Come here for the freshest fish in town. Seasoned to perfection. Just stick it in the oven! They…read moregive extra sauce on the side.

I called and they are open and you can pre-order. I will definitely order some blue crabs, which…read morethe guy over the phone said will be available in August. Keep up the good work by providing excellent seafood!

SUPER FRESH - Seafood Department…read more I've had a heck of a time with supermarket fish mongers lately. But Super Fresh's Seafood Department has made a fan out of me. Jason, the Manager, understood my concerns and accommodated my requests without hesitation. The last thing any customer wants is to splurge on a prime piece of seafood only to receive an unscaled, ammonia smelly disappointment. Sadly, I've had that unpleasant experience while dining at a high end restaurant. For Shame! Another unpleasantry, encountering a fish monger at a supermarket who states they're not allowed to scale fish. Oh really?! Sounds more like lazy to me. Back to the positives. Though busy, Jason took the time to go to the back and pull out half a body of freshly delivered Chilean Sea Bass and masterfully scaled and portioned out my request with ease. Fast forward a couple of weeks later, I prepared this still fresh, buttery, umami filled Sea Bass, fulfilling our desire for an ideal meal. I thank the workers at aptly named Super Fresh for providing me a Super Fresh product. TIP: Seafood Dept. opens at 9:30am 5% supermarket discount before 10:00am

False marketing, actually closes at like 10:30pm and employees lock the door. Thanks for nothingread more

ALWAYS stocked...excellent produce, meat and seafood depts. Friendly and helpful staff....CLEAN!!read more

On October 15, 2025, my wife bought 275.00 dollars worth of food. She never got a 4.15 package of…read morechicken thighs that she paid for. She called and returned with the receipt. She was walked to the security booth where the video was reviewed to see if she ever received the chicken. We shop there weekly. We've lived in Baldwin for 30 years. Paid off two houses. We will never shop at Baldwin's Gsla Fresh, we will now shop at Stop and Shop in Baldwin.

We enjoyed the visit in this area. We enjoyed the boat ride via the water taxi. The sunset view…read moretrip was amazing. We were thinking that it would just be a boring ride that the tour guide will explain about the places we will be going. The ladies band music added to the great experience. We went for a pre-dinner at one of the historic sea grill restaurant along the mile-Otto Grill and enjoyed the live band as well as food and drinks with a view of the canal. There are many things to see and explore along the Nautical mile and staying during the night after the sunset boat trip was a very fun thing to do. Will I come back ? Sure , why not. I heard of their boat festival event during Christmas time.

I really love it here. It's got such a unique vibe, pretty much one of a kind in my opinion. While…read moreit's waterfront life, it's chock full of charm, character and diversity. I love the relatively new addition of the volleyball courts and the public workout station at the park along end of the mile. I'm also quite fond of the new restaurants that call the Nautical Mile home, namely Off the Hook and Secret Thai Kitchen. There's also a cute little ice cream shop called Sam's Scoops as well, which has a seriously yummy vegan cookies & cream flavor. My favorite thing to do on the mile is kayaking and spending a whole afternoon on the water. There's even a couple of "secret beach" islands, though they seem sort of inhabited, though fun to explore the perimeters of. Like I said, I really LOVE it here.

Service, decor, food, $$, & happy hour at the tables too. Happy Cinco de Mayo baby. Got here when…read moreit opened up at 1500 and got street parking in front of the restaurant. That's how PopPop does it does it. Perfect Peach Sangria & flavored Margaritas. The best tender sweet mussels we ever had. Finished up with the Termisu...... "Voila!!!" Christina was a great hostess. Very attentive and attractive too. Sorry...., EVERYTHING WAS SPOT ON!!! Nothing to complain about An easy 5 stars from Brooklyn PopPop!

Holy Moly!! I'm sure glad I followed my yelp elite friend's reviews to help me with dining here…read more TBH everything from the customer service, food and drinks was great!! I made reservations thru opentable, but when arriving I saw some availability inside and outside. We were promptly greeted and seated. Our waiter was Rich, he was friendly, funny and attentive to what we ordered. He apparently juggles apples too impressive lol but they are great at this restaurant. Food: I had the lobster mac and cheese and the not so old fashioned, both were delicious. My friends had shrimp and fries with the rum punch as well as the chicken and drink with prosecco and with a juice that made it turn purple pretty cool. I believe it came with a lemon drop shot. Appetizers we got the calamari and mozzarella Rangoon delish. We sat outside in front on the mile but I hear they have seating in the back area near the water. Definitely come here!! I will definitely come back here and try a few other dishes as well. Keep up the good work and great tasting food and drinks.

