Wow! I live in Los Angeles and this is one of the most delicious Italian restaurants I've ever been too! Well done! The bread is sooo good! We also had the Aracinni which I highly recommend. Loved the arugula salad too- wonderful dressing! I had the mushroom Risotto, which was to die for! My mom had the Rigatoni bolonise which she loved! BTW, their portions are extremely generous, enough to split or take home for another meal! I just wish I lived closer so I could come here more often! Certainly a great excuse to visit Reedley! I should mention too, Grace was our waiter and she was incredibly kind and efficient! Thank you Valentino's for a great meal and evening! ​ read more

We had a fabulous dinner at Valentino's in Reedley, CA! The restaurant is beautifully decorated, with comfortable seating and a thoughtful, patient team of servers. The menu offers a wonderful variety to suit every taste, along with an excellent selection of cocktails and wines. The unique appetizers, handmade pastas, eggplant parmigiana, and fresh-from-the-oven breads were absolutely delicious. We're still thinking about the meal and can't wait to return to try more of the menu. Thank you to the entire team for a fantastic dining experience! read more

See all

The service was incredibly slow, after over an hour they still had not even started marking out pizza. It took nearly 30 minutes to get non alcoholic drinks. The staff was friendly enough but the place has really gone down hill since the ownership change. read more

Valentino's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Reedley, California

Thought I would leave another review since they will be closing soon... great people, clean and amazing food read more

See all

Oh my gosh! The service was above and beyond! The environment was perfect for the moment. And the food was a million times better than I expected! The owner I give him 100%!!!! Him greeting us at the table and offering and recommending dishes a million thank you's! Then clam chowder my husband had or thought he had cus I think I ate it all, oh my gosh! Really'! Clam chowder was amazing! 100 percent! I want to come back tomorrow! The wine selection is above and beyond! The entire night out with the hubby was 100/100! read more

See all

It was our first time here and with it being just a 30min drive from where we live, we will definitely be dining here again! When we walked it was a simple yet home feel vibe. We were seated quickly on Friday evening at 7pm. The service was excellent and everyone was working together to be sure we were taken care of. Then our food came and it was even better. Fresh and delicious! We had the garlic bread appetizer, it was homemade to the perfect toast and flavor! I had the fettuccine Alfredo, it was creamy and light, not really heavy. We ended with tiramisu for dessert and it's by far the best I've had in our area! So grateful for a wonderful dinner! read more

See all

Absolutely delicious Italian food in the heart of Downtown Reedley. The owners and staff are so welcoming and the family environment is very enjoyable! read more

Valentino's Pizzeria - Eggplant Parmesan. - Pizza Near Me - Reedley, California

Absolutely delicious amazing food. Polite, respectful, professional staff. And the owner is the nicest man you could ever meet. Go there, you won't regret it . read more

Service was incredibly slow! Only 2 other tables with customers in the restaurant. We ordered our food at 5:20 and at 6 they hadn't started making our pizza so unfortunately we had to leave without eating.. We won't be back. read more

Whatever Grandma says goes, right? My Grandma's friend told her that Valentino's Pizzeria was good. She requested we go there for dinner to check it out. I left underwhelmed but she said it was adequate. Being a family-owned business, you can feel it right when you enter. The restaurant is spacious, pleasantly decorated, and homey. Every staff member was polite, friendly, and respectful. The restaurant was busy and the staff seemed disoriented. Getting our order taken and food delivered took a while. Some of our family's entrees came out faster than others; it felt like we were waiting more rather than enjoying our meal. The restaurant serves mainly pizzas and pasta. The one great thing is the portion sizes for the price--plenty for leftovers which we took home. My Dad had the Mostaccioli it sounded great but was pretty basic in flavor. My Grandma and I shared the Tortellini with Pesto. The dish was swimming in pesto and a bit salty for my preference. My Grandma also ordered a Calzone which wasn't her favorite. I'd say skip the pasta as it's something that can be whipped up at home and go for something else. There aren't many restaurants in Reedley, so for the small town it is, it's one of the limited options for a meal. As someone visiting, I felt that everything fell short in terms of the food and being acknowledged. Find them off G Street with parking out front. read more

