The employee at the counter was nice. After ordering a sausage and pepper sub, I paid cash and noticed a 3.5% service fee on the receipt. I did not see a sign and certainly wasn't notified of this service fee. When asked what this fee was the young lady had no answer except our computer adds it on. Expect hidden ghost fees, which are also subject to sales tax. The sandwich looked good, but once I saw under the cheese I realized the sausage and peppers were low quality pizza topping ingredients. It was very obvious based on the thinly sliced cup style sausage and mushy peppers. The pizza might be good, but I wont be back to tell you about that. read more

Our first time at Tony's and we loved it. The wives split the margarita pizza and the guys had the meatza. Sauce makes the pizza and this sauce was delicious. The crust was light and had a great crunch. Highly recommend. read more

Wow, the pizza here is unbelievable!! The slices are huge!! The sauce is great! The people behind the counter are so helpful and friendly. No disrespect, but BRONX HOUSE PIZZA has nothing on TONY'S!!! It's not a big place, but it feels like a real New York pizza joint! Get on out to Flagler Beach by the Publix; Tony's pizza you won't regret it!! read more

Tony's Pizza - Heaven - Pizza Near Me - Flagler Beach, Florida

See all

Tony's has become our family's go-to pizza spot. The staff are genuinely friendly--they even remembered my name after just a couple of visits. The pizza itself is incredible, and the jumbo size is perfect for feeding our family of six without breaking the bank. The salads are also fresh and absolutely delicious. Highly recommend! read more

Tony's Pizza - Jumbo Pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Flagler Beach, Florida

Had not been back to Tony's for a while, and I am surely NEVER going back. As usual, most of the tables were dirty. Sat down to eat the last piece of cheese pizza (thin slice) with a Cesar salad. I did not order the combination because I do not drink soda late in the afternoon. Menu reads $3.25 for slice of cheese pizza, and $5.00 for a Cesar salad. Also ordered the garlic bread. Young waitress asked if she should bring out the food with the garlic bread, and I replied that it was okay to bring as it came out. Big mistake. My daughter and I finished our meals without the garlic bread. I asked for the check and said that we would not be needing the garlic bread. "Oh, but it's coming out ..." It was boxed because my daughter wanted it, after all. When I looked at the receipt, I noticed that I was charged $10.50 for the combination meal. I mentioned that would it not be cheaper to pay for the small slice and salad separate. Young waitress replied, "No because with tax, it's more expensive." She claimed that the thin slice of pizza is $5.00, although I looked at the menu. Maybe the young waitress needs to learn basic math because even at $5.00 for a slice of cheese plus a $5.00 Cesar, you do not get to $10.50. Bill included a $0.79 service fee, or as the young waitress explained to customer, it is a mandatory restaurant fee. Luckily, I had some points to redeem to offset the overcharge and the disgusting garlic bread that had absolutely no garlic taste and was extremely soggy. My dogs loved it. Definitely will NEVER go back. read more

We have family in Palm Coast, and when visiting, we never miss a stop at Tony's for a few slices. We are from New York, but live in Fort Myers, FL, and we LOVE the pizza at Tony's. Wish we had one here. The flavor, crust, sauce...yum! The staff is very nice too...we always feel like we are welcome there. PS) Our family there told us about Tony's so I think that is their go to also! read more

Moved to the area last year - finally had a chance to check out Tony's Pizza! Ordered a couple of pies last week for takeout, and they were fantastic! The best pizza I've had in Flagler/Palm Coast! Thin crust, super-fresh toppings, and amazing flavor! The service was GREAT - I cannot recommend them enough! Will be coming back soon! I think I will eat at the restaurant next time - the ambiance was just perfect. Give them a try - you won't be disappointed. P.S. - order a bag of Zeppolis......you won't regret it! read more

See all

Got a cheese pizza. The oven temp could have been a little higher. Cheese was brite white and crust was soft. I was born and grew up in New York. The pizza I got was the typical Florida pizza. Sauce was meh. They could give the pie a shot of parm for a little flava. Staff was pleasant. read more