The Cajun boil seafood is very tasty. Served fast and the volume is big, very flavorful. The owner…read moreis very friendly. Highly recommend.

It was very good and it was the most authentic Cajun Seafood I've had on Long Island. The fried cat…read morefish here is also very good.

A three (3) star is because Service was a 5. Tony was swift, accommodating, friendly and had good…read moresuggestions. The remaining review had to do with the lack of quality food. Appetizers, Empanadas, although flavorful, came lukewarm, at best, as if they had been sitting under a warm lamp waiting for their name to be called, instead of cooked to order. The Guacamole, the same. Brownish, as if it sat in the molcajete awaiting the next guest's order. Accompanying Plantain Chips the same. They should be cooked to order and served hot tableside. The Fried Cheese is a good addition. You should not taste stale oil that it was fried in though. The Mofongo (Chicken) was decent, although a tad stiff (it definitely needed the Amarillo sauce.) The fried Chicken Strips again, should've been hot but were lukewarm. The Mofongo's serving amount was smaller than what we're normally used to but it's a dish we could reorder. The Seafood tower lacked flavor and was overcooked. Every piece of Seafood curdled (Shrimp, Lobster Tails). The Crablegs seemed old, as they had black spots on some of the legs. The Tower definitely needed the Sauce, which seemed prebottled and not exclusive. It doesn't take much to make an Housemade Seafood Boil sauce versus just providing an oily pre-bottled one. The Grilled Chicken with Rice and Beans, seems like a safe bet but here are the issues/concerns: 1. The Grilled Chicken flavor was fantastic and the Char was perfect! The Chicken itself was rubbery and congealed, as if it was wet brined too long. Rendered it inedible. The rice was good but the Frijoles severely lacked flavor or a decent amount of beans. Fallen skin from overcooked beans does not count! The Drinks were worrh coming for. The Coquito, Berry Smash and Manhattan were all fuerte (strong) and REALLY good! BE CAREFUL to NOT PARK in the lot adjacent to the right. They do have a dedicated lot on the left, behind the main restaurant and next to their Hookah across the street by the docks. It's gravel so watch your heels ladies They play music so it'sa fun vibe. Puerto Plata is a good time if you eat first and come for drinks and music afterwards.

With plenty of parking, friendly service and good seafood, Puerto Plata is a local favorite. Add to…read morethat their megamixes and it's a complete hit!! A megamix is a frozen alcoholic beverage that comes in a glass in different colored swirls. We didn't ask what was in it but be careful, 2 can be dangerously!! We were a group of four and had their chicken wings as appetizers and shared their seafood bucket for two. The bucket had salmon, jumbo shrimp, lobster, broccoli, carrots and I may be missing a vegetable or two. For dessert, we had a chocolate lava cake with a side of vanilla ice cream. Super delicious!

Overall place was ok. Cheese pizza pie was average. crust was thicker than I am used toread more

11-25-25. Been here a few times in the past. Very sold…read morepizza. Lots of specialty slices to choose from. Plenty of seating available in the "pizza" portion of the restaurant. They also have another are for table service. Casual , comfortable atmosphere. Staff is always friendly. Prices are on par with everywhere else in the area.

A rude and unprofessional cashier yelled at me due to her mistake…read moreI inserted my credit card to pay for grocery, the machine failed processing it, and the cashier told me to try again. I tried again and it worked. The cashier yelled at me Don't remove credit card early. I didn't remove it but she yelled at me that I removed my credit card. Apparently, the machine malfunctioned. It was an extremely nasty experience. I went to the store every weekend, she was always there and always rude. She always showed superior attitude over customers. Every time I bought grocery at the store, the cashiers always excessively charged on me, I had to tell them the correct prices, they checked those prices, and corrected the prices. I've been getting tired with them. This store is a crap.

I'm not happy . How did I spend $45 and walked out with 1 bag of groceries. I come here to get my…read moredogs food because they have the best prices on that. But I only purchase (7)dog food, (2)collards, (3)yogurt, (3)avocado, (1)bag of bagels and (2)sharp cheese. These prices are killing me. Something is going to have to give or my dog is going to have go on a diet.

Store is always busy which means food is always fresh !!! Cashiers are all super friendly . Produce…read moreis beautiful. What I love the most is all the poultry , fish and meats are in a huge room in the back . It's refrigerated and everything I've ever bought tastes great ! Your Welcome

Old and Outdated items, food as well. , tried to share the…read moredates and items I just purchased. Date and time on the receipt doesn't LIE! But it wasn't an Option! Yeah that part!