See all

We had an amazing dinner tonight! The service was fantastic and the food was delicious! It's so great to have a place in Reedley to come and have a great meal and a great glass of wine! They carry Daou, Tobin James, Opolo, J Lohr and so many other great others. read more

Valentino's Pizzeria - Eggplant Parmigiana - Pizza Near Me - Reedley, California

Amazing night at Valentino's tonight! Pizza and eggplant parmigiana was delicious. Calzone's the size of the plate!! Service was on point. We got to meet the owners and amazing staff! The newer atmosphere and wine selection are exciting. We can't wait to come back! read more

Valentino's Pizzeria - Eggplant and Wine! - Pizza Near Me - Reedley, California

Awesome pizza! If you haven't tried it in a while, be sure to go back and try it again! The pizza tastes like it did with the original owners, many years ago. We have a new Friday night tradition. Looking forward to trying their full meals. read more

After nine incredible years of dining out with my wife, I can confidently say that this restaurant offers the best service we've ever experienced! From the moment we walked in, we were greeted with warmth and efficiency, and I was seated almost immediately. While researching the restaurant, I noticed a lack of recent food photos, but I completely forgot to snap one myself--the dishes arrived looking so mouthwatering that they vanished before I had a chance! I ordered a calzone customized to mirror "The Works" pizza, and it was a flavor explosion. My wife indulged in the tortellini pesto with steak, which she raved about throughout the meal. The service was truly exceptional, creating an inviting atmosphere that made our dining experience memorable. I can't imagine any other restaurant surpassing this level of care and attention. I will definitely be back try the rest of the menu Don't listen to any of the lower star reviews hahahahhah read more

I've been there twice now since new ownership. Great food! The new owner's are very nice! Thank you!

My guy Doc and I absolutely love Valentino's and we highly recommend! The quality of the food and service is great! Everyone is very nice and you can tell the owner has a genuine passion for what he's doing there and we definitely appreciate that and will continue to come back. There is a bit of a wait for the food but nothing too bad at all, that's because the food is fresh - and very reasonably priced - they feed you! So far, we have tried calzone a couple different ways, fettucine alfredo - once with chicken and once with shrimp, the meatballs, a beautiful Tuscan zuppa soup and dinner salad. All sooo delicious and fresh, homemade quality with fresh ingredients you can really taste. The meatballs are made with tri-tip and they're so flavorful and meaty, not full of breading etc which I can't stand. I usually avoid ordering meatballs anywhere but I definitely order them from Valentino's! We haven't tried their pizza yet, but soon! It definitely looks and smells really good The place is comfortable, very clean and inviting. All around a great, locally owned business with fresh food made from scratch with good pricing and excellent service read more

The food was amazing. Staff is very friendly and the owner when he's not busy helping his team, greets and talks to guests. Great prices. We will definitely be going back many times and look forward to introducing our family and friends to this gem. read more

Wow, What an incredible meal in the quiet small town of Reedley. After a day of thrifting and pumpkin patch exploring we found this small family owned "Valentino's Italian Restaurant" located in the center of downtown. As soon as we walked in the door we had great expectations. We were greeted immediately by two very friendly waitresses who worked together to clear a table by the front window my wife requested. Within a minute our table was set with a new tablecloth, cloth napkins, silverware, & candle. After looking over the wine list we had a couple questions our waitress was unsure about so she asked the owner. Dan came over to our table and introduced himself then asked us a few questions about our price point and taste preferences. He guaranteed us we'd like his selection or we could try something else. He wasn't wrong, Dan picked us out a bottle of Ghost Pines Merlot from Napa. A very nice merlot with notes of dark berry fruit, chocolate, and vanilla with a smooth finish. It paired amazingly well with our meal. As for the meal... I hope you're hungry, the portions are HUGE and delicious. We started with bread & salad. The house-made bread was served with olive oil & balsamic vinegar. The antipasti salad was loaded with salami, pepperoni, black olives, tomatoes, artichoke hearts, pepperoncini, pickled carrots, cauliflower, mozzarella cheese & croutons. Dan also recommended the housemaid ranch dressing. Again his recommendation did not miss. It's hard to describe ranch dressing because in the end it's just ranch dressing but this was garlicky and savory, really the best ranch dressing I've ever had. For the entrées... Wow! My wife was served an extra large portion of Eggplant Parmesan, and I ordered a split plate of 1/2 lasagna and 1/2 beef ravioli. I believe both dishes were served using the same delicious red sauce. Chefs Kiss! For dessert we highly recommend the spumoni ice cream. Mmm, mmm, mmh! read more

