Splendid!! A great find after a day of winery hopping. My wife and I started with the feta fries. I didn't think these would be a big deal, after all, it's fries with feta. They were fantastic! If I had one critique it would be that these weren't hand-cut, but honestly, who cares! Delicious. My wife had the Spinach pie with a side of asparagus and roasted potatoes. She was very pleased with the dish. I had a simple Gyro with house-made chips. It was outstanding. The Gyro was meaty and the tzatziki was fresh and delicious. The house-made chips are made to order!! They were still hot from the fryer! They have a decent selection of beers and wines. One small note and I hope the owners see this. It would be helpful if you had a printed beer list. Our waitress struggled to name all of the bottles on hand and she shouldn't have to do that. There should be a list. We were glad that we found this place and hope to return. read more

We started with the feta fries. How wonderful! House made fries, very fresh and flavorful! They have a nice selection of craft or mainstream beers. Wait staff was knowledgeable, helpful and attentive! I had ahi tuna sandwich. Very nice, not overcooked. My wife had the Matty melt which was also very good. Yes I will be back, Yes I recommend! I just wish I lived closer! read more

Uncle Matty's Eatery - a sandwich and chips - Comfort Food Near Me - New Windsor, Maryland

Terrible experience. Beware! New cook and/or change in product line. Ordered Jerk Ahi Tuna! What I received was an over cooked, grossly, inproportionate sample of tuna on a hard bun without a garnish with a side of overlooked chips. The garnish of shredded lettuce and two slices of over ripened tomatoes was added after delivery of the order. When asked to speak with the "chef," I was redirected by the waitress, "will that be all?" Followed by "don't shoot the messenger," when the chef did not return my request to speak with him. Highly unusual to receive such inadequate service. Accustom to consistency??? Would like to say busy and understaffed but, quite the contrary. Not so much the failure of the product as the responsiveness to service. In a small town, word travels fast..... read more

My mom and I visited here at around 6-6:30 pm on a Tuesday evening. I'm from out of town, however, my mom had told me on several occasions that this place was a MUST, so we decided to go while I was in town since she'd had prior pleasant experiences. On this particular evening, there was just one other party of 2 seated in the restaurant. I ordered the Matty Melt panini. It was just ok. The side house chips were way over cooked. The real issue we had here was with my mom's meal. She ordered the petit filet medium rare which came with the vegetable and starch of the day -- asparagus and roasted red potatoes. The steak was cooked to at least medium, not medium rare, and she described the red rose potatoes as "dry little hockey pucks." Upon letting the waitress know that she was dissatisfied with her meal, the waitress offered to make her a new plate. Having worked in the restaurant industry before, my mom has heard the slew of horror stories I've told in which returned food was met with some form of revenge (not by me). I'm not saying all restaurants do this, but it's generally a risk we don't like to take. We also just weren't interested in spending the time waiting for her to get a new plate considering I would've likely been finished eating by then anyhow. My mom asked if she could instead just comp the meal or maybe half of it. The girl said she wasn't able to do that and walked away. She came back about 10 minutes later to collect our plates (mine mostly empty and my mom's still in the same condition as beforehand), and asked if everything was still tasting good. My mom said no, and that she didn't want to pay for the meal. The waitress said "I already offered to have them make you a new one. I can see what I can do." My mom again told her that she despite her "seeing what she could do" that she simply wasn't going to pay for it. Eventually, another waitress came by and dropped the bill and had comped the meal from the bill. We left, and the employees did not greet us goodbye. Poor food and poor customer service on an evening where the restaurant was dead empty. I can understand not wanting to comp meals very often at a small establishment such as this one which doesn't seem to ever get very busy, however, in this case it was clear that the chefs just simply didn't care about putting out a good plate of food. read more

Great food. Great service. I had the mattys melt - it was great - the superior quality (and amount) of cheese on this sandwich definitely sets it apart! It's obvious they do care about what they are preparing for you. They make it like I'd make it for myself! The service was very attentive and friendly! Like the food terminator would say - I'll be back!!! read more

