We found a leak in our tire while on vacation in the area. Given that it's the only garage in the area and we had no other options, we were worried that it was going to cost us a fortune to have the car fixed. We asked around and were told that Main Street Garage was great. We went in and told them what was going on with our car. They had great customer service and our mechanic was friendly, knowledgeable and efficient. After about half an hour, he had patched the tire and topped up the air in the three others. Even better, it cost us less that $20 for the repair! We feel really grateful for the great service, very reasonable pricing, and quick turnaround time. read more

Fixed my issues quickly. Friendly and knowledgeable staff. Good prices on tires as well.

Very poor ownership the owner Ray was sitting right there when I was complaining about being charged four hours of labor when it took two hours to fix my vehicle the mechanic Jordan did a really good job on the work and was able to get it done in a timely matter I do appreciate himunfortunately you should not ever charge a customer more than what you're actually doing the work for I should've only been charged two hours labor not four horrible business. read more

Fairplay is fortunate to have Utopia Tire. We have used them several times for oil changes on both of our vehicles as well as other issues we've had. Polite and excellent team. Fair pricing, fast service and quality work. Thanks to Utopia once again! read more

I made arrangements last week to have my van worked on. I was informed to bring it in the following Monday at 8am. It should only take a hour. At 10:15 I asked what is going on ? We are waiting on part. I said I gave you a deposit last week so you could get the part. We are in the mountains. I politely asked for my deposit back. He expected me to wait all day. read more

We were on the road and had some issues with the transition slipping. The shop had a full schedule, but Jordan fit us in and was able to get us back on the road. They were very accommodating and helpful! read more

Scheduled oil change and tire rotation and all went well and was completed in a timely manner. The waiting room was clean and comfortable and free Wi-Fi was available. read more

My car broke down over the weekend and I was lucky enough to be right by Utopia. I left my key in the drop box and they got back to me by 9:30 Monday with a full diagnosis. It wasn't good news but I really appreciate that they were so prompt, as I was from out of town. They let me leave my car there for a few days while I worked out a long distance tow. Great service! read more

If I could give zero stars I would. I brought my car to these guys on 3 consecutive days to learn each time they could not perform the work in any reasonable time frame. The issue was brakes and all I can say is that it is not fair to have a client wait all day for a brake job especially when parts were pre ordered. It seems they cannot provide appointments or more to the point stick to them. On the third day I was then told sheepishly after I had waited 4 hours that the previous person's job had 'run over' and they would try to get to my car before closing after coming at 8 am. I simply canceled the job, found a shop in Denver who indicated the parts they ordered were not good quality and happily dod the work for half the price. Rather go to Denver and come back in half the time these guys were doing the repair. I also have to add that if you are doing anything beyond tires I don't think these guys have the expertise and it is real hit and miss. They should not advertise themselves as a generalmshop, they are not and simply exist due to lack of competition in Fairplay. If you want a job done within the promised time and with assured quality, DON'T COME HERE! read more

Was able to get us in last minute on a coolant leak during a cross country road trip.

This is the best repair shop in the High Rockies. They get the job done right and have fair pricing. Definitely local friendly too.

Always great, reliable service. The folks at Utopia are incredibly knowledgeable, friendly and always ready to answer your questions and explain things really well. I recommend Utopia without any reservations whatsoever. read more

Our car was disabled outside of Fairplay in the evening hours and towed to Utopia Tire & Service in Fairplay. We were pleased with the communication and timely repair of the vehicle, even when parts had to be ordered. Everyone at Utopia Tire & Service was friendly, professional, provided quality service and value to get this car back on the road. Thank you! read more

Had a soft tired and needed to fill up with air. I don't trust grocery stores or gas stations for air pump so I stopped by Main Street garage. They were casual and helpful, super nice. The gentleman who took care of our tire was friendly and professional. Although it's not like you have many options in the area, still, I think you'd be taken care of here, based on this one experience. read more

Installed 4 tires on my truck and changed the oil while I waited in a timely manner. They were professional and courteous.

