I have been wanting to try this place for months because there is literally always a line out the door, and now I get it. I finally stopped in on a Sunday night and was so impressed. The line moved fast, the shop was super clean, and everyone was genuinely SO nice. One of the owners actually scooped and packed my ice cream herself, and she was incredibly kind. Three very generous scoops for $10 in the South End is also kind of amazing. Nothing felt skimpy or overpriced. It is just a really cute, tiny neighborhood shop that seems to be doing everything right. You can tell the owners actually care about the business and the people coming through the door. Definitely worth the line, and I really hope they stick around! read more

I stopped by Uncommon Ice Cream while visiting Boston and thought it was a cute spot. The shop is very small, but the bright red exterior makes it easy to notice from the street. There did not seem to be much seating on the ground level, and it felt pretty tight with people waiting in line. I noticed a staircase, so there may be more space upstairs, but I did not have an opportunity to check. The flavor list was the best part. They had a lot of interesting options, including Campfire S'mores, Watermelon Mint Sorbet, Peanut Butter and Jelly, Cinnamon Cornbread and Jam, Toasted Coconut Cream Pie, and 4th of July Cake Batter. Since I was there on the 4th of July, the seasonal flavors were fun to see. I ended up getting a small scoop of the Peanut Butter and Jelly flavor. It was rich and creamy, and overall an enjoyable flavor. The peanut butter flavor was definitely the strongest part, though. I could see the jelly in it, but I could not really taste it as much as I expected. It was still good, but I think adding toppings would have made it a little more balanced and interesting. Overall, Uncommon Ice Cream is a nice stop if you are in the area and want to try creative flavors. I would go back to try another scoop, especially one of the more unusual rotating options. read more

See all

Uncommon Ice Cream is a small Boston shop that takes its name seriously, and the flavor creativity here is genuinely unlike what you will find at any other scoop shop in the city. We walked into a space where the owners are local and the passion behind the menu shows in how much thought goes into each combination, with flavors rotating frequently enough that repeat visits almost always offer something new to try. The six scoop sampler at twelve dollars is the obvious way to experience the menu on a first visit and makes it easy to move across the range without committing to a full scoop of anything you are unsure about. The basil strawberry is the standout, landing somewhere between a dessert and a Caprese salad in a way that sounds unusual until the first bite makes the whole concept click. The cinnamon cornbread is another strong order with a warmth and depth that feels more like a baked good than a traditional ice cream flavor. Gram's Magic Bars and the fluffernutter are both worth trying for anyone who wants to lean into the nostalgic, dessert forward side of the menu, and the roasted banana brings a caramelized richness that works well as a complement to something brighter. The texture across the menu is smooth and well made, and the sweet cream base that runs through many of the flavors is strong enough to stand on its own if you want something more classic while still being in the room. A few flavors have landed lighter on intensity than the concept might suggest going in, so sampling before committing on a less familiar flavor is always a smart move here. Service is friendly and the staff is happy to walk you through the rotating lineup, offering samples without hesitation. The space is small and can get crowded during peak hours, but the line moves efficiently. For an ice cream shop in Boston that rewards exploration and takes creative risks that actually land, Uncommon Ice Cream is a genuine standout. read more

See all

Friend recommended Uncommon ice cream for their unique ice cream so decided to give it a try while we were in South End area. Shop is very small, with limited indoor and outdoor seating. We sampled a bunch and ended up getting a small scoop of the Cookies & Cream and Cinnamon, Corn Bread, and Cherry Jam. Ice cream was delicious and had good amount of mix-ins. Very creamy and sweet as well which I prefer. I like how they rotate flavors often - if I lived in Boston, I would definitely frequent this shop to try their new flavors. read more

See all

My mother-in-law happened to hear about Uncommon Ice Cream, so we stopped in while visiting my brother-in-law nearby. Love that they have a monthly rotation of flavors. I tried their chocolate and peanut butter & jelly, and both were good. Small little neighborhood place but super cute! read more

Uncommon Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Boston, Massachusetts

