The meats here are simply fabulous! We travel 1 1/2 hours several times a year for this quality and…read morebest tasting meat we've ever had! Several different kinds of brats to choose from to suit your taste buds! not near the the fat content as what you find in local stores. Smoked link sausage, bacon, beef sticks, ground sausage, & beef are all to die for! Bacon Lovers! this bacon is beyond good! and will leave your house smelling of awesome bacon the next day after.. My last trip there, shared some with family who have been helping us through some difficult times (hubby had shoulder replacement & also discovered he had cancer, but happy to say all going well!); I will be making a trip in a few days with our order and theirs too! We most likely will make another trip there late winter/early spring as well. Wished they had an active website with current prices on everything, I do like to plan ahead to have plenty of cash on hand for everything we like to get or perhaps to add to our list. I will be asking if they have a pricing list on their products and see if there may be plans for a future active website. WE LOVE WINESBURG MEATS!

Was great. Love their weiners and bologna. Service is great.Always really clean and everyone is so…read morenice.Ha e lots of meat there.

I ordered the day before drove 1.5 hours and was pleasantly surprised by the quality of my order…read moreand I really appreciated the welcoming service of the staff! Itnis definitely one of my go to for Ox Rails and look forward to returning!

Great meat shop. Outstanding bacon. Great meat sticks. Some cheese and lunch meats, too…read more Great place. Mostly locals shop here.

The entire Dutch Valley complex is beautifully appointed and landscaped. There is a decent sized…read moretheatre, hotel, gift shop, restaurant, bakery, and then the market, which I ventured into the other day. It is not large, but there are a lot of unique Amish goods, frozen pies, sauces, soup mixes, fudge, cheese, etc. The people who work here are very friendly and welcoming. Even though I didn't end up buying anything this time, they were still kind and personable. It was busy for a Friday, with full parking lots at each venue on the complex and several large group tour busses. While there may be bigger markets in Amish country, this one is located on the grounds of the most beautiful complexes in Sugarcreek.

Visited this market after attending a show at Ohio Star Theater. It's small but stacked with Amish…read moregoodies, i.e. jams, pickles, peanut butter, spices, etc. I bought a small jar of hickory salt. The employees were pleasant & polite. I would return here when in the area.

Excellent friendly service! A great place to deal with to get your custom meat processed.read more

Yummy rolls and bread. Love the pies also. It's a nice stop to grab some home baked good to take…read morehome

Great deli service, I like the 2 yr aged cheddar and the off the bone ham!! A large selection on…read morepastries and breads

Walnut Creek Cheese and Market is a SUPER Supermarket! With a n inside balcony cafe, escalator,…read moreAmish goods, And every sort of grocery item, many bulk goods!

This place was an absolute mad house on a Saturday afternoon. I don't know if it was the perfect…read moreweather we were having or if that was the norm for a Saturday at Walnut Creek Cheese & Market, but it surely made for a stressful shopping experience. Lines were wrapped throughout the large market and I found myself weaving between carts and lines everywhere. There were several displays that I couldn't reach, but what I did get to was tempting! I browsed the extensive cheese and meat selections, all of the candy, and some of the baked goods in the center. I left with cheese curds, meat sticks, and a plastic clamshell of root beer barrels. I thought the prices were fair for the quality of the products. The store was massive and laid out in an organized way. They even had a seating area upstairs that I would love to come back and check out.

Okay, so this place is amazing. So much cheese of all flavors... and you can try a lot of them…read more Samples everywhere. This was my favorite part (as with many people who visit). By trying some of them, we found a couple of cheeses that we took home. So delicious... you really can't go wrong with many, even with the weird flavors. They even had cream cheeses that you can try with preztels. Lastly, you can watch them make the cheese. Such a great experience and definitely worth the stop.

Stopping at Heini's is an Amish country tradition. What was always great about this place, was…read moretheir samples. You could try all the cheeses and take home your favorites! COVID guidelines took that away, but I'm happy to report the samples have returned Locally made from fresh ingredients, you will find some of the best tasting cheeses here. Plenty of other interesting items as well, like nuts, candies both new and classic and many other things for the eager tourist.

I visited in July 2025 with some friends. We were visiting Ohio Amish country for the day and…read moredecided to stop by this store. My friends really wanted to visit the Guggisberg cheese factory but they were closed for the day. This store offers not only cheese but other smaller grocery and household items such as butter, apple butter, mugs, t-shirts, etc. I don't like cheese so I didn't buy any cheese. My friends may have bought small cheese blocks but I can't remember. They did sample some cheese which they liked. MY PURCHASES -- I bought an Italian bread dipping mix which is a small tin of herbs. I finally tried the dip in April 2026 by adding olive oil the dipping bread in it. The spice mix is too strong so I don't like it that much and I don't believe it was made locally. I also bought Apple butter which is locally made and tastes good. The Apple butter is too sweet for me though so I've hardly eaten it but it goes well with toast. If you're in the area, stop by this local store. The back of the store is cute because of a little fountain and a well-kept lawn. **** GOAL of 250 reviews in 2026 - 87/250 total reviews in 2026 - 928 total Yelp reviews - Reviewed on 19 May 2026

Part deli, part gift shop, part factory. This cheese shop's…read moreclaim to fame is is that they are the creators of baby swiss. They are apparently now one of the largest manufacturers of swiss cheese in the US. When you enter, there is a shop which is a combination of gift shop, cheese accessories and grocery items. There is signage that shows off their awards, talks about some of their history and also takes about the difference between regular and baby swiss. The deli where you can get freshly sliced cheese is in the back. The clerks were extremely friendly answering questions and providing samples of anything you want to try. Much like the outside, the inside continues the swiss theme. The reason I gave it four instead of five stars is the space itself. It was really congested even though it wasn't really all that crowded. I can't imagine what it would be like on a busier day. J don't know what, if anything can be done about this that, but it definitely can be hard yo navigate if you have mobility issues or don't like crowds. Oh and the cheese hats are a fun nice touch.

I wish we had more little shops like this out west. Truly, a delight. If you've ever been to…read moreBerlin, you know you have to check out the unique Amish charm that makes Main Street what it is. For me, this spot takes the cake. The owners are delightful, hard working and warm. The entire staff could not have been nicer. They allowed me to sample the fudge after I was torn on two, and I will absolutely be back the next time I am in town. The place is pristine, clean and smells absolutely delicious and everything was made with heart and love - what more can you ask for!

Great small local shop serving all sorts of odds and ends, plus ice cream. The kids got some candy…read moreand a frozen banana. I didn't buy anything for myself, but there were certainly some things calling my name! Friendly guy working there. They were a little busier than usual because of the live music that happens on Fridays just adjacent to their shop.