11 months ago I added a review. First one! It was a new place. I figured they had some learning…read morecurves to figure out mostly in training employees and well I guess things have not changed. I've been there a half a dozen times or more in the previous year and every time has been just OK My biggest gripe is the service. There seems to be a bit of a training issue. Many times the servers do not know the menu, the drinks they offer, or some of the options like daily special. There may be great servers there, I may not have been lucky enough to be seated in their section. The lack of experience or work ethic in many of their servers really are a strike against the level of service. They're hoping to provide. It seemed as if many of the servers put in the minimum. They come get your order, either they drop it off or a coworker does. A little bit later if they come and say hey, how is everything. And then you get the check. Every time we've gone there, it's difficult to get a refill. I'm not talking booze. I'm talking soda or iced tea even water. If you don't get a refill when they come to check in you're not going to. The food does not live up to the dollar amount attached to it on the menu. It is just your average food at an elevated price. I get that everywhere is expensive these days but this place is even higher It is an interesting building with a very nice history. However, the decor is sparse. There is a series of plain tables with generic type chairs on half of the floor. There's some couches that felt a tad low for the tables. Plus there's not a lot to absorb the sound. The hard concrete floors, walls and windows make sound bounce around, so even if they are moderately busy, it can be very difficult to hear your dining companions. The view is great. How could you not like a water view. The round windows of the building give it a certain appeal. Honestly, the historic building and view are the best part of the dining experience at this restaurant. I don't understand why there are a role of slot machines in a place that's attempting fine dining. That doesn't really go with that type of establishment. There is plenty of other bars and taverns with those machines. It is not something you expect at a destination attempting to offer an elevated experience. I was truly excited when they first opened as this town really needs more places to eat. I really was hoping it would be a fine or even medium dining experience. Somewhere nice to take a date or family for special occasions. I was talking with someone the other day and they just said it's not even on their radar anymore. They expressed same concerns but said mostly it was the cost of the food for what you get. They were disappointed and aren't going back. I don't mean to be over critical. I'm just trying to be honest. I really wish they would straighten out these issues. This town really deserves a really good restaurant. It's a shame to have to drive to the neighboring cities to get a great meal.

This is a refurnished bank building and they did a good job remodeling it, almost too good. There's…read morereally nothing resembling a bank, not even the vault incorporated into the design. We went on a Friday night to compare their Friday fish to other area places we've been to. There was a sign at the door asking to wait to be seated. But no one came to do that, so we eventually we went and sat at the bar. There was one inexperienced bartender for the entire bar area and as we were just getting ready to leave because of the wait, she came over to us. I had to point out to her that the couple next to us were waiting longer than us and she should serve them first. The sad part is that the bar was only half full. We were seated and our order taken in a reasonable amount of time. They offer a salad bar with soup, which is a plus. Our food came out just as we finished our plates from the salad bar, which was great. I had the three piece perch dinner. It came with a baked potato, no vegetables. Unfortunately, the pieces of perch more closely resembled three pieces of smelt. Basically two bites per piece. No offer of a dessert was made by the wait staff so I'm not even sure if they offer any. There is no separation of the bar from the dining area so it only took a couple loud talkers by the bar to affect our dining experience. Unfortunately, there really isn't anything special to warrant returning. The food was okay, the soup on the salad bar was good but no where near hot enough, and the service was mediocre. It's nice, not great, and nothing special to make it stand out from the other area supper clubs.

So.Much.Food I'm definitely coming back to Matthew's. The service was great. The food was really…read moregood. I'm stuffed so my waistline would prefer that I not come back (but I will).

We have always had amazing food and service at Mathews Supper Club.The appetizers are great, too…read more We may go there tonight for Mother's Day. Hope so.

By far the best pizza I have ever had. The staff is very welcoming and friendly and I never felt…read morelike it was a locals only kind of bar. Only wish it was closer but still worth the 50 minute each way commute.