Me and my friends stumbled upon Uncommon Ice Cream while walking back from dinner in South End. I'm not exactly sure what possessed us to go in 30-degree weather, but I'm so glad we did. After huddling into the small shop, we sampled a couple of different flavors (which Uncommon does allow--something that honestly should be standard. I'm looking at you, Honeycomb Creamery), and every single one we tried was a hit. Between the four of us, we went for Sweet Cream, Oatmeal Creme Pie, Strawberry & Cream with Cinnamon Toast Crunch, and Rosemary Honeycomb. In hindsight, I kind of wish we had gone with the 6-scoop sampler since it's arguably a better deal, but alas, we chose to be individualistic. Of the four, my favorites were the Oatmeal Creme Pie and the Rosemary Honeycomb. The Oatmeal Creme (which I ended up getting a full scoop of) was perfectly sweet--definitely on the sweeter side compared to the others--and I loved the bits of oats throughout. The Rosemary Honeycomb had a noticeable hint of rosemary (duh), but it came across refined and almost elegant, which is not something I usually associate with ice cream. As I'm typing this, I'm still thinking about how soft and creamy the texture was. If they had a location closer to Newbury, I'd probably be going every day, but just know I'll absolutely be back whenever I'm in South End. read more

Uncommon Ice Cream - Excuse the blurry pictures... but pictured top is the Strawberry & Cream, and bottom is the Oatmeal Creme Pie! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Boston, Massachusetts

See all

There was a line out the door and I see why. The flavors are innovative and all sound delicious. I should have gotten a sampler and definitely will come back for one. I ordered the campfire s'mores which was full of chocolate chip and marshmallows. Definitely more filling than ice cream but I still enjoyed it. read more

Uncommon Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Boston, Massachusetts

Very good ice cream here! Fun rotating flavors and rotating specialty cones which I found very cool. I loved the matcha cone and the strawberry basil ice cream. The matcha peach ice cream was just okay. I would definitely go back and try out more unique flavors here! read more

Uncommon Ice Cream - Matcha cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Boston, Massachusetts

Yum! This is going to be my new go to ice cream spot! We came on a weekday night and it was pretty packed in there but the line moved quickly. We got the 6 scoop sampler with chocolate, cookies and cream, pumpkin pie, almond mocha latte, cinnamon cornbread, and peach cobbler (?) Almond mocha latte and pumpkin pie were our favorites. I would highly recommend! read more

Uncommon Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Boston, Massachusetts

Uncommon Ice Cream in South Boston is one of those places that completely lives up to the hype. We stopped by recently and decided to try their 6 flavor sampler for $12, which is honestly one of the best dessert deals I've seen in Boston. It's perfect if you're visiting for the first time because you get to try a mix of their creative flavors without having to choose just one. Out of everything we tried, the roasted banana completely stole the show. It had this deep, caramelized flavor that tasted incredibly fresh and rich. The pistachio white chocolate was just as impressive -- easily one of the best ice cream flavors I've had in the city. We also had chocolate and cookies & cream, and both were done really well. Super creamy, balanced sweetness, and exactly what you'd want from classic flavors. What really stood out to me was that they don't just focus on traditional ice cream. They also offer great vegan options, and the cranberry sorbet and peach green tea with candied ginger were both genuinely delicious, not just "good for dairy-free." The space itself is small but charming, and the staff were extremely kind and patient, especially while we were deciding between flavors. If you're in South Boston and craving dessert, this place is absolutely worth checking out. The sampler alone makes it a must-visit. read more

Uncommon Ice Cream - 6 different scoops of ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Boston, Massachusetts

Flavor bomb, but long line. We got there around 8pm on Tuesday and the were in line for about 15minutes. We tried the matcha peach and the basil balsamic strawberry. The basil was the overall winner. Matcha peach lacked peach flavor and was very icy, but the matcha flavor was packing. Upon first bite of the basil, I was shocked. There was a lot of basil and the flavor was strong. Upon my 2nd bite with some strawberry, it mellowed down and was very enjoyable. The ice cream itself wasn't too sweet, which is perfect for me. However, the ice cream was also a bit icy likely due to the water content of the strawberry. I didn't get any balsamic flavor but overall, I loved this ice cream and will be back. Hopefully they'll improve on the texture and never stop making this flavor! I'm excited to come back for the other flavors. read more