It's true doesn't look like much but it's a pleasant surprise. Food and service was very good !you won't be disappointed

Hidden little gem in New Windsor. Great food great service. Cream of crab soup was excellent. I had the spinach salad and my son had the peach glazed pork special. Both were really good. Will definitely visit again. read more

Excellent restaurant, cozy, friendly staff, very excellent food -- cheesesteak with homemade chips, yes please!! Will be recommending and coming back. read more

We love this restaurant ! The Chef owner is a hardworking and superbly skilled flavormeister. There is something on the menu for every one and every budget. Come support this family business and indulge in deliciousness! read more

We had great food last time we went, so another trip was warranted. The quesadilla appetizer had a nice thin flour tortilla and plenty of melted cheese inside. Wife had Chicken Marsala with a side salad instead of vegetable of the day, eggplant, and starch of the day, rice. Portion size was huge and take home for tomorrow was necessary. I wanted the Atlee ribeye steak, but was told they were all out. My second choice was the Spinach Pie. That too was not available. So, my third choice was their signature hot dogs with French fries. I got the bacon wrapped dogs. I asked for fried onions, but there was a communications failure and the dogs came with raw onions. I asked that the onions be removed and didn't get fried onions in their place. The dogs were deep fried and the outside was nice and crispy. The bacon wrapping was a nice addition. The French fries were crispy outside with just the right amount of crunch with a nice inside. They were seasoned well. I would give them another five stars except for the unavailable dishes and the mess-up with the onions. read more

Terrible food. Terrible service. Owners are rude. Servers are rude and say rude comments that they think implies to you. If you loved to be stereotyped....this is your place. Garbage to say the least. NEVER WILL I EAT THERE AGAIN! read more

I love this place! I guess I've become a regular. Good food, friendly staff, they remember my name every time I come in, great service, very nice little place. Just 4.5 miles west of Westminster off of 31. My meals are always well prepared and tasty good! They even have craft beers, some local, some from other places. Inexpensive overall, Street parking. read more

We started with the cream of crab soup, I have had better but still very acceptable! Waitress very friendly and helpful. Then my delicious monster chopped rib eye burger came with home fried chips WOW! read more

I spend a lot of time in winter in the Westminster/New Windsor/ union Bridge area. Food options are kind of limited, so I took the recommendation of a friend and went to check out Uncle Matty's. I was surprised by the variety of sophisticated options in what can be described as a very small town. The food was great, the atmosphere close and homey, and the service from Jordyn was excellent. She was attentive, and quite helpful as I was trying to work around the menu with a dietary restriction (dairy). I'm happy to say that the combination of good food and great service from Jordyn, this has become a weekly tradition for me to come over and work my way through this menu! The down side( if there is one) is that with this many options I end up ordering three people's worth of food. Definitely check out the shrimp and crab scampi, and don't overlook the house salad dressing! I now order a large house salad every time just so I can enjoy the dressing. I look forward to many more visits in the future. read more

Tried it twice hoping it would be better. First visit with my grand kids was ok. Their kids menu satisfied a need for decent food but fun for kids. My Cubano panini was edible but definitely not a Cubano, over cooked crispy ham made the sandwich hard to eat. Visit 2 with my husband- club sandwich was standard fare, no complaints. The Matty's Melt panini was a slab of "prime rib" that was tough, not sliced for ease of biting into a sandwich and I basically gave up as each bite dragged a slab of meat out of the sandwich and wouldn't cut off as a bite to chew. We ordered 6 hot wings with blue cheese- wings under coked with soggy skin and the chicken was dry. Spice was ok but no carrots or celery to dip in the blue cheese as an accompaniment. Really wanted to like this place but they have a long way to go to get the basics right! read more