$28 dollar canzone with rotten ham. And I mean rotten. $13.99 dollar subs with meat only in the middle. Price is normal for a pizzeria. But usually the choice of meat is from end to end not just tge middle. Napoli and Terranova are much better and you get more bang for your hard earned money. Thet treating this place like a tourist trap which it isn't it's at a Publix parking lot in Flagler Beach highly highly highly disappointed I would never recommend them not even to my dog I'm saying and with that said my dog actually spit the cows on out because the ham taste stale rotten tastes like crap . Also Anthony's Pizza and Palm Coast blows this place away so does Rocky's and I never liked Giovanni's in Flagler Beach but it's better than this s*** hole this app made me give a star I didn't want to give any stars but I had to give at least one or it won't let you continue another scam read more

Didn't event get to try the food this time. Last few times I've been here ticket times have been slow, and items have been missing (bread, lemons, garlic butter) and I've had to alter my order accordingly. Today went In and waiting an hour and not a single part of my order was even ready. I saw several people come in, order, and walk out before our food was even In The oven. Very sad and poor service as our waiter said "I don't know what they are doing back there" when I can literally see the back of house staff. They need to work together and ensure tickets times are reasonable, and tickets are processed in order. read more

Quick to order and made fresh. We come here all the time when we are in Flagler. Stromboli and Calzones are fantastic. Highly recommend the garlic knots when you get a pizza. You can eat in or carry out. read more

got a welcome to the neighborhood for a free two topping pizza, got a calzone to not just get a free pizza, won't be back, could have spent a couple of bucks for a store bought frozen, hard ass crust no sauce or toppings per say, bad, calzone, fortunately it wasn't put together well so the grease was able to not pool bit made for a messy box, we won't be back read more

See all

So I have gone here in the past and not had a huge issue and the food has always been good however this time we decided to order on the website and go and pick it up as this place is actually quite a distance away (around 15 minutes) when I arrived to pick it up they said it would be about 8 minutes more ( it was supposed to be ready at 6pm and I arrived at 6:15pm) the guy making the orders seemed stressed and overwhelmed, and when they said my food was ready it was the wrong order and it was someone else's, they had my ticket but had no explanation as to why it wasn't made or ready. I received my money back and left angry and scrambling for another option for our dinner, thankfully Marcos in palm coast provided. Absolutely no excuse for this, if you can't handle online ordering or DoorDash orders as a small business then don't offer the service! This will be my last time trying Tony's, it's a shame too because the food isn't half bad read more

Solid family owned place. Plenty of variety by the slice for lunch options and great menu options for ordering in. The staff is great. I'm assuming it was the daughters of the owner that were here during lunch today. They were great. Friendly, plenty of welcome interaction and even the music playing was right up my alley. This is my second visit to this place and it has been great both times. I fully recommend. read more

Tony's Pizza - Cool place! - Pizza Near Me - Flagler Beach, Florida

Excellent! Everything pizza! Buffalo wings outstanding! House salad Delicious and fresh!!! read more

Management here appear to not care about making customers happy. Went to pick our order , order was wrong , wife had to wait an additional 30 minutes without an apology. Will never go here again. read more

I ordered twice with delivery on Toast. The first time, they got the order wrong. It happens; they said to call and give your phone number for a credit. Everyone says the pizza is good, so I tried it again. I called, but they could not find my credit. So, after getting everyone to agree and have it delivered, I ordered online again. Bad move -We got the wrong pizza again. I can't say the pizza is bad because we did not want what we got, so that ruins your perspective. Twice, they messed up our order, and at this point, I am not taking the chance to try again. From my experience, if you want to try Tony's, I recommend visiting and not ordering. Still, I am out of two pizzas, delivery charges, and tips for different pizzas than I ordered. read more