See all

BACK IN THE 80s 90s was the best Pizza .its nothing close to what it was.They made a lot of changes .not good ones

Food is delicious, plenty of options and service is outstanding. I was there for a birthday part but will definitely be going back. My only issue with them is the hours of business on a weekend. I was craving Valentinos tonight but they are only open until 8pm on a friday night. I guess I will have to take care of this craving another time. read more

Holy RAVIOLI... where do I PASTA-bly begin? If you are lookin for some tasty, delicious, and affordable Italian food, then look no further! Valentino's has everything your tummy is searchin for! I am not just sayin this to say it, one thing about me is my reviews are nothin but the truth, Janice don't lie! Now let me tell you... Food? Impeccable! My girls and I got the Gourmet Chicken Pizza and added garlic!!! My oh my, do I love my garlic. We also got the Tortellini With Alfredo Sauce!!!! Yea... I'd get it again. If you are gonna take anything out of this review... GET THE CRACKER BREAD!! It is a must, I guarantee you will like it, and if you don't, see a doctor. read more

See all

Excellent Service. A bit of a wait but only to be accompanied by unmatched quality. A gem in Reedley. Do not hesitate to find out for yourself. . So satisfying! read more

Valentino's Pizzeria - Meatball sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Reedley, California

Great place to eat wonderful beautiful people that work there. I love their soups. This guy makes a different kind all the time good salad with ranch. Their pizzas is very good too very relaxing place to go have your meal. read more

I just had an extra large works with extra sauce pizza. It was absolutely delicious! If you don't live in Reedley, it would definitely be worth the drive! read more

My wife has renal disease and has to have her food prepared without salt and other ingredients that may compromise her health, the new owner was very accommodating in ensuring that she had a safe and delicious meal. She has the Salmon with grilled veggies and a small portion of plain pasta. I had the ribeye and pasta which was excellent. Same small town feel with a revived family atmosphere. We've come to Valentino's for decades and the new owner has continued the traditions of the original owners. read more

Zero stars. We waited an hour and a half, with six little kids, and had to walk out because they hadn't started making our food yet. Our server, instead of being apologetic, said "well you didn't have a reservation." read more

Pizza is great and the house wine too! I like the house salad and vinaigrette dressing. Cozy atmosphere.

Excellent food . Let me just start with how good the service is and how friendly and attentive the owner . I loved the pizza and the dessert. We will definitely be back. read more

Valentino's Pizzeria - Dessert - Pizza Near Me - Reedley, California

Absolutely outstanding! From the moment we walked in, the warm aroma of garlic and fresh basil let us know we were in for something special. Every dish--from the silky handmade pasta to the perfectly seasoned entrées--tasted like it came straight from a Nonna's kitchen. The service was attentive without being intrusive, and the ambiance struck the perfect balance of cozy and elegant. Easily one of the best Italian dining experiences in town! read more

Best Italian food around service is top notch I recommend trying the meatballs and the sausage. Both are delicious homemade.

My husband and I went to Valentino's for the first time under the new owners and had a great meal! It's not a huge menu but they do have the staples. My husband loved his chicken parm and the chicken in my dish was perfectly tender and juicy. I wouldn't get the grilled chicken entree again only because the pasta wasn't really in a sauce, it was more like olive oil with some chunks of sun-dried tomato. Our server was excellent and presented everything with a flourish. There is only beer and wine and I would have preferred it have a cocktail, but we felt everything was reasonably priced. We went a little extra with wine and appetizers and still got out for around $100. read more

Valentino's Pizzeria - View from across the street - Valentino's parklet with the water towers in the background - Pizza Near Me - Reedley, California

Elvedin guy from Bosnia, I brought my whole family for some pizza clam chowder soup and ofcourse the best Tiramisu ! Food was so delicious we enjoyed every minute spent in the restaurant ! read more

Original and authentic. Atmosphere is Italian and service is commendable. Their sauce is pretty good.

