I used to frequent this place before Covid came.,then found out it had been sold. Last week I…read morepopped in around 4pm and ordered a slice to go. The cashier was friendly, but then he put the slice in the warmer,and went in the kitchen and was making pizzas and chatting away with another worker. I kept thinking...that needs to come out,as minutes passed. I could not get anyone's attention. Finally , I just yelled out ,can you check my pizza?? He got it out, put it in a box, and said, " it's ok, I gotcha." Long story short, I was in a hurry and drove home.AS I feared, it was way overcooked.,too crispy. ( not burnt. But over done.) I ended up eating around the hard parts, and threw half of the slice out. I didnt think of taking a photo! Im pretty disappointed. Probably won't go back.

Stopped in after a college tour with my daughter. You man working the shop was excellent and…read morefriendly. We got slices and they were hot, crispy and New York style. Will stop back each time I visit!

My friend has been sick for days and is finally recovering. She worked up the energy to order food…read moreand your piece of shit phone operator was horrible to her and made her cry. Your food tastes like dogshit on cardboard so I don't know where you get off exactly, but you need to seriously review how your employees treat customers. The last lady she spoke to was lovely but this one ruined her whole day and I barely kept myself from finding him and kicking his fucking teeth in. Do better.

Small town pizza place, its not fancy, but it doesn't need to be. It's really good and clean with…read morereally nice staff. Prices aren't too bad. We got thin crust which was awesome and perfectly crispy. I'll be back!

Prices have gone way up, but portions and quality have gone down…read more I'm not spending $21 on a small average tasting piece of lasagna then paying like $4 to add a basic side salad on. This is sad because we used to drive over an hour to go there. We heard from someone at the bar at another local place that they think the reason why L'Italia changed so much is because it has different owners now. Our last visit it was a chilly rainy windy day and it was uncomfortably cold in their dining room. The music was also too loud. The straw that broke the camel's back was seeing the smaller menu with higher prices. We chose to go elsewhere.

Love our L'Italia! Always my go-to when back home visiting. Owners are spunky, motivated…read moreyoungsters on the move, who genuinely care about their customers and business. The team works seamlessly together for a very satisfying dining experience, always love their youthful smiles and friendly vibe! I'm a sucker for the same dish, usually, Pasta Chicago (sub tortellini), but have also enjoyed the burger. Tiramisu is my default dessert! Experimented with the pizza too, def a solid choice! Go here! Say hi!

Decided to take a ride to Pizza King when visiting our son at Alfred State. We walked in and were…read moregreeted and placed our order We got a large pie/half pepperoni and a chicken quesadilla. I was surprised how quiet the area was . Cute town. The quesadilla was very good and the pizza was good (a little oily from the cheese) I should have asked to have the crust done a little more on the well done side, but that was my fault. We took it to day and ate it outside in the garden area across the street. Price was fair.

The best pizza in New York State and great customer service! I would recommend the All the Way…read morePizza, but their Pepperoni and cheese is amazing also.

Staff is super friendly, and pizza was great. Got the chicken parm pizza 10/10 would get again!read more

I ordered a build-your-own pizza, and nowhere on the menu does it say that white pizza isn't an…read moreoption. I also wasn't told when I placed the order over the phone that red sauce was the only choice. Unfortunately, because of the poor communication, the rest of my family was able to eat while I was left without a meal. What was even more disappointing was how the situation was handled. For a $7 pizza difference , I would have expected a little more professionalism and an effort to take care of the customer. The restaurant looked clean inside and I really wanted to have a good experience, but the lack of communication and customer service was extremely disappointing. Unfortunately, I won't be back.

Very good authentic old school Italian! The red sauce was delicious!! I will definitely go back !read more

3.5 stars. Staff are…read morereally friendly especially the waitresses! Our waitress was so fast and right ontop of bringing warm rolls, staying ontop of drink refills, and checking on us. Really old school a little beat up 90s pizza place vibe inside. Great warm soft rolls served with butter. Okay spaghetti, nothing to write home about, but it's the only Italian in Olean so it did the trick. Amazing meatballs! I wish we got more than 2 because they were the star of the show. I'd literally order a tray of those meatballs with minced garlic and cheese over them. Good fries perfectly cooked. Crispy outside creamy inside. Meh...not very good chicken parm sandwich. That patty was kind of dry inside. Not enough cheese. Okay sauce. Good bun, but it needed to be garlic or something the whole thing was just so bland. I hate saying this, but I've had better chicken parm sandwiches at dive bars, chains, 50s burger restaurant in Jamestown.. anywhere. I only ate half and left it. Desserts looked good, but I wasn't in the mood.

Excellent! We sat inside, place was nice and cool, very clean. Pizza was a good price. There is…read morelovely outdoor seating! Food was well made. Ordered a pepperoni pizza and a couple salads. Crust was perfect, crispy on the bottom. Really enjoyed our food. Server was super friendly. We come up to move our son in to Pitt and to visit. We have never tried this place. Felt good to have great food and service after a 5 1/2 hour drive from Philadelphia. Pizza here definitely competes with South Philly places from home. We will definitely be back again.

The half pizza sub was the size of 2 of their rolls the put in their fish frys,, seriously I paid…read more6.50 for maybe 4 pieces of pepperoni alittle cheese and tiny bit of sauce! That sub was the size or less than a sandwich..Now the fish fry amazing as always,, very disappointed

The sauce and the dough was amazing !!! I loved the calzone and the Stromboli !!! I would…read moredefinitely go again !! The price was slightly high in my opinion but I was happy with the food!!

Did you know they cater? Yesterday, my sisters, Dad, and I went into Tony's Napoli to see about…read morecatering the reception for our Mom's funeral. It came up as a recommendation when another local restaurant we had planned to use was, unbeknownst to us, closed through the weekend. We needed food less than 24-hours out and we met Ed, the owner, when we walked in. He put together a menu with us while we had lunch and just made us feel like it was all going to work out just fine. The next day, he delivered the food and it was set up and warm when we arrived with our extended family and friends. I hadn't had Tony's Napoli before, but the food was good! All around a 10/10 for service, treating us like family during a terrible time, great food, and we have a new family favorite local restaurant! We will be back! Thank you, Ed, to you and the team for your kindness and the phenomenal Italian comfort food!