I make my own pizza at home in Nashville so I'm a tough critic. We ordered a large pizza with thin dough. I thought $31 was a bit high but ok. The dough was not thin and could have cooked further. They barely sprinkled it with toppings we ordered. Sauce was bland. I think I would have done better with a frozen pizza from Publix. read more

I ordered food from there for many years. My last order I placed on line was for delivery. Time passed, no delivery. I called. They said you placed a pickup even though I had a delivery time. They said they wouldn't deliver and to take up the refund with my bank. Will never order from there again read more

One of the best pizza in the area. Small place right on the beach. Service and prices are excellent always makes you fell comfortable. Highly recommended for a great pizza. read more

This is hands down the best pizza joint in Flagler County! The staff are excellent. Everything I've ordered here, (try other options on the menu besides pizza too!), has been fresh, hot, delicious and the pricing is great. read more

Good large NYC style cheese pizza. Caprice and sausage pizza wasn't bad. Good service and place was clean.

Just had to update this... was hesitant to go back because all the recent reviews. My last visit was 7months ago. I only eat pizza here when I visit, so I can't comment on other food on the menu. Pizza is always great! They kicked ass tonight again. This pizza was ordered with like 20 minutes to close (a time people def slack and make sucky pies). It's great! read more

Tony's Pizza - Half a pie - Pizza Near Me - Flagler Beach, Florida

See all

Excellent and hot slice of Pineapple and ham pizza with a Mugs root beer soda. Reasonable price. Friendly counter staff. read more

Tony's Pizza - Front counter - Pizza Near Me - Flagler Beach, Florida

See all

Absolutely outstanding pizza! Delicious, fresh salads, reasonably prices. Such friendly service. I'm originally from NYC and am very particular about my pizza. Tony's gets four stars. What a great find after a long day of driving. Thanks for a great meal. read more

Stopped in, hoping for a hot slice and a cold beer. Success, I received both. Gotta love being able to get a darn good tasting slice of pizza and a cold beer. We'll be back for more! read more

Nice service. Good portions. Solid food. Only downfall was the fried pickles, were not really fried and very small portion for the price.

Visiting a friend in Flagler Beach her go to pizza place is Tony's. I have a gluten allergy and saw they offered a gluten free pizza so I ordered one and it was one of the best ever. I actually went back 3 times in the week I was there. My only wish they were in in Pa where I reside. My husband also said the regular pizza was a winner. read more

We've been to this pizza joint few times as it's convenient. But I can say that we won't be back! The service is friendly but they just don't listen. Every single time we ask for pizza and fries together, they serve the fries first! We eat all the fries because we are hungry & then don't enjoy the pizza. When I asked the waitress to please PLEASE serve them together, what she do? You get the story. Anyway I asked to take the fries back & serve our full dinner together. They did and gave us the burnt fries! I mean brown & black! I'm done with that place. As for the pizza it's good but they are not generous with their toppings. read more

To start, we had just left from a horrible experience with a different pizza place near the beach. We were looking for a new place to grab some pizza that was also dog friendly (outdoor seating). We came across this place and we're blown away by the cleanliness before we even walked in the door. When we went in to order, we were greeted by great service and wonderful people unlike what we had just gone through previously. Now, about the pizza, we unexpectedly ordered a jumbo pizza which was about half the size of our table, but now that I think of it I don't think it was much of a mistake but more of a blessing. As the pizza hit the table you could already tell that you were in for some of the best pizza you've ever put in your mouth. It was cooked to perfection, the crust looked divine, the cheese was golden brown, and it was just overall beautiful. read more

We're from out of town and stopped in for lunch after my boyfriend's Lacrosse Tournament. We were very please with the options Tony's Pizza offered and definitely could finish an entire pie in one sitting. We opted on ordering the Sausage and Onion pizza (he's a big fan of that combo) and I asked for a small Greek salad on the side. To our surprise, both were served with generous portions and toppings! My Greek salad has plenty of fresh greens, feta and even sliced ham! It was about 3PM in the afternoon on a Sunday, we had the whole place to ourselves, but we didn't mind! We noticed a lot of orders were being picked up to-go versus dining in as we were. The seatings were a-plenty! The staff was very friendly and it had a nice 'mom-and-pop' local pizza shop feel and quality to it. We're glad we stopped by to fuel ourselves post-game and pre-roadtrip! read more

Tony's Pizza - Sausage and Onion Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Flagler Beach, Florida

See all

Just pretty bad pizza. Been twice and no better the second time. Just blah. They needed to cook the pizza a bit longer.