First, I wanted to wash my hands. It was 13° outside and not much different in the men's & I'm…read moresure, the women's. Plus, a flashlight would be good. I ordered deep fried haddock and my only potato choice was French fries. My wife went with Mexican and I would have had a chimi but they didn't have shredded beef, only hamburger. I asked for lemon but that wasn't available. I did not care for the fries at all and the fish was middle of the road. My wife who would never complain if the food was horrible said her shrimp was fine. Our server was cute and friendly and spoke reasonable English. Although we sat way on the inside (it's a very small dining room) I do not recommend setting anywhere near the entrance in the winter time. Portion sizes for good but if the food's not good, why bother? I just tell it the way it is...

Nice quant spot, was pretty slow; only one cook on a Sunday morning but the food was worth the wait…read moreand the server is very kind! Tequila Sunrise is the bomb, get the corn tortillas!

Everything -- service is awesome. Adorable ambiance. And the…read moreFOOD! Too much, so great leftovers. And the coffee? Strong but tasty. Ten stars!

Always great food and amazing pie!!! Not a lot of seating…read morebut worth it if you have to wait.

My husband and I visited this spot, and loved it. Candace, maybe Cassandra was so cool! She took…read moreexcellent care of us. The food was great, as well as the atmosphere. The owner took the time to chat with us, and also recommended a wrap for us to take the following day on our hunt. We highly recommend this place! We'll be back next year!! Dallas and Gary

Great little bar with all of the standard Midwest bar comfort foods and they do it very well I love…read morethe deep fried green beans.

We have gone twice now to Haufschildts for Friday night fish. Both times the food has been…read moreexcellent and the service great! I've had the perch and then the haddock. My wife loved their shrimp so much sh had it both times and was not disappointed. They make a really good old fashion and are very friendly. We ate at tables in the bar area as we could keep an eye on the Brewers game, but they do have a small dining room also. We will return and if it's a Friday my next try will be the pollack.

Not a very good experience. The locals were priority, I get it but it was so obvious. Too busy to…read moretake our order, playing dice with locals. The hot beef was flavorful and I would recommend. Substituted potato salad for fries and charged $3 for the substitution. A separate side order of potato salad was $4, seemed excessive. The potato salad was good until on my second fork full when I pulled a hair out of my mouth from the last bite. Unfortunately, we had a clear view of the kitchen where we watched the cook vaping while cooking. We won't be returning.

People were very friendly and we felt welcomed. The…read moreatmosphere was rustic as expected and the food was great!

This pizza, y'all! I would be ECSTATIC to have this joint near me in Milwaukee and as luck would…read morehave it, it's about a mile and a half from my northern Wisconsin hideaway in the Nicolet Forest. Bear Paw has a lot to offer, including: kayaking, lodging, gear and incredible food. It's in a stunning location, very near the Wolf River. We had a " pub style, plank pizza". It was loaded with fresh vegetables and meat with a medium thickness crust. A crunchy, yet tender crust, at that. I can't wait to go back. Eric, one of the owners and operations manager, was cook, bartender, server and entertainer. He does it all with a smile and makes you feel right at home. I highly recommend you try this place. It's on a stretch of Hwy 55 that winds and dips and while it is fun to drive, is a puke factor "8" out of 10 when I'm driving with my cat. Yeah, I drive with my cat.

Was there on St Patrick's Day - walked in and a Nickelback song was playing so I almost walked out…read more Glad I stayed because the pizza was great and the bar has TouchTunes so we fixed the music with the Irish Rovers, Flogging Molly, Dubliners, Dropkick Murphy's and a few other more appropriate songs for the day. Garlic bread was great, pizza was solid, they had a 2 for 1 deal so I got a a thin crust to eat there and a hand tossed to take home.

Out of town working. Ate here twice already. Staff is great…read more Entrees, pizza, wings were all very good. Wine, beer and booze selection is good. Will go back. Thank you.