One of the worst ice creams I've had. There's less cream in this than in most store-bought brands. They overload it with sugar to mask the poor quality. And the young woman working at the store barely said two words and could not find it in herself to crack a smile. You're selling ice cream not caskets! read more

Great ice creams with many creative flavors that change each week or so. We tried the six flavor sampler for just$12, what a deal. Ours included chocolate, Oreos and cream, cornbread and jam, toasted coconut, and shortbread and a sixth that was great but we can't remember the name. We also sampled a few others such as matcha and peanut butter and jelly that tasted exactly like the classic American sandwich. Lot of topping choices and homemade cones. All the ice creams and cones are made on site by a great and very friendly staff lead by owners Blair and Kady who are not only new business operators but also recent dog owners and best of all new parents of baby Harper. No lack of gumption with these two. Location is on Columbus Avenue in Boston's historic Southend. Great flavors, great value and super location. What more could you ask for ? read more

Went Sunday night around 8 and there was a 15 minute line. A little overpriced for ice cream but the flavors were good and the ice cream was very creamy. read more

A true gem in Boston's South End. They have such a great variety of unique flavors and the portions are generous. Everything tastes fresh, and the ice cream was packed with flavor. If you're in town, this spot is a must visit. read more

Really good new ice cream place in the South End. They have a few classic flavors (I.e. chocolate) but mostly more inventive flavors like pumpkin pie with Cinnamon Toast Crunch or balsamic strawberry. The six pack sampler is a great option for those who want to try a little of everything (and maybe share with others). I really loved some of the flavors, like the dump cake and balsamic strawberry. Some other flavors, like the pumpkin pie and magic bars, were more muted for my taste. The shop itself is charming but tiny so plan to take your ice cream to go. read more

A new, very small, ice cream place opening in South End on Columbus Ave. They definitely have uncommon ice cream flavors that you wouldn't expect to find at a typical ice cream place. They do have sweet cream and chocolate, but also cinnamon corn bread and pumpkin pie. They also have 2 sorbet flavors cantaloupe and orange cranberry. I decided on grams magic bars and fluffernutter. There was one guy working who scooped up my ice cream and rung me up at the register. His favorites right now are the cornbread and fluffernutter. I also really enjoyed the fluffernutter flavor as it has the creamy peanut butter texture as well as the sweetness from the marshmallow making it the perfect combination. The grams magic bars was good as well having gram crackers, chocolate, coconut, nuts, and condensed milk. If you like a chunky ice cream that's the flavor for you. I'll definitely be back to try out the cantaloupe sorbet or other seasonal flavors and would highly recommend checking them out! read more

See all

I took my brothers here and the staff were very patient and friendly. I got to take a few bites before the kids devoured it and it was delicious. There is no seating but the pastel colors are really nice. read more

Came on the 4OJ on a hot summer afternoon, desperate to feel just 2 degrees cooler. The welcome of 4OJ cake batter, the atmosphere, and the cold water in cans, alongside the respite we found in a summer storm, the unexpected torrential downpour, met with rags to pat ourselves dry made this the best ice cream spot I've been to since moving here. Thank you, Uncommon Ice Cream. read more

Uncommon has some of the best ice cream I've ever had. I couldn't decide on which flavor to try, so we got the sampler and all of the flavors were 10/10. They have your classics and then some really unique, delicious options that I haven't stopped thinking about. My 3 year old son usually sticks to vanilla but was a huge fan of the sampler. If you're in the neighborhood definitely check out the shop, and if you're not, it's worth the trip! read more

So good! Quaint place with quick service, a relaxed vibe, and phenomenal ice cream! Creative flavors, too

My family joined me for ice cream at Uncommon IceCream and all of us were very pleased. I had basil strawberry and peanut butter/with chocolate pieces and walnuts in a waffle cone--DELICIOUS! Creamy yet held its body without melting all over hands. The matcha cone with sweet cream ice cream was a hit. Fast service and reasonably priced. Do not miss this spot for a sweet treat. read more

This is a nice addition to the neighborhood. Very good ice cream. Try the pink lemonade and the shortbread cookie. Prices are great as well. 2 scoops for 7 bucks. Thought it was 1993. read more