Bruschetta 5/5 Lasagna 5/5 Tortellini 5/5 You can tell the owner takes pride in his product. He was very friendly and excited to share about their new ingredients. We have been there before and liked it but this time the food was amazing. Tiramisu was excellent as well. New favorite spot in town. read more

The food was absolutely amazing. The pizza was unbelievable. All organic ingredients made in house. They even make sausage that's to die for. Haven't had a slice like this in years, reminds me of home. The atmosphere here is heavenly. The place looks like it was renovated yesterday, but still has that classic feel about it. Not only is the food and atmosphere exceptional, the service is next level. Attentive, charismatic, knowledgeable, and especially friendly! The owners are some of the kindest people around and do everything in their power to keep this amazing restaurant running. This is the kind of place you can safely recommend to your girlfriend's Italian grandfather. No doubt the best pizza in California. Must try!! read more

Food and service was amazing! Dan was kind enough to customize an order for us and it was to die for. Overall great experience and highly recommended. read more

Valentino's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Reedley, California

New owners is amazing and friendly! And food is fantastic too! Here my favorite: I would take ravioli with Alfredo sauce, tortellini with Alfredo sauce, and calzone with extra cheese and meatball and fresh mushroom. And in room it's pretty cool it's kinda mixed " diner old time style with Italy vibes. There's picture of Italy map in there its pretty cool too! Differently start come back more. Also it's feels like family and friendly because of new owners welcome and treat us like "home". Take care! Hope it's going amazing! read more

This is a family owned Reedley business since 1963! Wow! It is still popular on Friday evenings. Luckily we only had a short wait to be seated. Old school vibe-they have a cute window seat table. Friendly service from the busy staff. We tried soup, salad, and one of their signature pizzas. I really enjoyed the minestrone soup, fresh and pepper-spicy in a great way. The pizza toppings were delicous and plentiful. Our pizza tasted great the next day after the microwave. Downtown Reedley is very nice, plenty of parking and a coffee shop and candy shop close by. read more

My friends and I had wanted to try out the pizza from Valentino's for awhile, so that's what we did. Valentino's has a very affordable pizza special that we took advantage of (ask about it in-house, but I believe it's something like two large, two-topping pizzas for roughly $35). All five of us ate VERY well with multiple slices per person. There were roughly 12 slices per pie. This would be a nice place to have a casual family pizza dinner in a relaxed environment. My favorite pizza of the two we ordered was the pepperoni and olive. I would revisit Valentino's just for that pizza alone. I was not a huge fan of the sausage and pepperoni pizza, but my friends enjoyed it, so perhaps it's just a matter of taste. The pizzas have a thin, crunchy crust (my favorite), that is just as good as the pizza itself. If you're a habitual crust-tosser like myself, you'll find that these crusts are worth the eat. The restaurant was clean and dimly lit in the evening (mood lighting). The wait time for food was good, and the owner is friendly, but the service from the waitress was "okay". She seemed kind of detached and uninterested, but she got our orders in and got everything out on time so I'm not losing any sleep over it. I'd come here for pizza again! It's nice to find a good pizza place that isn't obnoxiously loud and that has a full menu with other options for friends and family that might want to eat something else. Perhaps I'll explore the rest of the menu since Valentino's offers a full Italian menu. read more

Valentino's Pizzeria - Pepperoni pizza with sausage. - Pizza Near Me - Reedley, California

See all

We are back! They make true NY pizzas. Great soup, cheese pizza, and the special meat pizza are the best! Both served on NY pizza crust! I had to have cheese ravioli! Had the meat last time and both are great! My husband gave the pizza a thumbs and New York approve! He even wore his Babe Ruth Yankee shirt! We are bring the leftovers home! Don't miss this wonderful place! read more