I was born, bred, and spent the first 47 yrs of my life in NYC. I'd put Tony's pizza up against the best NY (traditional pie) has to offer. Added bonus -- the staff is always enthusiastic and friendly. read more

Eddie Z here again.if you like New York, New Jersey pizza,you'll love Tony's. This is the crown jewel of pizza shops anywhere in the state and we have been to many. Delicious dough,crispy bottom,good sauce and cheese make this a one of a kind pie Visited Long Island recently and went to my old pizza joint and Tony's was as good as the Long Island one. read more

Tony's Pizza - Plain pizza - Italian Near Me - Mooresville, North Carolina

See all

The pizza is definitely NY style unlike some places that advertise NY pizza. It was good. The salad dressings are Ken's brand. It's not my favorite dressing but was decent. Staff was polite enough. read more

This pizza is authentic and top tier. The crust is thin and crunchy and the cheese is great quality and melted to perfection. If you want authentic this is your place. The sauce receipe is perfected! The wings are perfectly crispy and flavorful. i definitely recommend Tony's if you are in the Mooresville area! The service was fast and courteous. read more

See all

If you're in Mooresville, NC, and craving authentic New York-style pizza, look no further than Tony's Pizza. During our two-week stay at a house on the lake, we tried their classic cheese pie--and it was so good, we went back for more! The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, the cheese had that salty, gooey deliciousness you dream of, and the sauce was just the right balance of tangy and sweet. This place nails it. Highly recommend stopping by if you're in the area--this is legit New York-style pizza at its best! read more

Tony's Pizza - Classic cheese - Italian Near Me - Mooresville, North Carolina

See all

My husband stopped to get us lunch. 2 cheesesteaks and an Italian hoagie. First of all it cost $55.00 which is expensive, and secondly none of the sandwiches were worth the price. I asked for pickles on my hoagie and was told they don't have any? What? Then they toasted it and I don't want it toasted, they didn't even ask. The hoagie consisted of 2 pieces of ham and 1 piece of salami and 1 slice of cheese that's it. My husband asked for ketchup on his cheesesteak and was told they can't do that! Both my husband and son said the meat was rubbery barely any cheese and it was very dry. We will not go back again and tell others to avoid! read more

Cannot say that I've ever had a worse customer service experience than the one with the person I spoke with a bit ago regarding an incorrect order. Below is a photo of the $18 lettuce sandwich I received instead of the Italian sub I ordered. Nothing but lettuce, onions, and mayo. How yummy!!! I hope no one else has encountered a similar experience only to be told "that's what the app does" even though I've ordered this exact same thing, the exact same way every time. How about perhaps an apology or an offer for a credit on our next order? Totally unacceptable and due to this, we will no longer frequent this establishment not because of the incorrect order but rather for the lack of caring for their (former) customer. read more

Tony's Pizza - Who likes a good ole lettuce sandwich? - Italian Near Me - Mooresville, North Carolina

Oh my goodness, originally born and raised in Brooklyn, New York. This is our go to place since we just moved here! Even the gluten-free vegan cheese pizza was delicious! Service) is fast and a very relaxed atmosphere with all memorabilia of New York.!! it actually felt like Home! read more

Talk about huge NY slices!! This is the spot to go! They have 15+ locations throughout NC... always a hit!! Love this place!! read more

Tony's Pizza - Cheese Pizza by the Slice - Italian Near Me - Mooresville, North Carolina

I'm shocked Tony's doesn't have a higher rating. I'm here almost every day for a slice. The only place in the Lake Norman area that can compete with Tony's is Brooklyn South (not Brooklyn Boys). But that's pizza, not Italian food, which is a whole other conversation. For pizza, I highly recommend Tony's. The pizza is really good, the people are friendly, there is plenty of space, and the prices are fair. Not to mention the slices are ginormous. An easy recommendation. read more

See all

The guys and young ladies that work at Tony's are mad chill and courteous they never disappoint. They basically know me by name and always greet me with sincerity. I love Tony's pizza and the Philly cheesesteaks are out of this world amazing and the Stroms are top notch. Check them out worth every penny. read more

Only ordered a slice, so can't speak on getting a whole pie. The menu is huge, so tons of options. Pizza almost tastes like a mix between NY style and Napoli. Fantastic and quick service. Excited to come again. Be aware they offer cash discounts so make sure to bring cash! read more

Tony's Pizza - Cheese Pizza by the Slice - Italian Near Me - Mooresville, North Carolina

The quality of their food. The food was badly burn and extremely hard. There were hardly any customers there and was not busy. There was no reason to get the order wrong. read more

