I stopped by Treetops Cidery on a Friday afternoon during a July 2025 vacation stay in an AirBnB lake house on West Bluff Drive (near Keuka Lake State Park). It was only a 10 minute drive across Bluff Point. If you're staying near or in Penn Yan, I would recommend a visit.
Lots of pluses. First, this is a local, family-owned cidery that opened in October 2024. The Geertz brothers (Eric and Doug) are co-owners. I was served by Eric who is an American Airlines pilot (3-4 days per week) and grew up in Penn Yan, NY. His father and grandfather were also pilots, so you'll see aviation images in the tasting room. Second, the handcrafted ciders had a wide variety and mix of sweet and tart flavors. I personally liked the "Locals Only Catawba", but the Grape Escape is one of their bestsellers (especially in the fall). A sample flight of 5 different ciders is $15 and a pint is $7.
Third, it has a friendly and down-to-earth vibe. I did not feel rushed on a Friday afternoon. Overall, it's worth a visit if you're staying near or in Penn Yan, NY (on Keuka Lake). If their cider cans are not available, you can order a $25 glass growler (which must be kept in a refrigerator and preferably consumed within 2-3 days after opening). read more