NY style with a Texas flair. Go at closing and find a few extras tossed in. Our favorite go to.

Pizza and Salad was great and served hot. They gave plenty of meat and toppings. The large is exactly what it says it is. Salad's are a very good serving and fresh. The waitstaff was very accommodating with the music request when we asked for a change. Thank you! The decor is very Pizza oriented and appreciated the art on the boxes. Good viewing window and hours. Easy to find and park. One of the favorite places I hear from students too. read more

See all

I ordered two pepperoni slices by the slice, and unfortunately the experience was disappointing. The pizza was already prepared and on display when I ordered, yet it still took about 30 minutes to receive two slices on a day that wasn't busy. What made the wait especially frustrating was that it appeared the restaurant was preparing every other order before serving my slices, even though my food was already made and ready to be heated and served. It felt like pizza-by-the-slice orders were being placed behind full meal orders instead of being treated as the quick option they're typically expected to be. The pizza itself was also underwhelming. The sauce used on the pizza did not have a good flavor and took away from the overall taste. While the slices were edible, the quality did not match what I expected, especially given the long wait time for an order that should have been quick. I hope the restaurant considers improving both the order flow for slice customers and the consistency of the food quality, because a faster and better-tasting experience would make a significant difference. read more

As someone from CT and a pizza snob, I was pleasantly surprised. We will be coming back! Good pizza, not too much cheese, proper thin crust, and great sauce read more

We were in town for a gymnastics meet and wanted something for takeout. I looked up pizza places close to our hotel and this was rated the highest.. and I see why! It was so delicious. We got a large pepperoni pizza and a large sausage and pineapple pizza. The cheese is delicious and the sauce is not too sweet. This was great NY style pizza! Each pizza came with garlic knots on the side and they were delicious! read more

Top It Off Pizza - My kids loved the pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Tyler, Texas

See all

The pizza is "real New York" pizza. Great ingredients, thin crust and good service. There also have fresh salads and yummy desserts.

I'd describe the pizza more as "spinach and chicken", rather than chicken alfredo. The white sauce is mild tasting at best, and the bacon had almost not taste at all. The chicken was a pretty bland to boot. read more

Top It Off Pizza - 14" Alfredo Supreme - Pizza Near Me - Tyler, Texas

Wow, just wow! This place is legit. All the dough is made from scratch and you can taste the difference! The restaurant is cute with soft lighting and the decor is fun! Customer service was fantastic and they checked on us regularly to make sure we were enjoying the meal. Our 13 year old said 10/10, would recommend! read more

See all

Super friendly place. Pizza was decent and okay. Inside the store was cool. Have Pepsi and Mountain Dew but Coke signs outside lol.

This man knows pizza!! the red sauce is hands down best in Tyler. you walk in and are transported to the east coast, you hear the owners accent and know for a FACT its gonna be good. Be hard pressed finding a better garlic knot put here too. read more

True New York pizza!!! Fresh. Hand pulled crust. Fresh toppings. So good!!! Pls look past the shopping strip interior & walk inside! read more

The pizza is always great but the customer service is top notch! Every time I've gone, it's been a great experience.

Very good pizza! Accommodated my dairy allergy like a pro! My cheese free pizza was perfectly delicious! read more

Top It Off Pizza - What's left of our food! Yummy - Pizza Near Me - Tyler, Texas

We ordered the pizza roll and a pepperoni Mushroom jalapeno pizza both were excellent I would highly recommend this place read more

Top It Off Pizza - We ordered the pizza roll and a pizza and both were perfect. I would definitely recommend this place - Pizza Near Me - Tyler, Texas

See all

Delicious pizza! Such a gem. When I crave a veggie pizza I order it from top it off every time

This is the best New York style pizza I've tried yet in East Texas. We will definitely get pizza here again read more

I've tried a ton of different pizza places in town and I can say without a doubt this is my new favorite! The toppings and super fresh and you can taste the quality of the mozzarella. It was the perfect balance of flavors and I think the hula hula pizza (add jalapeños) is the best pizza I've had in a VERY long time. We placed an order for pickup and everyone was super nice but we'll definitely be back to dine in. It was a super cute place and it was fun looking at the decorations. read more

Top It Off Pizza - Hula Hula Pizza (add jalapeños) - Pizza Near Me - Tyler, Texas

See all

this is got to be my families favorite pizza place in all of Tyler. If you happen to be in Tyler, or traveling through, it is definitely worth going over to try, his crust is amazing, and the toppings are high-quality. https://youtube.com/shorts/_2ke5fvKE_Q?si=xuTlImD9oNe9p9vG read more

Top It Off Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tyler, Texas

Great NY style pizza! So good --- and the pepperoni rolls are great too! Fun, family-friendly atmosphere to enjoy!!

