Loved this place! If you have an older boat, you need to stop here! Lots of parts in bins, but…read morealso other random things to look at. I loved all the maps of the Long Island sound! I actually bought a necklace and a couple of photo cards - local artists have their work on consignment in the shop. Definitely stop by and take a look around!

Cool cool store with all things water related. There are used and new items, boating paraphernalia,…read moredecorations, lanterns, fishing gear and lots lots more! Relatively small space lacking any real organization, but so fun to maneuver and move things and discover something you never knew you needed or wanted. Went with a friend you said she so wished she had known about this in her boating and fishing heydays. It is worth a stop!

Jonnycake Center of Westerly absolutely lived up to the hype. The multi room refurbished warehouse…read moreis filled to the brim with new and lightly used clothing and household items (for other thrifters it reminded me of Pop and Bernat Mill Antiques) each room was organized, clearly labeled, and well lit. I also like that they had a donation ticket kiosk at checkout , where you could pick a tag and that food pantry item would be purchased for a Rhode Islander in need. The employees I interacted with were pleasant and efficient. The prices were on par with other competitors. They also have an off street parking lot directly across the street from the warehouse. This business fills up quickly (they have a waiting line outside when they hit capacity) with patron, so my best tip would be to arrive early, so you have ample time to browse all of the different sections of the warehouse.

Nice large parking lot but there is as limit of how many people they will let into the store so…read moreoftentimes you will have to wait for people to leave before you can go on. Wait isn't king though. Didn't like that they overcrowded the pictures and frames so much that it was very hard to see what was there. On the plus side, the furniture was in good condition and priced to sell at very low prices.

A treasure hunt with charm and value…read more Penny Wise Consignment is one of those places where you walk in "just to browse" and somehow leave with a bag full of finds you didn't know you needed. The shop is well‑organized without losing that fun, treasure‑hunt energy that makes consignment shopping so addictive. Clothing, accessories, home goods--everything feels curated enough to be worth your time, but still priced like a true local gem. What really sets Penny Wise apart is the staff. They're friendly, patient, and genuinely invested in helping you find something that fits your style or your home. There's a sense of loyalty and community here--you can tell regulars come back not just for the deals, but for the people. Inventory rotates often, which keeps things fresh, though it also means you've got to be quick if you spot something great. A little more space or updated displays would push this place into five‑star territory, but honestly, the charm is part of the appeal. If you love good value, unique pieces, and a shop that feels like it's run with heart, Penny Wise is absolutely worth the stop. Enjoy

The best thrift store in this town, with lots of clothes, handbags, THE SHOES OMG (got a pair)…read more Lots of named brands items like Michael Kors, Kate Spade, and entire table of Tory Burch, I spent $100 & came home with lots of summer attire. Loved this place

I hear what some folks have said about staff having conversations and not paying attention to…read morecustomers. I've experienced that in the past. But this seems to be changing. I had a GREAT experience today. Staff asked if they could help, and they located a pair of earrings I was looking for that I didn't see displayed. I told them they were for an upcoming photo shoot and, when I accidentally left them on the store counter, one of the staff jumped in her car to find me. She didn't, but she did offer to meet me half way so I didn't have to drive an hour to get them! Or she offered to mail them to me at their expense. Who does that anymore?! They have beautiful things that are reasonably priced. I always make a point to stop by when I'm in the area!

What a unique store! Perfect for Christmas gifts!! The customer service and gift wrapping was…read moreamazing. DEFINITELY make this a stop on your way to Mystic.

Stopped in here yesterday for small business Saturday and found a few cute finds. Some of the items…read morein here are indeed a bit overpriced for a thrift shop. Others are more decent then. There's definitely some nice finds within. They have nice selection of shoes for sale.

Love the employees and the overall atmosphere of this thrift shop under the bridge in Stonington,…read moreCT.

This shop is the go-to for denim and cashmere! The owner/buyer has carefully selected the best…read moredesigner denim (KUT, Big Star, AG, Etienne Marcel) in a multitude of styles and stocks the largest inventory of alluring cashmere I've seen in one spot, ever. Her antique displays are filled with soft tees, leather belts, vegan handbags, artisan jewelry, tasteful baby/kid wear and so much more. She also carries a Massachusetts painter's truly inspired work - which she can't keep from selling off the walls. Keep an eye on their faceboook page for the launch of their shoppable website.

I've been meaning to post this for a while now but decided after a recent shopping visit to Hope…read moreand Stetson, it was time! Mystic has been in dire need of a store like Hope and Stetson. They sell high end denim, such as Seven, Miss Me, Hudson, True Religion, Joes, Citizens of Humanity, Paige and more. I always visit them for my jeans needs but end up finding much more. There are great dresses for summer time and amazing cashmere year round. I recently got a cute dress for a wedding and received so many compliments on it. I always go there for baby shower and children's gifts, too. It's a perfect place to pick up a gift for a friend, of any age. The accessories (artisan jewelry, scarves, vintage looking belts, and bags) is awesome. The people that work there are friendly, helpful, and I'm so happy Mystic FINALLY has such a great store!

Love a good thrift spot that has a dressing room to try on your goods. While visiting my friend we…read morewent to a few thrift shops & this one,altho smaller, was my favorite. Lots of good finds here, I purchased a paid of mustard yellow pants(yay me) and 4 tops, came to $28. No one bothers you while your shopping, just drift thru take your time,enjoy. Good spot

Love to support the Chorus of Westerly. There are always some great treasures if you look for them.read more