I was driving through from Denver to get to Crestone for an event. On my way through I hit a nail and almost had to get towed all the way from FairPlay back to Denver. But when I swung by they got my tire patched and fixed with a smile on their face in less than 30 minutes. It's a lovely local business with a super cute dog as well. I didn't care about the price as I'm just lucky it was here and they were so kind. read more

Very very busy shop. We had a diagnostic done. I wish it didn't take as long as it did, but I also understand they were very busy. Thanks for taking care of us. If we're ever in the area with car troubles, we will be back! read more

We were staying in Fairplay and one of our tires got a bubble in it and was spewing air. They were able to get to it within a few hours to see if it was able to be patched. Unfortunately, it was not. A tire needed to be ordered from Denver. We called the next day to see when we could pick up the new tire. But we had a miscommunication with the gal on the phone. We thought she ordered the tire and she thought we were going to call her back to tell us if we wanted to order a tire. I don't know how the ball got dropped. It could have been cell service or lack there of. We could have said order a tire and she never heard that. Anyway, the tire was ordered and came in the next day. We were driving back from Buena Vista and received a text that it was ready but we were not going to make it on time and they weren't open until Monday. So we paid for it on the phone and they said they'd leave it outside for us. When we arrived 25 minutes after they closed, it was not where they said they were going to leave it. Thankfully, a nice gentleman hoped out of his truck and said he worked there and could help us. (Whew!). Overall, we had a good experience besides the miscommunication about ordering the tire. They sent regular text updates and were very friendly. read more

My truck broke down and I towed it to Main Street Garage on a Friday and they said it wouldn't be until Monday that they could get to it. I called on Wednesday after not hearing from them, and they said they were backed up but they'd get to it tomorrow. I called a week later, again they promise they'll look at it tomorrow. Call another week later, they still haven't looked at the truck. Finally, 6 weeks after bringing it to them, they had a chance to look at it and it turns out the problem had fixed itself (electrical system had gotten wet, now it was dry and it started just fine). It's my work truck so it was really frustrating that it took them 6 weeks just to look at it and tell me nothing was wrong. Especially since they kept telling me they'd get to it the next day, each time I called they gave me a false promise. It set me back quite a bit not having my truck for that long, I would've taken it somewhere else had I known that would happen. Then they charged me $50 for looking at it after all of that. I'll never do business with them again if I can help it. read more

We had a tire issue during our visit to Fairplay on 8/23/23. We stopped in (the correct business name is Utopia Tire & Service) and the staff were so kind to us! While we had to wait while they completed other vehicles, they communicated with us the whole time. They were able to patch up our tire and get us back on the road for a VERY reasonable price! We are forever grateful to the team at Utopia! read more

I normally only take my vehicle to the Muffler Amigos on Federal and Colfax, but these guys are even better! Would give 10 out of 10 if I could. read more

Utopia Tire Fairplay - Tires Near Me - Fairplay, Colorado

We were camping with middleschoolers last week in the beautiful Horseshoe Campground near Mt. Sherman. Somehow the latch to our passenger door on the 15 person van broke. It obviously would have been unsafe to travel this way. It was late in the day, but I called Main Garage and they were extremely helpful. Told us to come in and they would look at it. Mitch the owner and team evaluated and fixed it expertly and with suoer customer service! Thank you to their office staff and mechanical expertise and friendliness toward tourists!!! They saved us a lot of headache! read more

We were off-roading with our son in his Toyota 4Runner up Mosquito Pass. His car started making a noise, and we took it into Main Street Garage to get it checked out. Chip helped us quickly solve the problem even though they were super busy. Thanks Chip! read more

During a trip from Santa Fe to Denver, my partner's car broke down - stopped running - a short distance from Main Street Garage in a pretty heavy snow storm. The car was towed by AAA just before closing. Fearing the car was unrepairable, MSG gave him hope that it could be fixed the next day. And fixed it was. They went out of their way to get it done first thing so that he could be on his way. Throughout what was a difficult ordeal for him, they were helpful, positive and very competent. He made it to Denver and back with no further incident. Too bad we aren't closer! We would both take our cars there! read more

Car had a flat tire, they fixed it in less than a hour and we were on the road again. THANK YOU Main Street Garage very appreciative for their speedy service. read more

Lucky there isnt a lower rating. Total rip off. Overpriced, and cant get a repair done without having multiple attempts. And you pay for each attempt. Dont learn your trade on my dime. Takes weeks to get a simple repair done, and then it wasnt done correct. The owner, Chip, is arrogant beyond imagination. Horrible customer service. Its the only game in town, hope another shop opens, this place should be investigated for fraud. Take your car anywhere but here. read more