Great pizza in Tyler Texas. Awesome and friendly service as well. The kids and adults loved every bite. We will be back :)

My first time trying this place out and I was not disappointed. The pizza has a different flavorful taste. The salad was fresh, and the customer service was excellent. From the moment we walked in it was a friendly atmosphere. The owner is very friendly. We ordered Texas size pizza. Try this place out already! read more

Top It Off Pizza - Texas size pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Tyler, Texas

See all

I think the thing that appealed to me was seeing the guy toss the dough round but after tasting the food, my goodness just go try it already. It's delicious. read more

Top It Off Pizza - Cheese pizza,Old Wilbur Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tyler, Texas

Very nice gentleman working the counter/making the food. I was initially turned off that he was making another customers calzone, went immediately to ringing up our order on the cash register, and then went straight to handling our dough and pizza without ever stopping to wash his hands, and was not wearing gloves. I could have looked past that except that our food (12 inch pizza, and the mild boneless wings) were soggy, greasy, and really not enjoyable. Probably the worst pizza I've had. A poor experience, unfortunately. read more

Seriously the best pizza in town! It is actually NY style. This will be the only pizza we eat from now on.

Pizza is amazing! They got my pizza wrong but fixed it immediately. Most impressive, they checked my pizza before I left and caught it themselves. I don't think anywhere has done that before. Good job!! read more

I love mom and pop Pizza joints over chain places. Top it off isn't bad but there are a few glaring issues. # 1 being the price of the toppings, especially if you the 18" pie. They charge 4.89 per topping, so a 2 topping pizza ends up being just over the $30 with taxes. And they didn't even have the decency to load up said toppings. We got a pepperoni and Jalapeno, had about 2-3 pepp and 1-2 jalapeños per slice. Cheapskates # 2 It's ungodly hot inside if dining in. I got it it's a pizza place, big ass oven but jeez turn up the AC guys, again cheapskates. The saving grace is the service and the pizza actually being good. Cannolis weee decent as well. read more

These mom and pops need love! Great pizza with cheese that keeps going! Had the supreme 12 inch but it really was closer to 16 inch. Was it the best ever pizza, no, but I've had a lot of pizza all over the world. I ate in at 6 pm and only one in here. Looks like most carry out but pizza is best right out of oven for me. I'll certainly come back when I travel through Tyler read more

First impression from the outside was to go somewhere else because of the old strip mall feel but as soon as I walked in the door I felt like I was in the right spot. The atmosphere, music and the staff was perfect. Once I got my pizza I really knew I was at the right place. Pizza was perfect, crust, toppings flavorful. read more

See all

Awesome service, friendly staff and amazing food! This is a must visit dining location.

Finally! The real deal. Finally a pizza shop that uses ricotta on pizza. They are also very friendly!

Good crispy crust, great toppings, really good pizza. Enjoyed the pizza very much. Woman at counter brought us free garlic knots while we waited, how cool is that. read more

See all

Definitely the best pizza in Tyler. Great crust and tasty toppings. Call ahead for take out..

Amazing service, cozy atmosphere, food was perfect! Thank you guys for the experienc -Jesse

I've see this place for over a year now and have always been curious to try it. I am a BIG foodie and bread LOVER so as soon as I saw garlic knots on the menu, I knew it was meant to be. Super friendly staff! Will be going back regularly!! read more

Top It Off Pizza - Cheesy Garlic Knots with Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Tyler, Texas

They were out of the Buffalo pizza rolls, however; they accommodated. Staff is pleasant. Food is freshly served. Disappointing I didn't try what I hoped. read more

THIS is the best pizza in Tyler, if I ever claimed that about another place it's just because I hadn't been to Top It Off yet. We are from the Northeast and therefore, super picky about pizza. Not naming names, but we had found acceptable pizza here and maybe even thought we liked it. But this pizza isn't just good for Tyler, it's good pizza period. It's definitely a drive for us, but completely worth it. read more

The best pizza in Tyler! The crust, the sauce, the toppings are all fresh and so yummy. Also consistently good. I live in Whitehouse but the drive is so worth it! read more

Best Pizza in Tyler! Go to pizza place. Owner is makes authentic NY style pizza. Garlic rolls, garlic cheese rolls, Calzones all yummy. I recommend this place over all other if they are open read more

wait time was accurate. the pizza was very thin. and the bottom was a bit tough. the sauce was good. cheese was okay. sausage was flavorless pretty much. had to put it extra work with each bite just to detach it from the slice. if u like thin pizza then this is ur place. if you like a normal pizza or a fluffier one, dont even bother with this place. i dont see why people love this so much. read more

Top It Off Pizza - sausage pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tyler, Texas

John makes the most delicious pizza!Wendy was a wonderful server! You got to try this place the pizza is fantastic!