Tony's Pizza - Went to tony's pizza tonight and i picked up a slice The slice was completely burned and hard. - Italian Near Me - Mooresville, North Carolina

See all

The sincerity is first of all good customer service, but what it is like to wait 30 minutes and when you get home and see how the pizza is horrible and black. read more

Tony's Pizza - Italian Near Me - Mooresville, North Carolina

Terrible pizza- walked in on a Sunday and ordered two slices and they came out very old. Cheese was not fresh I can simply tell before even eating it. I should have checked the reviews before coming in. How can pizza stores have such low ratings it's so sad! read more

For the local area this is probably the most authentic "New York" style pizza. They have a great selection of toppings and specialty pizzas. The wings are pretty, surprisingly, good as well. We've ordered online and in person and our orders are always spot on and ready on the quick. This is the best pizza joint in the local area we have found so far. read more

I'll be honest yall...I don't know what the hell happened to this place. Years ago the pizza was truly good and sandwiches were warm and moist. Yesterday I order a 17" and a chicken cheesesteak. The pizza was terrible. Tasted like the cardboard box it was wrapped in and that chicken cheesesteak was so damn dry, if someone is drowning in Lake Norman, just throw one of those bad boys in and the entire lake will get soaked up! What a disappointment. Dang. read more

Definitely the best pizza in Mooresville. No close comparison if you like NY style pizza.

Amazing. No other words. Do you want a juicy, succulent, flavor blasted monster of a pizza slice? Go to tonys. You wont regret it. Only other thing ive dared to order there is boneless buffalo wings, ended up more of a chicken nugget (And yes there is a difference between a boneless wing and a nugget). Regardless, it was also really good. No idea if that buffalo sauce was homemade or not... but that and the ranch were 10/10. Go to tonys. read more

Delicious! Easy to order via phone. Timing estimate they gave me was spot on. I ordered the 10 inch "The Works" & as you can see by my picture, it was picture perfect & fantastically delicious. Crust was perfection & right balance of toppings. Even as hot as it was, I couldn't resist eating a slice in the car on the way home. ‍ Friendly employees, ample inside seating, vast array of menu items, & great pricing. read more

Tony's Pizza - 10 inch, The Works - Italian Near Me - Mooresville, North Carolina

Staple in Mooresville. Best crew!! Love Tony's!! Thanks for everything guys!! Highly recommended.

We love this pizza ... have been coming here for several years. In fact, it's about a 30 minute drive from our house, so we purchased our own pizza delivery bag to keep it warm. It's been a while since we ordered, maybe close to a year. We ordered a pizza on Monday, while good, the sauce tasted different, it didn't have the flavor we were looking forward. I sure hope they haven't changed up the recipe and that this was just a fluke. read more

I tried Tony's for the first time on Tuesday and got a 15in pizza with extra sauce and a side of garlic knots delivered through DoorDash and I really enjoyed that meal. I ordered a second time today through DoorDash and the pizza was undercooked, so much so that the sauce and cheese were all falling off. DoorDash only refunded me 5$. It's upsetting because the first pizza was really good but this one was horrible. read more

Tony's Pizza - undercooked pizza - Italian Near Me - Mooresville, North Carolina

Ordered a large pepperoni pizza and Buffalo chicken wings for pickup and both were very good. I called close to closing but they were very nice when I asked if it's too for the pizza and wings. The wings were delivered with the sauce on the side so they arrived nice and crisp and a good size. The pepperoni pizza was very good and the crust nicely cooked with a little char and crispy which I like. The best NY style pizza I've had so far in the year I've been in Charlotte area. read more

Tony's has been our go to pizza place. There have been inconsistencies over the past six months, mostly one time the pizza will be nice and thin and the next time it will be a little too thick. We usually get a pie with ham and sausage, and sometimes it has a lot of meat and sometimes it's so little I wonder why I paid for it. Even with these issues, the pizza still tasted good, and the family was happy. Last Saturday night was terrible. We ordered two pizza's to go, one with ham and sausage (to be well done) and the other plain. They reversed them, and the plain pizza for the kids was well done (actually too well done) and the ham and sausage pizza wasn't cooked enough. Both pizza's were over-sauced. The cheese stopped well short of the crust in many parts of both pizzas, leaving a lot of goopy sauce. Of course my young kids were turned off, and so were we. I understand it was Saturday night and the place was busy, but they still to have consistent quality control. If this was our first time going, we would not be back. Not sure what's going on there, but I feel like it is not as good as it was just six months ago. I hope they get things back to normal. I reached out to the company via email, but no response. Disappointing. read more