After driving our minivan down CR 18 and hiking the Limber Grove Trail, we discovered that the front driver's tire was flat. We put on the spare and dropped off the flat tire at Main Street Garage towards the end of the day. The next day, after pressure and bead testing the tire, they called and said that nothing was wrong with it. We must have hit a hole that unseated the tire enough to cause a slow leak. When I picked up the tire, they handed me an invoice for $0.00 and refused to accept payment, even when I said I owed them something for their time and trouble. Since then I have driven the minivan from Alma to DIA to Fort Collins and then from Fort Collins to the Chicago area and had no problems with the tire. Thanks Grace and Jack! read more

I like the owner he is a great person. Is hard to find good quality employees but the owner himself is a good person he is not out there trying to get people he works every day, poor guy. If someone is being ripped off here when he is not around he needs to know. Is hard to write anything bad about this place when the owner will break his back to make it right for anyone. My truck got too old now I have a new one. I had never met anyone who had met Chip the owner in person said anything wrong about him. When I have a problem I ask to speak to him his employees don't like that they will act as jealous wives but is his business let him know employees can closed down someone else business, the owner needs to be know no matter what and if he can't fix the problem is what it is is a small town Chip will do what he can to make you happy. read more

We had some car trouble on our way to Fairplay from Iowa. Main Street Garage was able to look at our van within 24 hours. Super friendly, great value. They had us on our way to enjoy the rest of our vacation. Thank you so much! read more

I was in Fairplay for work and got a nail in my tire that was leaking pretty bad so I stopped into Main Street garage at about 9am. They were super busy and their original estimate was that they could squeeze me in in the afternoon sometime. However, they were able to get me in much sooner and I was on my way about two hours later. Being as busy as they are, it was a huge courtesy to get me out that fast and I really appreciate it! read more

Helped us with unscheduled repairs while we were on vacation and in the middle of a snow storm! Staff is kind and knowledgeable. They made us comfortable, worked to diagnose the problem and got us back on the road so that we didn't miss our evening reservation. Had no other auto issues the remainder of our 10-day trip. Auto garages sometimes have the reputation of ripping people off, but for $150 these folks saved our vacation. Highly recommend! read more

I had a flat tire in near Frisco, Colorado this morning. I put the flimsy donut tire on around 5:30 AM on the way to Alma, Colorado to climb some 14er mountains. I did a Google search for the nearest tire repair shop to Alma. Main Street Garage in Fairplay came up as the nearest place. I pulled in and within 15 minutes, I had a repaired tire and I was on my way to Aspen. As soon as I pulled up they had a guy out there taking the flat tire out of my hands within 1 minute. These guys are quick and no-nonsense. I paid my $18 and was on my way. Highly, highly recommended! read more

I have been coming here for 8 years. They repair all my vehicles and do a great job! I got 4 new tires today from Jack- he's amazing. I highly recommend and their prices are the same as Denver read more

I had just moved to the area and blew a tire. I received wonderful service from both the tow truck driver and from the garage! Unfortunately, my tire was unrepairable, but by the next morning I had 4 new tires and was back to work by noon. Kendra and Miguel were so helpful! read more

stopped with nail in a tire 2 guys standing around doing nothing said we cant get to it young man outside extremely rude i ask if i could just jack it up there and put the spare on refused to let me do that horrible service lazy i would very much recommend not even trying cannot say enough bad things about this shop read more

Quick, courteous, and reasonably priced. Did not take advantage of an out-of-state traveler. Friendly service

My clutch went out on my way to the mountains from Denver. Main St did a great job on my 2000 Jeep. I was very impressed with the work they did, the timeliness of the repair and the fairness of the price. I considered towing my truck back to Denver, as it turned out the repair cost was similar to the tow expense alone. Busy, well organized shop with excellent communication. I highly recommend Mains St read more

I was on vacation in Fairplay for a week. On the last night, the tire on my rental car went flat. The spare tire was also flat (thanks, Avis!). To make my flight in Denver the next morning, my best option was to have the tire repaired rather than have Avis bring me another car. I was at Main Street Garage when they opened. They worked my tire repair in so that I could make my flight. They had me on the road in less than 30 minutes for a very reasonable price. If you ever have car trouble near Fairplay, you should go to Main Street Garage. read more

Drove into town at 4:45 on a Friday afternoon and heard a funny noise coming from drivers front tire. Nicest folks in the world checked out our car and found all four wheels lug nuts loose. Fixed that then wouldn't charge us. Only problem is feeling a bit guilt now. They will get our business. read more

Staff was so accommodating! My gas pedal stopped working right in Fairplay while driving back to Denver. The staff here was so friendly and accommodating, it was a busy day being right after Christmas and they were able to send me on my way safe and sound. Great customer service! Thanks from Laura and Cooper read more