Never again!! This is the place I went & they sent me a very saucy Fettucine Alfredo, because it was like soup. I didn't want it and wanted something else after receiving it. The waitress asked me what else she could get me so I asked for a Sub instead. I heard noise in the kitchen like the Cook freaking out. Throwing stuff, yelling... it turns out it was about my returned food but I'll get back to that is a few but leading up to that the waitress brought me my sub and I thanked her & I ate it. It was good but then when we went to pay, they had my wrapped fettucine alfredo and a bill for both items as well as my family's items. The Wife (co-owner) told me they didn't think they did anything wrong and are charging me. The Waitress was in the wait station listening and smiling & laughing at this news to me. I said the waitress never told me I needed to pay for it and asked if she could get me something else... that wasn't fair that she didn't tell me you weren't taking the item back. The waitress was laughing and the wife said we believe our food is good and nothing is wrong with the dish... meanwhile in kitchen a very angry chef/cook is cussing and screaming in anger who turned out to be the Owner of the restaurant. He could have come out to discuss with me but he didn't, he just continued to throw a fit and leaving his wife to tell me I was paying for that meal. Then I was thinking, what did he do to my food???? This waitress and Owner were laughing at me as to put me THE CUSTOMER in my place over my return of the food. I couldn't believe what was happening and I rejected the situation and said, why didn't you come to me and tell me before I ordered another dish? Why??? The food came out not appealing and was very saucy, like soup. And I asked the Owner why did she ask me if I wanted something else and tell me I wasn't getting the food replaced but that I would have to pay for it before serving me the sandwich???? And said if that was the case, I wouldn't have ordered a sandwich. They behaved horrifically. I will NEVER EVER RETURN TO THIS BUSINESS. They shouldn't be in business with their attitude toward customers. The Owner can't take criticism. I should have called the Better Business Bureau... why I didn't I don't know. I'm still haunted by eating the sandwich because something is so unsettling and I believe he did something to my sandwich but I can't prove it. By the screaming and yelling and throwing of things PLUS the way the waitress & Wife Owner was laughing over the situation made me wonder. JUST A HORRIFIC BUSINESS!!!! read more

We love this place and go here at least once a week. Such a quaint little eatery where you feel at home and the food is great! Try the Tuna steak sandwich or a Greek salad with gyro meat. The soups are always to die for!! read more

Great atmosphere, spotlessly clean and wonderful comfort food. Staff always makes us feel welcome and the crab chowder was the best I ever tasted. Our go to weekend spot. read more

Had an awesome patty melt with clients of mine who will be moving to New Windsor. Felt very welcome. Seated right away and quick service with a smile. They have nice artwork for sale from local artists. I like patty melts and always order from any restaurant I visit and this patty melt was top notch. Will tell friends. Looks like the bar would be a great place to catch the Ravens game. read more

Great food, good bottled beer selection of various microbrews, and friendly staff. Definitely worth a return visit.

After moving to the area we have been exploring local restaurants. We really enjoy the food here!! The booths are a tight fit. The dining room has been on the cold side. The wait staff is not super professional. Parking is just fine. Even though we'd rather sit in more comfortable seats, we have enjoyed the food so much we will become regulars. read more

The food is great! They have a good selection of beers as well. The customer service is on a first name basis and you can tell the staff really cares about making the customer happy. I haven't explored the menu as much as I would like since I love their blackened tuna steak sandwich so much, but what I have had has been nothing short of delicious. There's nothing like Uncle Matty's in Carroll County. I sometimes get their feta fries on the side when I'm really hungry and they are on point! One thing worth mentioning are their homemade chips. Everywhere else I see the fries and chips as fillers, but not these chips! Sometimes I even eat the chips first. Good people, good atmosphere, and great food. read more

The food and service was excellent. My wife loved the zucchini. The restaurant has a great atmosphere and it's very kid friendly. We would recommend this to anyone. read more

Our family really enjoyed eating here - they had this Bruchetta hot dog that was amazing and creative - the server we had seemed to be young and not at all attentive to our needs but we did enjoy the food ! Will come again if we're in the area. read more

