino's is Fantastic!!!…read more All of their food is fantastic we normally order the half trays and the Pizza we have no complaints everything is always fresh, hot and arrives on time with their delivery service. My family threw me a surprise birthday party there for me and it was fantastic and all the guests were extremely happy also with the food and the service. The staff is also fantastic there

I order food from here all the time. Great place they always get my order right. Food is great and…read morewhen I call to place my order they're friendly!

Always excellent when delivered but yesterday we stopped inside to order and the staff and owner…read morewere fantastic and kind. There are many options in this area but Metro really stands out. This is the type of local neighborhood business you want to support. Excellent vodka pie.

Food is decent, but they charge higher prices than listed on the menu. They charged me $14 for a…read morepersonal pie that is $10 on their menu, and refused to honor the price in both the menu I got in the mail, and on their website. Too many good restaurants that are similar to this one in the neighborhood to come back here, if they're not going to be transparent about pricing.

I can't rave enough bout the calamari pizza! The fried calamari pieces had a good crunch, not flat…read moreat all. Good flavor. Friendly staff. They had other pizza slices that I'm definitely eyeing for next time. Pay in cash, there's a discount.

They added a gelato machine. You have to check it out. The coffee gelato is delicious.read more

The best pizza!!!! Food is the best!!! Always delicious!!! I wish they delivered closer ... but…read morethen again.... It's too good to not order all the time!

My review is purely based on take out of a cheese pizza…read more Food- 2/5- The pizza we ordered honestly was not the best. It could've just been my pizza pie, but when we started eating it, it was cold (not the fault of the pizzeria as we had to drive back home) and a bit dry + hard. My biggest disappointment in the pizza was the taste. I honestly felt like it taste a bit cardboard like. The dough was too tough and the crust was definitely thin. You can tell from the photos. Service 5/5- Great lady working behind the counter. I could tell they had a passion for what they did. They treat their customers with respect. The sweetest lady I've ever met. Ambiance 5/5- Regular pizza take our spot with a fantastic lady behind the counter. My only suggestion for the pizzeria is to improve the ratio of cheese and sauce. That may add to the taste as the pizza felt like I was eating cardboard. 3/5 - great ambiance and service, pizza not too great.

I've been ordering pizza from Village Maria for a decade, and simply, they always come through…read more They just sell good New York pizza, prices are competitive, and their food is consistently good. On the rare occasion that they mess something up, they make it right. They are always pretty fast on their delivery, as well. I've tried a ton of pizza places on the north shore, but I always keep coming back here. They've earned a customer as long as I'm still here. It's not an artisanal pizza restaurant, but rather more of a classic NYC pizza joint.

Ordered a beef patty with cheese, a Sicilian slice, and a buffalo chicken slice. Everything came…read moreout quickly and was served hot. The buffalo chicken slice was a little oily, but it still had great flavor. The restaurant was nice, cozy, and made for a pleasant dining experience. Overall, a good spot for a quick bite!

I had a great experience at Mr experience the guy in the front convinced us to dine in , from there…read morewe were shown to our table and given menus so many options to choose from I missed a whole section lol . I order a traditional Cesar salad with no Cesar dressing with Italian dressing on the side (one of the best salads I had in a long time and a sausage , pepper and onion hero it was okay I felt it could of been better with a sauce / mayo or something it's a little dry and one half was toasted a little to long . The restaurant had a old Italian restaurant vibe with family oriented vibes which I enjoyed

We order from here quite often. Certain dishes are excellent. Service is good but the more popular…read morethey get expect wait times. We love their vodka sauce. They used to make a chicken dish with spicy rigatoni but they took it off the menu. If in the neighborhood check them out.