Tony's Pizza - Italian Near Me - Mooresville, North Carolina

We just ordered lasagna from Tony's. We ended up throwing it all away. We both agreed that it was the worst we had ever had, and that's saying a lot. The meat is hamburger meat with no seasoning. They flood it with cheese but there is no flavor at all. We have always thought that their pizza was pretty good so we were pretty surprised that is was so bad. It was so bad that I don't think we'll even order their pizza again out of principle. read more

Service was not good ordered online @7:00 was told food would be ready @8:00 got there at 8 and didn't get my food until 8:30. Obviously they didn't even start making it until we got there. Won't be back. read more

Great pizza best I've had in a while. Price is just right too Saturday night carry out special is the way to go

Honestly, it was okay. Being okay isn't bad and sometimes I think giving three stars is perceived that it's not worth it, but I don't think that's true. We ordered garlic knots, a small pizza, and a sub. The garlic knots were definitely garlic-y, which I love. The marinara that it came with didn't really have a ton of flavor which kind of bummed me out and honestly leads me mostly to my three star review. The pizza has the same sauce on it... which leads to a somewhat flavorless pizza. Keep in mind though, I loved the thin crust - definitely think there's a time and place for that - I'm not biased either way. I only got pineapple on my pizza (yes I'm that person) so while the toppings I picked could have led to the less than flavorful pizza, I prefer one with a flavorful sauce as a base. Again, not amazing, but not bad. And I imagine pretty consistent. There were a ton of people in there and they all ordered giant pizzas so there's clearly an audience for it. My boyfriend ordered the sausage, onion, and pepper sub and said the only thing it was missing was either a sauce or some cheese. I did go back up and ask for honey mustard and he said he'd definitely order it again with some dressing. The staff were super nice so no complaints there! read more

Awesome place awesome people awesome pizza!! Love it!! Highly recommend this place!!! read more

Tony's Pizza - Italian Near Me - Mooresville, North Carolina

Pizza was not good and kinda cold and so thin it just didn't taste that great like everyone said it would be I also tried Greek salad that was actually good . I might have to try it again to see if it's good . Maybe they were having an off day. read more

Excellent service and delicious food. Just moved from NY and this is my new favorite place. The slices are huge. Also for the guy or gal who gave poor rating i suggest you order inside instead of door dash lol . i highly recommend the food and place read more

What's the matter with some of you people? Fast friendly service. Best authentic NY pizza in town. Definitely try it before believing some of the poor reviews read more

Stopped in for a quick bite. Fast friendly service, reasonable price and good pizza (better than any frozen option).

Ordered a bunch of pizzas for a family dinner. Service was quick, and the za was solid! I'll definitely go back.

I would have gave Tony's Pizza a full 5 stars if it wasn't for the girl cashier who's always giving an attitude at the register. Anyways, I enjoy their pizza! It comes out hot and the bottom of the slice has that crunchy texture with it and also that good (but not healthy) grease dripping down from the pizza slice! Now that's what makes a great slice! I'm from NJ and know what real Italian pizza tastes like and this pizza is spot on. Every time I'm visiting mooresville I always have to visit Tony's at least for a slice. I also enjoy their cheesesteaks (Tony's way) and their hot fries! Those who have moved down from NJ/NY and miss that godly Italian pizza slice, visit Tony's it will NOT disappoint! read more

Tony's Pizza - Cheese slice, Cheesesteak, Hot Fries - Italian Near Me - Mooresville, North Carolina

We just moved from BY so we have been searching for something resembling genuine NY pizza and we found it at Tony's. I usually have 2 slices but the slices are huge so I could not finish both. read more

I just enjoy this style pizza, reminds me of the mall pizza and that may sound bad to others but I love it! Hard to find a thin crust with flavor but Tony's hits the spot. I give it 4 stars because I think the crust is a little chewy. read more

Pretty much spot on for NY Style pizza. Stopped for lunch and got two slices, one toppings each with a drink for about $9. Right about what a lunch out is going for these days. On to the pizza - two slices are HUGE. I'd bet that one slice could get it done for most folks. Tons of other options on the menu, sandwiches, salads, and more if pizza isn't your thing. Good amount of inside and a few tables outside. read more

Tony's Pizza - Italian Near Me - Mooresville, North Carolina

The pizza from Tony's is great...as long as they don't accidentally delete your online order! Twice we have driven to get out take out and been told they don't have an order for us. Both times they suggested we must have ordered from a different location. Thanks to our online receipts, we could show we had ordered and paid. The sad thing is, I understand anyone can make a mistake, but these guys don't even apologize! Common folks, an apology goes a long way to adding another star to this review. read more