Burger with ghost pepper cheese is awesome. Cheese steak is made with actual steak. Potato chips are incredible. If I lived closer, I would go way more often. read more

Ordered the gator as appetizer and it was pretty good. Then ordered the cubano Paninis witch was delicious except the ham was grisly but the taste made up for it, almost. The chips were the best and service was good. Carrot cake was ok. read more

Last nights carry out order was a big disappointment, my wife and I had their hot beef sandwich with French fries and gravy. Thank goodness the fries were good because the beef was so tough we couldn't eat it. My dog's did enjoy it .never again. read more

A hidden gem! An experienced Chef takes fresh, local-grown food to make great dishes. Atmosphere is a step above diner. Great touches like Tiffany lamp shades and art for sale. Will definitely return to try the soup. read more

Great small town food for a good price. I found the ingredients to be local, fresh and not heavy. The service was friendly and attentive. Not an actual 4 star restaurant, but the food and service make it that way. If u r in the area, stop by. read more

Our favorite go to local place. While there are standards like burgers and subs, there are also delightful surprises such as the specialty hot dogs and a variety of Greek dishes. Service is friendly and relaxed. Atmosphere is comfortable and I love looking over the different antique items for sale in the windows. read more

Fantastic sandwiches! We found this place while house hunting. I would definitely go back if we were in the area. I was disappointed in the chocolate cake, tasted frozen, but our sandwiches were great and other lunch offerings looked good. read more

This place has great food and great service. I love eating here. Burgers are amazing and worth every penny. Although I ordered a salad and it was much of a salad for the price. Other then the salad the place is great. I will be returning. read more

Uncle Matty's Eatery is now one of my regular stops. I normally get the chicken salad sandwich with homemade potato chips and pickle and it is fantastic with large chunks of chicken. Recently I had the shrimp salad sandwich and it was excellent. Their hot dogs are delicious and crab soup good. My wife has had assorted menu items also and has bee very satisfied. Prices are fair. read more

it's quite simple....... the food.... the staff..... the atmosphere and the owners are "superb"..!! they take great pride in their business, how they cook their food, and in their employees. a dynamite place to enjoy some wine and other fine drinks also at the bar after work and house work.! their attentiveness makes me feel so much more comfortable in being there also. you like cream of crab soup.? asparagus..? steak or incredible desert.? i promise uncle matty's to be one of your favorite restaurants...... if not your favorite..!! read more

Really good food and excellent service last night. We had the bacon crab penne and feta fries, along with chicken tenders for my daughter. All was good, but I was really thrilled at how welcoming they were to a toddler. We will definitely go back. Too good to not go. read more

When you think of New Windsor, a great restaurant probably wouldn't be the first thing that would come to mind, but this little town has one and I would highly recommend giving it a try. Serving classic American fare in a quaint, somewhat small, dining room that is usually never too crowded that you would ever have to wait to get a table. Great burgers. Love their take on mac-n-cheese and there crab chowder/bisque is also quite good as well. Always clean and the staff is very friendly and the service is very good as well. read more

Food is fresh and well made. Good sized portions. Comfortable, clean atmosphere with friendly service. Will come again.

I haven't had anything that I haven't liked yet! Very kid friendly & Amber-Lynn is amazing!!

We eat here a couple times a month. The restaurant is always clean and the wait staff is friendly and consistent. The menu offers a variety of items from bacon wrapped hotdogs, burgers, salads, all the way up to fancier pasta dishes and filet mignon. Everything is homemade except the desserts. We once ordered calamari and it was the best we've ever had. The homemade marinara sauce was out of this world. The prices are reasonable, and the portions large. Some of the dinner dishes are a little pricier, but we tend to stick to the basics of burgers, sandwiches, salads, etc. We have never had a problem with anything we've ordered. We always leave full, and with leftovers. I would recommend Mattys if you happen to be passing through our small town. If you live farther out like Westminster, I would recommend the drive. We have never had to wait for a table, which is great, but I do hope they get busier and remain open! read more