Went here based on a "Tony's pizza" back hime and it was pretty good! We will def come back.

Tony's is our go-to for the best pizza in Palm Coast and Flagler Beach. Always quick and piping hot with super friendly service. Thank goodness we found y'all!!! read more

My partner is a long time PC resident, and has been ordering their chicken Parmesan sub for almost a decade and constantly raves about it when we're in town. Upon visiting to host a yard sale, and staging at the Topaz Hotel up the street, we decided to pick up dinner around 7pm. We placed the order and about 45 minutes later, we sit down to watch American Horror Story and chow down on our Italian feast. I ordered the spaghetti with meatballs, which was a nostalgic choice, but definitely not the best one. It had a thick layer of melted cheese on top, which I can see why some would like this, but to me it felt like a pasta version of the sub my partner was eating next to me. I've never seen melted cheese on top of a pasta and meatball dinner. Have I missed something? I scooped it off, and was left finally able to enjoy the meatballs, which I certainly did. (I took the photo after I had removed the cheese layer) The pasta was cooked perfect as well. Sauce did taste like it was store bought, like I've had it before. Generic I'd say, or maybe I'm just a tough critic when it comes to Italian food. Overall it gets 3/5 stars. The chicken parm sub was 5/5 stars according to him. I also ordered garlic bread and pasta fagioli soup, in which the soup I did not get to try. The garlic bread was good, but over cooked. On a grander scale, this place was good. They were busy, but the food was still warm upon arrival back to the hotel. I would try the pizza next time, it seems to be their niche. My biggest issue was the containers, styrofoam and the metal ones that you fold the sides down to hold the lid in place. This left is with no way to heat up our food, which was disappointing because so much was leftover. It was by far the most food I've ever wasted, and I'm embarrassed to say. I know it's more costly for sustainable or higher quality take out containers but it's worth it. The piece of mind it brings knowing there's no chemicals seeping into the food, and it helping the environment (if choosing recycled, post consumer or biodegradable). Something to think about! read more

Tony's Pizza - Spaghetti & Meatballs - Pizza Near Me - Flagler Beach, Florida

You would think that you should get your order before the guy that orders 5 minutes after you. But if it happens to be somebody they know forget it. And a thing that really gets it is he ordered the same thing I did just about a slice of pizza all they do is warm it up but he got his first. My lunch is just as important as anybody else's read more

Wow! This was a seriously well made and delicious pizza we got last night from Tony's in Flagler. I'm a very finicky person and everything was perfect on our take out order. The crust was freshly baked with just the right amount of crispness. I love spicy Italian food and the Meatza large pizza we chose was the best pizza so far I've had in Flagler since we moved here last year. Generous amount of authentic Italian sausage and pepperoni bacon ham and delicious meatballs. The best part was the sauce which obviously was hand made. Highly recommended! read more

Pizza was good. Wings are terrible, rubbery and not cooked correctly. Watch out as these guys add an extra 3% service fee to your bill without warning even for pick up orders! read more

Not impressed, ended up tossing the pizza in the trash. The crust was soggy no crunch to it. Weak on the cheese and toppings. The expression eating cardboard, I get it now. read more

Tony's knows PIZZA. We were amazed that this little gem could produce a tasty pie. Their sauce, crust and toppings were so delicious. read more

Tony's Pizza - Dining Room - Pizza Near Me - Flagler Beach, Florida

See all